Leadership • Talent Development

Should There be an IT Leadership Maturity Model?

Should There be an IT Leadership Maturity Model?

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Alan Hackney (John Hancock Financial Services), Tim Cook (Russell Reynolds), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that there is no formulaic way to mass produce IT leaders. Alan Hackney of John Hancock Financial Services argued that rising through a single technology is an attribute of a bygone era, citing an email from his 8-year-old niece as a sign that people now use technology as naturally as breathing, so the technologist’s job is to connect technology to business needs. Tim Cook of Russell Reynolds put the share of outstanding CIOs below 10 percent and tied later success to being pushed out of your comfort zone early, including international postings. Both pointed to experience as the teacher: GE’s technology management training program, started 32 years ago and modeled on a finance program about 100 years old, the reassignment program Hackney runs at John Hancock moving managers of 50 to 60 person teams between business units, and a willingness to let people fail, as in Cook’s client who wanted a program director who had failed three times on big SAP rollouts.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Alan Hackney, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer at John Hancock Financial Services, and Tim Cook, Co-Lead for IT Officers Leadership Practice in the UK at Russell Reynolds, about whether there should be an IT leadership maturity model. Hackney describes a great IT leader as both an agile problem solver and a steward of efficiency, and places leaders on a continuum from fixer to builder. Cook explains why he rates fewer than 10 percent of CIOs as outstanding, and both argue that leaders are grown through diverse and international experience rather than a fixed formula. They point to GE as an academy company, the reassignment program at John Hancock, and the role of managed failure in developing leaders.

Contributors

  • Alan Hackney, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer, John Hancock Financial Services
  • Tim Cook, Co-Lead for IT Officers Leadership Practice in the UK, Russell Reynolds

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Alan Hackney, Chief Information Officer at John Hancock Financial Services, defines a great IT leader as both an agile problem solver and a steward of efficiency. He places leaders on a continuum from fixer, the tactician who digs into operational problems, to builder, who turns a wisp of an idea into operational reality, and says the rare leaders shift along that spectrum as business needs change.
  • Tim Cook, Co-Lead for IT Officers Leadership Practice in the UK at Russell Reynolds, estimates that fewer than 10 percent of CIOs are outstanding. He says many CEOs have had poor experiences with IT and set low expectations, so a transformational CIO who acts as a trusted advisor to the chief executive surprises them.
  • Tim Cook of Russell Reynolds argues that success in your 40s correlates with being put in harm’s way in your 20s, well outside your comfort zone. He cites an executive they placed who built cross-cultural influence early, later ran a FTSE 100 board meeting as a 15 minute agile stand-up, and moved into a role carrying P&L responsibility.
  • Alan Hackney of John Hancock Financial Services credits GE for embedding leadership development in its culture. He notes GE’s technology management training program began 32 years ago, modeled on a financial program about 100 years old, and that his reassignment program at John Hancock moves managers of 50 to 60 person teams into different business units to break a time and grade mentality.
  • Tim Cook of Russell Reynolds says the academy companies that once trained IT talent, among them Procter and Gamble, Unilever, Mars, and Ford, have largely disappeared. He urges organizations to give rising leaders real international exposure, warning that technically strong professionals from the US and India often have not lived and worked in another culture.
  • Alan Hackney of John Hancock Financial Services and Tim Cook of Russell Reynolds agree that managed failure builds leaders. Hackney points to Walter Isaacson’s biography of Steve Jobs as a man who failed his way to fame, while Cook recalls a client who wanted a program director who had already failed three times on big SAP rollouts so the fourth would go right.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: should there be an IT leadership maturity model
  • 3:41 What makes a great IT leader
  • 6:24 Why outstanding CIOs are rare
  • 9:28 The fixer to builder continuum
  • 13:49 Can IT leaders be grown
  • 20:45 Early career exposure that shapes leaders
  • 26:39 The John Hancock reassignment program
  • 33:59 The decline of academy companies
  • 37:31 How GE embeds leadership training
  • 41:25 What working in Japan changed
  • 48:16 Building an academy of experiences
  • 51:25 Infancy, adolescence, and adulthood of IT

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: should there be an IT leadership maturity model 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:01:04]:
Today’s topic is, should there be an IT leadership maturity model? And our guests for today’s show are Alan Hackney, who is the Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer with John Hancock Financial Services. Good morning, Alan. How are you?

Sanjog Aul [00:01:55]:
And also we have Tim Cook, who is the Co-Lead for IT Officers Leadership Practice in the UK for Russell Reynolds. Good morning, Tim. How are you?

Sanjog Aul [00:02:33]:
And I am honored to have both of you on this show. We picked up this topic because we always talk about predictability and predictable growth patterns or maturity models and everything almost IT does at any given time. So is it at all possible for us to bring some predictability and the required numbers of leaders to the marketplace, which are so much needed today given the speed at which business and IT are moving and you need more and more of such folks, to provide a framework so that we have the right level and right type and right quantity of leaders taking charge of what all is going on. So with that said, the question I’d like to start with, Alan, and this is just your personal viewpoint or what you’ve seen others also talk about. How does one define a great IT leader? Is it someone who you feel is just delivering consistently or someone who just gives you totally awesome results?

What makes a great IT leader 3:41

Alan Hackney [00:03:41]:
So, I guess I’d have to say yes to both of those things. When I think of great leaders and picture them in my mind in the IT environment, I’m always thinking about people who at their core are agile and adept problem solvers and folks who can readily grasp a business need or a business opportunity and translate that into the action that advances that need. But if it were just that then I don’t think you’d have the complete picture of an IT leader. I think an IT leader is also for many businesses a bit of the machinery and a bit of the factory floor for companies. This is particularly true in my opinion in the services industries. And so the IT leader needs to be the steward of efficiency as well. As I look at the landscape, I find that great IT leaders are at the very same time very focused on problem solving, connecting the dots between a business strategy and the ultimate outcomes that deliver the strategy but at the same time being the steward and the consciousness of the organization as it relates to efficiently deploying its business processes and utilizing its financial and human capital to the best advantage.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:49]:
So Tim as you go about talking to a variety of different individuals and you might have placed a number of them in different companies. First question is, what is the expectation when you are asked to deliver somebody who would turn out to be a rock star? And then when you do talk to people, where do you find the delta where you say, okay, this person is just gonna be a reasonable fit versus this person will totally transform your organization just because of the DNA the person has and/or the type of experience or faculty and/or capability?

Why outstanding CIOs are rare 6:24

Tim Cook [00:06:24]:
Those are two really good questions. I think as far as expectation goes, my own experience is that many chief executive officers, many CEOs have had a poor experience with their IT function and therefore their expectations tend to be quite low of the sort of candidates that they’re going to see in front of them. And they’re very pleasantly surprised and surprised is probably the right word when they meet people who are very transformational, who are strategic and who see themselves really as trusted advisors to the business, particularly to the chief executive. Now I don’t think there are many of those CIOs around and you sort of know it when you see them and you know it because they have some great examples of how they’ve connected with colleagues at a senior level and influenced successfully internationally.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:24]:
Do you think the fact you just mentioned that CEOs or other members of the executive management have rather low expectations. Does that reduce the benchmark of the level of leaders we will produce and/or will be able to place there? Because demand is what drives the supply. And people start working towards delivering what is needed versus unnecessarily working or investing more into producing a product or a person in this case who’s going to totally wow the executive management. So where is this demand and supply? Do you think you are at par or you are flooding the market with the right type of leaders?

Tim Cook [00:08:12]:
I don’t think that there are very many outstanding CIOs. I think it’s probably less than 10% of the CIOs out there I would classify as being outstanding. Now that doesn’t mean that there aren’t a lot of really very good IT directors and people running discrete parts of the function, for example infrastructure and service management and application delivery and so on. But I think that in terms of flooding the market and setting expectations, I think that it depends where the business is that this person is going into in their cycle. I mean if the business has got a whole set of really quite profound infrastructure issues or IT issues or program delivery issues, then the person coming in is probably going to have to be quite tactical and very operational to get those issues resolved quickly. If on the other hand there is a sort of profound turning point in the organization’s life, for example, many publishers moving towards online, then the person coming in is likely to be much more transformational. They’re likely to want somebody who’s got a broader strategic view as well as an operational delivery capability.

The fixer to builder continuum 9:28

Alan Hackney [00:09:28]:
So Sanjog Aul, if I could step in here, I agree 100% with what Tim is saying. In a way, using different words to describe what I call the great IT leader a few minutes ago. Maybe even another way of thinking about it, if this is useful, I think of a continuum of skill where at one end of the continuum you have what I call a fixer, the tactician that Tim was just referring to that gets in and can really dig into operational problems or efficiency problems and sort those out and get them straight. On the other end of the spectrum, and I think Tim was alluding to this as well, is what I would call a builder. Somebody who can grasp a wisp of an idea and put substance and form and ultimately bring that into an operational reality. I think if you accept that premise of a continuum from fixer to builder, great IT leaders that sustain themselves in the leadership roles are able to shift their focus along that spectrum as the needs of the business ebbs and flows. And what I find is that many, many leaders, many IT leaders are skewed in one sense or the other. They’re more of a tactician fixer and when the business need evolves to having to do something transformational or something that’s very creative, it’s hard for them to make the shift. Likewise, the developers and the great transformational people find themselves unable to deal with practical problems and that’s where you see a lot of turnover in my way of looking at things. That’s why if you have people who can move across that spectrum, you get down to those very vital few, that 10% that Tim was just talking about.

Tim Cook [00:12:00]:
I agree with Alan on that. I think it’s a very shrewd observation that the people that are really outstanding in this area are people who have made that transition. And I think the transition goes in two ways because quite often you find an organization has evolved itself to a position where it’s right for the CIO to be engaged in strategic level discussions about new markets that the organization can go into. But every now and then, the organization goes into some really quite operational or quite tactical phases. For example, it might have just done an acquisition or a divestment or it might be wanting to enter a new market. And then there is a requirement for the CIO to engage in being pretty operational and focused. Now if doing that journey from being a fixer to becoming a builder, the CIO has lost sight of what actually happens at the fixing level of an organization and doesn’t really understand anymore what good looks like or can’t ask the right questions to establish what’s actually going on down there, then they’ll quickly fail and the halo, I think, will wear off very quickly.

Sanjog Aul [00:13:14]:
Now one is to look at the nature of these individuals who some people we just happen to find who are good and others, the nurture part. So the question here is that are we on the mercy of mother nature that she spins out a number of good leaders on a regular basis, otherwise, we’ll have a vacuum, or we have a way to build those competencies and build those leaders, if you will, for our IT to continue to deliver. So Alan, what do you think is the case here?

Can IT leaders be grown 13:49

Alan Hackney [00:13:49]:
Yes. So I would hold the view, Sanjog Aul, that there isn’t a formulaic way to nurture a population of leaders. The reason I hold that view is I think twofold. One is, in my opinion, the days of being able to rise consistently through increasing scope within a particular industry or within a particular business on the basis of your mastery of a particular type of technology or a particular type of technology application I think is an attribute of a bygone era. The reality today is that more and more people are quite comfortable with technology and my anecdote on that, my epiphany on that happened about 5 years ago when I got an email from my 8-year-old niece and it suddenly dawned on me that when I was 8 years old I could barely do block letters let alone cursive writing and now I’ve got an 8-year-old niece who’s able to master a keyboard and knows how to send an email. The point of that little anecdote is that people are using technology not as a learned skill but simply as if they’re breathing air. The role of a technologist can’t be the steward of any particular technology but really has to be the steward of how that technology dovetails with business objectives and business needs. That’s one reason why I think a formulaic approach is probably not the right way to go for a technology leader. I think the other issue is that great leaders are really great leaders and we can debate this point but really great leaders are going to be great leaders irrespective of what function they happen to represent in a business environment. We’re talking about technology today but I would submit that great technology leaders could come out of other functions and other disciplines within an organization and likewise great technology leaders could move horizontally into some of those other functions as well because the attributes of being a great leader transcend the technology. So for those two reasons Sanjog Aul, I don’t think that there’s a formulaic way that we can maybe grow a population of IT leaders.

Sanjog Aul [00:17:38]:
Tim, let’s discuss and explore these developmental stages through which some of these people who eventually start maybe in a business role and/or in an IT role, but eventually grow and build the competencies in themselves so that someone identifies or they themselves see a role as an IT leader and eventually assume that position and do well. So, what are those? What has been seen, based on your experience as you’ve dealt with multiple CIOs and/or step up candidates for CIOs and how they have been developing themselves?

Sanjog Aul [00:20:13]:
So, Tim, the question here would be, can we look at the different developmental stages that you’ve seen people go through, and can we compare the pedigree of people who you’ve seen as being successful now versus people who are wannabes and perhaps they don’t seem to demonstrate the right DNA for the same? Is the background of any value, has it been making any contribution towards this?

Early career exposure that shapes leaders 20:45

Tim Cook [00:20:45]:
Yes, it does. I mean, I think that when you look at individuals that have been successful in their careers later on, I think that there is a correlation with success perhaps in your 40s and older with the degree of exposure you had in your 20s to situations that in a sense put you in harm’s way. Now what I mean by that is situations where you were severely out of your comfort zone, working perhaps in a culture that you hadn’t worked in before where you had to adopt your own influencing style and take into account the people that you’re working with that you needed to communicate to in a different way. So for example, somebody who might have started in a programming role and we’ll come back to programming as an interesting example in a second, but has perhaps been involved in a project rolling out maybe an ERP application or maybe something else that’s been developed in house. And in the process of rolling out that application has had to work with development teams in other countries and has had to work with multiple business units and business unit leaders in other countries. And so you’re starting to get a problem that is quite a complex problem. It’s a multidimensional problem. You’ve got multiple countries, multiple languages, and particularly with software, you have a high degree of ambiguity about what it is the business wants and what it is you can actually deliver. And then you have to try and frame your questions as the leader to try and get the answers that are going to help you develop what it is your client wants. Now if you’re exposed to that kind of situation fairly early on in your career and I mean perhaps in your first or second role in a programming function for example, then if you deliver it successfully and in fact even if you don’t because you’ll learn quite a lot from it, then what you will have acquired very early on is an ability to understand how to reframe questions and how to push in an appropriate way in different cultures internationally with colleagues. Now getting that understanding of how to communicate I believe is a key skill that you need to have later on in life. And the very best CIOs that we see are people who are extremely good communicators. They can adopt their style later on. So that would be one example. Another example I think would be where you’re given a great deal of responsibility in a line area where you might have previously you might have had a virtual team reporting into and now you’ve got a big fixed team reporting into. So all of a sudden you’ve got to figure out how you manage people, how you do their performance appraisals, how you give feedback properly, how you maintain performance, how you deal with poor performance. And the sooner you acquire that in your career, the better that’s going to be later on. Because I think being able to lead people effectively, as Alan was alluding to earlier on, is a really crucial skill set. Now I’ll give you a little example of somebody that we placed a little while ago. It’s a big financial services business, I won’t give you the name of it, the big financial services company. She is a very diminutive rather small Asian lady who became the first non executive director of a FTSE 100 company in the UK. It’s a very prestigious role. Now she worked her way up through a variety of roles that had both IT and operational responsibility in it. And very quickly broadened her experience out. So by the time that she’d been doing IT roles for 10 to 15 years or so, she was beginning to get other things given to her. For example, retail service and retail operations, call center management, property and procurement responsibility. And she ended up being the group director covering both IT and procurement and a few other areas for a big retail financial services business. Her next role after that took us straight into a chief operating officer role and we placed her as the Chief Information Officer in a much larger financial services organization. And when I was doing the search, I asked the Chief Executive, I said how will you know what good looks like in this role when I present somebody to you? And he said whichever CIO you present to me that I think can be moved off into the business and run a P&L later on within 2 or 3 years of delivering what we need here, that would be my characteristic of success. Very unusual and that is now what she’s doing. So she’s got broader responsibility and some P&L. So early on in her career, she had learned to influence and shape cross countries and in other organizations. And because she was slightly shorter and she wouldn’t mind me saying this, she doesn’t immediately make a big impact when you see her but she introduced agile techniques into this company that she’s working for now and it went down so well that the board of the company asked her to run a board level meeting with the non execs in an agile fashion and she got them all to stand up for 15 minutes and ran a meeting, a board level meeting for 15 minutes to time, covered all the points and it went down very well. And she’s now been asked to run a transformation program internationally across this organization. That’s all down to acquiring really good communication skills early on in her career.

The John Hancock reassignment program 26:39

Alan Hackney [00:26:39]:
If I could pick up on the first point that Tim just made about the diversity of experiences, just to give you an example, a practical example that we follow here at John Hancock that listeners may find useful. I 100% agree with the point that if you are put in a position where you have to reframe the questions that are necessary for you to succeed in a new environment, it forces you to be able to confront different problems. One of the things we do with John Hancock to force that issue is something that we call the reassignment program. This was specifically to get at a problem where the IT, the middle of management of the IT organization was stuck in sort of a time and grade mentality and were really missing the opportunity to diversify their career experiences. So we created this reassignment program where we took a finite number of managers, managers of decent sized teams of 50, 60 people and so forth and we simply moved them to a different business unit for a different function and it was a very orchestrated thing. We did this specifically because we wanted to break up a mode of thinking but what we observed the first time we did this and we’ve now made this sort of an institutional program now is that when you pull people out and you force them into a new environment where they have to look at what skills that they genuinely have that are transferable and can apply to the new problems. It generates a whole new set of thinking. It creates a lot of innovation. It also helps people realize that they’re able to solve problems in different contexts, contexts they didn’t even realize that they could solve. It really gives them a boost. Now, my desire of the program at John Hancock has been fantastic, very, very successful. We’ve done it more than once now. But of course what you really want is people to realize that they need to get this experience on their own, that they have to get themselves out of whatever environment they’re in today and continually diversify their experiences because that’s what’s going to lead to Tim’s second point which is people who are nimble or agile are able to solve problems in different contexts and that’s when it’s when you can exude that confidence so that people believe that they can solve different problems with your capabilities that you’re going to start to get those opportunities.

Sanjog Aul [00:30:14]:
Let’s explore the possibility of an organization taking the onus of developing leaders by putting in the programs, but then if they do have a phenomenal program but they don’t have people with the right DNA, what’s the expected outcome? And on the other hand, then there are companies who may not have anything particular and they either get lucky or if they’re not lucky, then the IT is doomed. So what is that healthy balance which you feel that we can strike so that there is a constant supply of the right type of leadership for the most companies that are out there in order for IT to start becoming successful in a more predictable basis, and most companies are able to make the most of those related investments.

Sanjog Aul [00:32:56]:
So, Tim, the question here would be is when we are trying to get a constant supply of the right type of leaders, and when I use the word supply, it’s not really we need loads of them, but we need the right number so that most organizations can make the most of IT. Where does the onus truly lie? Because we have heard about companies like GE, which is known for building leaders, and then many of those other companies who really look for people outside and perhaps look for some company like GE from where they can pull somebody as a leader and help them in their own organization. So what’s happening in the marketplace in your viewpoint, with respect to building leaders? Are we on our own as IT leaders or is there going to be a more pervasive awareness around having a program like what Alan mentioned he has in his own organization to churn out the right type of leaders from within as well?

The decline of academy companies 33:59

Tim Cook [00:33:59]:
I think it’s a very interesting area there and I think this is a very serious issue for the IT function at the moment. I think ironically, many years ago particularly in the 90s probably the back end of the 80s, there were many companies who were academy companies in the way that they trained and brought through their IT function. Procter and Gamble, Unilever, Mars to name but three, Ford very good. Those organizations were excellent at training up a really good generation of individuals, many of whom have gone on to become CIOs in other organizations. Now in a situation where technology is all pervasive and everybody is trying to do as much as they can do online, we’re intimately connected with technology whether we like it or not, you would think that the IT function therefore must be crucially important in an organization and very strategic and therefore it’s worth investing in training and bringing on the next generation. Well I don’t think, I’ll be very interested in Alan’s view on this, I don’t think there are very many academy companies out there anymore. I can’t point to very many organizations that invest properly in this function. I think that what’s happened is that with the growth of outsourcing and so on that you find good talent in places like Accenture or IBM where people are coming on a structured training program and they learn the fundamentals of program and project management, and then after they’ve been in that organization for 5 to 10 years or whatever, they then go off and do a line role somewhere else. I think that organizations need to invest seriously in this area. And one of the things that they can do I think in terms of training programs for people is to make sure that individuals get international exposure. There are two countries where from the outside you would think the technical function must be fantastic. We must hire from these two countries. One of those is the US and the other one is India. India has a great richness of technically highly capable individuals, but many of those have not traveled outside India. The US has a wonderful history of excellence in this function and has generated some of the world’s greatest CIOs in there. But many people in this function don’t travel outside the US. And so getting some exposure to a completely different culture, whether it’s Europe, whether it’s Asia, wherever it is, I think it’s really important. And I don’t mean by that simply running an operation from your own country that’s international, running IT infrastructure from London, for example, or from New York. That’s not what I mean. I mean, if you’re an American, going and living and working in India or living and working in Switzerland or France or somewhere else in there, profoundly changes the way that you approach problem solving and gives you much better handle on dealing with ambiguity and those skills are really important when you’re persuading and influencing around the boardroom table when you’re a CIO.

Sanjog Aul [00:37:17]:
Alan, what triggered the kind of program that you’ve created or your organization created to nurture some of those diamonds in the rough and/or hone them to become the leaders that they can become?

How GE embeds leadership training 37:31

Alan Hackney [00:37:31]:
Well it’s interesting you asked that question. Having just mentioned GE just a second ago, I’m a product of that GE environment, spent more than half my career coming out of university in that environment. One of the reasons that I think GE is held up on a list of companies who are able to nurture and grow leadership talent is that it’s embedded in the fabric of the culture of that organization. I’ll give you a very specific example that when you come into GE as an entry level hire, whether that’s in the technology function or the finance function and the HR, the technical sales functions, there is a training program that you go into which has its roots going back years. The technology management training program, which is still at GE today, was started 32 years ago and it was modeled after the financial management program which was started about 100 years ago. So if you imagine how deeply rooted in the culture these training concepts for programs that have existed for a century. I mean it’s just, your mind’s eye goes quickly to this must be really important to how GE operates. What happens in these training programs is precisely what we were talking about earlier which is you automatically get exposed to people who are in different industries, different geographies, different continents, the native language is a different language than your own. Almost from day 1 you start to realize that the world is a small, small place, that you need to be able to interact across industries, you need to be able to interact across cultures, across geographies, and then that mindset pervades your early career and then as you become a manager you start hiring people who have these attributes and then you become a manager of managers and you’re holding managers accountable for developing those attributes and it just feeds on itself. With that as background, to answer your question, I think what I feared was that this wasn’t happening at John Hancock. People were stuck in a time and grade mentality and you were climbing a ladder within a very narrow silo and people were missing the opportunity to broaden their view whether that’s to work in a different business unit or to do what Tim just suggested which is get out of Boston and go to our facilities. We have facilities in China. We have facilities in the Philippines. We have great relationships that we nurture in India. We have a lot of functions in Canada. So get out of Boston, go to these other places. It changes the way you view problems.

Tim Cook [00:41:08]:
Now, Alan, you should have a point of view on this. If I remember rightly, didn’t you work in Japan for a bit?

Alan Hackney [00:41:14]:
I did. I did.

Tim Cook [00:41:17]:
What were your learnings from that? How does that change your viewpoint about this function and how to get traction in it?

What working in Japan changed 41:25

Alan Hackney [00:41:25]:
Well that’s a great question. I think the American psyche of just full frontal confrontation of issues and problems very clinical and direct simply doesn’t work inside the Japanese culture. Japanese are not direct people. I learned the word nemawashi. Nemawashi is the problem solving through a third party and many of the great decisions are made through the concept of nemawashi. That’s not anything you’re going to learn in America. Once you figure out the power of how to get things done in that environment, that does work in other cultures. It works in America. It works in Europe. It works in Latin America and other places. It just changed my whole outlook. It wouldn’t have done, to your point, I wouldn’t have gotten the same place if I just swooped in like a seagull, did a project and left. That has a certain amount of value and it’s better than not going at all. But boy, living on the ground, that’s a real eye opening experience.

Tim Cook [00:42:51]:
I agree with you. And I made a mistake, not so long ago. I was doing a search to put a chief operating officer into a bank, a financial services institution in Saudi Arabia. And we narrowed the candidate pool down and we had a great list of candidates we thought. And the individual that we selected and I thought was going to be fantastic for this was somebody who had never lived and worked outside an Anglo Saxon environment. So he’d either been in the UK or he’d been in the US, one or the other. And theoretically, he could do the job. But actually when he went over to that environment, it was so profoundly different from anything that he had seen before that his reference points were nonexistent. And he tried to create his own reference points and those didn’t work for the Saudis. And he only lasted about twelve to 18 months in the role before they and he decided that it just wasn’t right for him. If we had been tested a little bit more the cultural affinity around that, then he might have lasted for a bit longer. But I do think that in trying to identify what’s going to work, to your question around maturity models and how do you get some guarantee of success, what have organizations got to do to produce outstanding leaders? But I think that organizations need to have in a kind of formal sort of way an opportunity for their rising stars to go into an environment which they haven’t seen before and to learn how to adapt as quickly as possible in that environment and then perhaps bring them back into the mothership a little bit later on after 18 months, 2 years or a little bit longer?

Sanjog Aul [00:44:39]:
And when we do talk about the different programs and/or different initiatives that companies may be working on, what could be construed as a good and/or not as good a program? Because from a qualitative angle, we could give it a lip service or perhaps we put some budget aside to say, okay. Let’s do a bunch of training programs, etcetera. But if it is not structured properly, if the academy is not set properly, then the results would be less than stellar. So what is it that we should expect if an organization wants to see a leadership maturing through different stages? What is that school that should be created in an organization or even outside for it to have the desired results.

Sanjog Aul [00:47:38]:
So, Alan, based on what you just created in your organization, and it seems to be working, do you have any suggestions on anyone else who’s going to try to do it just by getting inspired by listening to this show or otherwise? What should be done in order for that program to be successful? And even as we were talking during the break, something radical has to happen here. Not the same old, same old and expect new results. What’s new that you’d like to see happen in this so called academic to build an academy to churn out the right level of IT leaders?

Building an academy of experiences 48:16

Alan Hackney [00:48:16]:
Yes. So when I think of an academy, I think in the context that you’re asking, it’s not so much about school, if you will, or a particular ladder of training or a particular checklist of experiences. When I think of academies and I think of the companies like we were talking about a moment ago, the GEs of this world that create these great leaders, it’s about having programs in place that seek to get people experiences where they can use their talents in different ways to solve different problems. There are so many different dimensions that you can pursue. We have been talking about the international dimension, which in this day and age I think is absolutely vital. I don’t know of any significant company in any industry that doesn’t have some connection with an offshore or overseas affiliate or vendor or supplier in one fashion or another. But there’s other dimensions. You can work on running an operation or you can work on new business development and more strategic issues. You can work in larger companies across different business unit lines. You can manage large teams or you can move into staff functions. The key, in my view, the key to success is that there’s a willingness of the organization to first of all ensure that its people are moving through a variety of different experiences. Secondly, there’s a willingness of the organization to accept somebody into a role where they haven’t done that precise work previously because I think that’s the other missing ingredient in this. If you want somebody to learn, you can’t just hire somebody or promote them or move them into a role where they’ve already done that work previously. You’ve got to get people past that. Those are the two ingredients. It’s the willingness to move, in my view, and it’s the willingness of people to accept the fact that when somebody comes in, you’re going to have to develop some piece of their competency or knowledge for them to be successful.

Infancy, adolescence, and adulthood of IT 51:25

Tim Cook [00:51:25]:
So I would agree with those. I mean I think the question to ask is also of the organization. You know what stage is the organization at? And I think that when my colleague Eric Sigurdsson and I talk about this, we often think of organizations in one of three phases. They’re either at infancy, adolescence or adulthood. An organization where the IT is in infancy is a place where IT is back office only. There’s no partnership with the business. The IT functions often run by the CFO, it’s never considered innovative and there’s always a focus on reducing costs. An adolescent organization is one where IT is beginning to build a reputation, it’s delivering against its ROI objectives, it’s top grading its IT talent and it’s getting a bit of visibility at the senior level. And an adult organization for this function, I believe, is where the CIO has got a seat at that table. He and others are translating business issues into technology solutions. They are bringing things to the CEO’s attention. They’re coming up with ideas. They’re seeing what technology can do to help the business. They’re engaging in the strategy side. And also the businesses are recognizing the commercial value of the CIO and adding other things like shared services, supply chain procurement and other bits and pieces. So I think that if an organization is clear where it is in its life and its maturity, then IT can fit into that. And in addition to the very good points that Alan was making there, I think the only other one I would add is that it is okay to fail from time to time. I mean doing a job and stretching yourself means that you’re not going to get everything right all of the time. And providing that you’re learning from mistakes and not repeating the same mistake, then you will be improving as a leader. And I think an intelligent organization that is trying to coach and mentor and develop its staff particularly in this area will put people in harm’s way and will expect them to fail from time to time because that is part of what is going to turn them into being an outstanding leader. I once had a client who was rolling out a big SAP program and he said to me, look, I want you to find me a program director that’s failed 3 times because by the time they do it the 4th time they would have seen everything that’s gone wrong on these big international programs and they’ll get it right.

Sanjog Aul [00:53:53]:
Very interesting. In fact, one of the examples I remember where somebody told that every CIO and/or every consultant who truly turns out to be good is at least someone who got fired from the client side or from the company where they worked once. How true do you think, Alan, that is? Of course, I’m not sure what has happened to you or what you’ve heard from others, but is there immunity provided to those people who are trying to do the best they can and still if they fail and if they get fired, that the doors don’t close on them?

Alan Hackney [00:54:29]:
Yes. So certainly, I wouldn’t be advocating taking action that’s going to lead to you getting terminated. And the reality is, if you are part of what makes a great IT leader is managing risk. If you’re taking too much risk such that you put aspects of the business in jeopardy, well that’s not good either. I’m just finishing a great book by Walter Isaacson about Steve Jobs. It’s very, very popular right now. There’s a guy who failed his way to fame and infamy. Many of his early attempts were gross failures and yet Steve ultimately proved to be one of the captains of IT. Failing is good because if you don’t fail, you’re not taking risks. But to the point, I think one thing people have to realize is that when you take risk and it doesn’t go as well as you want, you’ve got to realize when to cut your losses and when to think about absorbing the learning and moving on to the next challenge. Sometimes that’s hard for people to realize. It requires a fair amount of self-awareness. Sometimes that means that you’re going to have to consider yourself looking at a different company. Get a fresh start based on a fresh outlook and not carry the millstone of a failure with you but use that as a basis for why you would be a great problem solver in the next place.

Tim Cook [00:56:47]:
Yes, I agree with that because I think you can also draw energy from that. There’s a very good book written by a guy called Tim Harford called Adapt: Why Success Always Starts With Failure. And if you’ve had a problem and something hasn’t worked out the way it should have done for you, Alan’s right. I mean, you can always move somewhere else where the environment is going to play to your strengths. But I also think that you can draw energy from some of these things. I don’t want to be over focused on failure here. It’s just that in order to be successful in this role, you’re going to take some cul-de-sacs here and then you’re going to go down some roads that aren’t going to lead anywhere. Those are okay, but you don’t do it all of the time and you manage risk properly. But those are important because that’s how you’re going to learn how to adapt to probe ambiguities and to be equipped with better questions so that you are a better leader of this function in the future.

Sanjog Aul [00:57:44]:
On behalf of the show and our listeners, thank you so much, Alan and Tim for sharing your thoughts. It seems like there may not be a rule book and/or a structured leadership model, leadership maturity model, which will lead these individual organizations as well as individuals to the predictable successful leadership role. But definitely, the environment does matter and there is an appeal to individual organizations that they should set up some programs and also appeal to individual leaders that they have to take the time to go internationally if possible and get the right type of exposure.

Contributors

Allan Hackney

Allan Hackney, SVP & Chief Information Officer, John Hancock Financial Services

Allan Hackney is SVP & Chief Information Officer – John Hancock Financial Services with oversight of the company’s technical teams. In this role, Allan is accountable for developing and executing strategies that increase productivit... More   View all posts
Tim Cook

Tim Cook, Co-lead Information Officers Practice in the UK, Russell Reynolds

Tim Cook co-leads the firm's Information Officers Practice and runs the HR Practice in London. He conducts senior-level assignments within the technology sector, with a particular focus on CIO & HR roles. He has over 10 years of executi... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

FWS - AWSMarketplaceFreshservice MPU 300X224
Allan Hackney