This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.
About this conversation
A CIO Talk Network conversation with Lutz Beck (Daimler), hosted by Sanjog Aul.
What the conversation established
The conversation established that Lutz Beck sees no limitation to where digital can be applied, extending digital twins, VR, and AR from the factory floor into softer, analog problems. He gave the example of digitalizing assembly line worker training to teach processes and simulate building trucks more effectively, producing efficiency gains on the production line. Beck named culture as the key component, arguing new tools fail unless people accept them, so his team works hard to take away the fear of what happens to my job as processes change. He said talent management is now fully digital, from LinkedIn profiles to posting a problem to the open-source community, where a task can go from roughly 100 people to 1, 2, or 3 million working on it. He was candid about limits: measuring how digital changes culture is very hard, and simulating the people side of change management will not make him 50, 60, or 70 percent sure a change will land, though retail and e-commerce customer behavior are easier to predict. On cost control he said manufacturing is a key area, where simulations with enough data can show that cutting another 10 dollars would hurt output. Beck described funding innovation from value rather than cost cutting, showing a project saves, for example, 5 million dollars and repurposing a 10 to 20 percent slice into new digital initiatives, with a digitalized control tower checking whether the value actually arrives. He drew hard lines, refusing to predict security risk and declining to build a digital twin of an individual employee on ethical grounds, and he used Formula racing, where every driver movement is tracked to shave lap time, to show that a personal, human component of leadership still cannot be digitalized.
Host Sanjog Aul talks with Lutz Beck, Chief Information Officer of Daimler, about using digital to solve analog problems. Beck says digital has no limitation and that the same digital-twin and simulation ideas used in manufacturing can extend to softer areas like organizational effectiveness, talent management, and leadership development. He argues culture is the key component, because even the best tools fail if people do not accept them, and much of his work goes into removing the fear that digital will cost people their jobs. He is candid about the limits, saying culture change and the people side of change management resist measurement and prediction, and that he would not build a digital twin of an individual on ethical grounds. Beck describes funding innovation from value created rather than cost cutting, repurposing a slice of proven savings into new digital initiatives tracked through a control tower, and he refuses to apply risk prediction to security. He closes on leadership, calling for a more holistic leader who delivers value across the whole value chain, including partners.
Contributors
- Lutz Beck, Chief Information Officer, Daimler
Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network
On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript
Key takeaways
- Lutz Beck, Chief Information Officer of Daimler, says digital has no limitation and can be applied well beyond the factory to softer, analog problems. He points to digitalizing assembly line worker training to teach processes and simulate how to build trucks more effectively, which yields real efficiency gains on the production line.
- Lutz Beck of Daimler argues culture is the key component that decides whether digital tools succeed in areas like talent management and organizational effectiveness. He says new tools fail if the culture does not accept them, so his team works hard to take away people’s fear of what happens to my job as processes change.
- Lutz Beck of Daimler says measuring how digital changes culture is very hard, even though technology clearly reshapes how people work. He contrasts culture, which develops slowly over time, with organizational effectiveness and talent management, where digital concepts and simulation are easier to apply and measure.
- Lutz Beck of Daimler says change management can only be partly simulated because the people element cannot be predicted. He says that wherever there is data in the background he can simulate an initiative, but once the human element enters he would not claim even 50 to 70 percent confidence that a change will land.
- Lutz Beck of Daimler funds new digital initiatives from value created rather than from cost cutting. He describes proving a project adds value, for example saving the company 5 million dollars, then repurposing a 10 to 20 percent slice of that gain into new digital initiatives, tracked through a digitalized control tower.
- Lutz Beck of Daimler draws a hard line at using digital to predict security risk, calling it a separate topic that must be tackled differently. He also refuses to build a digital twin of an individual employee on ethical grounds, insisting a personal, human component of leadership cannot and should not be digitalized.
Chapters
- 0:00 Using digital to solve analog problems
- 2:49 Digital twins and efficiency on the line
- 7:09 Culture as the make-or-break factor
- 10:29 Can culture change be measured?
- 14:11 Simulating leadership development
- 17:37 Where digital helps change management
- 27:02 Treating people as assets, not resources
- 28:03 Workforce analysis and tailored training
- 33:33 A digital twin for cost control
- 37:08 Funding innovation from value created
- 41:34 Why he will not predict security risk
- 45:49 Digital across the partner ecosystem
Explore more
- Using Problems to Drive Focus
- Digital for B2B
- EA as the Digital Catalyst
- Digital Divide
- The Chief Digital Officer 2.0
- Who should Lead a Digital Transformation?
Transcript
Using digital to solve analog problems 0:00
Sanjog Aul [00:00:23]:
Our topic for today is using digital to solve analog problems. Let’s talk about the concept of digital twins for a second, which we have seen in the manufacturing world. Organizations which make such products, in the prototyping stage, actually build a digital twin of sorts, and they use that for innovation, to incrementally see how it’s gonna fare in the real world and accordingly make changes to it. So the whole digital twin concept has been around, and it’s been successfully deployed and adopted by companies. This topic was more to see if a similar concept could be picked up to tackle analog problems – whether you talk about organizational effectiveness, workforce optimization, change management, cultural relevance, team effectiveness, cost control. All of these things are usually not put in the domain of what you’ll solve through digital, but we thought we might as well see if the scope of what digital can help with can be stretched. That’s why we’re talking about whether digital can be used to solve analog problems, and why and how. So, to that, I’ve invited Lutz Beck back, who’s the CIO of Daimler, onto the show. Hey, Lutz Beck. How are you?
Lutz Beck [00:02:02]:
Good. I’m good. Morning.
Sanjog Aul [00:02:04]:
Very good. Good morning to you, sir. So, the topic, as you can see, is connected on both ends with what you do as a company in terms of working on physical products, but at the same time I’m talking also about the softer side of things. What do you think is the possibility of even envisioning a simulation of what you’re trying to do with your company, your culture, your team – and working on it before you actually go and make those big sweeping changes, which could be damaging in some cases – and preventing all of that, the very reason why you do that in a manufacturing environment?
Digital twins and efficiency on the line 2:49
Lutz Beck [00:02:49]:
Well, let me say it like that. Digital has, for me, no limitation. This is the big thing we have. So there is no limitation in what we are doing, and we see that, as you described, using digital twins or using virtual reality and augmented reality in the manufacturing area. And this is, of course, also applying for all the other business areas as well, where you try to somehow simulate topics with the digital world. In terms of the team or organizational effectiveness, this is a big topic, and we can apply a lot of learnings out of the digital twins. We’re using digital also in our warehouses, in our assembly lines, and this is helping to be more effective in the whole processes. One big example is the whole digitalization of the training of assembly line workers, to help them learn, first of all, the processes in the assembly line, and second, to simulate with the learning how we can be more effective in building trucks. So there are a lot of opportunities where we take examples out and connect them to the real world and see how it works and simulate the whole process. So we have a lot of efficiency gains, actually, in the production line due to these programs we are running there.
Sanjog Aul [00:04:33]:
And exactly to that point, what you just shared is the value proposition, and that’s why companies are not holding back on using digital in such areas where you are able to simulate things far in advance, see where the inefficiencies and kinks can be removed, and then get a superior product without having unnecessary cost-related or workforce-effort-related leakage. So it’s a great concept, very well adopted, and life is good there. Now let’s talk about – go ahead.
Lutz Beck [00:05:05]:
I just wanna add here to what you said. At the end of the day, we are always looking at where we are adding more value with technology. How can we add more value with the technology? This is exactly the concept we’re applying: using the digital world, using the technologies which are available, and seeing where there is a big value-add for the company. There are also topics where you say it’s not bringing any value for us yet, so we’ll leave that out for the moment. But wherever we see a value – it doesn’t matter if it’s in organizational effectiveness or in budget topics, whatever – we would try to use it.
Sanjog Aul [00:05:46]:
So with that said, how about going into those interesting areas related to, say, organizational effectiveness? Let’s start there. When people talk about organizational effectiveness, it’s not just one thing. An organization becomes effective when you’ve got the right type of leaders driving whatever is to be driven, then you’ve got talent management and organizational design. If we were to first see what are the top challenges related to organizational effectiveness – and I’ve just shared three areas, maybe there are more – and then look at, in the process of trying to solve those problems, where all can digital even be of use? When I say the word digital, I mean rethinking people, process, and tools, and leveraging whatever new digital initiatives or technologies exist. How can we use those to handle these soft problems? I use the word soft because we have traditionally looked at leadership and talent management and organizational design not in a binary way, because we’re dealing with humans – we’ve always seen them in a fuzzy manner.
Sanjog Aul [00:07:04]:
How can we solve these softer problems using digital, if at all?
Culture as the make-or-break factor 7:09
Lutz Beck [00:07:09]:
Well, it’s a big question. I would take on your softer topics – when you look at organizational effectiveness, leadership, talent management, organizational design, I would add one component, which is actually the key component for being successful with digital, and that’s culture. We need to work hard on changing the culture within a company in order to make this digital concept successful. It doesn’t help me if I’m using, for organizational effectiveness, new technologies and new tools, but the culture is such that everything you bring in is not accepted and is somehow taken aside. So what we need to do is work on the culture. We are working very hard to change the culture, to transform the organizational culture, using tools as well, showcasing what can be done with the technology and how. Look at talent management – how you do talent management nowadays is a completely different story, including the hiring process. We no longer have the traditional channels. Everything is digital now, everything is online. You’re scanning through social media, you’re looking at LinkedIn profiles, you’re looking all over. You have a completely different set of processes implemented. Now, bringing that into place and making them successful is still dependent on the people working on the topics, and this is something we’re working on – looking at how we bring the people into these new tools. It’s a bit easier, because everybody is actually digital: everybody is using a smartphone, everybody is using services on the phone. People in their private life are using all of these topics. It’s just a bit of a challenge to make that happen also in the organization, as it’s seen as disruption, as fear, where fear is created – what happened to my job, because I change everything now? And that’s the reason why we work pretty hard on the culture now, to take this fear away and say, hey, try out, use that, use all the tools which are available, bring in tools where you have some experience from your private life, and then adopt that into the organizational business life as well. So we have a full package there, because I do believe we can use tools also in the areas you mentioned, but as long as these tools are not accepted by the humans, we have a big issue, where even if we apply all the concepts and simulations, it will not work.
Can culture change be measured? 10:29
Sanjog Aul [00:10:29]:
So that’s a good point about trying to look at where the culture is and working towards getting that culture fixed. But, like talent management or organizational design, culture is also, for many people, a fuzzy concept, because they are not able to pinpoint what areas you have to fix in culture and how you go about it, and that’s why for most companies culture remains a big issue. So let’s take culture as that analog problem. If you are to fix culture, you have to somehow measure it, benchmark it, and give it a current-state snapshot, so that you know that, on a scale of 1 to 10, this element of culture needs to be improved because it’s currently at 6. And then, when you come up with specific strategies, perhaps the concepts of digital or the digital technologies could be deployed here, so that I can come back in 6 months and say, because of this specific implementation of digital, I was able to move a cultural element from 6 to 8. Do you think we can do that in the first place? Do you think what I’m saying is Star Trek or science fiction, or is it possible for us to make sure something like this can be done?
Lutz Beck [00:12:06]:
I think if you talk about culture specifically, and then measure the change of culture with tools or whatever, I would say you certainly have an impact from technology on culture, because things are changing – you work differently. Let’s say the introduction of email years back changed the culture of a company, how people collaborate, how people work. Right now, with the chatbots and everything else, this is changing more and more. But measuring that – saying, hey, this is what I want to achieve and this is how I get there on a cultural element – would be very hard. I would see it definitely on organizational effectiveness. I would see it on talent management. It would probably be easier to do that with the technology, with digital concepts. But culturally, I think culture develops over time, and now digital is changing the culture. Measuring how digital is changing the culture is a bit difficult. I’m not sure if we –
Sanjog Aul [00:13:28]:
So, Lutz Beck, that’s totally okay, and that’s why it was an interesting question in the first place – can you do something like that? And maybe we should keep that aside. So let’s come back to the specifics. You mentioned organizational-effectiveness elements or legs, which are, say, leadership development. Do you think you can improve leadership in a company by building a digital twin and thinking through scenarios and seeing what the impact is going to be, and not have unnecessary disruption in the company or negative morale because the wrong type of leadership approach was tried? Do you think you can build a digital twin of that and try it, and then make sure what’s gonna work with this particular organization, and then deploy the real leadership changes?
Simulating leadership development 14:11
Lutz Beck [00:14:11]:
I think you are able to do that, yes. You can deploy certain elements of simulations there to see what’s happening. You have tools and technology available which help you also to drive business decisions. And doing that with the technology will help, or will impact, the leadership as well and will go into leadership development. So I think, yes, there is a possibility to certainly use digital also for leadership development and leadership behavior.
Sanjog Aul [00:14:47]:
So let’s take these four areas, or at least the three areas I mentioned earlier – leadership development, talent management, and organizational design – which are the legs to eventually get your organizational effectiveness to the next level. What all did you try to do, leveraging digital, to impact these areas? And what was your journey like, and what were the results?
Lutz Beck [00:15:09]:
Well, first of all, let me say the journey is not over yet. Digital means also that we are learning every day, improving every day, applying new things every day. This will not stop, because technology is evolving much faster than we can apply it. So we need to work towards taking more and more in there. If you look at organizational effectiveness, there is a huge amount of examples we implemented in terms of process changes, automation of processes, simulations within processes where you see how it’s going. Also simulations – specifically, if you look at our world on the truck side, simulations of the behavior of trucks in certain circumstances and environments. This can all be done, and then you can run the simulations and look into how you can make that better, or what you can do to improve the complete process afterwards. So on organizational effectiveness, there are a lot of examples we have. If we look at talent management, it’s of course also much, much more digital than it was before. If you are looking proactively on the market, if you look for talent on the market, you do it in a completely different way nowadays. You use digital tools, you use stuff on the internet, where you look and say, hey, we have a specific problem, how can we solve it? You can go on the open-source community, you can give them a specific problem, and by doing so we also look at which kind of talents we have in the open-source community. So there is a completely different approach nowadays, and this is helping us quite a lot, because if you give specific problems out, you suddenly have, instead of maybe 100 people, 1 million or 2 million or 3 million working on a problem. This is helping us solve the topics much faster than we did in the past.
Where digital helps change management 17:37
Sanjog Aul [00:17:37]:
Let’s talk about change management. Every major shift you make in your organization – what it offers, what it stands for, where it wants to go – change management is what people work on to make sure the organization morphs to your desired state, and it’s invariably fluid, but still there could be some sort of benchmarking, some sort of measuring. Do you think there are specific opportunities to make sure that change management goes as planned as much as possible, by leveraging digital at strategic places? And if yes, what are those places where digital can really help the whole change management discipline?
Lutz Beck [00:18:27]:
For change management specifically, you’re saying I’m using digital to see the progress on my change management – is that the topic you’re looking for?
Sanjog Aul [00:18:38]:
Think about it. So, suppose you’re trying to come up with a new way of making the company, or a division, work, or you’re transforming. Change management involves changing the mindset of the people, changing the organizational structure, changing the way processes are, and all of that might have some issues with people rejecting the ideas, some coming on board, and then whatever processes you thought would work don’t work when you actually apply them. So all that could cause leakage, and that’s why change management initiatives are very expensive. Are there ways by which, anytime you’re going into any such change management initiative, you could apply digital to become as proactive as possible, and almost simulate a change management initiative – to say, if I do this, this is gonna happen, as you would have done in a digital twin situation – and make that particular change management initiative as predictably successful as possible?
Lutz Beck [00:19:50]:
I would love to do that, to be honest with you, but, as you said rightly, we are dealing with personal interests. We are dealing with people on the change management front, and rationalizing that and simulating what people are thinking goes only to a certain extent. Based on your data from the past, you can figure out if a certain initiative – let’s say we are applying a new process in the manufacturing area, in the production plants – if we have enough data on how this was done in the past, we can see, to a certain extent. But I would not say it’s making me yet 50%, 60%, 70% sure that this will work or will not work, because I still have to consider what the people are thinking about it, and this isn’t something I can just calculate based on the past. So from my point of view, it’s still limited in a certain way, because I still need to figure out how I can deal with it. Of course, it’s easier if you look at a retail business or an e-commerce business, because based on past behavior I can more or less calculate what kind of behavior a certain customer is having and what kind of parts he will order in a specific month or week. That’s what I can do, but I would not consider that yet change management within the organization.
Sanjog Aul [00:21:45]:
And the goal was not to have it just as a binary, which is either fully successful or not at all. So which areas within change management do you think you can be proactive about and leverage digital? And some areas, like you said, when you’re dealing with people, their whims and fancies, maybe that’s not the area you can really impact. But if you want to maximize use of digital, where all would you use it?
Lutz Beck [00:22:10]:
Wherever I have data in the background which helps me simulate a certain thing, I think I can do it. Wherever you come to a point where you say, hey, there is also the people element in, which we cannot predict, it comes to its limitations.
Sanjog Aul [00:22:32]:
So to that end, it should be intuitive for most companies, but they still take change management initiatives as not an area where digital could be utilized. Do you think that’s where the world is going now, where they are even partially trying to get into any place where data is, to leverage digital to churn some reports out and make decisions that way? Is that where the world is going?
Lutz Beck [00:22:59]:
Of course. We all know that data is the key asset of each of the companies we have, and we need to leverage that key asset. Everything you create – if you look around at all the new business models, all the new services coming out – are based on data. So this is the key asset you have. We need to leverage it in all different aspects, not just in terms of creating new services; you need to leverage it also for how you internally create more organizational effectiveness. That’s a big portion of what we’re doing. Of course, very importantly, if you work with data, you need to consider all the different legislations and regulations you have around that, because this is an important topic. We just recently, here in California, had the CCPA coming up, and we are expecting more to come. So these privacy laws we need to consider, and we consider them the highest good you have. This is very important to do. But nevertheless, there is a lot of other data you can use in the different areas you mentioned.
Sanjog Aul [00:24:31]:
Let’s get into the workforce development area. When we talk about people, we know there is a fuzzy side to people, but when you are about to deploy a set of people on a project, or you’re trying to estimate the number of people you will need, and also making sure that their workload and utilization levels are optimized – not maximized, so that there is no burnout – there is a possibility of using data. But still we see, as initiatives are carried out, there is burnout, there is confusion, there is undocumented work, and there is not enough effort, in many cases, put into developing our people so that they are ready for the next set of initiatives, whereas there could be data available here. So if you had to come out with your playbook to say, okay, I’m gonna use digital wherever possible to help build or improve this workforce development function, so that we are always keeping our people ready and also have their morale high, what would you do?
Treating people as assets, not resources 27:02
Sanjog Aul [00:27:02]:
So, you know, the people we are trying to utilize – instead of calling them resources, we say nowadays that we want to call them assets, which they truly are. For any initiative to be successful where people are involved, you want to make sure they are kept ready, feeling confident that they have the skills, the background, and the experience to take on some projects, and at the same time you want their morale to be high, that they are not feeling burnt out, and that it’s going in the same line as they wanted to grow their career, because that’s where an individual’s development-related desires should be kept in mind, not just the corporate desires. So if you look at this space of making the people perform and be at the best they can be, what would you say are the opportunities, and what have you tried to do in this regard?
Workforce analysis and tailored training 28:03
Lutz Beck [00:28:03]:
What you need to do as a first thing is look at all of the individuals on the people side, and make sure you have a good understanding in terms of experience and skill set of the people themselves. What we are doing a lot, especially now on all the new technologies, is training the people, bringing them up. We’re looking into their past experience and know-how, and in which kind of positions, looking into the future state, they actually fit, because they bring a lot of experience with them already, so that we can train them on the right elements. So very individual training plans, to make sure people are going onto the new technologies and leveraging what they have as experience, because this is very important. If you have people with a lot of experience, it’s helpful, and if you combine that with the new knowledge, it’s value-creating for the company. So what we did is we looked a lot into what we call workforce analysis, where we looked into which skill sets we have currently, which skill sets we need in the future, and then matched who is fitting into what. Of course, also asking the people in which areas they actually want to develop. There is a difference between the generations as well, which you need to consider, because especially now, if I look at the talent, the younger generation, a lot of them are more interested in the content of the work, and they are not necessarily sticking to one company. What they want is actually excitement and, every day, a new challenge when they join a company. So if this is not challenging enough, or if there is one project that is interesting for their personal life or career, they just come in, do this project for 1 year, 1.5 or 2 years, and then they leave. And this we need to learn as well. We need to make the topics we are working on very attractive for the people, so they can have a learning in what they are doing. This concept we can apply also to all the other assets, as you said, because everybody is interested to learn and to develop new things. So we look into this people element quite a lot, to see also how we mix the teams, how we bundle, how we can do some mentorship and reverse mentoring. So you have, on one side, a younger generation or less experienced people going into a mentee role for specific topics, and then you have experienced people, like myself also, where we go into reverse mentoring. So I have a mentor who is teaching me about robotics and about programming of robots, because it’s just very interesting for me to see, in order to also learn what is possible and what is not possible.
Sanjog Aul [00:31:48]:
Now, what you just mentioned is, of course, the right type of thing any organization should be doing, so that people feel – and based on what you mentioned, different generations have different interests. Do you think we could plan this? Or is it more experimentation or sandboxing, and see where it takes us? Can you simulate that this type of person, who we collect information about their interests, and then literally create a blueprint and see if this, done in this way, is going to take us to an optimal growth and utilization of people while their morale stays high? Do you think you can simulate and build a digital twin of something like this and then deploy it?
Lutz Beck [00:32:35]:
You can simulate the interest of people, based on all the information you have. You can find out what kind of interest the persons are having and in which kind of positions you should put the people, in order to let them perform well and have them motivated – all these kinds of things. But I do not think we can simulate it, in a certain sense, like a digital twin where I say, hey, I have one person, and this is the digital twin of the person, and now I know exactly. No, I don’t think we can do that, and, to be honest with you, I’m also a bit hesitant to do that, because this is an ethical question we need to answer here as well. I do believe, even if technology is coming to that point, we also need to apply ethics here, where at a certain point we stop.
A digital twin for cost control 33:33
Sanjog Aul [00:33:33]:
Okay. So now let’s talk about the issues we feel in cost control. That’s not new – people always want to control cost, and that’s, in a way, one of the first things any organization has been trying to do forever. Do you think we could create a digital twin on all areas where we have costs, and start simulating that, if I reduce this cost by this percentage, if I cut this much from here and this much from here, then it’s going to lead us where we want, and it is not going to create a negative impact? Because sometimes, as you may have realized, if you cut down to the bone in certain areas, over-cutting the costs can have a detrimental impact, but then we’ll realize it only after we have done so.
Sanjog Aul [00:34:28]:
Do you think we can get proactive in cost control and the related outcome, and related simulation, and once we feel that this is the right level of cost cutting or cost control, then we deploy it?
Lutz Beck [00:34:43]:
For specific areas, in manufacturing, I would say yes, we can do that. We have concepts in place, and we’re working on concepts where you see what certain cost elements are doing, and how, if we apply specific measures, what is happening there. I think we can do that for specific areas already, and it will certainly be possible to do that in future for more areas, the more data you have, to control that in a completely different way and do budget programs, or plan your budgets, in a completely different way in the future.
Sanjog Aul [00:35:32]:
What areas would you recommend, if somebody were to go there?
Lutz Beck [00:35:36]:
Well, manufacturing is certainly a key area, because especially here, if you look at production areas, there are a lot of people working on that, and cutting – okay, can we take another dollar out here? Can we take another 10 dollars out here? What will happen? In this area we can apply it, because with the simulations, when you have enough data to simulate everything, there are a lot of possibilities where you say, if you take that down by another 10 dollars, this will not work, it will have a negative impact on the output. So there are areas where you can really apply it, because this is the first area where you have a high impact if your production is impacted.
Sanjog Aul [00:36:24]:
Okay. So now, if you were to think about all the different places where we have to do innovation – something new – that means you have to spend some money on new innovation. But sometimes, as you may have tried as a CIO, you may say, can I cut cost somewhere else and repurpose that cost into innovation?
Lutz Beck [00:36:46]:
Okay.
Sanjog Aul [00:36:47]:
Do you think those kinds of things can also be brought into the same mix? So you are not just looking at cost control for the sake of cutting cost, but actually to support innovation, and you can show a much better business case to management because you’ve got numbers in front of you, and you’ve leveraged digital for it.
Funding innovation from value created 37:08
Lutz Beck [00:37:08]:
I think here it’s very important to come back to this topic of value creation. What we specifically do here is look at the value we are creating with new initiatives, with new projects, with digital projects, and then see, okay, if this value is really coming also for the company. So there is a lot of control of what’s really happening. If you say, hey, I have an analytics project, a big data project, where I’m saving with all what I’m doing there, let’s say, 5 million US dollars for the company – so what we created is, I need to showcase to the organization that it’s value-adding what we’re doing, and then I take a portion out of what I saved, or what I gained as organizational effectiveness, 10%, 15%, 20%, whatever, and then I repurpose this budget into new digital initiatives. This is the way it should be done, because then you’re not just trying to run digital initiatives via cost cutting, where you say I need to cut here and here in order to do that. You run them in a completely different manner, which is always value-based and value-creating, and not depending on the cost cutting. So you have a cost cutting element on your, what I call, digital foundation, which is your back end, and then in all the digital initiatives you are always looking at the business cases, controlling the business case and saying, okay, instead of the anticipated 5 million euros, I just have 4 million. Okay, I get 10%. Now I don’t have 500,000 euros, I just have 400,000, because I just have 4 million. So this is the way we are working on the topics, because this is, from our point of view, a very healthy way to do it, without going into too much cost cutting.
Sanjog Aul [00:39:16]:
So what you just suggested, this is how I’m assuming any seasoned leader like you would have done even pre-digital. What do you do to leverage digital to go to the next level of accuracy and effectiveness in the way you do your math?
Lutz Beck [00:39:33]:
What you leverage digitally here, in this process, is basically to say, do I really gain what I was having in my business case? I do believe, in a lot of industries, we did a lot of business cases, but we were not really looking at the outcome afterwards. Now what you can do, with all the control – we call it a control tower, which is digitalized – is you can look into whether that value is really coming or not coming, and then, based on that, act. So the transparency of what you’re achieving is much higher using tools.
Sanjog Aul [00:40:11]:
I’ll take an interesting area related to something like security. Now, security may or may not be part of your group, but as an organization it’s becoming very important, and you can keep spending money on security and not always know whether you’ll stay afloat or be breached. So when someone is going to make an investment like that – and it’s primarily the security leaders working with IT leaders – can they predict that if we do A, B, C in terms of taking measures, we are reducing risk by X? But that is more subjective, and that’s why it is tough to stomach for management. Can we do something where you’re predicting risk, like you predict profitability – you could predict risk, but supported by data, versus an individual or a security team’s hunch – so that we are able to keep the business secure while we are doing so many things for cutting costs or growing the business through innovation?
Why he will not predict security risk 41:34
Lutz Beck [00:41:34]:
I would say you can predict risk in specific areas, but I would not apply that to security.
Sanjog Aul [00:41:45]:
Okay. And what would you say to that?
Lutz Beck [00:41:46]:
This is a very complex topic, and I would not be able to do that, to be honest with you, even though you might have measures in place and so on. I would not do that. For other risks, on the infrastructure side, if you have risk and it’s not related to security, those are topics where you can look into and calculate and do a lot. But security, for me, is a bit of a separate topic that needs to be tackled completely differently.
Sanjog Aul [00:42:24]:
Okay. So now, coming back to the type of people that we deal with – and, frankly, humans are the interesting ones who become a catalyst, or they could become the dampers. So if you had to use digital to your benefit as a management person or a leader, how could you use digital to get the people to become the best they can be?
Lutz Beck [00:42:55]:
Well, if we are looking into workforce analysis, and if you are looking into training programs, and into effectiveness of people, this is all, in a certain way, digitalized already. So we can give the people KPIs and measure their performance in specific, digitalized ways, which helps give us a certain hint on specific people. We can hire people based on their profiles, which you find all over in LinkedIn and other social media channels. So there are a lot of things you can do. Still, as a leader, you need to be aware of the people themselves. There is still a very personal component which is not digitalized, where you need to talk with people, communicate, have direct interactions. This is not going away with the digitalization. Analyzing, bringing the strength out of people – especially if you look at sports, if you look at racing, you see that very well, because it’s incredible what they do with the data there. They track every movement of a race driver. They look exactly at what the driver is doing. Each part of the track, they know exactly, and then they say, hey, your behavior was like this, and if you change that – if you brake, for instance, one second or two seconds later – it will give you another improvement in your lap time. This is good, and you can do that. On the other side, there is still a very human topic in there, which is the interaction with the person, talking with the person, giving confidence to the person, and this you cannot digitalize. I saw that actually on the racing quite obviously, and this was a big learning for me, when I learned how they are improving the lap times slowly by really analyzing each of the movements of the driver and knowing exactly, also combining that with the car. This is quite interesting, and I think you can apply that concept also in other areas with all the movements, but still there was, after talking also to the drivers, a very personal component in there as well, where the motivation was more on the direct interaction.
Digital across the partner ecosystem 45:49
Sanjog Aul [00:45:49]:
When we talk about digital, they say that digital is not typically to be used and leveraged just by thinking inward. In fact, partnerships with our value chain partners, because it takes a village to serve the customer. That means that village could have other partners working alongside you, and they are not the same people. They are not part of your company, so you have only influence. You don’t have control over them. When you are looking at building an ecosystem of entities with people working within them, and you want all of them to come together and make that ecosystem effective so it moves the business forward, would you think there would be opportunities for digital to play a role there? Because typically you’ll have supply chain management or procurement dealing with those partners, but what they do on a given day, how motivated they are, how cost-efficient they are, so that overall the cost of delivering the service to a customer becomes the lowest and the experience we deliver is the highest – that is an area of opportunity, an area of growth. But since they are partners, you don’t control them, you can only request or motivate them. Can digital help there?
Lutz Beck [00:47:10]:
Yes, of course. Digital can help there, and you’re right. You need to motivate, you can ask them to help there. But, you know, I think there is a win-win situation, if you look into supply chain, for everybody when you are connecting, when you’re integrating that with tools, where you know exactly what kind of capacity a specific robot can do, you know exactly when there is an issue and the impact on the supply chain itself. So there is a huge benefit for both sides when you’re doing that and integrating the supply chain. This is a topic we’re working towards as well, because it gives us insights, but it also gives the suppliers insight, and this is helpful for both parties to also save cost for specific topics.
Sanjog Aul [00:48:10]:
Now, when you are looking at the managers who are taking care of the people on the front line delivering – they also need coaching, because most people are either demotivated, or they actually leave the company, when they have bad managers. So one is to say, you’re gonna have some leaders who are gonna coach or mentor some managers, and we leave it at that. Could there be a way by which you build that layer of people who are management people, but you make them turn into self-leaders and leaders, so they do the best they can, so the people who are actually delivering on the front line can become the best they can be?
Lutz Beck [00:48:52]:
This should be the goal. This is leadership. As a leader, you need to deliver value every day for the company, and you need to deliver the value with the group of people who work for you, and with everybody in the organization, or, as you said rightly, with partners. So you need to do that, and I’m with you, this requires a different leadership skill, because you need to think much more holistically than you maybe did in the past. You cannot just think in your silo anymore. You need to go out and look at the whole value chain, at the whole process. The ideal goal is, of course, that you have leaders who have this motivation to change into that role, and giving this motivation, commitment, and enthusiasm also to their people, so that they create a performing team, which at the end of the day is also a winning team, and the important thing is to work together in the company to achieve that. So clear cut for us is, one team, best team. We’re all in one team. We are working towards a high-performance culture and a high-performance organization.
Sanjog Aul [00:50:20]:
On behalf of the show and our listeners, thanks so much, Lutz Beck, for sharing your insights and experience about how you have worked on using digital to solve analog problems, and on becoming a good leader yourself as well as bringing other people who work with you and report to you to become leaders, so everybody wins in the process. So thanks so much.
Lutz Beck [00:50:43]:
Thank you very much as well.


