Governance • IT Strategy & Business Alignment

Measuring IT’s MPG

Measuring IT’s MPG

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Bob Baskerville (Scripps Network Interactive), Roger Kent (Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that IT contribution is hard to measure precisely because technology is pervasive, so Bob Baskerville of Scripps Network Interactive and Roger Kent of Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures argued for pairing ROI with an MPG style utility measure. Kent said he groups spending into three buckets, growth or margin, innovation and risk, and required work such as regulatory, lifecycle, and cybersecurity, and that given today’s pace of change he may move innovation spend from about 20% to 30% or 35%. Baskerville said cybersecurity is table stakes after the Sony and Anthem breaches, and pointed to a content scheme delivering over 30,000 additional hours for TV Everywhere and over-the-top partners such as Netflix and Hulu. Both said legacy leakage or bloat must be fixed before IT earns the credibility to fund innovation.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Bob Baskerville, CIO with Scripps Network Interactive, and Roger Kent, Senior Vice President and CFO with Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures, about how to measure the value of IT investments using both ROI and a miles per gallon (MPG) utility measure. Kent describes a three-bucket portfolio approach that separates growth or margin initiatives, innovation and risk, and required work such as regulatory, lifecycle, and cybersecurity spending. Baskerville describes a content scheme at Scripps that delivers over 30,000 additional hours of content for TV Everywhere and over-the-top partners such as Netflix and Hulu, and treats cybersecurity as table stakes after the Sony and Anthem breaches. Both argue that some initiatives carry value that is hard to measure in the short term and should still be funded, and that legacy leakage must be fixed before IT earns credibility to invest in innovation.

Contributors

  • Bob Baskerville, CIO, Scripps Network Interactive
  • Roger Kent, Senior Vice President and CFO, Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Bob Baskerville, CIO with Scripps Network Interactive, says that in a mature entertainment business the first question on any IT investment is whether it creates cost efficiencies or drafts off existing ones rather than its return on investment. He frames decisions around tangible value and keeping the organization lean and efficient rather than ROI alone.
  • Roger Kent, Senior Vice President and CFO with Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures, groups technology spending into three buckets: growth or margin improvement, innovation and risk management, and required work such as regulatory, lifecycle, and security investments. He measures return across the whole portfolio rather than expecting a return on every individual project.
  • Roger Kent of Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures says that given today’s pace of change he may raise innovation-type spending from about 20% of the budget to 30% or 35%. He argues companies can no longer spend 3 years evaluating a project when the business cycle might be over in 6 years.
  • Bob Baskerville of Scripps Network Interactive treats cybersecurity as table stakes for keeping the confidence of the Board and shareholders, citing the Sony and Anthem breaches. He says a company can be as prepared as possible and still be compromised, which he calls the new normal.
  • Bob Baskerville of Scripps Network Interactive points to a content distribution scheme that delivers over 30,000 additional hours of content to cable, satellite, and over-the-top partners such as Netflix and Hulu. He says the work was rooted less in traditional IT than in operational workflow, with the content team leaning on IT to help drive revenue.
  • Roger Kent of Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures says legacy is unavoidable and must be evaluated so assets move from a legacy view into a forward-looking view. Bob Baskerville adds that he does not feel comfortable pursuing innovation until IT has its house in order and has fixed leakage or bloat in systems from 10 to 12 years ago.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: measuring IT’s MPG and ROI
  • 2:51 Why IT contribution is hard to measure
  • 5:53 Investment value in a mature business
  • 8:26 Doing more with less
  • 14:09 Three buckets for technology spending
  • 18:46 Cybersecurity as table stakes and TV Everywhere
  • 24:27 Shifting more budget to innovation
  • 27:34 Speed to market versus long IT cycles
  • 39:41 An investment pool instead of play money
  • 43:31 Fixing legacy before funding innovation
  • 48:23 Dealing with legacy and forward-looking views
  • 52:24 What makes a strong IT business case

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: measuring IT’s MPG and ROI 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:25]:
Today’s topic is measuring IT’s MPG, which is synonymous to miles per gallon. Our guests for today’s show are Bob Baskerville, who’s the CIO with Scripps Network Interactive. Hi, Bob. How are you?

Sanjog Aul [00:00:55]:
And we also have Roger Kent, who is the Senior Vice President and CFO with Allstate Technology and Strategic Ventures. How are you, Roger?

Sanjog Aul [00:01:05]:
Now this is an interesting topic, one of a kind. We actually started discussing about how we can have another discussion on ROI, which is the way most organizations evaluate whether they should fund an IT investment or not. So we said, how about comparing that to a car? So suppose that initiative, which an IT initiative was a car, then ROI for the car could have included the features, luxury, the prestige value it might offer, and over and beyond whatever that you get out of it as a transport. And another measure could have been miles per gallon, which is a typical utility value of a car as a transport. So if we are to look at ROI for an investment, not always we have a way to quantify every piece of it, the luxury and other things as I mentioned about the car. So how can we introduce this concept of miles per gallon in a combination with ROI so that we are not letting an investment go down south or not getting funded just because we did not have a quantifiable value. So with that, we wanted to explore this topic keeping in mind miles per gallon and return on investment. So, first question is for you, Roger. As we see that we are always looking to figure out ways where IT will provide some sort of an enhancement or some addition to the business capability, and that’s why you get approached by different proposals. How do you go about precisely measuring contribution that IT would make if they were to go with this initiative?

Why IT contribution is hard to measure 2:51

Roger Kent [00:02:51]:
Well, first of all, it is very difficult to be that specific in terms of measuring IT’s contribution. If you look at technology and businesses today, it is incredibly pervasive throughout the operation of an entity. It’s fundamental in doing day-to-day work. It’s illustrated by if you ever have an outage in many businesses, business really comes to almost a complete halt. So it’s very difficult to measure the overall contribution that IT makes to an organization. It’s a little easier when you look at an individual initiative. Some initiatives are fairly straightforward. If you have that initiative that’s targeted at delivering a new product or a new channel or new geography, those are pretty easy to measure via traditional measures. Same thing can be true of initiatives that have more of a cost or efficiency play. Typically, you know where to go to find the resulting savings from that initiative. It’s a lot tougher when it’s a project that enhances customer experience or brings an innovative capability to the organization. Those things get much more difficult. And I think logic says that over the long term those will provide measurable value via traditional measures through customer loyalty and retention. But it is harder to recognize on a short-term basis. So I think you really have to understand the business you’re in, understand the business model that you operate. And really some of these become on a short-term basis a little bit of a gut instinct in terms of whether or not you think there’s going to be a long-term value there. And value again like you mentioned upfront isn’t just ROI value. It can be customer value. I heard recently that great technology is a function of consumability and value and value of course being both economic and utility value. So I think that when you look at it from those aspects of it, you do get a sense that that initiative can add value that’s not measurable at least on the short term.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:14]:
And I wanted to piggyback on that and ask Bob. So, Bob, when you go about envisioning an investment and something you want to propose that this is going to really bring value to an organization, can you realistically go to them and say, I have this thing which may have some standard numbers that you can evaluate it on, but that’s not what it is. This is more futuristic. This is going to really position our company in a different light, and you wait as if you’ve gone to apply for a Visa to INS. And whether they reject or not, they’ll not give you a reason, but they’ll reject it or approve it. Can you really function like that?

Investment value in a mature business 5:53

Bob Baskerville [00:05:53]:
That’s an interesting analogy. I would say that it is not that simple at all, at least not in the business that I am in. If you look at the business we’re in, we’re in the entertainment business and because we’re a relatively mature business at this point, much of it is about our capabilities to some degree commoditize what we do and create efficiencies by doing that. And when I say efficiencies, it’s going to be cost efficiencies. So when it comes time for an investment at this point, that’s going to be the first question that comes to us whereas it might not have been that question in earlier days. But now it’s more to the tune of, is this going to enhance our customer experience? And are we going to be able to do this in a way where it will help us either, A, create greater efficiencies than we’ve already had or, B, kind of draft off of existing efficiencies so we’re not going to have to grow our scale, so to speak. That’s the question we get regularly at this point. It’s a sign of our times in the industry I work in and probably a sign of the times in a lot of industries frankly. But it isn’t that easy to quantify at this point. I think it’s got to be, at least for us, characterized as how is it going to bring value, not even so much return on investment, but some of the other tangible value propositions that I just talked about in terms of us trying to be an organization that is going to be as lean and efficient as possible?

Sanjog Aul [00:07:47]:
So IT is typically asked to do more with less or sometimes more with nothing. And, Roger, when somebody comes to you, knowing that IT is already for the most part, most organizations, or rather 100% of organizations, are now coming to a point where they’re cut to the bones when it comes to any slack that they may have. So any new initiative that they are proposing, would you give them the benefit of the doubt that they will definitely try to find ROI wherever possible, which is tangible in hard dollars? Anything else that they are bringing is only going to move the company forward. Do you work with that mindset or is this not distress, but a healthy skepticism?

Doing more with less 8:26

Roger Kent [00:08:26]:
Well, I think I’m probably paid to have a healthy amount of skepticism. The way I would address the question is that we are asked to do more with less. Part of our fundamental responsibilities are to continually drive efficiencies and productivities and enhancements through our base functions of running technology. And that’s true also whether you’re running some other part of the organization as well. But particularly in technology, I think we have to continue to always be focused on how we can run our place better and how we can create opportunities for efficiencies and productivity improvements. One of the things that, in my opinion, that does is if we’re proactive on that and do so kind of at the right time in the business cycle, we can create some headroom to fund some of these initiatives ourselves. And I think when we have an ability to take our own destiny in our own hands, that’s always preferable in my mind. I’m a big fan of being out front, driving the initiatives, reinvesting some of those savings into things we know we need to do to run technology better. And also then having some ability to contribute to the business needs whether it’s improved margins or funding X amount of projects and so forth. I think that’s where I like to see technology get to in terms of how we participate with our business partners.

Sanjog Aul [00:10:05]:
Bob, when you look at these initiatives that you are coming up with, are you essentially able to realistically measure the MPG, which is the transport value or utility value of that investment, or is it such that if you front-ended it, your investment will never see daylight?

Bob Baskerville [00:10:32]:
I would say that there’s a bit of a challenge. Ideally, that would be the way I’d like to envision it. At the same time though, and I can’t speak (Roger may experience some of this as well), often it feels like there are certain initiatives where we certainly feel that we could be capable of measuring what success looks like. But often, at least in my business, the partner or the stakeholder that we’re supporting is going to be the one that determines what success looks like. Specifically when we’re supporting areas that are going to have their eyes wide open on what the investment would be (areas in kind of a corporate or business systems realm such as finance or legal affairs or even HR, stepping away from our actual content activities), that’s a bit of a challenge for us because, in some instances, you may be dealing with teams or executives that may already have their mind made up on what success needs to look like here, investment level notwithstanding. And that can be a challenge sometimes. I think part of my role as the CIO for this group, Sanjog Aul, I’ve been on your show before and we’ve talked about this before, is that I’m probably not your garden-variety CIO. And what I mean by that is not to disparage any other CIOs out there. As a matter of fact, I would say that I have an operations background, but less of a systems background. I’ve had more experience running P&Ls and actual businesses. That was one of the reasons I was appointed in this role, to work with our actual business units and business support partners and ideally garner a greater level of faith and credibility with them in what our investments are going to be rooted in in terms of growing business initiatives, driving revenue. The same things every company envisions and wants to do in their technology efforts. But at the same time, our company chose someone like me because they wanted to make sure that their other stakeholders in the company had a level of confidence in what they were hearing from their CIO, with the notion too that I’m going to be supported by a tremendous team of technologists that report into me.

Sanjog Aul [00:13:26]:
So, let’s take an example of security. We know security is paramount. Everybody’s thinking it’s not a matter of if but when we will get hacked or we’ll be attacked. So suddenly, earlier security being a stepchild, now it is a blue-eyed child for most and most security initiatives are being funded. So, Roger, coming to your camp, if there is a sponsorship like Bob mentioned from the top for some reason that they feel this should be done no matter what the investment is, does that come ahead and influence the way your team would evaluate, in objectivity, the ROI and MPG, and still go in that favor even though there’s not a business case, or would you have the veto power?

Three buckets for technology spending 14:09

Roger Kent [00:14:09]:
No, I think we do look at security as a great example of a set of initiatives that I think we all know we have to do. You can argue about the degree you do it, but we all have to pay attention to this and do some work on this. One of the ways that I like to look at initiatives is from an overall portfolio perspective. If you look at initiatives and you kind of group them into three different areas: The first area is really one of growth or margin improvement kinds of initiatives and those are very measurable and you can apply the normal financial measures on those kinds of things. The second set of initiatives centers around things like innovation and risk management where you may or may not have real tangible benefits that are measurable. And then the third category are things that you just simply have to do, whether it’s regulatory requirements or infrastructure investments. Some of your lifecycle investments fall into that category. Security clearly does. Cybersecurity is something that we’re all faced with. The potential downsides of that are almost immeasurable. So I like to look at things in those three buckets. With some of those like that last category, I don’t expect a return on that. There’s things we have to do to run our business that are required investments. We look at hurdle rates for some of the other buckets and then you try to measure what your return is on the whole portfolio. Are you getting value for your investment in total, not necessarily for every single individual project?

Sanjog Aul [00:16:00]:
And let’s talk about the MPG, which is miles per gallon. If that should be the formula utilized or we should look at some soft factors as well, especially when we’re looking at initiatives which may be a critical enabler for innovation and perhaps will offer a catalyst for business growth versus just a way to reduce operational cost. What do you do in that regard? How do you go about looking at that particular type of investment?

Sanjog Aul [00:18:21]:
So, Bob, we would like to look at areas where we are talking innovation. We’re talking disruption. We’re talking about putting an investment in which would be acting like a catalyst to business growth versus just doing the same old operational efficiencies, etc. How would you go about putting MPG versus ROI or a combination in terms of the formula?

Cybersecurity as table stakes and TV Everywhere 18:46

Bob Baskerville [00:18:46]:
Yes. I actually have a great case study, if you will, or example to present on that. But first, I want to, if you don’t mind, just jump back to the question that you and Roger covered before the first break regarding cybersecurity. I want to give you maybe 60-90 seconds on what we’re living through as well. You made the comment that it’s become the blue-eyed child. I would say it’s a blue-eyed child that, at least in our world, is a bit of a screamer too. I think we have learned (Roger put it well) that in the realm of cybersecurity the investment for what we have to do is basically table stakes for us to make sure we have confidence from our Board and our shareholders as well. Now more than ever, it’s going to be critical. To be clear, the position we’re taking is not to shirk any responsibility. It’s to be as prepared as possible. However, we could be as prepared as we possibly feel we could be and we could still be compromised and breached. That’s the new normal, I’m afraid, in our world and in business in general right now. We’ve seen it happen so many times recently with other companies. It definitely became a bright light for us when it happened in the media sector with Sony, and then even with what happened recently with Anthem too, in the healthcare side of things. For any company that’s going to offer a medical plan through a major carrier and of course Anthem is one of those, it definitely caught our attention. So for us, we certainly felt we had good measures in place to begin with, but we’re trying to ramp those up, but it still may never be enough. The return on investment there is you have to, to some degree, believe in what you’re doing (that you’re doing all the right things) and then also keep your fingers crossed that the level of sophistication in these attacks or compromises is such that it doesn’t leave you with some sort of major exposure. Jumping ahead to your question coming out of the break, so now the example I can point to for us where I would say the industry disruption has correlated into some of the things we’re trying to do that I would say are innovative and keeping pace with what our partners are expecting from us is what’s going on in the side of media consumption. It’s not just about watching linear or traditional television anymore. It’s not even about watching video on demand or DVR video. It’s watching live TV anywhere, anytime that you want it, or also watching library shows or episodes of your favorite shows wherever you want them. The notion of what they call either TV Everywhere or Over the Top, which are two different things but are also in the same organizing principle of on-demand new-age content consumption, we have a very, very large stake in supporting that initiative of delivering that kind of content here at Scripps Networks to all of our partners, whether it’s traditional cable and satellite operators who are creating TV Everywhere strategies or whether it’s over-the-top opportunities with companies like Netflix, Hulu, and others for the cord cutters. We now create a scheme that delivers over 30,000 additional hours of content to all of our partners, not just domestically but globally. I’m happy to say that our content distribution team at Scripps leaned heavily on our IT team, which was certainly a great complement to our ability to deliver the goods, and also create an investment scheme that made sense to help the company drive revenue. It was not rooted in traditional IT; it was actually more in an operational workflow that in previous years would have been more on the broadcasting side, where in fact now it’s becoming more of an IT function.

Sanjog Aul [00:23:38]:
Roger, when you look at the game, I would not want to call it in a derogatory fashion, but it is an art form, if you will, to evaluate an IT investment, especially when most things are not measured. How are we getting better at it? So there are things which you today cannot measure, but is there any hope? Is there any incremental improvement in the things? Suppose 10 years ago, you were not able to measure well, but now you figured out a way and then there is light at the end of the tunnel that there will be more. So then you are moving more of the soft facts or the soft advantages. They can also be measured, and you will be far more confident in each IT investment that goes through you that this will indeed create value.

Shifting more budget to innovation 24:27

Roger Kent [00:24:27]:
Yes. I don’t know that the tools are any better than they were a few years ago. I’m a financial person by training. ROIs and payback periods and cost-benefit analysis are tools of the trade that have been in existence for a long time. I think they have their place and they add value to a certain set of initiatives. The MPG notion that we’re talking about here in terms of the enhanced utility value is something that I try to encompass more and embrace through this. Again I mentioned the portfolio view. When I think of what we’re spending on innovation-type initiatives, if that normally might be say 20% of our overall spend, I may look at that and say, OK, given what we’re facing today, maybe that needs to be 30% or 35% of the initiative spend as opposed to 20%. Because I think what we’re facing today is a set of challenges that are much harder to measure than we’ve seen before. When you look at consumer expectations today in almost any industry, the impact that companies like Apple, Amazon, and Google have had on everybody is that consumers want to do things; they want all the information available instantaneously. They want to do things when and where they are. You look at the amount of data that exists today, it’s just exploding. How we manage that and what we do with it is a difficult challenge for us all. And then just the pace of change and how that impacts both technology as well as business cycles. We can’t afford to spend 3 years evaluating and developing a project anymore. The business cycle might be over in 6 years. So we have challenges today that require us to be more responsive and reactive. To me that means we’re going to have to be prudent and understand what we’re doing, but we’re going to have to make investments that don’t always have the traditional financial measures behind them that we’re used to seeing.

Sanjog Aul [00:26:47]:
Bob, would you agree that the credibility of an IT investment getting approved also depends on the track record and that could mean that we were either too slow in investing in an IT initiative, which would have brought a good amount of value, or we would have spent way too much, way too quickly, and then the results were not as good. So this is a team sport, which also includes the CFO camp and the CIO camp because both were responsible for making the case, approving the case less or more. Do you think we can do better in terms of improving our probability by each time incrementally getting better at this sport?

Speed to market versus long IT cycles 27:34

Bob Baskerville [00:27:34]:
That’s a dense question, Sanjog Aul. What I would say to the first part is that, at least from my perspective and keeping in mind that I’ve sat on the other side of the table before as a business leader, there’s a perception at least with our group (and I do think it’s IT in general) that the work cycles to work through a plan are long. I’ll give you a great example: we’re going through a rights management initiative to best understand how to have a uniform rights approach on how we manage all of our intellectual property, and now with partners creating additional revenue streams (the Netflixes, the Amazons, the Hulus), there are royalty implications tied to some of the content that’s created by partners that we select for our lifestyle media brands. That’s a new piece we need to pay attention to. We’re looking at a rights management concept that’s going to be all-encompassing throughout the business. It doesn’t mean we don’t manage our rights today. We’re just looking at a way that’s going to be more efficient and can satisfy all the stakeholders at once, which is a mighty task. If we were having this conversation 3 or 4 years ago, we would probably have had an IT group telling the partner that, yeah, we can come up with a solution and it’s going to take X amount of time and it’s likely going to be a number associated with years to complete. That’s not going to be acceptable anymore. There’s too much off-the-shelf opportunity out there with products that our businesses can basically say, look, let me re-track: what I’ve told my team is we can either be a partner and lead the way in building this car that these folks can drive and get the best utility out of that vehicle as possible. If we don’t get in front of this, these folks are going to go and they won’t look for somebody to build a car for them. They can go find an off-the-shelf solution that’s going to provide maybe 70% of what they want. So speed to market is going to be incredibly important. We need to be there and be a partner that understands that and not be viewed as a group that will be wrapped up in taking X amount of years to build a solution. Those days are fading fast in this side of the business, and that’s what I’m trying to preach to my team to change.

Sanjog Aul [00:31:25]:
Talk about heroes, which is IT people who are trying to help rescue the business in case there is an emergency, and who are trying to help optimize and grow the different business functions so that we can grow as a company. However, IT, for the most part, is left to fight its own battle. So this question is going to be for you, Roger: if IT was to get better at identifying or improving its own MPG and overall ROI, what outside help is available from within the organization but outside of IT so that they can get better at their job and thus improve what they deliver to the organization.

Sanjog Aul [00:34:04]:
So, Bob, can we call IT folks heroes, and can we help them get better at the game from other departments in the organization so that they bring better MPG and better ROI?

Roger Kent [00:34:18]:
I think we can. The things I would say are twofold. One, part of our job is to help the business get better. We all have to understand that we have to be partners with the business. We have to help deliver results and bring new capabilities to the table that they may not have before. Sometimes there are capabilities that they don’t even know they should have yet. We have to be leaders in helping technology drive the strategy. We do have to market ourselves a little differently with our business partners because we can be viewed as a cost center and cost centers are intended to be optimized. I think there’s a ton of value that we generate both in the traditional ROI dollars and then this less traditional MPG utility value. The thing I would say too is I’m not so sure that I would really look for a whole lot of outside help. In my opinion, we understand technology and what it can do better than anybody else in the company. So the onus is on us to make sure we’re delivering this and we’re drinking from the same fountain we’re asking everybody else to drink from. I believe in taking destiny in your own hands and driving results, so I’d like to see us take the lead on that and work it from that perspective.

Sanjog Aul [00:36:06]:
So Bob, would you have any pointers on what they could do new and different or more so that you are in a better position to positively respond to the initiatives that they propose?

Bob Baskerville [00:36:17]:
Well, I think if you go back to the notion of heroes, I think when I look at my own team, there are a lot of folks who are absolutely heroes and many of them, to some degree, think they are heroes. The point is how do you characterize that and create what I call a new-age IT organization, which is always going to be a group that’s in the conversation or has a seat at the table when big business initiatives are coming up. I would much rather that we’re called upon as a resource that they want to know our point of view, rather than being a necessary evil. Some of that can be controlled by our own psyches within IT in terms of understanding that we do have a lot of heroes, but we’re not always (the work Roger mentioned is true) nobody’s going to have a better technological view of what a support solution can look like than we will. That’s fine. How do we engender with our partners that we have that knowledge but we’re here to help versus being the ones who need to save the day? Those are very different positions. Sometimes partners worry that coming through IT will be a choking process that will disable some of their business drive. They recognize they need us, but they want us to be able to simply answer the question they have without over-complicating it. For us, it’s important to maintain that mindset when going into a partnership on a particular project. We have a lot of heroes, but we shouldn’t get too rooted in being full of ourselves in that thinking. Success in a project requires collaboration and speed.

Sanjog Aul [00:39:03]:
Roger, when you look at the play money concept, we are saying we want them to work where there’s a transport or utility value for sure, but at the same time we want some innovation. And since you’re not able to measure at all times, that’s why sometimes there could be a false positive. How about offering a bucket of play money which could be utilized because there is a certain amount of investment that has to be made, and that relieves you of that pressure. And also both parties are at least able to try some new things because you miss 100% of the shots you don’t take.

An investment pool instead of play money 39:41

Roger Kent [00:39:41]:
I think the concept is valid. It’s hard to sell in most companies the idea of having play money. I do think we have to create an investment pool within a normal technology budget because there are things you can’t plan for that come up in terms of both things you have to do (lifecycle investments, cybersecurity) or testing your way into something, maybe an extreme agile development process, or trying a different platform as a service. I do think you have to be able to prudently look at those things and spend some money on them. Whether you call it play money or investment dollars, you have to set aside something.

Sanjog Aul [00:40:49]:
So who shoots it down? Do you think someone shoots it down? Or are you yourself not able to figure out a way to present it to senior management because frankly, everybody’s looking up to you. So you are the hero in the limelight here because that’s the allocation of funds which can be very clearly identified, and then IT can have some relief that, okay, I can have some of those new things that can be tried out under this umbrella.

Roger Kent [00:41:16]:
Yeah. I’m a believer in taking direct action. As Bob referred to, we have to drive efficiencies in the core running of technology. I’m a believer in taking those efficiencies and specifically looking at how you want to reinvest that money. Keeping a portion of that to reinvest in things we know we need to do within technology is important. This investment pool is one of those things. We know we have to invest in new things coming down the road or we’ll find ourselves further behind. That just makes the process more expensive long term. We really do have to carve out a portion of benefits we drive and keep that for reinvestment in the future state of technology.

Sanjog Aul [00:42:17]:
So, Bob, when you are looking at any of the innovations that you are working on and you know that if you innovate or modernize or transform whatever you had as legacy, you will be miles ahead. But still we have to carry the fact that a lot of organizations are still carrying that legacy. And if you were to truly see the MPG or ROI, they are not that stellar. Why is it? Why are we living with it then?

Bob Baskerville [00:42:52]:
I’m not sure I follow that line of questioning, Sanjog Aul.

Sanjog Aul [00:42:55]:
So the legacy investments that we have today may not be offering the same level of automation or capability or cost efficiencies, but we still carry them. We are not even talking about new investments here, but preserving IT investments that we made, say, 10 years ago. When we talk about MPG or ROI calculation, frankly, they may not be the best. If there’s a past investment causing leakage, why not evaluate those legacy modernizations and do the same type of calculations?

Fixing legacy before funding innovation 43:31

Bob Baskerville [00:43:31]:
Okay. Yes. That’s been one of my key directives with my team because our executive management demanded it. You talked about play money earlier. I think we had a group that probably had their share of play money back in the day and those days are gone. We do have some legacy systems in place that I’ve asked my team to evaluate because of what you’re talking about, leakage or bloat. We’ve been doing things just because that’s the way we were doing things and there’s not necessarily great efficiency to point to anymore. While I’m not trying to create pain for an organization just to do it, we really have to ask some hard questions because otherwise the notion of reinvesting in future-looking opportunities or innovation is dead on arrival if we don’t show a proven track record that we’re trying to evolve beyond legacy issues. We have to change that thinking to have any credibility in a conversation about allowing us to innovate. I don’t feel comfortable pursuing innovation if we don’t have our house in order with the current state. The current state needs to be current and not rooted in what was happening 10-12 years ago.

Sanjog Aul [00:45:41]:
And Roger, would love to get your input on how do you evaluate preserving IT investment type of legacy which should be modernized versus the new investments that somebody brings forth which will bring innovation. What is your basis for someone in your shoes to evaluate and objectively say to IT?

Sanjog Aul [00:48:01]:
So there’s a term called creative destruction, which is where you remove the old in order to make way for the new. Roger, how do you evaluate whether to remove legacy? Do we bite the bullet and just go for it or are we just going to live with it?

Dealing with legacy and forward-looking views 48:23

Roger Kent [00:48:23]:
Legacy is tough to deal with because every company has legacy. The way technology grew up over the last few decades, everybody has applications or technology stacks or processes or business constructs that are not optimal for being responsive and agile in the marketplace today. So we all have to deal with it and it’s tough pick-and-shovel type work that we have to address. As we look at each new project, we really have to evaluate that we’re not adding to the legacy and that we’re constructing this in a manner that is forward-looking. There’s a view today that says whether it’s a bimodal kind of construct or other names, there’s merit to looking at things from a legacy view and a forward-looking view in terms of how to continue to put more of your assets and capabilities in the forward-looking view. We’re always looking to add to that bucket and take things out of the legacy bucket. If we can have that lens when we evaluate initiatives, it has merit.

Sanjog Aul [00:50:03]:
Bob, if you were to request sponsorships, blessings, and support from the business, what would you like to see so that whichever initiative you propose actually will have enough MPG and, of course, overall ROI for them to approve it?

Bob Baskerville [00:50:21]:
So when you’re positioning that question, Sanjog Aul, you’re asking what would I want to see from outside the IT organization?

Sanjog Aul [00:50:27]:
No. Not from your team. From the outside people. What type of support so that when you do your due diligence, it’s not under fear, uncertainty, and doubt. It is with a positive outcome in mind, and then when you present something, it’s seen in an objective light versus a pie in the sky.

Bob Baskerville [00:50:44]:
Yes. Okay. I think what I would want to see is,

Roger Kent [00:50:49]:
a real-world

Bob Baskerville [00:50:49]:
view of what the expectation is from the business. Frame that up with what the opportunity would be first and then follow that with what their expectation would be and why we’re in that conversation to begin with. Is the technology solution truly going to be the way to make that successful moment happen for the business? With our group, IT goes well beyond just technology. We have a capable team that works in project management and program management. In some instances it might just be business processes that flow through our team, and we would then look at automated opportunities that might exist or innovation through technology that might support a plan down the line. But it may not start with technology, if that makes any sense.

Sanjog Aul [00:52:01]:
Roger, when you look at the IT MPG measurement and the ROI, if you had to give a few tips to IT leaders so that when they come to you they are presenting a good enough case, what would that look like which has a higher chance of you saying yes?

What makes a strong IT business case 52:24

Roger Kent [00:52:24]:
I think Bob touched on it in the last comments fairly well. I look for, first and foremost, what’s the real business case. Understand what’s the business going to see down the road. Sometimes that’s a measurable outcome, sometimes it’s not. When you have an initiative that’s a mixture of both, include payback periods and ROI when you can and talk about the other softer benefits and business outcomes right alongside it so I have the whole picture and can evaluate it appropriately. I’m a financial professional, so I tend to look through that lens, but I want to see the business benefit. I want to see how we’re moving the business forward and what the business outcome is. To the degree people can make that case, they’re much more likely to see my stamp of approval.

Sanjog Aul [00:53:38]:
Thirty seconds, Roger. Again, anytime you will make exceptions to your playbook?

Roger Kent [00:53:45]:
Well, sure, there’s always exceptions to a playbook. As I mentioned before, in my portfolio there are always some things you make exceptions to and things you believe you have to do. Cybersecurity is one of those. We’re going to spend the money to do it because we believe we have to. It is table stakes today.

Contributors

Bob Baskerville

Bob Baskerville, Chief Information Officer, Scripps Networks Interactive

Bob Baskerville Chief Information Officer, Scripps Networks Interactive Bob Baskerville was named the chief information officer for Scripps Networks Interactive in the fall of 2013, continuing his impressive tenure at the lifestyle me... More   View all posts
Roger Kent

Roger Kent, Sr. Vice President & CFO, Allstate Technology & Strategic Ventures

Roger Kent Sr. Vice President & CFO, Allstate Technology & Strategic Ventures Roger joined Allstate in 2014 with over 30 years of experience leading a variety of financial functions in global financial service companies. He is... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

TECHM - DNA - MPU01 - 300x250
Bob Baskerville