IT Strategy & Business Alignment • Finance • Governance • Innovation

Rethinking The 80-20 Budget Rule!

Rethinking The 80-20 Budget Rule!

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Jon Walton (City and County of San Francisco), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that, in Jon Walton’s view, a government cannot fund innovation until it cuts what it spends keeping existing systems running. Walton, Chief Information Officer of the City and County of San Francisco, said the government runs a 6.8 billion dollar citywide budget and faced 300 to 500 million dollars in shortfalls each year, which pushed the old 80-20 operations-to-innovation split toward 90-10. He concluded that the fix is partnership and transparency, not asking for money in isolation, so a governance council of 11 department heads, their CFOs, the budget officer and the mayor reviews all IT spend in open meetings before budget season. He said cutting operational cost rarely returns full savings to IT, with about 70 cents of every saved dollar going to the general fund deficit and only 10 to 15 cents reinvested, yet moves such as abandoning the aging data center for colocation, shifting 16,000 users to hosted email off Lotus Notes, and building modular, line-item budgets still moved money toward new work.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Jon Walton, Chief Information Officer of the City and County of San Francisco, about rethinking the 80-20 IT budget rule, where roughly 80 percent of IT money keeps existing systems running and only about 20 percent goes to new work. Walton explains how budget shortfalls pushed that split closer to 90-10, and why IT was historically buried in department budgets as an expense rather than a strategic investment. He describes the moves he used to shift the mix, including a citywide IT governance council, open budgeting with the mayor and finance office, asset and portfolio management, colocation and hosted email, and pushing application development out to departments. The conversation also covers tying IT costs to projects the public values and reallocating savings from operations into innovation.

Contributors

  • Jon Walton, Chief Information Officer, City and County of San Francisco

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Jon Walton, Chief Information Officer of the City and County of San Francisco, says most IT budgets lock the large majority of money into keeping existing systems running, leaving little for new work. He notes that with budget cuts the old 80-20 split of operations to innovation has slipped closer to 90-10 in some organizations he talks to.
  • Jon Walton argues that budgeting in the City and County of San Francisco has to be an open partnership rather than backroom deals. He credits several months of public meetings before the budget talks with making the final decisions smoother, because every policymaker already understood where the shortfalls were.
  • Jon Walton, Chief Information Officer of the City and County of San Francisco, says the way out is to cut operational costs and reallocate the savings, even though IT rarely keeps all of it. He explains that for every dollar he saves, about 70 cents goes back to the city general fund deficit and he may keep only 10 to 15 cents to reinvest.
  • Jon Walton created a citywide IT governance council in the City and County of San Francisco with 11 department heads, their CFOs, the budget officer, the mayor and the board president to review IT spending together. He says showing the group how much of the spend is operational versus new projects educated policymakers about the unfunded demand for innovation.
  • Jon Walton describes abandoning the City and County of San Francisco’s aging city-owned data center and moving to a colocation site instead of repeatedly asking for tens of millions of dollars to fix it. He frames the move to a new business model as a transformational step that saved money while improving service.
  • Jon Walton says moving 16,000 users off an old Lotus Notes system to hosted email in the City and County of San Francisco cut cost while improving the experience, because running the infrastructure in-house would cost three to four times as much. He also kept a small core team and used crowdsourcing and hackathons with public volunteers to build over 80 open source applications for the city at no cost.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: rethinking the 80-20 IT budget rule
  • 0:46 budget shortfalls in a city and county government
  • 1:28 budgeting as both art and science
  • 5:29 why most IT money is locked in operations
  • 7:14 how IT became a buried expense
  • 10:12 a citywide IT governance council
  • 12:44 abandoning the data center for colocation
  • 18:10 asset and portfolio management as the foundation
  • 24:18 a la carte budgets and line item choices
  • 31:25 using cloud economics to cut operational cost
  • 38:48 pushing application development out to departments
  • 49:21 what the business expects from the shift

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: rethinking the 80-20 IT budget rule 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:00]:
Today’s topic is Rethinking the 80-20 Rule, and our guest for today’s show is Jon Walton, who’s the CIO of the City and County of San Francisco, California. Good morning, Jon.

Sanjog Aul [00:00:37]:
The city and county of San Francisco is truly lucky to have you as a leader who is helping them lead IT. So how’s life and work there?

budget shortfalls in a city and county government 0:46

Jon Walton [00:00:46]:
It’s great. We obviously have our budget challenges germane to this conversation. Over the last few years, we’ve had budget shortfalls here in the city and county. We have about a $6.8 billion annual budget citywide for all services we provide, and unfortunately we’ve had in the neighborhood of 300 to $500 million in shortfalls every year in our general fund revenue. So it’s been a challenging time, a time of challenges and opportunities to try to figure out how to make things better while our budgets are decreasing.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:16]:
Now, when it comes to the very budgeting, do you think it is still an art, or you, the people, other decision makers, have really been able to convert that into a science?

budgeting as both art and science 1:28

Jon Walton [00:01:28]:
I think it’s both an art and a science. Most importantly, my observation is it’s got to be a partnership for IT to be successful, and for most departments in government to be successful, it’s really tough to go alone through a budget process and have a meaningful conversation with the folks that make the policy decisions, the budget decisions at the highest level in the organization. So you have to create a forum where the budget discussion is a partnership, not only among your internal staff, but with your external stakeholders and agencies, about what are you trying to achieve, and really having a plan, a strategy about how you’re going to meet budget shortfalls and at the same time continue to support your operations and make things better and achieve some level of innovation and improvement at the same time. So I think it’s an art in the sense that sometimes it takes some artistic ability to paint a picture of where you’re going and some faith to jump off that cliff and to take some risks, but it is a science, and I think you have to make as transparent a process as possible. The old days of the perception of how government works, a lot of backroom deals, is dead. A lot of it’s got to be done in public hearings.

Jon Walton [00:02:37]:
People have to be very aware of the decisions that are being made, where the shortfalls are and how you’re going to balance the budget, and once you go through that, we had actually, this year when we just got done with the budget last month, probably the most, or should I say the least indiso conversations when it finally got to the final decision making process, because everyone had been so plugged into the whole process that they knew exactly where they were when we got there.

Sanjog Aul [00:03:02]:
So one is the process of building the budget. Another is to actually live it, and when you do live it, do you see major deviation from what you anticipated, and if you do indeed see at times, would you attribute that to poor planning slash budgeting, or is it just a dynamic business environment that we are in?

Jon Walton [00:03:24]:
Building a budget, like you said, and planning a budget, that’s probably where the art of it is. There’s always plans, and I think everybody tries to make the best plans possible. Currently here in the city and county we plan year over year. It’s a one year budget. We’re moving towards a two year budget. The nexus between planning and living the budget comes down to you can’t always anticipate the visa things are going to happen during the year. So you might have a disaster, you might have some large federal law passed, or you might have something happen after the budget’s been passed. Any private sector, when I worked in private sector, you have somewhat more flexibility to react to external forces, to adjust to those types of things. The weakness in how we budget and plan in government is we are very down to the penny.

Jon Walton [00:04:17]:
We’re going to spend a dollar here, two dollars there. At the end of the day, our budget process, we’re very specific about exactly where our homes are going to be sent. So in living it, when something comes along that you hadn’t anticipated, you couldn’t see on the horizon, affects you during the middle of a budget year when there is no money left, it’s all been allocated. Then really the challenge is how do you have that honest conversation about, okay, we said we were going to do these things, but because of some change that happened that we didn’t hit coming or some impact on us, we’re going to have to only do three of the five and reallocate funds here, and that’s always concerning, because everyone goes to the budget process saying, okay, we’ll come back in a year and there’ll be these five things done, and it just doesn’t always turn out that way, and again the important part of that is you have to continue to have this all rotation throughout the year

Jon Walton [00:05:08]:
about the budget. The budget used to be, you look, talk about it once a year for a month or two and then forget about it. In my mind, when we get done with a budget, I take about a month off and then we’re right back to talking about next year’s budget again, because it’s almost a year round, like all about, what money did we get, how are we spending it, what’s our plan for next year. It’s really a continuous process at this point.

why most IT money is locked in operations 5:29

Sanjog Aul [00:05:29]:
So with company budgets, and of course every company does it, and specific to IT spend, the common denominator looks like that most of it is pre-allocated to the IT operations and you got very little money for innovation and projects, and almost nothing. In fact, in the past show we discussed about play money, and most CIOs in one voice said I do not have play money to basically try new things. Until the time I try new things, how do you expect me to help innovate? What’s the situation which you see in your organization, as well as what you heard in your peer group?

Jon Walton [00:06:11]:
That is the common theme when I think about it and I reflect back, at least in my view, on how IT came about in government. At least in government, you had, over the hundreds of years that the government, local governments have evolved in the US, when the government started, IT obviously wasn’t a service that was provided, and so most government organizational structures and budgets are built around traditional governmental models. Every government can relate to police departments and fire departments and public works departments and street departments and things like that. What has happened of course in the 70s, 80s and 90s with the emergence of technology, that became oftentimes initially centralized and then with distributed computing pushed out to the departments. The weakness of that from a budgetary standpoint is that IT being buried in departments’ budgets individually was often viewed as an expense, like paper and paperclips and things like that. So IT was funded as an expense and not really a strategic investment.

how IT became a buried expense 7:14

Jon Walton [00:07:14]:
The downfall of that approach, and we talk about the 80-20 rule and most of the funds, in some organizations I talk to now with budget cuts it’s probably more of a 90-10 rule. What’s happened is they’ve built this entire infrastructure internally, similar to building roads. The example I always use when I talk to the policymakers is IT in my mind is no different than a building department or a public works department, in the sense that we’re building infrastructure, we’re installing fiber optics, we’re installing phone systems, we’re installing computer systems, we’re building data centers, and because that was an expense no one acknowledged at the top line, it wasn’t individual top line budgetary items, it was buried in the expense accounts of departments. There was a lack of understanding of when the bill was going to become due on replacing a lot of that infrastructure, the increasing cost of maintenance of aging infrastructure, and so we had less and less money.

Jon Walton [00:08:10]:
I think IT initially, probably in the early days of IT when we all started, that was all about innovation. Every time you bought a new computer that was innovating, you got a new computer, everyone was excited to see that new computer come in, the first time you installed an application everybody could use that was innovation. But what happened over time was we ended up spending more and more of our time and more and more and more money maintaining what we had already bought, and so it’s created this huge need in government organizations to continue to invest in supporting and maintaining the old systems, and because our budgets are finite, because we don’t generate our own revenue in IT and government, we have less and less of that money to spend on new things. So you really have to find a way to break out of that downwards spiral of all the money you have goes towards maintaining the old.

Jon Walton [00:08:58]:
You have to find a way, knowing that you’re not going to get new money, to reduce your operational costs and reallocate some of those funds to do new and innovative things that continue to move the organization forward.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:12]:
So one is to find the money, another is to make use of the increase, if at all you get one from one year to another. Even at an inflation rate, if you get an increase in your budget, still the lion’s share of that goes into the operational side. Now it’s up to us, as IT leaders, you can very well not stay transparent with respect to that increase and say, okay, I’m going to use it, I’m going to deliver the value that you need, you shave off internally wherever you can from the operational budget, put that into the new projects and make IT really deliver value, because if you keep burning the candle on both ends, you do not have money for projects and your operational expenses are going to increase, and because you’re not creating as much value, because there is no innovation, your executive management loses faith and does not see that you deserve more money.

Sanjog Aul [00:10:06]:
It’s like a vicious cycle, and the CIO and the crew is the one which is going to be left holding the bag.

a citywide IT governance council 10:12

Jon Walton [00:10:12]:
Let me address that in two different ways and give you some examples of how we’ve tried to solve that challenge here in San Francisco. One is, like we talked about earlier, it can’t be IT versus other departments. You can’t always be in a posture of trying to defend your budget or fight with other departments for the scraps that are left over of money at the end of every budget year. So one of the things we’ve done to try to build support to this idea of understanding IT, recognizing the value of IT to the entire organization, getting support to invest in new technologies, is we created a governance council in the city and county that consists of the CIO, 11 department heads from each department around the city, including their CFOs, the budget officer for the city and county, the mayor, and the president of the board of supervisors, and prior to even starting the budget talks, we probably spend several months in open public meetings with this group talking about, citywide, what the IT spend is, how much of that spend is operational expenses, what the proposals are for new projects, for the innovative ideas, and not surprisingly, the lion’s share that we can show financially is going to operations below the fold, but it starts to educate the policymakers and the budgetary decision makers. We have this huge demand for new innovative ideas.

Jon Walton [00:11:45]:
We have all these ideas on how to make government better, how to deliver services better through innovative and new technologies, but there’s a cost to that, and there’s other millions and millions of dollars that are unfunded need, but then they start to get through this process of how we could make government better, how investing in technology is good, and then they become engaged in the conversation of, is new money available, are there grant funds available, are there some other types of revenue sources we can tap into to pay for some of those new innovative ideas, and they also become very engaged in the operational cost discussion and how to reduce those operational costs, and frankly, when you reduce operational costs, I’ve never seen that we ever get 100% of the money back. It’s usually an agreement that if I save a dollar, 70 cents will go back to closing the deficit in the city general fund deficit. I might get 10 or 15 cents out of every dollar I save back to reinvest

abandoning the data center for colocation 12:44

Jon Walton [00:12:44]:
but I still consider that a worthwhile endeavor. One of the examples of this for us, at least, was we had a data center down the street from our office that we had put in place back in the 80s, aging infrastructure, and we knew that we needed significant investments, tens of millions of dollars, to improve this data center, and we had this conversation for several years and we were initially going through the traditional government process of, we have a failing data center, please give us $15 million. We have a failing data center. Okay, we’ll take $10 million. We have a failing data center, please give us $9 million. So we were going through the traditional process of just asking for money, knowing full well in the budget situation we’re in that the money didn’t exist

Jon Walton [00:13:25]:
and I think everyone was frustrated, because we knew as IT professionals we needed to have a good data center and we needed to at the same time find a way to save money and invest in this data center. So we had to do something that traditionally in San Francisco we wouldn’t have done. We abandoned our city owned data center and went to a colocation site, and that was for us, believe it or not, a transformational step, to do something that we’d not done traditionally and to stop asking for money and go to an entirely new business model to save money.

Sanjog Aul [00:17:26]:
So the question here is IT portfolio management and IT asset management. These are the two specific areas where you would go to get a handle on what do you truly need to do and what do you truly need to maintain, and it seems like both of these areas are grey for most companies, and even the leaders are always looking at, what can I do better, how can I play the venture capitalist, if you will, or an investment banker, and make sure I allocate things right, and if we do not have enough hold in these two areas then we keep going to research organizations and try to get other form of sources. So is this the best we can do?

asset and portfolio management as the foundation 18:10

Jon Walton [00:18:10]:
I would agree that asset management, portfolio management is one of the keys to a successful IT budget discussion. When we talk about building credibility, having a dialogue about how we spend our money, I know when I came to San Francisco three years ago there was really a lack of understanding of where dollars were spent and we had to go through a very painful process. There was an intuitive sense that we were spending a lot of money on IT in the city and county and there was frustration that we weren’t getting our money to work, if you want to put it that way. Out of those dollars spent, people didn’t see the innovation, the new things, and we had to implement both a portfolio management system for our projects so that when people received money for a project there was a level of accountability and follow through that people could track and say, I gave you $1 million to do this project, I can see that you did it, it got done, and the results that you said would happen happened. Similarly, we’ve had to really spend a lot of time around our discussion around our assets and our contracts related to the maintenance of our assets, because again, because it was buried as an expense, it had surprised a lot of the organization as to how much money we truly were spending on maintaining old infrastructure through maintenance contracts, through break fixes, and because we didn’t have a citywide view at one time about what that total cost was, it had simply snuck up on us, until we started really implementing controls and understanding, do we need another server, what is a replacement cycle for PCs. I think budget processes are,

Jon Walton [00:19:50]:
when we talk about art and science, the art of it is having a compelling story to tell about, we really need this new thing or we need to reduce costs over here, and be able to connect with the business users and policymakers, but the science of it is, as good as your story is, as compelling as a story might be, you’re competing in the IT world in government with other very important things. If you want a dollar, there’s probably a library that needs that dollar as well, or a community center or a hospital or a police station, and so as compelling as your story is, I would argue that it’s going to be hard for an IT professional to have a more compelling story than putting a police officer on the street, perhaps, but it’s also, what we talked about, is data driven, and if you have good data where you show, if you give me a dollar to change something I can give you $2 back, that data part of it and the analytical part of it, that’s a key piece of the puzzle I see professionals need to get comfortable with, and accept the fact that we need to be able to account for every penny of where we’re spending our dollars and be able to match our compelling stories about why we want to do things differently with good data to back it up.

Sanjog Aul [00:21:02]:
Now, if you were to really look at the collaborative budgeting process, one is that we do our internal number crunching, we take it to the finance department and other folks who are decision makers, and then they take a fresh pair of eyes and look into it, slice and dice it with, I would not say 100% trust, but perhaps with a healthy skepticism, and then that could result in certain important pieces which might get cut, and here what we are trying to essentially say is that the things which you need to do to create value, they have a chance to get cut down, versus if you started that whole process where we said, what do you need to take your organization to the next level, maybe a government or a private sector organization, and then from there the budget is truly built and not a tennis match between the final executive management or constituents, policymakers, as an IT leader, then do you not think that you will be much better off at the end result level?

Jon Walton [00:22:13]:
Two things about that. One, I would say if you’re building a budget internally in government and then taking it to someone else to assess, I think you’re right, and that’s the traditional way of how we’ve done it in government, that we would, in our central IT department, build a budget, we’d come up with these plans, and then we would lob it over to the budget office or the board of supervisors, the mayor’s office, and say, look at this great plan, and again, they would weigh it against all their other priorities, and you’re right, it would be cut, and sometimes only a little and sometimes a lot, and then we would feel frustrated that we couldn’t realize this vision that we had painted. The thing we’ve changed now in our government is we don’t do that anymore. We don’t build an internal budget by ourselves.

Jon Walton [00:22:58]:
We spend months working directly with the mayor’s office and the budget office, the finance office, the chief CFO for the city and county, building our budget in a very open process where we say, here’s exactly where we’re spending our money, here’s the changes we want to make to our budget, here’s the investments we want to make and the reductions we want to make. So when we get to the end of that dialogue, there is no education that has occurred, the education has happened all the way along. So they still need to be critical, they still need to make decisions about, are we going to get everything we ask for,

Jon Walton [00:23:30]:
implement all of our plans, but it starts from a basis of their understanding and trust that they understand exactly how our budget is built and where the trade offs are. Again, the historic way we’ve done it, at least in the city, that we’ve had to change is we used to do what I call package deals, give me $100 million so I can do these 20 things, and when they say we don’t have that much money, we’ll give you X, we’ll cut it. We talk about how you never usually get all you ask for. We would in frustration throw our hands in the air and say, either you’re going to give me all of it or I can’t articulate back to you what that reduction means in terms of a reduction in our proposal. So we build very modular budgets now. We might have 10 projects, but each of them has a line item.

a la carte budgets and line item choices 24:18

Jon Walton [00:24:18]:
We’re very clear about which ones are interrelated and which ones can stand alone, and I refer to it as an a la carte menu. The board, the policymakers, the Chief Financial Officer for the city, if they have to make reductions in our proposals about what we want to do, they can very easily do line item veto items on there and understand, okay, then that isn’t going to happen, we’ll defer that a year, we’re going to have to change the whole idea there, but instead of it being a package deal, take it or leave it, and if you don’t take all of it, I’m going to become frustrated and walk away from the table and everyone’s going to feel like a loser, I think we have a much better process now where people have a better understanding of what our budget looks like and how we can adjust our budget through the budget process.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:59]:
Now you use the word reduction a couple of times as you were describing how this process works, and of course you are not alone, and this is a common theme, if you will, when it comes to getting money for IT, and knowing that IT has, at least traditionally and even lately, got the opportunity to make a strategic difference, the eyes and the sharp pencils that come, eyes looking for where can I reduce or shave off some money from IT, and pencils, sharp pencils which come to say, how can I remove a line item, are they doing the best justice to what IT could have delivered back? Do you think this is directly attributing to how the IT leader has handled the relationship, so that they do not take the budget and then get all the main items which actually could help strategically make a difference to that business or that organization struck off right off the bat?

Jon Walton [00:25:56]:
I think, being dreamers, idealists as we are in IT, a lot of times in our organizations, and this is probably another part of the conversation, we’re a highly decentralized organization. So in city government here we’re approximately 50 departments, 23,000 employees, and though I’m the central CIO and have a central IT department, it’s very decentralized here in the city. My budget, for example, is less than 30% of the total IT spend entity wide. Many other departments have their own IT managers, their own IT staff, their own IT budgets embedded in their own departments, and so one of the things that I’ve noticed, to be a successful leader in IT, one is the partnership that we talked about. In the past

Jon Walton [00:26:49]:
there was a competition between the central IT department and other departments for funding, and we all know the economy worldwide and the US economy is not as healthy and robust as we’ve seen in past years. So we’re all faced with budget deficits. So when you see those cuts, I think you have to have been proactive all year long as an executive, as a CIO, C level executive, building those relationships with the other departments. We talked right before the break about our data center. One of the other things we did, instead of the central IT department continuing to invest in building infrastructure, we actually, at one of our partner departments who has its own revenue sources, isn’t dependent on taxpayer dollars to invest in IT things, we actually partnered with them where they’re making up the upfront investment of some significant infrastructure improvement for the entire city that we’re going to pay them back over a 20 year period. So there’s a relationship, and then being able to connect with the C level executives across the organization, are critical to getting significant budget things moved forward.

Sanjog Aul [00:27:56]:
Now with respect to the new paradigms, maybe cloud, maybe shared services, another form where you are hoping to create transparency on what is the money being spent on, because anytime when we are not clear about something it introduces doubt and people think, oh, there’s way too much money being spent, which I’m not privy to, so that transparency that you can bring, one is to of course build a relationship and trust, but more importantly, do you think this new computing paradigm is actually going to help you to say, okay, I will tell you exactly, per user basis, how much are we spending, and on the operational side we’re able to take care of that more transparently, and then perhaps you will then be bestowed with another stash which you can put towards projects, or do you think that’s still dreaming?

Sanjog Aul [00:31:20]:
So Jon, take it away with what we just discussed.

using cloud economics to cut operational cost 31:25

Jon Walton [00:31:25]:
So cloud computing, one of my patents, and I just have to talk about it for a minute because you mentioned it before we went to break, and I do think it’s significant to government right now, and I have a lot of friends still in the private sector, we talk about it a lot, but government is oftentimes a low adopter sometimes of technologies and initiatives, and this is one. Every time I go to a government conference or I talk and give speeches, we always talk about cloud computing. First of all, I don’t think cloud computing is new, it has been rebranded, it’s being sold better now and I think it’s actually being delivered better now than it was previously, but I think we would all as IT professionals say cloud computing isn’t that innovative an idea. Perhaps the aired cloud model, the thin client shared cloud model, is now a more proven technology that we’re all, as IT professionals, more comfortable adopting

Jon Walton [00:32:21]:
but I argue it was on the consumer side, where you see where Google went with Gmail and a lot of other technologies, that the consumers adopted or helped prove out the model, now companies and governments are able to adopt it. Cloud computing to me really is about the economics, the bottom line economics. So we talk about the art and science, the science part of cloud computing is bottom line. I have not seen, and I’ve spent a lot of time with my staff talking to other organizations, any way that I can effectively deliver certain services internally running my own infrastructure. From a scale standpoint, I can’t build the infrastructure, maintain the infrastructure, have a redundant infrastructure for disasters, than adopting a data center-out infrastructure model for certain things, because it’s just dollars and cents, it’s going to cost me three to four times as much to build my own infrastructure.

Jon Walton [00:33:17]:
So a year ago when we were having a budget discussion in the city, there was that common sense conversation we had at a budget meeting where someone said, god, we have seven emails to this, and one CIO said, no, why would you have seven emails if there’s no benefit, no common sense benefit to a city having seven separate email systems, there’s no logic to it, but then once you get past the emotional common sense and you really get into the dollars and cents, what does it really cost us, bottom line, to buy our own email servers, to maintain those servers, to staff those servers, to back the servers up, to have a DR plan for each of those servers, and you look at models like Gmail or the hosted exchange model, you can’t compete with that. Now in government there’s security, there’s privacy, there’s confidentiality things, all the things you need to address, you can address practically with those vendors

Jon Walton [00:34:09]:
but from a pure dollars and cents standpoint, bottom line is you have to seriously consider that model, and when you talk about saving money and making improvements at the same time, I’m taking 16,000 users off an old thick client Lotus Notes solution that no one liked. Now personally, I think Lotus Notes ran fine, we ran it here for years, it was rock solid, it delivered us good, but it was expensive and my users didn’t like it. I can tell you I’ve never had an easier project in my life. When my staff go out now and get people on hosted exchange, my customers are ecstatic. I’m saving the city money and there’s

Jon Walton [00:34:46]:
I’m building this relationship with my customers now where they’re like, god, how are you guys able to do this, you’re giving me this great product, I love it, I was years behind, I’ve got all these great tools now, how are you guys able to do this and at the same time be meeting your budget reduction goals, and it’s really satisfying to me, I know my staff and a lot of the executives in the city, to actually be able to do a project that has such a good feeling about it. We’re making things better for the users and they’re really happy about it, at the same time be able to simultaneously meet our budget reduction goals, which I think is rare, to find those projects, that when you do, I think you have to celebrate.

Sanjog Aul [00:35:22]:
Now, with that said, do you think when you get the CFO or whosoever is basically involved in it, do you think they are ready to collaborate with you to make sure that, while you bring these new technologies and then you explain to them what are the new other projects that you want to do, do they give you a blind ear or do they actually listen and then look at the line item versus striking them off first and then say, okay, tell me, why should I add it back?

Jon Walton [00:35:51]:
I think they actually listen. I think the good thing is technology and technology initiatives have been around long enough now that you’re always going to have to compete, you’re always going to have to compete as an IT professional with other priorities in the organization. It’s oftentimes oversimplified, and people say, how can an IT project compete with a library project, everybody wants a new library in their neighborhood, if it’s a million dollars for a library or a million dollars for a new ERP system, which do you think they’re going to fund? The thing you’re able to do though, if you build a good governance structure and you get people participating in that conversation early, is, all we’ve been able to do is segment, break out the portions of our budget proposals that relate again to the business partners we support. So we can now say, for a library project, 1% of that library cost is the technology that goes into the computers that people can use, the free wi-fi in the libraries, the card catalogs, automatic return systems. So there’s an understanding now that by aligning IT with our partner departments and by being able to articulate the technology that’s required for every staff person we add in the city, there’s an IT cost, for projects, for common projects, for a building, we’re able to articulate the inherent IT infrastructure cost for those building projects. So rather than me coming up with a number that I have to defend against all these other priorities, I can now show the relationships between my proposals and other projects in the city, because nobody wants to build a library

Jon Walton [00:37:22]:
and the day it opens have no alarms, have no telephones, have no computers, have no card catalogs. So they can see now that if we approve this, there’s a related cost needing to be invested in on the IT side, and I think that’s a really important thing to continue to have IT professionals do, is be able to relate their projects, to connect their projects to things that people recognize better and appreciate.

Sanjog Aul [00:37:47]:
Now, if I were to take a private sector example, perhaps you also have similar situations where business leaders or unit leaders or departments in your case might have their specific needs, which they may have expressed in multiple ways over the years to the IT leader, but when they sit and do the budgeting, perhaps they look at everyone altogether and say where IT has to deliver, and that’s where, even though the budget may be created and then reviewed by the CFO, the end result could very well be that the business line leaders who this budget was essentially created for might not get their needs met. So what if this could be an extreme measure or an approach, what if IT comes totally out of the budgeting process and be more of a spectator and more of a validator and let the business line leaders and those department leaders build budget for their respective IT needs and give it to the CFO? Don’t you think that would get us a better end result or end product?

pushing application development out to departments 38:48

Jon Walton [00:38:48]:
It might. I have another idea that we’ve tried here that I would throw out for consideration. Let me give you an example of one of the budget reduction approaches we took here. We had a twofold effect. One is, we used to try to, like many traditional controlling IT departments, we used to try to control all of certain types of business line, we just said if you wanted X you had to come to us for it. So that centralized control model, we still do that in some areas for security reasons and things like that, but there were a lot of areas we didn’t feel like that was necessary. So we used to have a line of business application development and we used to tell all the departments in the cities, you want an application developed, you have to come to us for that

Jon Walton [00:39:27]:
and so, like you said, sometimes we would get some money, we were never able to meet the demand, we had a lot of unhappy customers because there’s always this huge backlog of work, and not only were we behind in our work, but we didn’t have enough funds that even if we could have brought in enough staff to ever achieve what we wanted. So we did two things. One is we took all the centralized application development support staff and we put them out in the other departments, we said three go here, four go there, we sent them all out to their business partners and they became employees of those departments so they would sit next to the business owners and be able to develop applications out there.

Jon Walton [00:40:04]:
Now, I would argue that the distributed application development model is perhaps somewhat weaker, but there was an instant level of recognition of, now they own those resources, they could see what the resource limitations were, and those departments then invested in allocating more of those funds for the application development business. Now the downside of that was there weren’t people to go around, and so there were a lot of departments that had no application development ability, so they couldn’t come to us anymore and they couldn’t really go beg another department for help to develop their applications, and what we did there is we kept a core number of staff, we started this initiative called crowdsourcing, hackathons, where the few staff I have left that focus on this area go out and meet with the department, identify an application, and then bring in public volunteers, IT professionals, we do weekend camps, and actually the community is now developing apps for us because it’s a benefit to them.

Jon Walton [00:41:02]:
These applications, they’re doing it with open source at no cost for the city, and we’ve developed over 80 applications in the last few years, at no cost for the city, using open source software, that directly benefits the public without controlling that process.

Sanjog Aul [00:41:17]:
Now as part of this whole 80-20 rule that has been happening, if you were to go back to the policymakers, and the private sector goes to the respective executive management, do you think if you were to ask them what are their top priorities and projects, not geek projects or IT projects, what are their business projects, and why don’t you invest in those instead of looking at that translating into an IT project, you are better off? Are you going to be better off with respect to getting money for the actual projects versus just operational stuff?

Jon Walton [00:41:53]:
Absolutely. When I talk to the policymakers and decision makers, to be honest, they’re not terribly interested in my operational challenges. They’re very interested in creating free open source applications for reporting crime, or a customer service interface, they’re very interested in free wi-fi for the public and increasing broadband accessibility to people around the city. So when I talk to the policymakers I really talk about the things that they see the direct benefit for and they can relate to. I think we’ve developed a level of trust where they trust that I will continue to look for a way to save money on the operational behind, to find ways to invest in these ideas. I think the dialogue is, you have to excite people about the opportunities technology can bring, and they have to have a level of trust and confidence that you, as a CIO, that you, as a C level executive, can find ways to solve that problem without continually only talking about the operational cost and challenges.

Jon Walton [00:42:51]:
They’re going to have to trust you that you’re going to solve the operational problem and move innovation forward.

Sanjog Aul [00:46:01]:
So let’s quickly inventory, Jon, the different priorities that you think would turn out to be the top priorities for the executive management and business line leaders, if you did go to them and say, okay, I would like to allocate more funds towards such projects and innovation which is going to get you value. Do you see a theme, because you’ve lived both sides, private and government sector, specific type of projects?

Jon Walton [00:46:24]:
I do. I would say the themes I hear most often when I’m pitching ideas or things, I try to keep two things in mind. It’s been hard for me to let go of a lot of things that as an IT professional I feel passionate about, because what I’ve come to realize is, a lot of the things I feel really passionate about that I think are priorities, I’ve had to come to realize that they assume when I go in to have the conversation that I’ve already figured out the solution. Security, for example, is a huge passion of mine that I’m very passionate about and believe that we need to spend a lot of time and effort on in IT and government, and though it’s a passion of mine, I have to say when I talk to people about it, it’s usually, yeah, we agree, but we assume you’ve already figured all that out, we assume every idea you pitch or all these thoughts you have, you’ve already solved the security problem, and so the thing I’ve learned that I see as a priority for our decision makers is, one theme for us here in San Francisco that funds a lot of projects, I group under what I call accessibility, there’s a lot of excitement about how do we get our citizens more connected with government services.

Jon Walton [00:47:33]:
That’s why we’re expanding our fiber, that’s why we’re doing free wi-fi, that’s why we’re putting more and more applications on the internet, that’s why we’re podcasting all of our public meetings and things like that. There’s a whole theme in our government right now, is what you’re proposing directly connecting, making government more accessible to the public, to the citizens, to the visitors, and how are you addressing the accessibility, because that’s what they want IT used for in the city, it’s connecting people instantly, to their smartphones, through their computers, through their TVs, we want our own TV stations connecting with the government

Jon Walton [00:48:10]:
and then the other theme that is always around is about accessibility, because if you gave me tens of millions of dollars, I would make it the most widely mobile accessible in the world, but I also have to always keep in mind that there’s still also that legacy view that IT is a luxury, this expense that you spend money on when all the other important things are done, and even though we’ve built these good partnerships, I always have to remind myself, when we have those conversations, when you talk about priorities, when I’m pitching ideas or talking about initiatives, there’s always this underlying conversation that’s about what’s the value of the project, what’s the efficiencies that are gained in government by doing these things. So when I talk about new software packages to manage RFPs, the contracts, the software itself, the concept that is appealing to them is it makes it more efficient because we’ll have half as many contracts, and every contract we manage in the city has an internal cost to do it. So it’s the whole efficiency conversation, how it contributes to efficiency and value of the organization, and then the human connection, how does it make technology, resources, education more accessible to the public. Those are the two main themes, I think, that resonate the most with people here in the city right now.

what the business expects from the shift 49:21

Sanjog Aul [00:49:21]:
One last question, very quickly. If you were to go out and ask this question straight out, we need to, and I want to, change the 80-20 rule with respect to IT budget allocation, what do you expect as the answer?

Jon Walton [00:49:38]:
I would think the answer would be, absolutely, that’s exactly what we expect you to do. The expectation for us right now, when we go through budget reductions, in the last three years we’ve had to reduce our budget between 10 and 20%, our base budget, every year over the last three years, and when I make those reductions, there is absolutely an assumption that the reduction I’m going to make directly comes out of that 80%, that the 20 is not going to shrink. There’s actually pretty severe direction that I need to grow that 20, and any reduction I need to make, any savings I need to achieve, need to come out of the 80, and we had very current conversations with vendors, with partners, about that 80% of how we’re spending funds today. We’re going to take the savings we need to give back to balance the budget out of that 80

Jon Walton [00:50:30]:
and we’re going to continue to find every new dollar we invest is going to be in that 20% to move things forward.

Sanjog Aul [00:50:37]:
It looks like that rethinking of the 80-20 rule, basically we should be doing it, and the business expects us to do it. Sometimes the how part is the one that is missing, and your comments were very pertinent in terms of how organizations can rely on CIOs and IT leaders to deliver IT, but at the same time, in order to get the budgets that we need, CIOs need to get the trust of those executive management and organizational leaders.

Contributors

Jon Walton

Jon Walton, Chief Information Officer, County of San Mateo, CA

Jon Walton Chief Information Officer, County of San Mateo, CA Mr. Walton began his professional career in Computer Technology working on international engineering projects. Following his time as a consultant he was the Deputy CIO fo... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

Wave 1 MPU 300X250
Jon Walton