This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.
About this conversation
A CIO Talk Network conversation with Charlie McMahon (Tulane University), Sue Schade (University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers (UMHHC)), hosted by Sanjog Aul.
What the conversation established
The conversation established that humor at work depends on leaders being genuine, real, and accessible, and on people earning the right to use it. Sue Schade said she leads a department of over 600 people and makes a conscious effort to seem approachable, and she pointed to a daily hospital huddle where a Michigan State fan joked that Spartans can do anything in ten seconds while the Michigan fan CEO took it in stride. Charlie McMahon said he uses humor deliberately, writes job descriptions to attract women into leadership, and has his direct reports meet without him to set their own norms. Both agreed that humor must never come at the expense of a person or group, that social media raises the stakes, and that a leader can build a humor friendly subculture even inside a serious organization. Charlie McMahon also said he works to purge do more with less from the lexicon at Tulane.
Host Sanjog Aul talks with Charlie McMahon, Vice President of IT and Chief Technology Officer at Tulane University, and Sue Schade, Chief Information Officer at University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers (UMHHC), about humor, laughter, and leadership. They discuss why most workplaces feel serious, how leaders set the tone, and why a person often has to earn the right to use humor. They compare using humor deliberately versus spontaneously, keeping it appropriate across a diverse workforce, and building a humor friendly subculture inside a serious organization.
Contributors
- Charlie McMahon, Vice President of IT and Chief Technology Officer, Tulane University
- Sue Schade, Chief Information Officer, University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers (UMHHC)
Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network
On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript
Key takeaways
- Charlie McMahon, Vice President of IT and Chief Technology Officer at Tulane University, said people almost have to earn the right to be funny at work. He argued that someone recognized by peers as serious and good at their job earns the license to inject humor, which he sees as necessary in IT given big projects, unreasonable deadlines, and inadequate budgets.
- Sue Schade, Chief Information Officer at University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers (UMHHC), said leaders have to be genuine, real, and accessible for humor to work. She runs a department of over 600 people and makes a conscious effort to come across as open and approachable even though people first read her as a serious person.
- Charlie McMahon of Tulane University said he uses humor deliberately rather than spontaneously, only when a situation could benefit from a change in tone. He also has his direct reports meet as a group without him so they set their own norms of behavior, which he compared to learning how to act by watching others in a church service instead of following a rule book.
- Sue Schade of University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers (UMHHC) said humor carries a risk that innovation does not, because a joke that offends someone is not a start over situation. She warned that social media makes pictures and quotes easy to share, so leaders must keep educating people from a diversity perspective to avoid jokes at the expense of an individual or group.
- Charlie McMahon of Tulane University said he works to purge the phrase do more with less from the lexicon at Tulane and replace it with doing the right thing with the resources they have. He called that assumption offensive to his staff and said it squeezes humor out of an organization, while pointing to Dilbert as proof that IT work still leaves room for humor.
- Sue Schade of University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers (UMHHC) said a leader can build a humor friendly subculture even when the wider organization is serious. She described changing her IT department’s subculture over three years by laying out her values and guiding principles and reinforcing them with staff.
Chapters
- 0:00 Introduction: humor, laughter, and leadership
- 2:54 the state of humor at work
- 4:18 leaders set the tone
- 10:38 earning the right to be funny
- 14:37 keeping humor from turning divisive
- 20:22 building a culture where humor is safe
- 25:23 being genuine, real, and accessible
- 33:21 using humor with bosses and peers
- 41:12 no line, only context
- 46:24 hiring for cultural fit
- 50:22 pushing back on do more with less
- 54:04 dignity and respect when humor is hard
Explore more
- Is Leadership for you?
- Leadership as an Orchestra
- Women and Leadership
- Leadership Howtos
- Leadership in Crisis
- Leadership and Smiles
Transcript
Introduction: humor, laughter, and leadership 0:00
Sanjog Aul [00:00:56]:
So today’s title is Humor, Laughter, and Leadership, and we have Charlie McMahon, who’s the Vice President of IT and Chief Technology Officer with Tulane University. Hey, Charlie. How are you?
Sanjog Aul [00:01:32]:
So we also have Sue Schade, who’s the Chief Information Officer, University of Michigan Hospitals and Health Centers. How are you, Sue?
Sanjog Aul [00:01:44]:
So now the reason we thought of covering this topic is because, of course, we have busy lives. We have some seriousness built into the kind of work that we do, but frankly, life is not all about just putting ourselves to a grindstone and not looking back and not living a little, and at the same time, we also see that when we are laughing, when we have a smile on our faces, we end up being more productive. We are more creative. We are more in a camaraderie mode versus doing what we want to do ourselves. So all of those areas are very important for an organization if they have that as part of the DNA or the culture that they develop, but for some reason, a majority of organizations have a serious tone about them, and we are hoping to have a discussion where we explore what is the best way to turn that around and have some humor and laughter in the workplace, which will allow us to be better leaders and better workers. That said, Sue, let me ask you. Of course, you could talk about your organizations or organizations in general. What do you think is the state of humor in today’s workplace?
the state of humor at work 2:54
Sue Schade [00:02:54]:
Well, it’s probably not very good overall for most people. I think people are working harder than ever. My experiences in health care IT span my entire professional career, and really, the rate of change is very fast and it’s constant for both health care and technology. We deal with a lot of serious issues in terms of patient care, saving lives, as well as in IT. Just this morning, I was looking at an audit report on security. Well, that’s not a funny subject at all. Very serious issues when you think about some of what CIOs deal with right now. We also have a much more diverse workforce than when I started in my professional career many years ago, and there’s a very necessary cautiousness I think about what’s appropriate and acceptable humor, and we can get more into that, but I think it’s finding the right balance between work and fun in the workplace. It’s a challenge for all of us, but when you think about the fact that we spend more hours with colleagues at work probably than with our families each week, we’ve gotta have some fun. Talking to a few people here prior to doing this, they all agreed that we need to work on it and have more fun, but I can get into later some of the stuff that we have done.
Sanjog Aul [00:04:08]:
Now, Charlie, when somebody’s driving into work, do you think most of them have a smile on their face and say, oh man, I’m going to have a good time?
leaders set the tone 4:18
Charlie McMahon [00:04:18]:
Well, I tell you, it’s a mixed bag. We all have organizations, departments within our companies that seem to have a heavy pall cast over them by their leadership, and we all have groups that you look at and say, man, I wish I worked on that team, because they just seem to enjoy each other and enjoy the work that they’re doing. So that’s a mixed bag. I think as leaders, and part of this discussion is about leadership, it’s our responsibility to make sure that we have an environment that people enjoy, that they look forward to coming to work, and if you fail at that, if we as leaders fail at that, then we’ve failed at our primary job of making our teams as productive as they can be, and humor plays a big part in that.
Sanjog Aul [00:05:19]:
So while we do realize that these are gaps and we would love to have this one happy family going about doing what they’re supposed to do, then you got a conflict or an issue or a seriousness if it is not maintained to the desired degree when somebody’s working and if they’re not cracking jokes every couple of minutes, then nothing will get done. So, Sue, when you look at this, is this more of a dilemma that we have created versus how a worker thinks today that if they have a smile on their face, they’re cracking jokes every couple of minutes, they are really actually more engaged in what they’re supposed to do. Do they really need to be a poker face when they’re talking or doing the job?
Sue Schade [00:06:03]:
No. People don’t need to have a poker face. I’m a serious person, and people think I’m a serious person. They don’t necessarily think I’m funny, but when they get to know me, they know that I like to have fun and I can be funny. So I think that, as leaders, we need to make sure that we’re really genuine and real and accessible to people, and we set that tone. Some of the folks here that I talked to prior to this said pretty much this is an organization that is serious and leaders are not. You have to be careful around leaders, but I think that once you start establishing those relationships, which are critical, that’s where the humor and the fun can come in a little bit more, but you do want people to get up in the morning and want to go to the place that they work, do the kind of work that they do, work with the people they work with, and have a positive attitude about that, and that’s the meaningfulness of the work, that’s the environment they work in, which is where the fun and the humor can come in along with just what they’re trying to get done. For us it’s a mission driven organization. So the passion for health care, and what we do in making a difference in people’s lives, comes into play a lot.
Sanjog Aul [00:07:24]:
So this is interesting the way you responded to this question. You said that you are a person who enjoys fun, but people have to get to know you before it will be revealed. So as a leader, you think that you’re at the top and somebody’s coming in. They may find you, I’m not saying you in particular, but anyone who has that demeanor, it is not perhaps that you’re putting on that demeanor. It just becomes the nature because you may be preoccupied with thoughts, but to the other person, especially a developer, for example, would find that to be okay. So how do I get to know this person? She seems unapproachable, and then it could be having its own challenges.
Sue Schade [00:08:01]:
I’ve got a department of over 600 people, and I have a lot of interaction, obviously, with the leadership team. We have a regular, twice a year all staff meeting where everybody sees me. I do a lot of written communication to people. So I try to get across a real open, accessible, approachable style to people in all my interactions. Though when you first meet me and see me in a meeting, you might think, wow, she’s all work and serious. So it’s a mix. It’s a mix, and it’s a conscious effort on my part to make sure that I have that very open, approachable style with people.
Charlie McMahon [00:08:50]:
So let me weigh in on this also. I think these are very important points for us as leaders. We do have to be taken seriously by not only our management, but by the people that work for us. So there is some natural inclination to act in that manner. That doesn’t exclude setting a tone in your organization where having an enjoyable workplace is prohibited, but I do think we just find ourselves as leaders in positions where we have to make sure that the serious side of our business is reflected in our demeanors and the way we approach leadership of our jobs. It goes hand in glove. It’s not something that we can walk away from.
Sanjog Aul [00:09:57]:
And Charlie, you are right in terms of what expectations somebody else would have or perhaps you would have to wear, not as a mask, but more as a demeanor for people to take you seriously, but perhaps because comics may not become the greatest leaders for specific and organizational setting. Now that said, would you think your demeanor or your approach to how to get respect and get the job done somehow percolates throughout the organization and that converts everybody else who otherwise wanted to have humor once in a while or at least most of the time while being productive, they think maybe that’s not an idea. You’re almost like a parent giving your kids a signal that it is better to be serious than to have some fun. What do you think?
earning the right to be funny 10:38
Charlie McMahon [00:10:38]:
So I’ll say that what I observe in my environment is that people almost have to earn the right to be funny. You have to be seen as a serious person, recognized by your peers as being good at what you do, and that makes it much easier for you to inject humor into the workplace, and believe me, I think that humor is a necessary part of the workplace, particularly in IT when you have many times big projects, unreasonable deadlines, inadequate budgets, and sometimes if you just can’t laugh at yourself, if you can’t lighten the mood a little bit, it can become oppressive, but my observation is that those people that are most effective at using humor to help the organization achieve its goals are those people who are perceived as having earned their stripes, so to speak, that they are taken very seriously, and that the fact that they’re taken seriously gives them license to lighten up a bit.
Sanjog Aul [00:12:01]:
So when you look at innovation and when we have innovation and somebody makes mistakes and you try to develop a culture of innovation, you say, that’s okay, because we are in that innovative culture. You got some immunity, and that’s gonna get the benefits that people will try harder. They will try more creatively and produce results. Now bring that back to humor. When we say that, okay, you can laugh a little. I’m gonna laugh a little when I do what I do, but then go ahead, mister worker. Go ahead and laugh a little, but then when they try to laugh and be themselves, then there is an unsaid or an implied pullback thinking that, oh my god. I’m not sure if I will be because I’m enjoying my life while working will be seen in the same light as if I was making mistakes in an innovation culture. So would you want to build a humor developed based culture like you would want to develop innovation based culture?
Sue Schade [00:12:54]:
If I understand your question right, I think that the innovation based culture, very important that people have an opportunity to experiment and to fail and to start over. I think when it comes to humor, there may be issues relative to actually making a mistake with a joke, offending someone. It’s not a start over kind of thing, so there’s a delicacy with that, and I’m just gonna pause and say that we’re a live show. The irony of this is that we took a power hit in my office building a few minutes ago, and I did get cut off. The phone system is still coming back. I’m looking at my display on my phone, but I did flip over to my cell phone, and I’m hearing a little feedback on it. So, hopefully, the quality is okay for now. The irony of this is just too much. This power hit like this has never happened. I’m looking out my window at a gorgeous sunny day.
Sanjog Aul [00:13:58]:
So then you made the most of it by laughing at the situation versus getting all wound up. So you kind of demonstrated what you just said. So coming back to you, Charlie, when you are looking at the organizations who have really used humor and fun in their culture to really take it to the next level of productivity, customer satisfaction, employee satisfaction, profitability, and growth. With all that happening, with that as a benchmark, are we missing something where we are not able to eat the cake and have it too like those organizations did? Because there’s a proof right there.
keeping humor from turning divisive 14:37
Charlie McMahon [00:14:37]:
I don’t think so. Each organization is going to develop with a character of its own. Each organization is unique, and I think you’ve got to find the right fit for your environment, and that’s a reflection of the leadership that happens above you and the leadership that you project to the teams that are working for you. If we think of this as a continuum, if we swing too far to either side on this continuum, we probably are not doing the best balancing act that we can do. We have a place that has no room for humor, just a pressure cooker. That’s not going to be a very healthy environment, and if, on the other hand, if we allow things to become so frivolous that we do take our eye off the ball, or something that was alluded to earlier, if we use humor inappropriately, that can be divisive in the organization, then we’ve allowed humor to become not a positive but a negative, and I feel fairly strongly that humor in the workplace is one area that we really have to absolutely be what people would term politically correct. We cannot, as leaders, tolerate humor in the workforce that is done at the expense of another group’s class of people or an individual. Those things would not be adding to the productivity of your group.
Sanjog Aul [00:16:31]:
And 100% correct in terms of not letting this humor impact someone adversely, but I’d like to bring back that tone of caution. Do you think any worker out there would like to lose their job over a joke? Do you think they would not be watching and I’m sure they’re all professionals and adults? Perhaps you’ve done the right hiring, then we should let it go.
Sue Schade [00:17:05]:
When you say let it go, we cannot let people get over a cautiousness or a concern about this. We need to continually educate people from a diversity perspective, ensure that people are not making jokes at the expense of an individual or a group of people, and I think as leaders, we have to take that very seriously, and I think in this current environment, you look at social media, what’s out there, there’s all sorts of pictures and quotes that people can be easily sharing and passing around. People have to be very careful as professionals what they say and do within the workforce and I would stand by that. I don’t think that means you have to be restrained or intimidated in terms of fun and humor, but you have to be very careful.
Sanjog Aul [00:18:03]:
So let’s explore what kind of culture would foster humor and laughter, what kind of leadership mindset would actually foster humor and laughter which is safe, and how would it help as an organization? We know the obvious benefits, but in what way would you bring about or develop such a culture?
Sanjog Aul [00:20:00]:
So, Charlie, let’s look at the type of culture that we need to foster in order to have the humor and laughter, and I get the point about being cautious so that it doesn’t go out of hand. So how do you develop that type of a culture where people are comfortable, but all along keeping in mind that they don’t cross the line?
building a culture where humor is safe 20:22
Charlie McMahon [00:20:22]:
What I do is first, I pay attention to diversity. We talk about this every week in my shop. We do succession planning. We are conscious about demographics. We take special efforts as we’re writing job descriptions to write them in a way that is attracting the kind of people that we want. For example, attracting women in leadership positions. We found that if you say things like, do whatever it takes, that kind of cowboy mentality doesn’t resonate well with women in general. If you use words that are more team building, collaborative, you have more success. So by talking about those diversity issues, in my view, it makes it more unlikely that humor would be used in an inappropriate or offensive way in the workplace. I use humor, and I use it deliberately. I’m not spontaneous with humor. I use it deliberately when I feel the situation could benefit from a change in tone, and the way I use humor sets some expectations for the way my team uses humor, and then the final thing that I do is I make sure that my direct reports have regular opportunities to meet as a group without me so that they can develop the relationships and the norms of behavior amongst each other that let them find their equilibrium, and I’ll say it like this. It’s kind of like going to a church or a faith different than yours. When you get into a service, you look around and you see the way people are behaving, and pretty soon, you figure out how to behave in that environment without somebody having to give you a whole list of instructions. So what I like to do is create an environment where people can look around and see examples of how to behave, so that you don’t have to have a rule book that people need to follow.
Sue Schade [00:23:13]:
Just looking at a couple of things beforehand, I just want to reference one of them was a Harvard Business Review article called Leading with Humor. Couple key points there talking about don’t be afraid to chuckle or laugh at yourself. It signals that everything’s okay, and the fact that laughter can be disarming in a difficult situation, and you can poke fun at the stuff that everyone’s worried about to kind of lighten it. Another thing I found was from Penn Behavioral Health corporate services on using humor in the workplace. They talked about how it can help people think more creatively, and if an employee is stuck on a problem, then a good laugh can help them clear their mind of the negative thoughts and return to that issue with a fresh, more positive outlook, and how humor can build self confidence in people, making people less afraid to make mistakes and help people regroup from a negative event. You certainly want to temper that depending on what the negative event is, but I think those are some really useful concepts.
Sanjog Aul [00:24:20]:
So, Sue, based on Charlie, what he mentioned about him using deliberate humor, and that’s his style because not everybody’s born with a funny bone, if you will. So now if suppose you cannot be comic and not be fluid at the same time. If you’re deliberate, then people can see from a mile away, and they’ll say, okay. This person is trying to use it deliberately, and then you, on the other hand, are trying to also develop a culture. So I’m trying to connect it back to the culture question I asked that if you are at the top and you’re not the only one responsible, number one, you have to be inclusive and ask those people what does it mean for them to be having a culture of fun and humor and laughter.
Sanjog Aul [00:25:04]:
What are the workers saying? This is our perspective, but what are they saying who are actually gonna be part of the culture?
Sue Schade [00:25:10]:
So what do they think of leaders who are trying or trying too hard?
Sanjog Aul [00:25:14]:
Both. I’d say what do they think about what that culture should look like? What should be the boundaries versus us saying that this is what we think and this is what should be adopted?
being genuine, real, and accessible 25:23
Sue Schade [00:25:23]:
I would just go back to what I said about leaders have to be genuine, real, and accessible. I take that as some of the highest compliments when I get that. I did a panel last week with five other CIOs at a health IT conference, and we covered a range of topics. A couple people came up to me afterwards and used those words. You’re very real and genuine, and they appreciated that. So leaders are real people, and we have to feel comfortable in our own skin when we’re working with people talking in front of large groups, and people can tell that, and I think that they look for that. I’ll give you just another example. We’re going through some organization changes here, and we will have a new leader for the clinical enterprise who’s been here for many years. People know him, but my staff hasn’t interacted with him that much. I had him come to our all staff meeting on Monday and really lay out why we’re making the changes, the vision, and how it impacts us. His talk was done in less time than we thought. We had over a half an hour for Q and A, and with 500 people in the room, I often don’t get much Q and A. People are hesitant. We went that full time with lots of great engaging questions from my staff for both that new leader of the clinical enterprise and myself. Checking with some people later, I got very positive feedback on his talk and how accessible he was and how open he was. Again, those words, they didn’t feel like he was holding anything back and answering his questions, and I think it’s had a very good tone.
Sanjog Aul [00:27:08]:
So the person was accessible and the person was genuine and he was forthcoming. Was humor playing any role in that?
Sue Schade [00:27:15]:
At times. I can’t remember anything in particular, but it wasn’t all serious.
Charlie McMahon [00:27:26]:
Let me go back and reinforce a point that I made earlier. In some respects, you really have to earn the right to use humor, and the circumstances that were just described is a perfect example of doing the things necessary to earn the right to inject humor into the workforce. People will look at both of these individuals as serious people and humor just becomes part of who they are. So I think that was a very nicely done example of earning the right to be able to use humor.
Sanjog Aul [00:28:18]:
So, Charlie, to that, what do you think because you mentioned that you may not have that funny bone in you, but do you think that is at least as a worker now, a person who’s working in the bigger organization, there are a lot of people who may have a fear that they are not funny, or they may have a risk of offending someone, and they’re being cautious, but then that makes them also, and that could be just a stigma or a reservation they may be holding, and that may not truly be the case, and then they may not use humor as much, which in turn will negatively contribute towards how they are seen as being more approachable, someone who can be a team player, and also perhaps their productivity. So how do we get people perhaps to have a line drawn around them to say, don’t cross this line in terms of humor, but don’t think that you are good for nothing?
Charlie McMahon [00:29:06]:
So first of all, I’ll come back and I’ll say, I think everyone has a sense of humor. Everyone can inject humor, laughter into the workplace. I say that with some trepidation, because in IT we all have people that really prefer to work with their door shut, the lights turned off, and just bathe in the glow of their monitor. So we do have a stereotype of an IT worker that is maybe more antisocial than you would see in a marketing department, but what I found in IT is all of our folks have a sense of humor, and what I think is important is that you develop an organizational culture that sets norms of behavior that give people a safe way, a safe place, to express humor when they feel it’s necessary, and I will also say we all have people in our organizations who use humor inappropriately. Everything they do seems to be taken as a joke, and you don’t have the seriousness that you would like. That typically gets dealt with by the social norms that grow up in the organization. So those are a couple of observations I have about your question.
Sanjog Aul [00:30:43]:
Let’s talk about the ways with which people can feel comfortable using humor with their bosses and not just their peers. Because, of course, with bosses, they feel that anything we do, we have to be super cautious because it might cost us our job. How do you make that happen, and how do you develop that along the chain of command within an organization?
Sanjog Aul [00:32:49]:
So, Sue, when we are talking to our peers, of course, we feel that there is no risk if you will, and, yes, we have to be careful, but with bosses, I think that changes quite a bit because our job is on the line every time we communicate or at least that’s how we feel. Of course, there are two directions here. One is how does a leader or a manager make their people comfortable, but then how does an individual make that happen where they’re able to enjoy that humor because that is also gonna break the barriers.
using humor with bosses and peers 33:21
Sue Schade [00:33:21]:
So I think it certainly depends on your boss’ style and what the relationship is, and I think that the strongest relationships are those where you can make some kind of personal connection, and that’s whether it’s with your boss or a peer or someone who works for you or your staff, talking about their kids, their families, their hobbies, you name it. Really getting to know people you work with in a genuine way can help build positive working relationships and allow you to be that much more effective together, and I think that humor and funny stories can be a part of that. I’m gonna give you two examples if I can, both where it would be a situation with someone and their boss. So in one example, I was the boss and we had all of our managers (we’ve got about 50 managers in my IT department) take a communication style tool from a place called Straight Talk. We did the survey. Everybody got their style. Then at one of our meetings, we had a facilitator who shared the results with everybody, how many people were of each different style. Then we broke out into separate groups, people with like styles and had to try to communicate with people with different styles. I made a joke openly in front of everybody that one of my executive directors had said to me, well, your style is probably dictator. I said that openly, and I said, but it’s not. My style is actually diplomat according to the survey. People were surprised that I would make a joke like that or that that direct report to me would even say something to me like that. You’re probably dictator style, but it was all in fun, and we were okay with it. The other example I’ll give you is that we have a daily leadership huddle now at the hospital, and the beginning of the huddle is what we call ten second follow-up on action items from previous huddles. One of our hospital leaders who’s a very serious Michigan State University Spartan fan, and you can imagine there is a huge rivalry between MSU and the University of Michigan, and it was a few days after the University of Michigan lost to MSU in the last ten seconds, if you remember that game, if you follow college football at all. She was called on for her action update, and her response was, certainly, we Spartans can do anything in ten seconds, and everybody laughed. Then she gave her update. When she was done with her serious action update on the issue, our CEO who runs the huddle, and he’s a die hard Michigan fan, and he signs his emails often with go blue, he just took it all in stride and said he was glad to provide something for them to laugh about. So it was an important moment there, in a serious meeting. It was short, and it was fine, and nobody was offended.
Sanjog Aul [00:36:25]:
So that’s a great two way example of how it was done. So what would you think, Sue, was the mindset at that time for the worker who went ahead and said something outright to the boss? Was that the boss created that environment that they are more approachable and they are more immune to such comments?
Sue Schade [00:36:47]:
I think so, and it wasn’t the person who said certainly, Spartans can do anything in ten seconds is one of our hospital leaders who also reports to the CEO. She’s new in the last year. I don’t know how strong or good their working relationship is, but we saw humor used effectively, and everybody was fine with it.
Sanjog Aul [00:37:11]:
So, Charlie, coming to the humor getting misconstrued as a distraction or frivolity, how do you know if that person is truly wasting time versus taking a break or bringing some fun into their daily lives, which otherwise could be mighty where a lot of effort has been put in every day by them?
Charlie McMahon [00:37:39]:
So that’s a fundamental management question. You really have to keep your eye on the outcomes that you’re working towards. I find that most of the folks where I’ve had to deal with people in the past that were using humor inappropriately or frivolously or to the point that it was distracting to the team, that gets surfaced by other team members pretty quickly, and it becomes the responsibility of the manager to deal with it appropriately. Of course it’s a fine line. You don’t want to snuff humor out of the organization by having an overreaction, but at the same time, if other people are not able to do their jobs effectively, if it affects the productivity of the individual or the team, you’ve got to recognize it and you’ve got to act on it.
Sanjog Aul [00:38:43]:
And so when you go out and try to set the tone of the organization, how do you somehow convey that, okay, humor is acceptable, in fact, welcome, but then a certain set of behavioral patterns will be seen as a sign of distraction because everybody could have a different benchmark? How do you create that pervasive, basically a way of interpreting how when are they crossing the line? Not in terms of what they say, but how much?
Sue Schade [00:39:15]:
It’s a hard question, in terms of setting the tone and not crossing the line. One way, let’s use a very concrete example. People do a lot of presentations in meetings or in large groups. Sometimes they’re for reviews and making updates and making decisions. Sometimes they’re just broadly informational. People also do email all day long. These are both places where you can appropriately or inappropriately insert some humor. What I would guard against is an example of someone who for quite some time in her email signature had a really kind of funny yet sarcastic photo image and end quote. I finally, as a professional woman and leader, sent her a note saying, here’s the way that comes across, and you might want to think about taking it out because this is how it comes across to people. So I was trying to give her some gentle guidance. It doesn’t work for me, totally different department, and I think that we as leaders have a responsibility to call things out when we see them and help guide people. So that was an example. Another example is how people can use images and quotes and humor within presentations. If it’s helping make the point and get across something versus just inappropriate or a distraction, you gotta find the line between those two as well.
Sanjog Aul [00:40:56]:
So what you just shared is basically in a formal communication. So I’ll come to Charlie. I just had a follow-up question. How do you take this beyond a presentation where there’s a canned set of slides and specific messages to be conveyed?
no line, only context 41:12
Charlie McMahon [00:41:12]:
So I want to come back and follow-up on the question you just asked. One of the things that I think makes that question so difficult is that there is no line. The line between appropriate and inappropriate has to be viewed in the context of what’s going on. So even very healthy humor in the workplace, there are times where that may be inappropriate due to the seriousness of what’s being discussed or the circumstances you’re dealing with at the time, and I found that many of the folks that really have trouble with humor have trouble with doing it in context, where they may get into a pattern of reacting with humor or injecting humor, and you get into a circumstance where what was appropriate in the normal course of business is now inappropriate because of the unique circumstances you’re dealing with. That makes it a very difficult road to navigate in the workplace.
Sanjog Aul [00:42:34]:
How do you deal with such a person who kind of has his funny comment just popping up at the right time? Do you shut that person up?
Sue Schade [00:42:44]:
I think you deal with it like you do any possible behavior issue: you take them aside and give them direct feedback. I’m a huge proponent of being able to give people real time feedback, not in front of others, but pull them aside after the meeting and say, you’ve gotten some feedback on this before. This example in the meeting was another example of it. You just need to be more careful about it. People don’t always see what’s going on, what they’re doing objectively as the other person does, and so being able to give them that feedback is important, and I think that, for anybody, but certainly for leaders, you can never let your guard down. When people are in uncomfortable situations or nervous about something, that may be when people let their guard down and start using humor in inappropriate ways or offhanded jokes at the expense of someone else, and you don’t want that in your environment.
Sanjog Aul [00:43:55]:
Charlie, I’d like to explore, what do you do when you are actually hiring people? Of course, all of these areas are not exposed fully when you are talking to a person in the interview. If somebody shows that they have this tendency to have humor in them and they enjoy fun, is that truly seen as a black mark? Or do you think you allow that in, but if you do allow that in, then later on, do you stifle it? How do you measure up before and after a person has joined the organization?
Sanjog Aul [00:46:00]:
So one is to deal with people who you have hired and now their positive or negative sides about how they use humor in the workplace are exposed and then you manage them, but what do you do when you’re hiring someone? Do you actually invite someone who has a funny bone and is at least showing signs that the person will contribute positively towards a humor based culture in the organization, Charlie?
hiring for cultural fit 46:24
Charlie McMahon [00:46:24]:
My approach in hiring folks is that by the time we get to the interview stage, everybody we’re talking to is qualified. So I’m no longer looking primarily at whether they can do the job or not. We know by this time they’ve got the technical skills for whatever. I focus mainly on the organizational fit and the cultural fit and how they interact with me, how they interact with the teams being interviewed, both in the formal settings and then frequently in the casual settings at a dinner or a breakfast, become very important. The appropriateness of the way they use humor is definitely a factor in what we evaluate. Again, at this point in time, it’s no longer about the technical expertise. It’s, are they going to help you build a high functioning team? And so you make some judgments about culturally how they’re going to fit in, organizationally how they’re going to fit in, and then you hope that those judgments turn out to be correct. As most of us do once we’ve hired somebody, there is, I’ll say, it’s kind of a free period for us as managers. For the first few weeks and months, if we find out we’ve made a mistake, we need to recognize it early and deal with it immediately, and sometimes it comes down to technical competence, but as I say, generally that question has already been settled before they get into the interviews. So it really comes down to whether they are contributing in a positive way to the organization. If they’re not, I fall back on the old management mantra: slow to hire, quick to fire, if they don’t fit in culturally, if they’re inappropriate in their interactions, and particularly if they’re inappropriate in the way they use humor to fit in, those are all negatives that you’ve got to evaluate very early in a new employee’s tenure.
Sanjog Aul [00:48:44]:
So, Sue, as interview advice, would you think that any organization which frankly wants some humor and laughter in that person so that they can be better team player, they’re more approachable, do you think that is a trait that you will advise for them to somehow demonstrate it part of the interview, not deliberately, but just by being themselves, or would you caution against it?
Sue Schade [00:49:05]:
I think that there’s two keywords you just said. One is just be yourself, and the other is approachable. So whether it’s humor or something else, I think, again, I go back to being genuine and real and accessible especially with leaders. That’s what you’re looking for. I agree with Charlie. By the time you get to the interview stage, a lot of it is about fit with the organization and the team, not about the actual technical competencies, and you’re looking for people that you’ll want to work with on whatever the project is. So are they approachable? And you want to, as much as you can in that interview process, see that person’s style and interaction.
Sanjog Aul [00:49:51]:
So, coming back to you, Charlie, do you think given we work in IT where we have to do more with less and more with nothing, and we are usually scrambling for resources, and we have burnout and everything else in between. Do you think there is much left for a person to have the breathing room to actually have humor, or do you even work on that side to give people some breathing room, if you will, to feel that they are working at a place where they as human beings can survive and have a little laughter?
pushing back on do more with less 50:22
Charlie McMahon [00:50:22]:
So I’m gonna start with one of the things you said earlier. I work very hard to purge the phrase do more with less from the lexicon at Tulane. We really work hard to change that into we do the right thing with the resources that we have, and frankly, I’m sorry I’m getting off on a non humorous topic here, but I find it offensive to my staff, to my leadership style, to assume that anything we’re doing is not being done efficiently and effectively. This concept that we can do more with less because we are not good at our jobs, we really have to push back against that, and if we don’t, then the way that manifests in our organizations is that it squeezes the humor out of it. If people look at you and say, you’re not good at your job, you just have to do better, you’ve got to do more than you’re doing. When everyone is working hard, everyone is doing amazing things, it limits the opportunity for humor in the workplace. Now having said that, we try and set the right tone, and you find humor in IT all the time. I don’t know if you’re a fan of Dilbert, but how can you look at the environment that we live in and not find humor and find ways to express it? So I don’t see a real risk in our business that the seriousness and intensity of what we do crushes your soul and leaves no room for humor. That’s just not our reality.
Sanjog Aul [00:52:26]:
So when you look at the overall environment that you may have, and you may want to build a subculture, maybe not an organizational level because perhaps the top management may not be a big proponent of humor, but you yourself might think that, okay. We should have some humor in our workplace because that’s gonna keep people alive and invigorated. Would you be able to insulate and build your subculture with something like this? Would you propose leaders in IT should do that so that their people, while working hard, also feel that they’re living?
Sue Schade [00:52:58]:
Absolutely. I think that there is a culture to your overall organization, but as you say, there are subcultures, and I have worked hard at trying to change the culture (the subculture if you will) within my IT department since I got here three years ago. I laid out in the beginning what my values and guiding principles were and I reinforce them all the time with people. I’ve been told I’m extremely different than my predecessor. There’s things that even after a year, they’re saying we’re still getting used to you, and I’m like, I’ve been here a year. This is the way I work. This is my style. This is what I expect. Get used to it. So I think you absolutely, as the leader of your part of the organization, can establish what you want that culture to be. Hopefully, it is very aligned with the overall organization’s culture on all its dimensions, but if there’s some things that you want to do more of, that you don’t see in your overall organization, by all means, you should try to figure out how to do that.
dignity and respect when humor is hard 54:04
Charlie McMahon [00:54:04]:
Let me interject a point here. We do have places in our organizations, not in the IT shops, of course, but where it seems like they are more grim and the interactions are less pleasant, and one of the things that I try and do with my folks is remind them that the only things they can really control are their actions, and that they need to very deliberately treat everyone, including each other, with dignity and respect. So when you get in these situations where humor doesn’t seem to be possible, people can fall back on their personal integrity in ways that preserve the spark of joy that they have in their own workplace by not letting themselves get dragged down by interactions with another organization that may not be as comfortable a working environment.


