Culture • Cybersecurity • IT Strategy & Business Alignment • Leadership

How to make IT security everyone’s business?

How to make IT security everyone’s business?

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Sheryl Rose (Summa Health System), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that security becomes everyone’s business when the security leader partners with the business rather than issuing mandates. Sheryl Rose of Summa Health System, drawing on 20 years in security and risk management, said cyber risk is now among the top concerns executives name, which gives security leaders an opening to partner. She argued that telling people to keep the company safe is not actionable, and that embedding security into forums the business already runs, such as a hospital’s safety huddle, makes it relatable. Rose said awareness is more than an annual training module that end users click through, and that phishing campaigns help because they feel like real life. Before asking leadership for funding, she recommended walking the floor and bringing phishing metrics and specific examples rather than a vague request for security awareness dollars. She also said most breaches still trace to phishing and end user actions, so the messaging has to keep changing.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Sheryl Rose, Chief Information Security Officer at Summa Health System, about how to make IT security everyone’s business rather than the job of a lone security department. Rose explains why cyber risk now sits among executives’ top concerns and how security leaders can partner with the business instead of pushing mandates. She covers embedding security messages into meetings the business already holds, such as hospital safety huddles, building a communication plan before asking leadership for funding, and treating awareness as more than annual training. The conversation also weighs funding security as a shared service and grooming security leaders who have the interpersonal skills to win over the business.

Contributors

  • Sheryl Rose, Chief Information Security Officer, Summa Health System

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Sheryl Rose, Chief Information Security Officer at Summa Health System, says IT security becomes everyone’s business only when the security leader partners with the business instead of pushing mandates down. She notes that cyber risk now ranks among the top concerns executives name, which gives security leaders an opening to work alongside the business rather than police it.
  • Sheryl Rose of Summa Health System argues that telling employees to keep the company safe is not actionable because no one knows what it means. She recommends bringing a specific, meaningful ask to the right people at the right level instead of a broad security mandate.
  • Sheryl Rose, Chief Information Security Officer at Summa Health System, says security messages land better when they are embedded in meetings the business already holds. She points to a hospital’s safety huddle as a place to insert a short security topic so clinicians can walk out knowing what to do.
  • Sheryl Rose of Summa Health System says security awareness has to be more than an annual training module that end users click through and acknowledge. She uses phishing campaigns, targeted brown bag lunches, and year round communication because threats and end user behavior change every day.
  • Sheryl Rose, Chief Information Security Officer at Summa Health System, says a funding request works better when it carries specifics than when it asks for security awareness dollars. She brings phishing metrics and examples from walking the floor so leadership sees real, business relevant risk.
  • Sheryl Rose of Summa Health System says most breaches still occur because of phishing and end user actions, which should keep security teams humble. She frames the work as a marathon, not a sprint, and favors embedding security roles in the business so it feels like day to day work rather than a race.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: making IT security everyone’s business
  • 2:33 Why cyber risk is now a top executive concern
  • 5:18 Keeping security a two way street with the business
  • 7:30 Keeping it simple and partnering with key leaders
  • 13:14 Moving beyond annual awareness training
  • 21:21 Building a communication plan and asking for funding
  • 28:02 Why this is a marathon not a sprint
  • 36:25 Embedding security roles inside the business
  • 42:00 Funding security as a shared service
  • 51:27 Grooming security leaders with softer skills

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: making IT security everyone’s business 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:29]:
And the topic for today is How To Make IT Security Everyone’s Business. So in the digital age, that’s what we are all living in. IT security is supposed to help with resilience. It is supposed to help as a catalyst for innovation and drive growth. That’s a lot of demands that business is placing on security. But then can we realistically do it when we are left as lone warriors in our security department trying to tell everyone, pushing everyone to think about security? What would it take for us to make IT security everyone’s business where we have a cohesive force with all business leaders, business users, technology teams to come together and make it happen. So to discuss this topic, I have with me today Sheryl Rose. Sheryl is the interim Chief Information Security Officer with Summa Health.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:42]:
So, the discussion is not new to you, but I think for the listeners, we really wanted to appeal the importance of the security function, at the same time, discuss this challenge that we continually bring up that the rest of the world doesn’t care about security which is in their interest, and they should. So when we were to go out and try to figure out what’s the way to do it, we have to first understand what business wants from IT security in the digital context. Do they want you to step aside and let them go like they are in a Ferrari? Or are they saying you come along with us?

Why cyber risk is now a top executive concern 2:33

Sheryl Rose [00:02:33]:
I think when I look back on my career, I’ve spent 20 years in security and risk management. I certainly see over the last probably 4 to 5 years a tide of shift. And that being, I think it’s easy for us to say security is everybody’s responsibility. I say that all the time myself. I also say that with that, when you look at business leaders and executives, and you ask them what their top 3 concerns are, odds are 1 of them is going to be cyber risk or security in general or concern about a breach. So I think that the fact that that is top of mind gives us as security leaders an opportunity to figure out how to partner with them in a way that makes sense for the business, and ensure that we are driving security forward with them. I think that is still a heavy lift, because at the end of the day, we all know that from a security perspective, it’s the day to day that we do every day that makes the difference and that makes us drive better security forward. I look at it and I see all the time, I’ll be asked or I’ll be told I want a partner. I don’t want to have a breach. I want good security. Are we secure? I think all of those things are really challenging, and I think we have to work through ways to find how to truly be that partner because being the partner at the table will not only help us educate and business folks carry some of the torch along the way, but it will also help drive some of the initiatives in an easier way for us.

Sanjog Aul [00:04:38]:
Question for you. Given security has always been seen as a necessary evil or a secondary function historically, and now it’s becoming important because there are breaches and nobody wants to lose their shirt while they make money. Do you think business has gotten used to saying, I want you to partner. I want you to help deliver for the business. Have they accepted this as a joint responsibility, or are there only asks from them but no yielding?

Keeping security a two way street with the business 5:18

Sheryl Rose [00:05:18]:
I think it has improved, certainly. I do think that the business sees that it’s better done together. I think that the days of IT security being kind of buried in the bowels of IT and provisioning IDs and putting firewall rules in place. I think that those days, that’s still critical work. There’s no doubt. But the element of being more forward in the organization is where we really need to be, and I think the business wants us to be. But I still think there’s a balance. I still humble myself constantly because like everybody in security, I’m super passionate about it. I could talk about it all day. But I also recognize that being in an industry, health care, financial services or whatever, I don’t want people saying our business is to run a hospital or our business is to run a bank. It’s not to drive security solutions. So I do try and balance that, and I think the way we kind of attack that with the business is what will help us partner better. Because I think if we just kind of push security towards them and not humble ourselves around what the business needs are, what they’re trying to drive to, it has to be a two way street.

Sanjog Aul [00:06:49]:
So the fact that we have this topic being discussed and the problem statement is we are most passionate and others are not about security. Where are we losing things in the semantics of the words we use or the communication that we do where they start feeling that it’s not my problem to tackle with. I want the results, but I don’t need to be, so I’m not supposed to contribute towards the outcome that security is supposed to bring. Where are we losing it?

Keeping it simple and partnering with key leaders 7:30

Sheryl Rose [00:07:30]:
I think every day, I kind of ground myself on. When you look at security, how we say it’s tons of disciplines that are an inch wide and five miles deep. And I’m probably patting us all on the back because we have to have a good solid knowledge on a lot of different stuff. And I think that when you get in front of the business and we start to lose them is we’re not keeping it simple. We’re not focusing at the most basic level of what truly are we trying to accomplish and what do we want them specifically doing. And one of the things I’ve talked about before is how do you mix it up going forward and partnering with 1 or 2 key people that at a leadership level can help drive a message? I find it much more impactful if I partner with a leader, say, a chief medical officer, and that chief medical officer then reaches out to the physicians and the clinical staff and messages something from a security perspective than if it’s coming from the CISO. So to me, I think the more we can engage the right folks specifically and engage at the right level without overwhelming on everything, I think, can help us drive more effectively.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:10]:
So whenever you are talking to the people there, in your business, have you asked them, the business leaders, especially? Because it’s not about just only the top business leaders are the ones who need to come on board, but even business users. Have you asked them for help to say instead of us just sending a communication to the overall user community so that they join forces with you, there could be some support offered by them. So they kind of establish the importance of security in the minds of those business users and the sponsorship for security? So the business users start thinking that, hey, if the top leaders are saying I got to pay attention to this, like other things, I must. How do you make that happen?

Sheryl Rose [00:10:02]:
And I think that is a unique avenue for every business, every company. I think it depends on culture and a whole bunch of different things. But I do think, to your point, I don’t think anybody doesn’t want to do something. I think that if you have a bunch of business leaders going to their next layer of management saying, thou shalt engage in security or thou shalt support or whatever, I don’t think any of them are gonna say, yeah. I don’t want to do that. I think it’s more what do you want me to do? And I think it’s when we say, hey. Go keep x y z company safe. That’s not actionable. No one knows what that really means. So I think what that means to the people that we want to engage with at any level of position is how do we bring it to them in a meaningful way? And I think some ways that work is instead of setting up, say, an hour-long discussion or a 30-minute meeting and calling it some kind of security awareness or we have a new security initiative and we want to talk about it, instead of doing that, because people are gonna be like, I don’t know if that applies to me, and I’m super busy. What about engaging and putting what we want to get across in some of their meetings? In a hospital setting, they have safety huddle meetings, and they talk about certain topics that are relevant on the floor to the clinicians. And if we can embed some of our conversation in those meetings with the right level of folks, I think we have a better chance of making it more relatable to them so they can walk out of there and go, yeah. That I see what I can do. Right? Instead of just security coming down and say, keep x y z safe.

Sanjog Aul [00:12:10]:
So when are we looking at the user base? And they are themselves supposed to be working with the security. Do you think and frankly, the reason I’m bringing this up is because the adoption of security is being connected to or as a solution to it, is connected to training. But is just giving people training and saying you gotta do it almost like training or giving a lecture to students? Their eyes would glaze over. Is that enough for them to adopt it, for them to embrace it and internalize that security is important for them? They may realize, but then if they have got a ton of other work to do, anything more, anything new is usually rejected by the user community. So are we stuck only dealing with security adoption and having everybody come on board, and the only tactic that we have available to us is just training?

Moving beyond annual awareness training 13:14

Sheryl Rose [00:13:14]:
I don’t think so. But I do think that’s a complicated topic. I think because there’s so much in there that isn’t technical to discuss. It’s user behavior. It’s getting inside the heads of people that say, how do we want to make them, or more importantly, how do we proactively engage them in understanding something and grasping it relative to their own work. So I think at the end of the day, we’ve had security awareness training has been around forever. It’s something, there’s a lot of reasons why we have to do that, and that plays its part. I think what’s important and what I’ve learned over the last several years is to say, yeah, we do security awareness training. I don’t think that that should mean we put some kind of system together and make sure our end users go through it and click the boxes and acknowledge, and we track completion. I think it’s bigger than that. And I think we need to do it in a way that doesn’t make it look like a task. I think there’s things. I think phishing campaigns have helped drive awareness and understanding. I think they have their downfalls if they’re not done well because I think people feel caught or trapped or something like that. But I think when we try and evolve into other things so a phishing campaign, I think that has helped bring awareness to people that’s more real life. But I also think that we can devise any great phishing campaign for somebody to click on it. And a lot of end users are like, when we sit there and we’ll highlight what areas of the campaign they should think about, I still think some of them are like, I’m not sure I quite understand some of that, or I’m so busy. I don’t have time for that. So I think that trying to figure a method out of keeping it simple and keeping it kind of actionable throughout the year is helpful. I think one of the things that I’ve also found is can we prioritize some of the user community and do specific training or specific brown bag lunches or specific whatever the venue works to have some dialogue. So we’ve done brown bag lunches in the past just to have certain topics specifically, say, with database administrators or with people that are familiar and want to better understand changes in payment card industry standards or whatever the specific topic is. So I think that looking at security awareness training needs to be a lot of things in your toolbox, not just an annual awareness training module. I think that needs to be there, but I think we need to set up a program. And quite frankly, I also think that as we build our security programs, I always say there’s two things I don’t think we should gloss over. One is awareness and the second one is communication. I think all too often, we view those things when we’re sitting there looking at our spend and where we need our dollars to go, and it always goes to the big solutions and the big controls. But I think that it’s extremely important to make sure that we’ve allocated something so that we can build the right communication plan. I always say I don’t want to sound like Charlie Brown’s teacher. The only way to do that is to mix it up and to find people that can help whether in your team or outside of your team, engage these topics in a way I’m a security person. I’m not a communication expert. I’m not a behavioral expert when it comes to this. But if I can leverage and find people in my communications department, in Human Resources, in other places, I think it helps bring a lens to this topic that we as risk and technical security individuals may not be able to bring, if that makes sense.

Sanjog Aul [00:18:07]:
And let’s talk about the specific solutions and strategies we can deploy, which will allow us to get leadership to give us the support and sponsorship. Perhaps we already understand the challenges. We need to figure out what strategies will actually work and have worked. That’s where, Sheryl, you could share some insights on your experience and your peers in the industry who have had experience in getting the leadership to give you all the support you need.

Sanjog Aul [00:20:57]:
So, Sheryl, I’m sure the challenges are understood. Let’s talk solutions. Let’s talk down to the brass tacks, tactics or approaches which would work well where the leadership, the business leadership says, yes. We are with you, and they actually yield to you, give you what you want to make this all happen.

Building a communication plan and asking for funding 21:21

Sheryl Rose [00:21:21]:
So I think that there’s a few things to look at and to tailor to any organization that I’ve seen work in the past. So one of the things that I think would be important and fairly easy to put together is to sit down with someone from the communications team and talk through what you want to accomplish and what you think some of the challenges are with your user base. I think that if you can get to kind of a homegrown basic communication plan together that is really partnered with the communication team or someone similar if you don’t have that size of an organization to be able to put down in simple terms what the concerns are, what you want to get across to your end user base from a security perspective. I think that once you have that and any other kinds of methods, let’s say your hospital system. I know that it’s very impactful to just go out on the floor, to go out and see what is happening, what your end users deal with every day. And understanding that gives you a better lens in how you can integrate in security awareness and other things you’re trying to bring forward to them into their day to day. But I think if you’re doing that from your office or from the IT department, you don’t really see what they’re challenged with, what maybe you need to focus on with them. So getting a better just ground understanding of all of that will help you kind of build a communication plan and a messaging plan so that when you go up to leadership to ask for funding, I think it’s important to give specifics. It’s not effective for me to go up to an executive and say I need x dollars for security awareness. First thing people usually say is, well, I know that we have an annual security awareness training. I think what’s more impactful is if we go up there with a larger message that says, I can provide our phishing metrics. I can provide examples when I walk on the floor, and I know how busy everybody is. But these are some of the things we see happening that aren’t in the best realm of security. And I think if we can provide those meaningful business relevant examples to leadership, we have a better chance of getting the support and the funding needed to then take what we can build from a communication plan and start to lay that out throughout the year.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:31]:
Now similarly, we talk about the leaders helping you work better downstream, at least with the business users. That’s one. Are there any direct interfacing related techniques or approaches which you could utilize to get better cooperation from the business users. And let’s also introduce other entities, which are like partners. So no longer are we working in today’s day and age where we are just internally focused. Especially in digital era, you got partners who you work with, and you, along with them, support and or serve customers. So all of them have to heed the security related issues or advice that has been given to them. So everyone has to be, like, we part of a village. How do you get even the partners to come on board, listen to you, change their systems, or bring them up to speed so that you are secure along the value chain? What approaches have actually worked?

Sheryl Rose [00:25:38]:
So some of the things that I’ve seen that are effective is really it’s just about having the common interaction and the communication at a detailed level. I think when we’re too busy and we just ask for some kind of third party report or what kind of assessments have you done, Mr. partner, I think that glosses over things. So I think the things that are more meaningful is when we get down to really kind of peeling the onion back and saying, what do you do today in your own organization? And here are the things that we look for, and these are our expectations, but let’s partner on that. I don’t like to kind of have it in us versus them. So I think it’s more around making sure that they clearly understand, but that we’re also willing to help because I think things change so quickly. If you don’t have the ability to say, I really want to partner with you on this and it’s more a finger pointing of thou shall, I think it’s a harder relationship. So to me, it’s about getting in front of your partner and walking the journey with them about what is needed. And I think that those again, I don’t think these are really complicated things we need to do, but I certainly think that a lot of times, if you’re not going into the detail, you’re losing some of the emphasis.

Sanjog Aul [00:27:21]:
So here then, the next point comes is when we have employees and partners and leaders all coming together, what are the places where we drop the ball as security people? Because they start showing some support, and it’s not gonna be a pure 100% fully cooked support from all different directions at one point. Are there things that we as security team and security leaders may be doing, which is undoing some of the progress that we make? Where could be the leakages?

Why this is a marathon not a sprint 28:02

Sheryl Rose [00:28:02]:
I think just from doing this for as long as I have, I think sometimes it’s not the sprint. It’s the marathon. And I think that what sometimes happens with us is there’s so many things going on that are we staying steadfast with our partners, especially once we have them along for the journey. We need to keep the conversation real, and we need to keep it up to date, and we need to not let it stale. And I think that’s what’s important. So I think building that plan and ensuring that security awareness is threaded throughout your security program. So as you put new initiatives together, as you identify new risks, those kind of things need to get integrated into awareness and in turn helps as you roll things out that your partners and your leaders and your end users have a better understanding of what you’re doing there, but also how they can help. So I think to me and that’s why I say I always talk about the majority of breaches are still occurring because of phishing and because of end user actions. And I think that that still should humble all of us that it’s our responsibility to continue changing and being nimble in how we message to our end users. It’s our threats change every day, so the messaging and the awareness and the partnering with our end user communication needs to change every day.

Sanjog Aul [00:29:48]:
So when we are looking at the different ways you have suggested, that the partners and leaders and the business users, they are ready to support you. We ourselves also put a bit of, get our act together, if you will. What else in your view needs to fall in place for us to not have to do this discussion, say, a year from now? We can say that it’s a marathon, but then would a marathon, even a 3-hour marathon comes to an end? Should we expect an end, or we should keep running as a tired warrior?

Sheryl Rose [00:30:33]:
So tired warriors, I think, eventually get too tired to keep running. But I think that once you get the integration and again, I think that there has been great I’ve seen myself and some of my peers. I think that there’s been a lot of really good movement in this space and a lot of good movement of getting security engaged more upfront in general. But I think it’s about how do we get it to a place where it doesn’t feel like that marathon? How do we get some processes in there and some of the things I’ve talked about that make it kind of more operational so that it’s just what we do? So say we come to the end of the year, or say we go into next year planning, if we operationally have things where we say, okay. We’re gonna go deploy a new solution that’s gonna be user impacting and we bring in communications or whoever that right individual is in your organization that can help drive the messaging at that level. Once we determine what we’re gonna do from a project perspective and we’re working with that person, if that’s more kind of just our day to day, I don’t think it feels as much of a race. I think it feels just kind of like what we do every day. And I think the more we ingrain security in that manner, it doesn’t feel like we’re pushing that heavy rock up the hill every day.

Sanjog Aul [00:32:19]:
Interestingly, I was at an event recently, with all security leaders, and one of the main problem that was brought up is to be able to help keep security at desirable level of acceptance by the business, while keeping pace with the business change. Not a new challenge. But the question here is that you get everyone to come on board, they say, yes. We are willing to work with you. But then as business is fundamentally shifting in many cases, even your security approaches need to change drastically in some cases. Are the business leaders and the users and partners willing to pivot as you are willing to? Because that’s your job. You get paid for it, but they are not. And for your security approach to change fundamentally, they will also have to again do things which they did out of compassion or maybe they felt, yes, it’s their need. But if it starts cutting into their own schedules and it starts disrupting their work, they will eventually throw the towel in and say, I’m not doing it anymore. How do you keep all of them motivated as you work through the space of change?

Sheryl Rose [00:33:42]:
That’s certainly a challenging issue. And on all sides or all fronts, I think what I’ve seen is the more we can embed security naturally in the business, the more successful we are, the more it doesn’t feel like we’re doing that big pivot. So I guess what I mean by that is, if we’re truly starting to engage and be at the table. So I think about kind of the journey. Projects and businesses would drive things, and then we get to the 11th hour and somebody didn’t engage security. So security comes in and then it looks like a security issue and there’s delays and it’s just a big mess. So I think over the years, we’ve gotten much better at getting in front of that, and being more at the beginning of an initiative or of a strategy so that we can walk alongside them. I think for me, the more we’re embedded on it together and getting and staying with them as they change business models, drive different directions strategically, etc., I think it looks like it’s not us and them. And I think that’s where oftentimes I think some of it is perception that were security oh, we need to make sure security is engaged. And the more we can just be in that and engaging alongside them, I think that will soften that perception.

Sanjog Aul [00:35:32]:
So when you use the word embedding with them, are you recommending because I know, there was a discussion about how do you get security to be seen a little more proactively or get it included proactively in the initiatives. And someone suggested in some discussions I had, is you get it as part of your product life cycle. As they get developed, there is a line item for security. So are you saying that even when the changes are happening and those businesses are envisioning new products, etc., you have to inject yourself in the very ideation phase and start also looking at what’s possible with a security lens as well? While it will be a great thing to happen, but are they willing to invite you at that stage?

Embedding security roles inside the business 36:25

Sheryl Rose [00:36:25]:
So I think that there’s a lot of different models that can be effective. I’ve seen and had a lot of discussions over the last few years with peers that oftentimes if you can secure the funding for a position, but that position is embedded, it depends on the relationship because that can get a little sticky, right, if you say, okay, I want to get somebody in there at the very beginning phases. Where does that person report to? Are they gonna report to security? Are they gonna report into that group? I think if you can work through that, the more you can embed upfront, the more you can have roles that maybe aren’t the traditional security. If you can sacrifice the spend of a headcount and put them in the business so they’re sitting there. I was asked years ago. We had business security officers, and people were like, well, what do they do? And I think what’s important is what they do, and it has to be the right person for sure. But what they do is they build that relationship with the business. They stay in front of what is happening with the business so that they can naturally start to deal with security. Anything that’s coming from a new product, a new whatever line to any issue that may be happening. But I think that we have to be nimble enough as we build the security organizations, to say, do we want everything kind of siloed in our enterprise functions? Or do we want them, some of them, boots on the ground, out with the business and then working back into our larger enterprise organization?

Sanjog Aul [00:38:31]:
And let’s talk about the concept of a shared service. The reason I bring this up is because many times investment has been a huge issue because we always go as security to the top people and say, show me the money so I can help you secure. And then there’s always a tug of war of how much money you need and then how much they’re able to give and then security at the end of the day gets compromised. But if it is really a value creation, so security is not seen as a necessary evil and it is a cost of doing business, then somebody should bear the cost. And like earlier, we used to have central IT, but then it was also used in a shared services manner. So the department which is using that service was supposed to pay for it, and it works well for IT. Then why not security? Could security not solve that budgeting and funding problem by converting it from just an overhead? The perception from being an overhead to cost of doing business, then request this to become a shared service and start getting the money from the department which perhaps wants to change the most and which needs to require revamping of security. Would such a model fly to make it happen and make it sustainable?

Funding security as a shared service 42:00

Sanjog Aul [00:42:00]:
So, the concept of shared services is not new. IT has done it successfully in many cases, and they are able to then make sure that they are not left holding the bag when it comes to finding money to get IT done because a particular business unit would have more needs than the other. Guess what? That particular business unit needs to pay up. Could the same model be brought to security? And in that process, what you’re essentially doing is if you’re able to make this happen, that means you’re getting the support. Someone who’s not just saying verbally, but they’re actually putting money behind this means you’re bringing the village together. Department by department, that’s okay. But at least it’s coming together. And when they show the money and they are ready to give you the money, means they will also get their people to give you the support. So this could perhaps be a good way to crack it, but love to get your thoughts. You are more than welcome to refute it or say, you know what? This is how we can make it work.

Sheryl Rose [00:43:02]:
I think it’s an interesting concept. I think when you break it down, the challenge today is it’s hard for individuals outside of the security to understand what we’re spending our money on. There’s a lot of behind the scenes. So I think that if we looked at it more as a service, every organization has the departments that are really driving new initiatives and new requests and then departments that are kind of just running operationally in an okay. So I think that this concept would be interesting in that realm, because the value could be given to the groups that do want to pay up and get what’s needed. I think the question is how do we effectively put more of the kind of compliance regulatory wrapper around it, just to make sure that as if they’re gonna pay for it and they’re gonna want us to move quickly, we still need to make sure without inhibiting that we put some kind of wrapper around it to ensure good security practice.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:24]:
And if this was to be indeed implemented like what IT does, you could have certain services which are essentially corporate supported, and the rest of them could be business unit level supported. And this could hopefully take you to a point where money is not the issue, and because a business unit is offering support in terms of money, then the people level support and their ability to give you the required inputs that you need all would fall in place. That was the whole idea. So you are in a way saying that if this could work, we have to think through this. But if this could work out, this could be one of the interesting approaches. Yeah?

Sheryl Rose [00:45:07]:
I certainly think that if it’s structured in that way, like you said, there’s the non-negotiable corporate functions, but there could be a lot of value given to a business unit who’s willing to help fund and putting security focus on what they’re trying to drive. I would think that that could possibly give them a lot more partnership with security because we’re very focused on what their business requirements and needs are in helping driving towards that.

Sanjog Aul [00:45:44]:
So let’s talk about the softer side, which is the culture, which is the overall organizational culture. Because that’s one of the things which is always brought up, is if the culture doesn’t support a secure way of doing business or any other attributes of cultures, if those are not in place, then security will have a tough time to hold ground and or get people or have the ability to move people. So if you were to literally request that I need this type of organizational culture for me to do my job right as a CISO and get security embedded where everybody comes along, what would that culture look like?

Sheryl Rose [00:46:34]:
That’s an interesting question. I think that an openness and a willingness to engage, an openness and a willingness to say we are all extremely busy and barely have time most of the time, all of us in business, to breathe because we’re trying to drive revenue and product and whatever else. But I think it’s how do we really come together in a way that we can balance it from a security perspective and still get the key points and drivers across to the business? I think it’s that willingness to take a breath. And that’s why I think it takes a village, but to get that entire village, you oftentimes just have to find the right enablers. And I don’t think security needs to solve how do we make every end user culturally open to engaging with security and understanding their role. I think it’s our responsibility to continue to understand who those right drivers would be to help us do that with the entire user community.

Sanjog Aul [00:48:01]:
And question for you. Do you think there would be a way where while digital opportunities are gonna keep coming down the pike, could we have some sort of a segmentation in the way where the innovative side is being put and also the traditional stable side is kept? Like, people talk about bimodal IT or bimodal business where you have these two lanes, if you will. Could we somehow separate those out and then plan it in such a way so that we are not always playing catch up? Because security, you cannot afford to play catch up. And we want to make sure that we are not totally bogged down with playing catch up where our own basic stable structure also starts crumbling. Do you think there is a way to divide and conquer when it comes to managing security and get everyone to understand and agree that, hey, we will work on the stable side, we will make sure this one is kept, and yes, we may not be fully secure because you keep changing. You don’t want to take the blame that I brought up something new and it was secured the very next second.

Sheryl Rose [00:49:16]:
I think that is really reasonable, because I think every organization out there has that stable side and that side of the house that needs to be innovative and driving forward. I think that that takes us when we’re sitting here thinking and planning how we could hone in and focus on those areas and support from the innovative side, of course. I think it’s reasonable and I think that it would be more effective, with one caution and that is as they drive on the innovative side still keeping a lens. I think what happens sometimes is we wanna go along and we wanna be in there on the innovative side, and it’s move fast, it’s fail fast, it’s do what’s necessary. But if we don’t do that in a way where we’re bringing security holistically to that, we don’t wanna miss anything, and have them moving forward. And then as it becomes more of a real project or a real initiative, something gets missed and it comes back and is like, why didn’t we think of that from a security perspective?

Sanjog Aul [00:50:38]:
Talk about the security leadership, and we’ve always spoken that security leaders come from a pure technical background. Unlike IT, as you’ve seen that lot of IT leaders are being invited even from business. They may not have much of an IT background, and they become IT leaders. And because they come from business, they’re able to relate well to the business community, and they become more effective. If you want everyone to come along, and the security leaders to really be able to say things or do things which will resonate with everyone else. Are there any creative ways of grooming these security leaders for them to come across as someone the rest of the business would want to work together with?

Grooming security leaders with softer skills 51:27

Sheryl Rose [00:51:27]:
I think that’s just such a key question. I think when you look at how to groom strong security leaders to your point, I think that just risk management and balancing of that conversation at a business level side is key. I think that when we sit kind of in security going through and talking about problems and solutions, it gets complicated and technical and whatever. I think grooming these individuals in a way to say, let’s just kind of settle on what the business is looking for and how we truly work through making that happen. And I think what we find is people that have those softer skills, those interpersonal skills that listening and balancing what the business is driving are the ones that usually get the ears of some of the senior leaders. So that’s a hard one to answer. I think that the focus on building security leaders is certainly on that interpersonal softer side, on what skills are needed to be that true partner that they’re looking for.

Sanjog Aul [00:53:00]:
So if I were to ask you for you to show your vulnerability as a security leader or maybe you can share any examples or any approaches that you may have taken for your deputies, your successors, so that they become more relevant, because you know what you’re dealing with, it’s only gonna get more complex from here. So what we have seen is IT security leaders are primarily coming from security background, technical background, much more technical than even IT. So has there been any academy? Has there been any conscious effort so that the next generation becomes better than the previous one? Because they will be dealing with more complex stuff. So if you were to say, this is how I’m grooming my people. It needs to be futuristic. It needs to be relevant to this new world that we are entering into, or rather already entered. So are there any things on the ground you’re doing today to help groom yourself as well as the ones who you are developing?

Sheryl Rose [00:54:07]:
I think I’d be over simplistic, and it’s easy to say and hard to do. I think it’s every day I try and humble myself. I try and think of if I’m sitting in front of leaders and my hair’s on fire about something security related, they have 4 other compelling issues that could be just as more or less impactful to them. And I think we need to balance that, and we need to humble ourselves every day that we need to help our business. And I think that there’s easy ways to do that. I remember years ago, just walking into a clinic and seeing what those physicians do every single day. And when you look at that and you look at how critical that role is and what they’re doing, yeah, I’d probably be pretty exhausted if I just spent 10 hours dealing with patients and illness and other issues and then coming in and saying, let’s have a security conversation. So I think the more that we can build ourselves up to say, yeah, we have a complicated world with security, but we’re also here to support our business and find ways to balance that with them helps us become better leaders.

Contributors

Sheryl Rose

Sheryl Rose, Chief Information Security Officer, Summa Health System

Sheryl Rose has spent her career in the security and risk management disciplines. For the past 8 years, she has served as a Chief Information Security Officer in the health care industry. She is currently serving as interim Chief Informatio... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

AVI-SPL-Service Banner-MPU-300x250
Sheryl Rose