This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.
About this conversation
A CIO Talk Network conversation with Atefeh Riazi (New York City Housing Authority), Mark A. Stone (Safety Kleen), hosted by Sanjog Aul.
What the conversation established
The conversation established that office politics is embedded in every culture and cannot be eliminated from how decisions get made, so IT leaders have to understand it rather than avoid it. Atefeh Riazi said IT has shifted over the last 20 years from building hardware and software to delivering transformation, which makes relationships and consensus part of the work, and she warned that when decisions cannot be reached the customer is the first to suffer, then the organization and its employees. Mark A. Stone offered a three-step IT circle of life, where relationships precede processes, processes precede transactions, and relationships outlive transactions, and he said leadership is influence whose goal is a win-win rather than winners and losers. Both held that employees are not commodities, that quality of life drives productivity, and that leaders should manage relationships in four directions and keep a finger on the pulse of politics, customers, and competitors.
Host Sanjog Aul talks with Atefeh Riazi, Chief Information Officer of the New York City Housing Authority, and Mark A. Stone, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer of Safety Kleen, about politics in IT organizations. Riazi argues that politics cannot be removed from decision making and can be a positive force when it serves a higher goal, while Stone describes sensing how the political climate shifts and building relationships before processes and transactions. Both keep employees central, defend quality of life, and use influence to aim for win-win outcomes rather than winners and losers.
Contributors
- Atefeh Riazi, Chief Information Officer, New York City Housing Authority
- Mark A. Stone, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer, Safety Kleen
Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network
On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript
Key takeaways
- Atefeh Riazi, Chief Information Officer of the New York City Housing Authority, said politics cannot be eliminated from decision making and is part of how decisions are made. She argued that IT has moved over the last 20 years from building hardware and software to delivering transformation, which requires relationship building and understanding the political process.
- Mark A. Stone, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer of Safety Kleen, teaches his team an IT circle of life in which relationships precede processes and processes precede transactions. He credited the idea to a Bob Lewis book and said you cannot begin addressing processes until there is a level of trust.
- Atefeh Riazi, Chief Information Officer of the New York City Housing Authority, described politics as a positive influence on decision making when it serves a higher goal. She said IT professionals tend to use only expert or information power and should use the full power quadrant, including legitimate and reward power, to deliver transformation.
- Mark A. Stone, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer of Safety Kleen, said leadership is influence and the goal of playing politics should be a win-win rather than winners and losers. He acknowledged it will not happen 100 percent of the time but said leaders should build relationships so the greater whole becomes everyone’s goal.
- Atefeh Riazi, Chief Information Officer of the New York City Housing Authority, said quality of life for employees is critical and that an employee without it cannot be productive. She called it unacceptable to post stellar results while people feel they have no life, and pointed to flexible hours, work from home, and telecommuting as ways to protect it.
- Mark A. Stone, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer of Safety Kleen, said leaders should address fear during economic uncertainty with open communication and management by walking around. Having led downsizing four times at two companies, he broadcasts it far in advance and manages relationships in four directions he calls North, East, West, and South.
Chapters
- 0:00 Introduction: politics in IT organizations as a silent killer
- 2:49 Why politics cannot be eliminated from decision making
- 7:08 The IT circle of life and relationships before process
- 10:06 Communication, collaboration, and customer service
- 15:49 Seeing politics as a positive influence on decisions
- 19:14 Leadership as influence and the win-win goal
- 24:40 Protecting employee quality of life
- 31:43 Standing against poisonous politics and using power
- 38:13 Addressing fear during economic uncertainty
- 46:31 Using political influence in staffing decisions
- 50:53 Managing relationships in four directions
Explore more
- Developing your Killer IT Crew
- Policy, Politics, & Pocketbooks: Improving IT for Present & Future
- What’s In It for Me?
- IT-OT Integration
- Selling IT
- IT Outsourcing: Why and How?
Transcript
Introduction: politics in IT organizations as a silent killer 0:00
Sanjog Aul [00:00:48]:
Now today’s topic is politics in IT organizations, the silent killer. And our guests for today’s show are Atefeh (Atti) Riazi, who’s the Chief Information Officer for New York City Housing Authority. Good morning, Atti.
Atefeh Riazi [00:01:13]:
Good morning, Sanjog Aul. It’s a pleasure joining the show.
Sanjog Aul [00:01:16]:
Beautiful. So how’s the weather up there in New York?
Atefeh Riazi [00:01:19]:
Rainy, a bit cold, and the fall is coming. The trees are already turning brown.
Sanjog Aul [00:01:27]:
Great. And we have Mark A. Stone, who’s the Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer with Safety Kleen. Good morning, Mark.
Mark A. Stone [00:01:35]:
How are you, sir? I’m doing very well this morning. Great. So how’s the political weather? The political weather here at Safety Kleen or in the corporate in the company as a whole? I’m talking about company. I’m talking about your region.
Sanjog Aul [00:01:49]:
I’m talking about national. I’m talking international. How is that going?
Mark A. Stone [00:01:52]:
It is, as always in politics, there are those that are on both sides of the fence, and they like to make each other not particularly look friendly to each other.
Sanjog Aul [00:02:03]:
So what you just said has got a little bit of a negative angle to it. And we know this topic has been specifically picked up because that could very well become the very reason why a company may not succeed in spite of the very best leadership or in spite of the very good strategy. So we call politics as the game that needs to be played or that has to be played. Now is that supposed to be an inevitable evil or you can get rid of it? That’s number one question. And, Atti, we will start with you. And what about where IT people, and especially in IT organizations where they don’t even have the time to breathe, do they really have the time to play politics?
Why politics cannot be eliminated from decision making 2:49
Atefeh Riazi [00:02:49]:
Those are two great and very complex questions. So let me see if I can take the first one. My perspective, being a CIO and being in the IT and engineering sector and working for both public and the private sector, I can tell you that you cannot eliminate politics and decision making. It’s part of the decision making. There used to be where IT was basically kind of rational, left brain, sequential type of thinking because we were building systems, and we were not really involved with the customer, with the users and many other factors, environmental factors, economic factors, cultural factors, factors that we’re facing today. And IT was not transformational. I think IT has changed tremendously over the last 20 years. And as a result, what we deliver is no longer that product. What we’re delivering is transformation. And transformation requires relationship building and requires understanding all aspects of the company, of the customer, of the environmental factors surrounding decisions. So we have to actually understand the political process. We have to understand how decisions are made in a political organization and in a political model so we could be effective leaders. So that’s essential and part of critical decision making. And I think IT people do have to make the time for it. Because without understanding the political nature of your organization, of the environment your organization plays in, your competitors, your customers, how that environment is changing, the different stakeholders, we cannot really deliver the transformation because we have kind of moved off the IT paradox, which was we used to think IT was about hardware and software, to a place where IT is about intelligence and it’s about information and it’s about innovation. And there are different factors impacting that environment than they did when IT was born years ago out of the back office in the finance department.
Sanjog Aul [00:05:20]:
So, Mark, in your view, since, of course, over the years you might have also come across organizations, is it the people who, like those few, I would not call as rotten apples because that’s too derogatory of a term, but then are there a few people in the organization which influence this or this is something which is gonna get embedded in a culture and everybody would be in a way without even knowing contributing to it?
Mark A. Stone [00:05:43]:
Well, first of all, politics is embedded within any culture, but that culture changes and morphs over time. And the intelligence that you require as a CIO is to have your hand on that pulse to be able to notice when what the political landscape is changing because it’s never static. And the key from an IT department is to be able to educate the department as to what that political landscape is to make them the most effective in interfacing with that user community, that political landscape that exists at any one moment in time.
Sanjog Aul [00:06:27]:
So if you were to look at the organizations where this is being played as the game, and of course people say that, yes, most organizations will have it. In fact, all organizations will have politics at one level or the other. Is it really in the best interest for an organization, which is a mini organization that’s IT that we are referring to, to even indulge in it or not kill it at the very instance when we see it happening? Because it has got too much on its plate as a mini organization, and people are looking up to it. Anything which is going to undermine the true potential has to be dealt with with iron hands, would you not think?
The IT circle of life and relationships before process 7:08
Mark A. Stone [00:07:08]:
Well, let me answer the question slightly differently. And what I attempt to lay out to my organization in interfacing with the user community in that political landscape is I try to teach them the IT circle of life. And it’s just three steps. Number one, relationships precede processes. I borrowed that from a book by Bob Lewis, 21st Century Manifesto. But relationships precede process. We must establish relationships. So that’s gonna require the IT department to understand the political landscape, develop relationships, because you can’t begin addressing processes unless there’s a level of trust there. Second, they must recognize that processes precede transactions. We don’t wanna get caught in the trap of pushing specific technological solutions on them unless those processes become enculturated, I mean become embedded within the culture. And then third, to close the loop, we must recognize that relationships outlive those transactions. Whatever way we implement a transaction, its success will ultimately depend on our relationship for that next transaction. So what is that importance there, going back to the political landscape question that you have? That is understanding the political landscape, establishing relationships, driving those to the processes, the transactions are dictated by the processes as we understand what needs to be embedded within the culture, and recognizing that there’s a cost to each transaction, which hopefully will establish solid relationships, so that the next time that you start that loop, you’re on a better footing. Must understand the political landscape. You must embed this kind of approach there. We have to do it as an IT department. We have to make time.
Sanjog Aul [00:09:01]:
Nobody comes from home saying, I’m gonna really play some good politics today. So how does this happen? Is this something that we get sucked into? Is this something that we are unknowingly using and or leveraging in order to perhaps make ourselves look better or to get a project approved, etcetera, etcetera? Mark? You were going to I was going
Mark A. Stone [00:09:23]:
I already had a chance to speak. So could you ask that question one more time?
Sanjog Aul [00:09:32]:
Sure. I understand. Maybe what we are saying is that when somebody comes in the morning, they don’t think that I’m going to play some cool politics today. And they don’t come with that agenda. But then they also have other agendas that have to be met that they want to really good look good in front of people and or they want to get a project approved or they want to get a promotion. I mean, there are so many different agendas that people have. And in order for them to achieve it and not purely on merit based perhaps, they think that there could be a shortcut by playing the game, if you will. Is that what is the trigger? Is that what the catalyst is?
Communication, collaboration, and customer service 10:06
Mark A. Stone [00:10:06]:
No, I don’t think so. I mean, there’s what you spoke to, again, was a fairly wide ranging question. There are going to be those individuals who approach each day with their own private agenda. There are going to be those others who will come and approach the day that they have an agenda that they think they’re pushing for the greater whole, whether that be the department or potentially even higher up in the organization for the company. So we have to be sensitive to that. And I try to train our IT department to, first of all, make sure that they are in tight communication with the other users or within the individuals within their department, to have a sense of collaboration that we’re trying to work with them, and to also be able to focus on customer service. And I mention those three things because politics, again, is a fact. No matter what we’re gonna do, they’re gonna still bring those political aspects, whether it’s an individual, as you stated, coming to the day. But what I’m trying to train my staff to do is to have that ability to be able to communicate, be collaborative, and have a customer service focus with them. And that’s very important, because now we begin to work with them versus against them.
Sanjog Aul [00:11:24]:
Atti, when you’re supposed to see some people, can you really see them wearing an invisible political hat all the time? Or do you see them only or do you see some of them when they are truly coming into the office and then they have something to achieve, which might be connected to their agendas when that hat is worn?
Sanjog Aul [00:15:15]:
Welcome back. Atti, we’ll start again with you, and this is with reference to the selective adoption of politics by individuals or as a group or as a department or as a company for that matter. So do you see organizations which have this game being played on a regular basis? People typically demonstrate behavior that they would be really wearing the hat and you can see them coming from a mile away all the time? Or is it mainly when they have an agenda? Because sometimes when you see people wearing it all the time, they perhaps might not be the fit in the first place.
Seeing politics as a positive influence on decisions 15:49
Atefeh Riazi [00:15:49]:
I think, again, more very complex organizational and human behavior questions. What I would comment on is that decisions are a political process, and we have to accept that. I look at the politics, or maybe because I’m more of an optimist, as a positive influence on decision making because it used to be, you know, IT decisions come from the space where they were merely made on the basis of financial methods and financial thinking. But there are other criteria, and these criteria are sometimes subjective, not necessarily rational and unobjective. And they appear to be political because you can’t understand it rationally, but strategically they may have very strong merit. So, I think politics are essential in decision making. They should be part of how we do decide, about projects, about how we’re going to transform the business. And a part of it is understanding that we do live in a political model. I mean, most of us used to think, kind of left wing people, think that ideology in an organization is about efficiency and effectiveness. But the fact is, especially in global companies where you have organizations with different ideas, with different visions, different goals, different missions, you have a struggle between the organizations and what the mission and the goal is. And to get consensus across these diverse groups and organizations, you do have to, I think as Mark said it well, understand relationships and understand what is it that they need to get so they can all come to a consensus. So one may call that a political play, but ultimately it has to be done if you are to be an effective leader and to deliver on your goals and targets. You have to bring people in to give and take positions, to build consensus to see other points of view because you do want to have a horizontal process deployed. And again, this is to what Mark said. Your processes cannot be vertical and siloed. And I think the CIO becomes someone between Churchill, Mother Teresa and a kamikaze pilot. You kind of have to move from a consensus builder to a point where you actually have to finally dictate a position.
Sanjog Aul [00:18:45]:
Now, Mark, if an organization and or an individual or a group uses politics to get a decision swayed in a given direction, do you think that creates a sentiment of win lose? Because if somebody won, then somebody else is sitting as somebody who lost. Would it not create a level of hostility, animosity in the organization, which are not the right, you know, traits of a good organization in the first place?
Leadership as influence and the win-win goal 19:14
Mark A. Stone [00:19:14]:
The answer is yes and no. Obviously, there are those who play the political game, and when they win, there are losers. I think the art of leadership ultimately means it’s influence, because leadership is really influence, nothing more, nothing less, just borrowing from John Maxwell. And if you as a leader are playing the political game, your goal should ultimately be via implying, hinting, suggesting, going back to my working on a collaboration using communication. You would love the outcome to be where there are no winners and there are no losers. Everyone is a winner. And that should be your that should be what the goal would be if you’re doing your leadership properly. But the reality is there are some that will win, will fight politically, and they will have winners and losers. Your goal has to be the exact opposite so that when the battle is finished, both parties have been winners.
Sanjog Aul [00:20:19]:
Do you think that is realistic? Can we eat the cake and have it too?
Mark A. Stone [00:20:21]:
100% of the time, absolutely not. But I think that as a leader, that’s what our goal should be, so that there aren’t losers, and we should strive for that. That’s striving for perfection. It will never happen 100% of the time. But if you have built a set of relationships across the organization, if you have set it up in such a way that the greater whole becomes what everyone’s goal ultimately becomes versus any individual winner, you have a better chance than not of seeing that win win situation take place more often. Never will happen 100% of the time, but it is something I think we have to work towards.
Sanjog Aul [00:21:06]:
So what’s the opportunity cost? This is for you, Atti. Based on what Mark said, as the SC does not work always, and when it does not work, what’s the opportunity cost to have some misery cost to the people who would call themselves as victims of politics?
Atefeh Riazi [00:21:22]:
Well, if proper decision making doesn’t take place, I think your biggest stakeholder is your customer that’s going to get impacted. So if you’re highly political in an effective way where you can’t get decisions made, and you can’t come to consensus, the customer is the first one, then it’s certainly the organization and it’s the employees. So it takes the whole organization to get that culture right. I think we’re getting into decisions of culture. You have different organizations and the way they bring about change differs. For example, from where I was in the global private sector where decision making was very collaborative, it would take a long time to come to a decision versus when you work for a government agency where decision making is more militant. When you come quicker to a decision, but then maybe you’re not taking into consideration all the aspects of the decision. So, ultimately, we all pay when you are either too political or non political at all, because you’re not taking into consideration some serious issues that impact the organization or impact your customer.
Sanjog Aul [00:22:52]:
So we use this word customer multiple times and we, of course, aim and this is our goal to satisfy them to the nth degree. Now would you not think that our internal customer, which is our employee, is equally important, and if we really step on their toes and on their heads in order to satisfy the customer, but there are people who have had a miserable life throughout that process and going forward, for how long can you have that sustained growth, profitability and customer satisfaction?
Mark A. Stone [00:23:26]:
Well, I mean, that’s a very complex question to be able to ask. I think that how long you can have that go forward, I think that that’s a, that again gets back to building a foundation. You build a foundation, and you have as many winners, internal customers as you can, on the very beginning of that foundation. Then in order to have any, a building can only be on a stable foundation, so if you want to have any longevity to that being a success, there has to have been that foundation of relationships, that foundation of communication, that foundation of collaboration. And then the next time that a transaction takes place, you have something to build upon. If you didn’t establish it in the very beginning, it’s going to be a very rocky forward, and there’s not a chance of being able to establish that on a long term basis.
Sanjog Aul [00:24:20]:
So on one hand, you as an IT leader or as a business unit leader might be getting a pat on your back for getting stellar results, which has made Wall Street very happy. On the other hand, you got people coming and complaining that I don’t have a life and I don’t feel like working here. What’s your answer to that?
Protecting employee quality of life 24:40
Atefeh Riazi [00:24:40]:
If I may answer that, that’s completely unacceptable. Quality of life is for your talent, for your employees, is critical and essential and part of what you have to need. We see a lot of changes in the work environment with flexible hours, with work from home, telecommuting. Many of those are because we want to offer employees a quality of life. An employee that doesn’t have a quality of life is not going to be a productive employee. So the goals are connected. I think happy employees, happy customers. If you don’t have if you have unhappy employees and happy customers, you’re out of alignment. And you can only maintain that for a very short period of time before you start going down a slippery road. So but politics doesn’t necessarily mean that it would be bad for your employees. I think when I’m talking politics, I’m talking about decision making around critical transformational issues that are positive for the organization, that are positive for the customer, that are positive socially, environmentally, and at the end, they increase revenue, develop a better margin. If those are not in sync, then politics will be viewed negatively. But I think if you’re using a political process for decision making for a higher goal, then I think politics are viewed positively.
Sanjog Aul [00:26:21]:
So, Mark, do you think we can really have an acceptance level or a threshold up to which politics is allowed in the organization and accepted by the executive management, including IT leadership, and not have that abused?
Mark A. Stone [00:26:29]:
Yes, absolutely. But again, that will take the leadership from the top from recognizing that the employees, somewhat going back to what Atti says, going back to what Releccan is, employees are not commodities. That ultimately your most valuable resource within a company is your employees. So that, yes, from the top, you can be having specific goals as a company. You can be having specific objectives that a specific department is supposed to follow. But it cannot be done absent a recognition that the employees are critical to that delivery, because you can sometimes get that first successful transaction and burn them out. The next one’s gonna be very difficult. So yes, it is possible.
Sanjog Aul [00:27:22]:
And if we have a situation where truly the IT department, since we are referring to the IT organization here, is functioning well and everything is going well. We are creating value for the business. And we are aware that there might be some people and or the politics that is being played currently in the organization is there, it’s existing and perhaps causing some harm. Would we really want to rock the boat or we would try to remove the problem?
Sanjog Aul [00:31:16]:
Welcome back. So you being an IT leader, we’ll start with you, Atti. And you see that things are going very well. And you then look at some people and or the political environment being the undercurrent and it’s also causing misery to people. Would you turn away and say things are going fine right now? Let’s wait and watch.
Standing against poisonous politics and using power 31:43
Atefeh Riazi [00:31:43]:
Absolutely not. My first commitment is to my staff. My second commitment, which is as equally critical, is to our customers, internal and external. So we have to make sure that we provide the safe environment where our staff can be productive and they can grow. And if the environment is poisonous, it’s not a good environment for them to work in. And therefore, it impacts the organization in totality. So no, if it’s a negative politics, if it’s politics that doesn’t deliver anything but regressed, then it’s something that we as the C suite, C level executives of the organizations are committed and must change. But at the same time, I believe the IT professionals have not really adopted politics and power. We still believe power is bad. And we only play, if you look at the power quadrant, we only play in a very small segment of the power quadrant, which I call expert power or information power. Instead of playing in the quadrant in totality, which is the legitimate power, the reward power, when we only play in a segment of the power that’s been given us to deliver the transformation, we become ineffective to some extent. And the issues that we consider political, that could be disagreements, it could be not understanding the other side’s point of view, why they’re coming to the decision they do, and not necessarily using the power quadrant properly, we end up not delivering on our goal. So I think that we certainly have to stand up for poisonous and against poisonous environments. But at the same time, we have to make sure that we ourselves understand, not only at my level, but at my senior executive level, that we need to use the power that we’ve been given to deliver the outcome that we’re expected to do.
Sanjog Aul [00:34:23]:
Mark, if suppose somebody comes to you and says, I’m a victim of politics, how objectively or what’s your process of evaluating if it is truly the case? And is that the only feedback mechanism that you have that political levels, if you will, in the organization, the mid level and operational level are rising beyond threshold, so let me take action?
Mark A. Stone [00:34:46]:
No, that is not the only way. And I would take any comment coming from my staff typically with a grain of salt, because I want to make sure that it has a variety of different validation points. And one of the reasons that I would never rely on just that one comment is it’s incumbent upon me to practice that management by walking around. I need to have informal relationships with all of my staff so that I can get an understanding of who is and who is not performing, who are the ones that are complainers and who are not the ones that are complainers. So by that management by walking around and getting an understanding, I would hope that that’s a second data point to that communication that the employee brings to me. And then third, I should be having an active basis of mentoring my staff, which is, by mentoring some of my leaders, I’m also learning from them who their key employees are. So that would be, at a bare minimum, a third data point that I should have, so that when they come to me, it’s not the only basis upon which I’m getting information.
Sanjog Aul [00:35:57]:
So Atti, in your case, would you deal with people any differently when they are coming to you repeatedly and saying, I am being a victim, I am being a victim? Would you just brand them as whiners, or would you take that as a strong sign that somebody truly is becoming bullied and or being played the game on?
Atefeh Riazi [00:36:20]:
I think we have the responsibility to listen to anyone who is raising an issue. And there is a process. Most organizations have a process. And we do. And any organizations I’ve been with, we’ve had a process where if someone believes they’ve been victimized for whatever reason, that reason needs to be investigated. And it’s my responsibility to investigate it and understand what the reason is. So I would certainly look into it. But I would also talk to the employee about the real environment that they’re confronted with in the workplace, and to see whether the issue is something that only they feel. Is it an isolated case? Is it maybe their perspective of the case or it’s real? But I think every case is worth listening to and investigating. And, again, politics has many faces. And under the underlying issue of politics, negative politics, could be prejudice, could be racism, it could be differences in political views. I mean, all of those things where we need to look into and they really have no place in the workplace.
Sanjog Aul [00:37:50]:
Mark, in current days, the economic climate and other things that are happening worldwide, while you’re able to insulate our people from internal politics, how do you insulate them from what they see outside, the fear, uncertainty and doubt which it is creating, which creates the job security mindset at any cost?
Addressing fear during economic uncertainty 38:13
Mark A. Stone [00:38:13]:
Very excellent question. Number one, to attempt to address that fear. Number, I try to make sure there’s an open line of communication that is formal and informal. Second, I already alluded to it earlier, I stay close to my people by that management by walking around, by dropping informally into queues, sitting down and eating with them at lunch. You can gain very quickly identify those who are fearful and why they’re fearful. In certain cases, you can then be able to dismiss that fear by giving information that’s valid. Third, I try to be accessible. I want to make sure that they have the ability to come in and talk to me one on one when they don’t have to have others around them. And then the last thing that I’ve attempted to do to try and dismiss the fear is to make sure that they recognize that I will always do whatever is possible to sacrifice, make sacrifices, either personally or by a department, for their benefit, so that they sense that there is a more familial approach to what we’re doing. None of those will eliminate fear. All of them will incrementally begin to address the fear. And at the end of the day, if downsizing is coming, and I’ve done this now four times in the last two companies I’ve had, I try to broadcast that far enough out in advance to say the fear may be real, it may be coming, but by giving that additional communication, I also hope to be able to prepare them for whatever the worst case scenario is, and if it’s better than that, that’s all. Those would be the four things that I do to try and quash fear. I can’t eliminate it.
Sanjog Aul [00:40:02]:
Atti, in any business, do you think, or any organization, do you think if you were to really take averages, do you see it happens or politics usually happens more in business versus in IT? And if that’s the case, do you think even within the organization we could have negative influence over IT because that’s a department you’re handling?
Atefeh Riazi [00:40:25]:
I would say actually IT is more protected from political decisions and politics, at least the negative politics. Because IT doesn’t necessarily compete with any other department. And it has a task of its own, although we do compete for funding. In an environment today where you mentioned and Mark mentioned, you have a lot of fear because of the economy, unemployment, employees are working longer hours. There is a lack of sense of stability. We do have a lot of anxiety in the workplace. We have a lot of organizations that are afraid by culture. And as a result, you have many issues, and many issues that are not necessarily positive. So yes, I think IT is isolated to some extent. But I do think that for IT to be effective in transforming the business, it needs to understand the environment around it. It needs to understand decision making most critically and the politics and the culture, the culture of the organization, the culture of decision making, because we have a critical task of using information to move the organization forward, especially now with major cost cutting. The focus has been a lot on more tactical areas than strategic areas. And to move the organization forward strategically, you have to know who to go to to get funding to move it forward. And that’s critical and important in terms of getting the organization ready so when the economy picks up, you’re ready to pick up. So I think it’s important to understand it, but to some extent, yes, we are sheltered from it to a large extent.
Sanjog Aul [00:42:36]:
And what we need to explore is that since there would be a pack of people within the IT organization, and that may also keep changing as the organization changes and if the needs are changing. So while we can handle that existing pack, but there’s always going to be more people getting hired. And if you’re gonna do reduction in force, people will need to get laid off and or you’ll have to get rid of them. But in both cases, what is the type of diagnostics that you have, whether this person is having that political mettle, not more positive or negative, and based on how much of that would be used to make a decision whether you’re hiring a person or getting rid of them?
Sanjog Aul [00:45:57]:
Welcome back. So we were referring to a steady pack of IT employees that we have in the organization. And since you’ll always have changes, the needs would be there for you to let go of people and or hire more. While we look at the skills, competency, and engagement, political games, if you will, and negatively and positively. So, Mark, what do you think?
Using political influence in staffing decisions 46:31
Mark A. Stone [00:46:31]:
Well, I’ll answer a part of that question very quickly. And any time that you are trying to let staff go, given all of the HR guidelines that you have, you better have that documented based on objective, and it’s based upon metrics. So that becomes a very clear thing that you must adhere to. But going to expand on that, if you were letting staff go, it really should be based upon performance. The skill set is no longer needed. They are not being effective. But you have to have a sensitivity here also to the, going back to that law of influence. There can be people in your organization who are a big positive political influence, who may, due to their skill set all of a sudden not being required, I would take that into account, because sometimes those individuals are worth retraining because of their positive influence on the department or positive influence on the team. And they are an ally that you as the CIO have, and you want to hold on to them. And so you may take extra steps to retrain individuals like that because of their positive influence. And then on the exact opposite frame, you wouldn’t save someone who’s a negative influence if their skill set is no longer needed. So that political aspect, I would definitely think, should come into play when you’re making some of those decisions.
Sanjog Aul [00:48:06]:
Atti, do you think what just Mark said would be measurable about political acumen, or how well they can play the game? And can that be part of an HR metrics?
Atefeh Riazi [00:48:20]:
I think it’s both a subjective and an objective process. And whether it’s measurable, yes, some of it is measurable. But again, as I said, decision making is not really truly a rational process. I’ve gone through some of these as well, both in the public and the private sector, and it’s very different in the public sector. You have titles that are civil service. You have some options that are available to you, like early retirement. Not always. You have categories of IT, which is becoming a commodity, and you can get it, you can offshore it or you could automate processes. So part of the decision is made based on what can I do cheaper, faster, better, outside than I can do inside? Those roles are completely objective. Then the next decision is made. What percentage of my staff who is more effective in what they do? And part of that criteria is a technical criteria. Part of it is which group can deliver projects better. How do they build relationships with their colleagues? Can they deliver? Is IQ as critical as EQ? So those are decisions that management would have to make as you go forward and you need, and you can only keep a certain percentage of our employees. It is a difficult time. However, having said that, we do see a shortage of IT professionals. A lot of people are not studying IT because they believe there are major cuts in IT jobs because of offshoring. And it is difficult to get this skill set. So we are in a hiring mode and we cannot find the expertise and the skill set that we need. So that’s something that we need to actually focus on. We’re not necessarily letting go of staff right now. That’s not the phase we’re in.
Sanjog Aul [00:50:35]:
Mark, very quick last question. As an IT leader, you’re supposed to set examples for others. What kind of example would you set so that they see you as someone who they would like to emulate, so you play the right type of politics and also get your job done at the same time?
Managing relationships in four directions 50:53
Mark A. Stone [00:50:53]:
The first thing I would love for my staff to see is I recognize that there are four different relationship directions I have to do I have to address. First of all, I have to manage up. I manage my boss, and we’ll call that North. To my East, I’ll call my organizational peers. To my West are my consumers, my customers. And to the South are my own staff. What I would hope that they would see is that I am active in building relationships and setting an exemplary example of how I’m managing in all four different directions, and that I’m recognizing that there are political relationships, and each one has unique aspects. And what I would hope to do is as they see that mentoring, that leadership model is one where they can say there’s something to be learned, there’s something to be followed. And that’s what I would hope they would be able to see, an example that I’m not so singular in only addressing one aspect, but I recognize that there are relationships in four different directions, and that I need to be working those political relationships, each equally, each one is just as important as any of the others, and that there are specific examples that they can see in each of those four arenas.
Sanjog Aul [00:52:16]:
Very quickly, Atti, 15 seconds. Any last comments?
Atefeh Riazi [00:52:20]:
I think it’s important to always have your finger on the pulse. In our positions as CIOs, in the pulse of the politics, the customer, your competitor, your product and the changes in all of these environments. And that’s the only way we could lead and we can transform the organization.
Sanjog Aul [00:52:43]:
On behalf of the show and our listeners, thank you so much, Atti and Mark, for sharing your thoughts on this politics, how it could very well be useful in an organization, but beyond a certain point, it could be counterproductive, and how you can keep your finger on the pulse and keep it under manageable levels.
Atefeh Riazi [00:53:02]:
Thank you very much. It was a pleasure.
Mark A. Stone [00:53:04]:
Thank you very much for the opportunity to do this. It was a pleasure to speak with you.


