This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.
About this conversation
A CIO Talk Network conversation with Jim Davis (UCLA) and Jim Wetzel (General Mills), hosted by Sanjog Aul.
What the conversation established
This CIO Talk Network conversation examines how to make the most of the manufacturing value chain, everything from production to finished goods and disposal, by connecting it end to end with the Internet of Things. Jim Davis, Vice Provost of IT and Chief Academic Technology Officer at UCLA, and Jim Wetzel, Technical Director in the Platform Center of Excellence at General Mills, both leaders in the Smart Manufacturing Leadership Coalition, argue that manufacturers have not truly optimized their value chains and that IoT can elevate connectivity when it is made cheaper, simpler, and more standardized.
Host Sanjog Aul and the two guests work through the seams where value leaks across companies and systems, why IoT is an enabler rather than a solution and needs an open platform to knit applications together, how to justify return on investment and fund the effort incrementally through a coalition, the architecture and operational performance questions of a connected value chain, the pitfalls of readiness, risk, cybersecurity, and data accuracy, and who in the value chain should lead the transformation.
Contributors
- Jim Davis, Vice Provost of IT and Chief Academic Technology Officer, UCLA
- Jim Wetzel, Technical Director, Platform Center of Excellence, General Mills
Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network
On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript
Key takeaways
- Jim Davis of UCLA and Jim Wetzel of General Mills, both leaders in the Smart Manufacturing Leadership Coalition, argue that manufacturers have not yet optimized the value chain and that the Internet of Things can elevate connectivity by making it cheaper, simpler, and more standardized to connect across plants and enterprises.
- On the recurring problem of seams, Jim Davis describes the points where information or material flows stop, break, or become inconsistent across companies, vendors, and organizations, and says these seams hold a large pool of untapped opportunity in performance, variability management, innovation, sustainability, and safety.
- On the dream of a connected value chain, Jim Wetzel frames it as speed and inventory, moving from farm to fork, or idea to commercialized product, faster and more profitably, while staying nimble enough to respond as demand changes.
- On why IoT alone is not the answer, Jim Wetzel says IoT is an enabler, not a solution, and that success depends on a platform that knits specialized applications together so point solutions can communicate and collaborate across the whole value chain.
- On return on investment and open architecture, Jim Davis notes the ROI is hard to justify company by company because the value is comprehensive and the up-front IT cost is large, an estimated sixty billion dollars of aging installed base in the US, so an open architecture that lowers infrastructure cost and risk is the way forward.
- On not going it alone, Jim Wetzel urges manufacturers to fund the effort incrementally and through a coalition, because the problem is too big for any single company to solve on its own.
- On operational performance and pitfalls, the guests point to cycle time and the tightness of supply-and-demand integration as the drivers of performance, and flag readiness, staying appropriately simple, risk, and cybersecurity as pitfalls, with Jim Wetzel adding data accuracy as the quiet danger of acting on wrong information at machine speed.
- On who should lead and how to start, both say the value-chain and supply-chain practitioners, not IT or engineering, must champion the effort, that leaders first need a vision of what is possible since surveys show most are not even aware of smart manufacturing, and that the time to act is now, together.
Chapters
- 0:00 Introduction
- 0:48 How IoT elevates value-chain connectivity
- 3:15 The dream: speed, inventory, and agility
- 4:16 Where the value chain breaks: the seams
- 5:52 Why IoT needs a platform, and funding it
- 13:14 Architecture for a connected value chain
- 14:53 Operational performance and pitfalls
- 17:18 Data accuracy and new challenges
- 18:53 Who leads, and educating the value chain
- 23:55 Final thoughts
Explore more
- The Rise of Fog Computing
- IoT Is the Future: Dangerously Close
- IoT Is the Future
- The Increasing Role of Data Analytics
- Challenges of Big Data
- Accelerate Digital Transformation
Transcript
Introduction 0:00
Sanjog Aul :[00:00:15]
This is Sanjog Aul, your host, and the topic for today’s conversation is making the most of the manufacturing value chain. I have with me Jim Davis, Vice Provost of IT and Chief Academic Technology Officer with UCLA, and Jim Wetzel, Technical Director in the Platform Center of Excellence with General Mills, both members of the Smart Manufacturing Leadership Coalition. As part of our series on connected manufacturing, we have talked a lot already about the Internet of Things and what it has the potential to do with manufacturing. Today, we are looking at what the manufacturing value chain, everything from production to the finished good and disposal, might actually resemble, how data and connected devices will shake up the industry, and what possibilities it suggests for the future. So, Jim Wetzel, I will start with you. The idea of interconnecting a manufacturing value chain and working towards demand visibility and planning is something manufacturers have already optimized within their existing models. But how can the Internet of Things elevate that connectivity?
How IoT elevates value-chain connectivity 1:47
Jim Wetzel :[00:01:47]
Well, Sanjog, that’s a great question. You know, when I look at that, I would suggest that maybe the manufacturers haven’t already optimized and that the Internet of Things really will elevate our connectivity through the concept of getting things more standardized and simpler and easier to do. So as we try to be more connected throughout the value chain, in the old model, it was very expensive to do this. It was complicated, took a lot of technical expertise to do. In the new model, as you move forward, it not only potentially has a lot of additional value, but if we can do that in a much cheaper, more standardized approach, it will dramatically change the ability to actually execute this across different enterprises within our plant networks, and across the globe.
Sanjog Aul :[00:02:31]
So, Jim Davis, what do you think about this interconnecting manufacturing value chain?
Jim Davis :[00:02:36]
Well, I… I’ll just build on what Jim was saying. Within the SMLC, we actually have a concept, which we call seams. And, this is basically these places where information or material flows have come to some kind of stop or break or inconsistency. And as we’ve examined these more and more, we see a lot of untapped opportunity, and that’s actually one of the things we bring out in the value chain. But untapped opportunity takes the form of performance. It takes the form of variability management. It takes the form of innovation, sustainability, environment, safety, chain of custody. So there’s a whole variety of things that are just… As Jim was saying, there’s a lot of room and a lot of untapped opportunity yet.
The dream: speed, inventory, and agility 3:15
Sanjog Aul :[00:03:15]
Now having everything connected in one seamless value chain is the idealized state that manufacturers have been working towards for some time. But why is this the dream? What end goal do you think the manufacturers have in mind otherwise?
Jim Wetzel :[00:03:30]
Well, I’ll answer that, Sanjog. This is very easy for us. It’s about speed, and it’s about inventory. So you think about the value chain and the speed of information that’s needed to go from the farm to the fork or from the beginning of your idea to the commercialized product, that’s all about money and profit. So if we can have that connected chain, that value chain from beginning to end, all connected, working on all cylinders, it’s about being more profitable. The second part of that is also being more nimble. And so as your demand changes, being able to respond to that demand, being more agile, that’s the dream. We just haven’t necessarily connected our systems in such a way to allow us to achieve that dream.
Where the value chain breaks: the seams 4:16
Sanjog Aul :[00:04:16]
Now, Jim Davis, this is a question for you. Where is the value chain currently breaking? If at all, that is… We could say that it’s breaking. How are certain components within this value chain either not providing full insight into processes, slowing the processes, or driving up costs? And what aspects can IoT handle and cover that?
Jim Davis :[00:04:36]
Well, let’s see. I guess to echo Jim, first of all, we use the terms agility and demand dynamic performance over and over again. So this is really just some terminology relating to what Jim was saying. The answer to the question though of where this… We call it the untapped opportunity goes back to these seams. And these seams exist as a result of having to cross companies. These seams exist as a result of vendors or vendor products. They exist as a result of organizational differences. They exist as a result of just the material or operations that are needed to move whatever is going forward from a manufacturing standpoint. But as Jim was saying, we’ve done a number of studies across multiple companies, multiple industries, multiple value chains, and the pattern shows up relatively stable. You know, it is interest in this, demand for minimal inventory. It’s really working with the chain of custody, making dynamic adjustments. It’s being able to forecast, control the premium, control premium costs like freight and having to move things around at the last minute, locking down on commitments and remedying defects much, much in much better ways. But, the seams are what’s blocking these kinds of things from happening.
Why IoT needs a platform, and funding it 5:52
Sanjog Aul :[00:05:52]
Now, Jim Wetzel, do you think there are any solutions which you can say are predictable in this regard, or this is still going to be a utopia that put in IoT and everything will be good?
Jim Wetzel :[00:06:03]
No. I don’t think IoT alone will solve this. It’s an enabler that won’t solve it. On the smart manufacturing side, what we think is the key to this success is actually having a platform that actually allows these solutions to be knitted together. So we talk about seams. The other thing we need to talk about is a platform to enable this future state. So I’ll give you a quick example. If you have a company that’s best in class on optimizing inventory and they have statistical methods to do that, they might be really good at that application but that application needs to be knitted into your ecosystem of manufacturing or your entire value chain. So how does that one solution serve the value chain? It can’t. They’re good at what they do. So what we’re trying to really go after in smart manufacturing is instead create a platform that allows these applications to play in so that you can continue to have your Internet of Things. You can continue to have your application specialties, the people that really have specific knowledge in particular areas. But the challenge is to make it successful in a manufacturing value chain is to knit all these things together and figure out how they can communicate and collaborate together.
Jim Davis :[00:07:14]
If I may, I can add to that too. The idea of the platform really also does depend on return on investment. And one of the things that we are seeing when one looks at this from a value chain perspective is that the return on investment when you look at it as an independent company is actually much, much more difficult to justify because it’s comprehensive. It requires multiple players at the same time. We’re seeing that the information technology that needs to be deployed before you can even add any value to the value chain is actually very expensive. So the platform goes toward cutting that infrastructure cost. Within the US, much of the manufacturing base is older. There’s a significant installed base and IT investment already there. It’s actually quite sizable. We estimated at about $60,000,000,000. So we are in a retrofit situation. And then one other thing I think Jim was alluding to is the platform drives down risk. There is risk with trying to develop these models, build up the skill sets, and so forth. The platform actually drives this risk down so that it’s manageable for small, medium, and large companies.
Sanjog Aul :[00:08:18]
So, Jim Wetzel, this is a question for you. Do you think there is equal motivation for all parties who would then say, okay. We are gonna collaborate and invest and jointly or mutually benefit from this transformation. Do you think there are any obvious stumbling blocks which we’ll have to get over before this dream would become a reality?
Jim Wetzel :[00:08:37]
Well, a few keywords there, equally and motivated. I think across the value chain, people are motivated. I’m not so sure it’s equal. It’s not equal in their ability to invest. It’s not equal on their ability to get involved from an education or a technology standpoint. And so when we… We’ve taken a look at this, there’s such a large variety in scale from the small player to the large player, their capability to adapt to and stay current with technology. So really to drive this smart value chain, this concept of Internet of Things and truly make it happen, we’ve got to address the landscape across all players. And so how do you get that small guy that may or may not be sophisticated with an Excel spreadsheet or a fax machine or the large person that has electronic data exchange and has fully networked everything and all of their systems are just looking for a standard to connect to. And how do you make that ecosystem work? That is really the challenges. And so as you think about these point solutions or these small areas, they’re really crying out for a way to connect and collaborate and invest towards the whole thing being connected. And I think that’s fundamentally what our challenge is.
Sanjog Aul :[00:09:51]
So, Jim Davis, question for you. How should manufacturing value chain players go about funding this endeavor incrementally? Where do you think they should start putting their dollars, time, and effort?
Jim Davis :[00:10:01]
Let me answer that partly, and I think Jim Wetzel needs to jump in on that one as well from his industry perspective. The SMLC has examined that question pretty in-depth and, with the basis that Jim just talked about. But one of the things that we’ve come around to is the idea of open architecture. And for this kind of technology to be accessible to the small and medium companies or companies that really have not had the opportunity or the chance to invest in these kinds of technologies and then cover the full gamut for those companies that have invested heavily. The notion of open architecture is a way to build this platform so that there’s full access and then have access to technologies at the level that you need them, at the time that you need them, and with the sophistication relative to the problem that you’re trying to deal with. So we do believe that open architecture is a way to proceed and it’ll allow for these dollars to go much, much farther. Architecture to us is not only just access, but it’s also the exposure of data to applications and various tools and how they’re used and how they’re best used and so forth. We believe that providing access at an appropriate level to that kind of data, which is not the IP, not the proprietary kind of data relative to the company, will also help the industry in a significant way and will make those dollars that the companies need to invest to take this on go much, much farther. So I’ll answer the question with this open architecture concept.
Jim Wetzel :[00:11:33]
If I could just quickly add on that, I would say do not do it alone. This problem is too big for any one company to solve, and that is why we would suggest getting involved in a coalition. We would also suggest getting involved in our Smart Manufacturing Leadership Coalition, but you cannot do this alone. The problems are too big. We need to be able to connect a broad spectrum of solutions to actually achieve this vision. So funding incrementally, doing it one hundred percent on your own, will not be successful.
Architecture for a connected value chain 13:14
Sanjog Aul :[00:13:14]
One of the challenges of having everything connected is that there are so many moving parts, and it is tough to identify an architecture stable enough to keep it all networked together. So is an IoT manufacturing solution equipped for something like this? This is a question for you, Jim Wetzel.
Jim Wetzel :[00:13:32]
Well, you just hit on one of the hardest issues that we’ve got here at General Mills and we probably also have across the industry. Getting that architecture appropriate for networking this together so this IoT solution actually works is the million dollar challenge. That’s what we’re trying to solve with our smart manufacturing platform but it absolutely is the problem of the day. It is moving all the time. Things do keep advancing. Technology keeps changing. And so how do you do that? I think you heard from Jim Davis earlier in the session that we think that the answer is around open systems and how we have that open architecture connected. But this is really the fundamentally big challenge for us.
Sanjog Aul :[00:14:12]
Now when we talk architecture, Jim Davis, would you think that there is a light at the end of the tunnel or this will become a boiling the ocean problem which never sees daylight?
Jim Davis :[00:14:21]
I think the problem, as you say, has the potential to be one of boiling the ocean and not getting anywhere. But I also think it’s possible to contain it or confine it so there is a light at the end of the tunnel. One of the ways we believe a good way to do this is to always turn to the practitioners and build against an actual problem set: what the practitioner needs are, what the manufacturing needs are. If we stay within that space, then I think one can build toward solutions that have near term benefits and then set for the longer term benefits as well.
Operational performance and pitfalls 14:53
Sanjog Aul :[00:14:53]
So, Jim Wetzel, this is a question for you. What about looking at all of this from an operational standpoint? Does operational performance within a connected manufacturing value chain vary depending on the degree of supply and demand integration? And if yes, to what extent?
Jim Wetzel :[00:15:09]
Yes. It really does. What I talked about before is that you think about your manufacturing value chain and where’s all your cost tends to be in inventory, whether it’s raw materials or work in process or in finished product inventory. And so the varying degrees of the demand signals and the supply signals that you have, it really is going to drive a lot of this. So when I look at this topic, it’s really about the cycle time. What is the cycle time of your process from supply and demand? Is it in days? Is it in minutes? It depends on what business you’re in. For us, it’s in days. And how tightly integrated those supply and demand signals are truly will drive your performance of your value chain.
Sanjog Aul :[00:15:52]
Now, Jim Davis, this is for you. What are some of the pitfalls that would hinder the value chain players who are participating from reaching the ideal state, and I’m assuming ideal state for them as a group as well as individually?
Jim Davis :[00:16:07]
Well, see, I think there’s several. One is in our discussions, we do use the term Internet of Things, but we also recognize that it’s about the network layer and the ability to, we call it the integrated device layer, but it doesn’t really get at the context or the objectives. And so one of the things that we consider to be a pitfall as well as an opportunity is kind of what I was saying before. We want to go after this from a business objective, a real metric, something that you really want to accomplish. So that’s one big thing, we would recommend. The second one is one that Jim mentioned earlier. There is a matter of readiness. So you don’t want to go into too sophisticated a level of technology when you’re not ready for it. And in fact, we find over and over again some relatively simple kinds of technologies actually produce really significant benefit. There is the matter of risk, so staying simple works in favor of reducing risk. And then another area which is very big and perhaps elephant in the room big is the cybersecurity cyber attack space because we are talking about web-based technologies. But all these do need to be taken into consideration and can become pitfalls.
Data accuracy and new challenges 17:18
Sanjog Aul :[00:17:18]
So, Jim Wetzel, do you have anything to add to these?
Jim Wetzel :[00:17:21]
Well, the only other item I would add would be data accuracy. So you think about reaching this ideal state where we’re fully connected. Do we actually believe the information that’s being transferred over the pipe and that we’re acting on? Because in this perfect world, in this future state, we’re going to act on information at the speed that we get it. What if it’s wrong? I’m now going to respond to a signal from a sensor that’s connected through the Internet of Things. It’s connected into my manufacturing value chain that’s telling me the wrong information. So how do we balance the technology with the people in the process? We need to solve that.
Sanjog Aul :[00:17:55]
Now this is a very interesting thing that you mentioned because basically whenever you have a new disruption or when you introduce something which is maybe in this case a digitally powered enterprise and this is again for you, Jim Wetzel. Do you think it is actually going to, in some cases, introduce some new challenges besides, of course, the data accuracy that you mentioned?
Jim Wetzel :[00:18:15]
Yeah. It absolutely will. We’re going to have to behave differently because all the things we didn’t know before, we’re now going to know. So it’s going to create some new problems and it’s going to solve old problems. Whether it be data accuracy, whether it be a focus on business analytics that we’ve never had before, whether it be insight into our process, whether it be value stream mapping and actually trying to streamline some of our processes that we weren’t able to streamline before. Having a connected digital enterprise gives us the opportunity to go after some of those things, and it’s actually quite exciting at the same time. We’ll have new challenges.
Who leads, and educating the value chain 18:53
Sanjog Aul :[00:18:53]
Now with respect to the members of the value chain that should be taking the lead during this evolution, Jim Davis, do you have any specific preference in the way a particular link in the value chain should be protagonist?
Jim Davis :[00:19:06]
Let’s see. Protagonist was the word I got, I got stuck on. The one thing I would say, though, is that we’re finding that collaboration is actually a working word here. I know collaboration is used a lot. But, in this particular case, a real collaboration is essential. And we are talking about collaboration among practitioners, vendors, suppliers, platform providers, universities. If those don’t come together in a good way, this doesn’t work very well. If they come together in a good way, it can work extremely well. So I’m not sure about protagonists, but this collaboration and the relationships with it to work well are essential for this to move forward in a positive manner.
Sanjog Aul :[00:19:48]
So Jim Davis said something very interesting where there’s no protagonist. Everybody’s a collaborator. So, Jim Wetzel, do you think that could create an issue with accountability?
Jim Wetzel :[00:19:56]
Yeah. It certainly does. And maybe I’d answer the question slightly different than Jim Davis did. I would suggest that the folks taking the lead on this are… In our case, we’d use the word supply chain, but I would say that your manufacturing value chain leaders. I would not have my IT people or my engineering staff be leading this effort. They’re clearly the people that can do it, and they’re clearly the people that can architect it. But I think the people that need to lead it are the people that need to use it. And that would be our supply chain and value chain leaders and to get them to champion the cause is what really needs to happen. So I think about people, process and technology. Just having the technologist sit there and say we’re going to craft a better world isn’t what’s going to drive it. It’s going to be the value chain leaders who want to truly transform manufacturing.
Jim Davis :[00:20:48]
If I can add to that too, I just want to underscore what Jim was saying and also clarify that I was trying to go down the same path. We use the term industry driven and when things finally have to reach a decision, we always say it’s gotta be the practitioners. I was previously just trying to emphasize not trying to defend, but emphasize that, for this to work though, you do need to have that collaboration and the relationships for this to come together and also be responsive to this industry driven decision making.
Sanjog Aul :[00:21:18]
So both of you, in a way, mentioned that people who own the assets are the ones who should lead this or should be having better control on the profit pool. If that’s the case, then what type of education needs to be imparted and or be embraced by these folks who own the assets so that they’re not totally depending on folks who are going to be putting the technology there? Jim Wetzel, what’s for you?
Jim Wetzel :[00:21:39]
Yeah. Well, I would say the biggest issue is they don’t know what’s possible. So as you have leaders who are trying to be thought leaders and trying to move the shift the paradigm and really trying to have a value chain that’s performing completely different than what we have today, how do they know what’s possible? They can clearly lead stuff, but they don’t know what’s possible. So I think the education side is to kind of give them a glimpse of what technology can do, what people can do, and let them envision what the future can look like. If all they see is what’s been done in the past, it’s very hard to envision a different future. So I think an education and a learning session is to really show them what’s possible.
Sanjog Aul :[00:22:20]
Now, Jim Davis, question for you. What would you think would be the best strategy and the ways people or, like, businesses should be taking on the people from the domain expertise, as well as from the technology leadership to make this a success? How should they hire people? How should they build organizational structure?
Jim Davis :[00:22:39]
I’m going to answer this by just reiterating in my own words something that Jim Wetzel just said. We’ve done a number of studies across companies and we’ve asked the question, are you aware of smart manufacturing? And if you’re aware, what have you done about it? And by and large, we see that a large percentage is not aware of smart manufacturing. In fact, it comes out to be in the 85% range. So that goes to the awareness leadership point that Jim Wetzel was making. Of the 15% or so that are aware, what we hear is either they’ve taken the technology on. And of those that have done something, the benefits have actually been significant, very significant, in fact, tremendous. The others that have not, it’s always been my company doesn’t see the vision or some leader in the company has not seen the vision, or thinks it costs too much and so forth. So I do believe that the starting point for this is just exactly what Jim Wetzel said is that there does need to be a vision painted and the leadership needs to buy into this, and then the other pieces can begin to fall together. Jim and I can talk at length about other areas of how do you bring the IT skills together with the operational skills and so forth. But if you’re not starting with that leadership piece, it doesn’t get off the ground.
Final thoughts 23:55
Sanjog Aul :[00:23:55]
Jim Wetzel, any final thoughts?
Jim Wetzel :[00:23:57]
Well, I agree very much with what Jim just said. And my final thoughts really are around as we try to envision a different place for manufacturing and a value chain that’s fully connected. It’s an aspirational vision. It’s hopefully not a boil the ocean strategy. But with the technology as it’s moved so fast in such a short time, as we’ve got Internet of Things now, as we’ve got a lot of technologies that we can only hope for are now commercially available, this actually is possible to happen. And so I guess I would leave your audience with a thought that we can do this. It’s not just aspirational. The time is now, but it’s going to take all of us working together to make a manufacturing value chain that we all envision to be highly successful.


