Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DEI) • Talent Development

How to Get More Women in IT

How to Get More Women in IT

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Fawn Germer, Janet Sherlock (Carter, Inc.), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that women hold a stalled 20% to 26% of technology jobs, down from 40% of computing jobs in the 1990s, and that retention, not only recruiting, is the core problem. Janet Sherlock, CIO of Carter, Inc., put the leadership funnel at 7% to 30% women CIOs, with 14% in retail, and tied the drop-off to work-life balance, a 24/7 job, and a confidence gap she has felt herself, including hesitating when a colleague recommended her for a CEO role. Fawn Germer attributed attrition to working conditions, low salaries, long hours, and boredom, and cited 1,400,000 projected technology openings against schools producing 52% of the needed graduates. Both argued that peer networks, visible role models such as Marissa Mayer, early STEM education, and flexible conditions would widen the pipeline. Sherlock noted that 60% of college degrees go to women but only 20% of computer science degrees.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Fawn Germer, a global leadership speaker and women’s leadership expert, and Janet Sherlock, CIO of Carter, Inc., about how to get more women in IT. Germer and Sherlock discuss why the share of technology jobs held by women has stalled at 20% to 26% and why women who enter the field often leave it. Sherlock describes the narrowing funnel into executive roles, where women hold 7% to 30% of CIO jobs, and her own path into a CIO role without a computer science degree. They compare the pull of work-life balance, the shortage of role models, and the confidence gap that keeps women from reaching for leadership, and they point to STEM education, flexible conditions, and peer networks as practical responses.

Contributors

  • Fawn Germer, Global leadership speaker, best-selling Oprah author, and women’s leadership expert
  • Janet Sherlock, CIO, Carter, Inc.

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Fawn Germer, a women’s leadership expert, said the real issue is not why women avoid IT but why they leave it. She noted that women held 40% of computing jobs in the 1990s, yet many left within two years of entering the field.
  • Janet Sherlock, CIO of Carter, Inc., said the share of technology jobs held by women has stayed at 20% to 26% and shrinks further up the ladder. She placed women CIOs at 7% to 30% depending on the study, and at 14% in retail.
  • Fawn Germer, a global leadership speaker, said working conditions, low salaries, long hours, and a sense of limited opportunity push women out of technology. She added that almost a fourth of women in the industry reported getting bored with their daily work.
  • Janet Sherlock, CIO of Carter, Inc., said a computer science degree is not required to lead IT, pointing to her own degree in supply chain operations. She urged women to set a career North Star and to plan home-life balance openly with a partner.
  • Fawn Germer, a women’s leadership expert, said there are an estimated 1,400,000 technology openings in the United States over four years while schools produce only 52% of the needed graduates. She said the field lacks visible role models beyond a few such as Marissa Mayer.
  • Janet Sherlock, CIO of Carter, Inc., said an inherent confidence gap keeps women from reaching for leadership, recalling that she first called herself unqualified when recommended for a CEO role. She said companies should measure diversity but also build an environment that inspires women to want to ascend.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: how to get more women in IT
  • 1:55 The woman’s perspective, not a feminine touch
  • 3:45 What the labor statistics show
  • 6:16 Why women leave IT
  • 9:33 The funnel into leadership
  • 13:23 Networking and peer support
  • 17:17 Janet’s path to CIO without a tech degree
  • 21:25 Setting boundaries in a 24/7 job
  • 29:17 The STEM pipeline shortage
  • 35:02 Building an environment that inspires women
  • 41:41 Confidence as the barrier for women
  • 48:07 Bringing business people into IT leadership

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: how to get more women in IT 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:26]:
Today’s topic is how to get more women in IT. Our guest for today’s show is Fawn Germer, a global leadership speaker and the best-selling Oprah author and women’s leadership expert. Morning, Fawn. How are you?

Sanjog Aul [00:00:55]:
And we also have Janet Sherlock, who’s the CIO of Carter, Inc. Good morning, Janet. How are you doing?

Sanjog Aul [00:01:04]:
Now there’s always a lot of conversation about gender inequality, and we especially see it in IT and technology-related fields. But for the purpose of this show, we really wanted to ask how organizations are prioritizing bringing women on board at different positions. And is it really just putting together a team of people where there’s a mix of both genders or is this more about bringing a feminine touch to the organization? So that said, the first question, let me start with you, Fawn. What do you think is the very basis of why anyone would want to talk about gender equality? Because if you look at beauty and fashion, for example, it is dominated by women, but I’ve not seen as many people saying we need to bring more men in there. So what’s happening on the other side when we’re talking about business and IT as disciplines?

The woman’s perspective, not a feminine touch 1:55

Fawn Germer [00:01:55]:
Well, I think that there’s a lot of education that still needs to go on. It’s not a feminine touch. That’s kind of where some of the old stuff gets caught up. So women are viable leaders in every possible realm of the business world. But the IT realm hasn’t moved forward enough and it has been a place where women have fled; they weren’t being successfully attracted or retained. Part of it is this whole education. It’s how we get people to welcome women and recruit women and advance them and make them feel like they have a place there because women are great contributors. We’ve seen so many studies showing what happens to teams when women are on them in terms of output and creativity. There’s one advantage Americans have is innovation and women are great innovators, particularly if they’re involved in diverse groups. And so it’s not a feminine touch. It is the woman’s perspective that is powerful and desperately needed in order to keep us as viable players in a global marketplace.

Sanjog Aul [00:03:13]:
So, of course, sitting inside, Janet, this is a question for you. We have never said as a community to say okay there should be fewer women or this is not a deliberate attempt to reduce the number to have majority of the other sex. Now what has caused this? For women to not start from the very top of the funnel which is to get educated in science and math perhaps or then following the professional path eventually to leadership. So at all levels nobody is stopping, but there still seems to be a perceived gap. What could be happening here?

What the labor statistics show 3:45

Janet Sherlock [00:03:45]:
Well, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, 20% to 26% of all technology jobs are held by women, and that number, unfortunately, has not been increasing at any rate whatsoever. And when I’m recruiting for roles within my organization, frankly, I don’t see a large pool of women candidates, and the pool gets smaller and smaller for the higher level roles and the executive roles. I hear the same feedback from my CIO colleagues, whether that’s locally here in the Atlanta area or nationally with my retail industry CIO colleagues. So frankly, the pool isn’t all that large. However, I remain pretty optimistic that there’s going to be continued change and there will be some positive impact on those statistics. First and foremost there has been recent heightened awareness of that topic. It is having conversations like the one we’re having today. It is the media, books like Sheryl Sandberg’s Lean In and dynamic public speakers like Fawn that are providing a forum for dialogue on this particular topic. So I think that the emphasis itself is going to have a positive impact on things. But in addition, I think that the technology field itself is in a state of metamorphosis. So those traditional IT roles like security, networking, development may not be increasing in percentages for women, but frankly, they’re not increasing in percentages overall because of cloud computing, the consumerization of IT and several other factors. I think the metamorphosis of IT is going to include areas that may be inherently more attractive for both genders and particularly for women, things like social media, analytics, business analysis, IT project management, to name a few.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:48]:
So, Fawn, coming to you, when we talk about something being an attractive profession, do you really feel that we should be pushing a particular agenda because someone is not joining a given profession and which could be because of a very different reason, their own choice? Why are we trying to push a community’s agenda when an individual’s agenda is not as aligned with it?

Why women leave IT 6:16

Fawn Germer [00:06:16]:
It’s not just a question of why they aren’t joining. It’s a bigger question of why they have left. Janet’s citing those Bureau of Labor Statistics; it’s a great place to start because from that same study in the 1990s, women held 40% of the computing jobs. But they weren’t being advanced. They weren’t being attracted. They weren’t enjoying their work. They found that 2 years after a female computer science major got into the field, she left it. So the biggest issue is what to do to make it something that women want to participate in. What makes it desirable? And that’s where the real debate needs to be.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:05]:
What do you think are the reasons somebody, if you go in polls, say a number of women who have joined the workforce within business and technology areas and then they have left, what was the disconnect? Where did they feel either they were not taken care of or there was an inherent disconnect in the very liking of what they were doing?

Fawn Germer [00:07:24]:
Working conditions, low salaries, long hours, and they sense the lack of opportunity. The work-life balance issue is a huge issue. I love the Lean In concept, but I’m just as much an advocate of leaning out because that’s where you get your whole life picture. That’s something if I speak in China and there are women coming up to me afterwards, the first thing they ask me is work-life balance. In India, how do you balance everything? So this is not something that’s unique to us, but it’s so real and primal, and it has to be considered. When I was an investigative reporter they’d say, go ask her how she does all that and raises a family. I was so offended because you would never ask a man that. But then when I got in the real world and I saw what was keeping women from accelerating and truly embracing, it was the pull. It’s the life-balance pull. The other thing is a study showed that almost a fourth of women in the industry said that they got bored with their daily work. So it’s constantly changing. We have to find ways to show that there is so much opportunity and excitement and that it’s the adrenaline industry of the future.

Sanjog Aul [00:08:48]:
Now all the factors that Fawn mentioned, coming back to you Janet, and over the years as you’ve grown from being, I’m sure, at the lower level in the hierarchy all the way up to a CIO, I’m sure you would have seen the same things happening to you. So is it a very individual’s perspective, what is important and you stick to your guns and continue to do it even though sometimes it may not be the most challenging? Because otherwise, if you were to say that most women are leaving because they get bored easily or things like that, then somebody might label them as high maintenance. And frankly, if somebody is trying to get their job done in a business, to what degree would they want to take care of an individual’s preferences and also balance the business interests? How do you see that?

The funnel into leadership 9:33

Janet Sherlock [00:09:33]:
Well, frankly, I think that someone who would say that they’re not being challenged by their job, everyone is responsible for finding their own challenges. Now I know that some lower level jobs aren’t necessarily always very challenging, but displaying self-motivation is a key to ascension into an organization. But to go back to Fawn’s point, I think our biggest issue is the funnel. It is that ascension into leadership and executive roles. There are a fair amount of women actually placed in entry level roles, and the funnel gets smaller and smaller until you get to the point of women CIOs where the statistics, depending on the study and the industry, is anywhere from 7% to 30%. In my particular space, 14% of CIOs in retail are women. I completely agree with what Fawn said in that women, and this isn’t just in IT, aren’t finding ascension into executive roles worth it. When they look at the challenges with work-life balance and what it’s going to take, they’ll often opt to stay at lower or mid-level jobs, opt to stay home, or take completely different career paths. Women in technology have the highest quit or fallout rate of any other women in the STEM fields. Particularly for technology, the CIO role had an average tenure of only about 2 years a few years ago; I think that may be a little bit longer now. IT is a very 24/7 job, and the expectations are very, very high in the IT field. There are literally millions of things that have to go right every day (lines of code, packets of data) and anything that can go wrong can result in a crisis. Many women find this pace grueling and this level of expectation potentially intimidating. But it can be very gratifying. If you are the kind of person driven by seeing transformation in your organization through the technology you’re delivering, it’s a great career path to choose.

Fawn Germer [00:11:58]:
And I think that when somebody is labeled high maintenance because they find something unchallenging or boring, companies in every industry right now are bending over backwards trying to find ways to keep younger employees stimulated and involved because they have so much to contribute and they are so valuable, but they need a lot of stimulation. So that’s not high maintenance. There’s just this workforce that you’ve got to figure out how to stimulate and bring into the fold.

Sanjog Aul [00:12:28]:
So Fawn, do you think, based on what you just said, that nobody likes to be seen as somebody who’s high maintenance, do you think the other sex, which is men, who are supposed to be, for the most part, providers, or at least that’s how society looks at them, then even though it’s boring, even though it is grueling, they stick to it because somebody has to bring bread to the table. And then because women are basically saying, I’m not going to be doing this. I’m going to change my career path, and they’re not going to go to the leadership position. That’s because they are choosing it. I’m sure if we could change the environment for both then people will have a better life overall. But what is being expected in terms of that change? Do we want suddenly fewer hours to be spent? Should there be more people to do the same amount of jobs so that the workload reduces or the work variety reduces? So what is the inherent expectation which people are trying to say the organization should provide?

Networking and peer support 13:23

Fawn Germer [00:13:23]:
Well, let’s remember that women are providers today, not just as single parents, but the number of women who are the primary breadwinners in the family is increasing dramatically every year. I’ve got those numbers somewhere, but I don’t have them on my head right now. They’re just choosing somewhere else to be a provider. How you get them in and do it is you make them feel like they matter, like there is a path to success that will lead them through that obstacle course into positions like what Janet has and that they have access to it. Good companies are constantly finding ways to help women to network them through the company and they’ve got women’s leadership events. I think the best ones are events that include men because women need opportunities to find their path and make the connections they need to make. Women’s leadership is huge and successful and it’s making a peer network that helps them get through the points where they might drop off. If you’ve got others coaching you along, there’s more incentive to stay in it and you feel like you’re gaining ground. A lot of companies have figured this out. There’s an energy there: they have events and women are talking. Since the workplace is so scattered, it used to be that everybody sat in one office and you’d see your colleagues. Now you find ways technologically to bring them together. I’m always a big fan of Skype and Wine because you can talk about what’s going on. So it’s creating opportunities to connect, share your mission, and advance. That’s all so important and it makes the experience a lot more meaningful. Women care about mattering. They care about meaning.

Sanjog Aul [00:15:21]:
And Janet, when we come back, we’d love to learn about your journey. What has been your trajectory when you have been with IT or maybe in different positions? How did you overcome some of the barriers that are being discussed right now? How did you manage to get through to the funnel where very few people reach?

Sanjog Aul [00:17:09]:
So Janet, how about your journey, the trajectory, the challenges that you face, and what did you do differently because of which you are here?

Janet’s path to CIO without a tech degree 17:17

Janet Sherlock [00:17:17]:
A couple of things. One thing other women (and not just women, but people) should find optimistic about a potential career trajectory into a CIO role is I did not have a computer science degree. I actually had a degree in supply chain operations, which I have to say has probably helped me within my journey in retail IT. So the emphasis that you have to have a degree in computer science is awfully helpful, especially in certain sectors of IT, but it’s not necessary. That’s one point I’d like to make. I was lucky enough fairly early in my career, probably early to mid-career, that the spark came and I realized exactly what I wanted to do. One of the things I’m struck by so often when I’m speaking with women is when I ask them, well, what is your career goal? They often don’t have an answer, which is in sharp juxtaposition to men who are often very clear and decisive: I want to be a CIO. When you know what you want to do (I knew that I wanted to be a retail IT executive leader several years ago), I was able to forge a career that allowed me to attain the skills and experience necessary to ascend into that role. So I think it’s really important that women have that North Star and understand exactly the path they’re willing to take. The other key element is marrying the right person and having the right partner and having that important dialogue where you discuss exactly how you’re planning on balancing your home life. Who’s going to take care of the children? How are we going to do this? If a career requires a move, how are we going to handle this? My husband and I have been very fortunate, and I’m married to a wonderful man who has been very supportive of my career, and I’m very supportive of his career. We’ve been able to make it work because we have a great partnership and have had that honest dialogue and have actively planned how we were going to manage in that area.

Sanjog Aul [00:19:38]:
Fawn, what do you think about the changes that you expect to happen in the social fabric which will, in a way, directly or indirectly impact inclusion or more infusion of women in business and IT?

Fawn Germer [00:19:53]:
Well, that change has been ongoing. I don’t know that there’s going to be anything more dramatic than what happened when we all became connected through social media. That found a way to help people find alliances to get together and meet to share things that they never could share with anyone before, and I think that was really great. Now in terms of what’s going to happen specifically in IT, I don’t know, because that is an industry where it’s spreading out more and people aren’t face to face with each other like they once were. Janet, maybe better to answer that one.

Sanjog Aul [00:20:38]:
So from a semantic standpoint, frankly IT is being used because this is CIO Talk Radio, so we’re talking about that. But if you were to expand the horizon a little bit more, any role which requires being 24/7 in touch with others or be more demanding, the same rules will apply and those will be the industries where people will find it difficult to cope while they are also trying to get their work-life balance. So to that, Fawn, do you think there is something which, if we were to do a root cause analysis or if something has been done in that regard, some elements are surfacing which are saying these are the main reasons why we are in this state today?

Setting boundaries in a 24/7 job 21:25

Fawn Germer [00:21:25]:
You’ve got this clash between what we want to do professionally (we want challenge, we want success) and what we feel obligated to do personally. I always tell this story about when I was a reporter: I was doing the biggest series I’d ever done in my life. It took 10 months, and it got nominated twice for the Pulitzer. Things piled up during that time. I just kept putting piles of mail into the guest bedroom. One day everybody was coming, we were meeting at my house before going out to dinner, and my husband opened that door to the guest bedroom and exposed the piles of mail that hadn’t been put away. It was a big pile. I felt like the biggest failure on earth, not because I’d failed professionally, but because you are expected to still be successful in your traditional roles while you succeed at everything else. As things become more demanding, how do you do the things you feel you have to do at home? I tell people, let some of it go. Hire out. If it’s not making you happy, don’t do it. People are starting to talk about that more because you’ve got a generation that has focused on work but also fun, and they’re realizing they’ve been conflicted and haven’t spent their time the way they should. They see friends get unhealthy, so there are a lot of other balance considerations they are trying to honor. If you talk about the 24-hour cycle and I stand in front of an audience and say, how many of you checked your email last night after work? Everybody raises their hand. How many of you checked it 2 times? Everybody raises their hand. How many have checked it 3 or more times? Most people raise their hand. How many of you have checked it endlessly? A good number. As the demands grow, it’s up to us to set boundaries that show what we’re willing to do and not do. There is no crime in saying some other things matter to me besides my job. It may conflict with my trajectory, but I’ve got to do the things that matter to me personally. That’s what’s happening across the board and I think people are learning what their values are.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:28]:
So Janet, when you look at the environment that you’ve been in and I’m sure you’ve come across other women who may have shared some interesting challenges they are dealing with, would you be able to share some of those which are not the challenges you have already answered, but they have to kind of live with and that may be causing them to not get up to the level of commitment they can show towards the job, which will in turn get them the growth they’re looking for?

Janet Sherlock [00:24:58]:
The whole thing of balance cuts both ways. I completely agree with Fawn that connectedness is making us readily accessible. Whether you’re in IT or not, it’s probably a little worse for those of us in IT. The connectedness is making us accessible and feeling obligated to work literally 24/7. I would be lying if I didn’t tell you that I don’t sleep with my smartphone right next to my ear. I do. At the same time, that gives us the flexibility to not be in the office and still stay connected and understand what’s going on. Sometimes you need to go away, take your vacations, and completely disconnect, but it does give you flexibility to not be in the office at consistent hours and to telecommute. Technology has been a two-way street from that standpoint. As far as the challenges and being able to prove that you can do it all, companies have high expectations regardless of your gender. I personally don’t feel that because I’m a woman I have any more to prove. You’ve got to find those boundaries and prioritize what you need to prove to your organization to show you are deserving of higher level and executive leadership roles. A lot of it is not necessarily about working harder; it’s about portraying your successes so there’s confidence you’ll be able to deliver.

Sanjog Aul [00:26:46]:
And when we come back, Fawn, maybe we should explore why in the first place when we are looking at the STEM fields women are not even entering from an educational standpoint. We know that women getting added to the workforce is exceeding the speed at which they are quitting so there is incremental growth and some hope. So if you don’t have a funnel properly filled at the top, then God bless us all.

Sanjog Aul [00:28:56]:
So Fawn, do you think there is a reason why in the STEM fields we find fewer and fewer women enrolling, as at least some of the research says? If that’s going to happen, then towards the end of the funnel you will have an even worse situation going forward and you’ll never incrementally add more women to the mix.

The STEM pipeline shortage 29:17

Fawn Germer [00:29:17]:
Well, I think we’re talking about how the funnel is emptier than it’s ever been, also because there’s an estimated 1,400,000 openings in technology in the United States in the next 4 years. Schools are only cranking out 52% of the needed graduates. What happened was that women did go in, but it just didn’t become something that seemed very attractive or fun. It’s incumbent on companies and industries to do the kind of recruiting they need to get people into these programs. I see that kind of recruiting going on in different disciplines all the time because one of the things I do every year is have several events where they bring in undecided majors trying to lure them; they’re high test-score, high performers who haven’t figured it out and they’re trying to lure them into certain industries. So tech needs to get on that and do that because we aren’t seeing enough role models out there. You’ve got your couple, like Marissa Mayer, and we need to show there is a path that is meaningful and achievable.

Sanjog Aul [00:30:35]:
So Janet, do you think only the not-for-profit volunteer organizations are taking the lead in ensuring that the funnel is filled, or are organizations and industry (which are the end beneficiaries of inclusion of more science, math, and engineering people joining the workforce) actually taking the lead as well?

Janet Sherlock [00:30:56]:
I don’t think it’s necessarily just in the not-for-profit area. There has been a large emphasis on promoting STEM education and STEM careers, not just for women, but for men as well. As Fawn mentioned, there is a huge shortage of IT talent in the United States. The unemployment rate, I believe, is hovering around 8% in Georgia, and it’s 2% for IT. So we do have an issue of having enough IT talent in general. For women in particular, 60% of college degrees are earned by women, but only 20% of computer science degrees are attained by women. So there’s definitely not enough women going through. Being over 50% of the population, you’d like to see something similar in those statistics. I am really happy there is a concerted effort to encourage STEM education starting as early as grade school. I know I’m participative in some of those functions here in the local Georgia area. Focusing on careers in these fields doesn’t just assist in filling projected demand for future IT jobs, it also helps to shatter the cliche that girls don’t have an inclination for math or science. It’s simply a matter of what’s presented and emphasized to young girls in our homes and schools.

Fawn Germer [00:32:40]:
Doesn’t that amaze you that that hasn’t changed? We’ve known that for so long and I just haven’t seen that much movement on it.

Sanjog Aul [00:32:50]:
Now would you say, Fawn, that many of these are obvious points we’re discussing here on this forum, but we do not see the follow-through or a more formal or measurable follow-through? Do you think that’s because there is not enough concerted or cohesive effort from industry, government, and academia together so that we work towards solving a problem versus just trying to meet our respective agendas?

Fawn Germer [00:33:20]:
I think you’re right on that. Getting anything like that pulled off is hard. It’s obviously needed because the things that made change happen in other industries have not worked in this industry. So it’s going to take something more dramatic to pull it off.

Janet Sherlock [00:33:38]:
It is very societal. I agree. I think back to a point you made earlier, Fawn: it is about having key role models out there and available so girls can aspire to ascend to those roles and to be something they want to be, not just one of the Kardashians or whatever the case may be. The more women that are portrayed in the media and spoken about and have press around them, the better. It’s a huge step in the right direction.

Sanjog Aul [00:34:20]:
So if you were to go out there, Janet, and try to make changes in your own organization in the way you bring new people on board, the way you groom them (they may not come just as fresh graduates but at any level) and then incubate them in order for them to be prime so they are willing to go that extra mile, whosoever chooses to do so, and eventually predictably follow that path towards leadership versus one-size-fits-all broad-stroking organizational development, because that is not delivering the results that you and I want, what would you do?

Building an environment that inspires women 35:02

Janet Sherlock [00:35:02]:
Within my own organization, it’s interesting. My obligation to deliver technology for my company, whether it’s this company or previous companies I’ve worked for, is to have the best talent to deliver it. So I don’t necessarily care about gender, race, or status at all. However, it is important that we continue to look at the statistics of who we have on our teams and make sure we’re trying to improve them. I make an effort when recruiting, especially for leadership roles, to talk to recruiters about really pushing and seeking diverse candidates, and obviously women for leadership roles. I pull out all the stops; I’m in the Atlanta area, I’m out there, and I’m trying to portray a great environment to work in here at my company that would attract good candidates. I’m trying to be one of those role models for women. I’m a reluctant one, but I do feel an obligation as a woman CIO to try to be that type of role model for women out there. As far as incubating things, recently I participated in a local event with about 20 CIOs in the Georgia area from major companies. The topic was how to be advocates for women in IT. Ironically, only two of us were women, and the men largely focused on the statistics and having goals for women in roles within their organizations and in leadership roles. I applaud measuring statistics. You can’t improve what you don’t measure. But I had to emphasize it’s not about the statistics alone. The important thing is to provide an environment where you’re inspiring women to want to ascend into leadership roles. Make it known that it will be worth their while to ascend. Help build their confidence. We should have a whole other discussion about confidence building because that’s another huge area of improvement for women. Instill confidence in them that they can do the job and actually ascend into leadership roles and provide an environment with flexible working conditions for both genders.

Sanjog Aul [00:37:39]:
So, Fawn, when you look at this environment that Janet mentioned, do you think as an individual, a woman who would like to get to the next level but doesn’t know how because the path is not clear or confidence is lacking, each organization could fundamentally look at this as an opportunity to build a system, a process, or a forum where such people could go with some immunity (that this is what they are trying to do) so they can take care of their home life as well as work life and then become the professionals and leaders they want to be? Do you think this could be done more at an organization level versus one person shouting within their company that they want to do something but nobody hears? Is that approach feasible? Are organizations willing to go that direction?

Fawn Germer [00:38:41]:
Part of it is something that could be institutionalized. But the truth is that as soon as you get women together talking and working on it, things start happening. I love women’s leadership events; I speak at tons of them. When I’m speaking to a group of men, I’m often paid more than for a group of women, but I always enjoy the women’s events because there’s energy and purpose. These women get together, and instead of waiting for the company to take charge, they start creating leadership committees that present to the company ways to attract and retain. It begins a dialogue between women leaders and women who may not see themselves as leaders, showing potential and identity. As I always say, there is no special DNA that makes someone more qualified for a leadership position than you. Odds are if you’re in a decent job, you’re smart enough to do a better job at the next level. When you get women together and say, how are we going to help each other, things start to happen. It’s powerful. I don’t think you need the CEO to come in and dictate a plan; groups within companies seem to be making it happen. But it must be sanctioned and empowered by company leaders. I can tell when things will happen: some CEOs come to launch a Women’s Leadership event, show up for 8:30 AM to 8:40 AM, and leave. Other CEOs stay all day. The ones who stay are the ones who truly want to change. I’d put my energy into empowering the women in the companies and asking, what do you think we need to do?

Sanjog Aul [00:41:18]:
So Janet, while you mentioned we could have another discussion on confidence, it’s a great forum to at least touch on that. Where do you think confidence is lacking (are the foundational building blocks in how they grow up, how they get educated and mingle in society), is that what’s causing the confidence issue?

Confidence as the barrier for women 41:41

Janet Sherlock [00:41:41]:
I’m not a psychologist and I don’t know, but I very often see women afraid to take on key leadership roles. I see them hesitant to lead major projects due to what I think is an inherent lack of confidence. I don’t know why this seems to be an inherent trait for women, but it’s pervasive. Heck, I’m even plagued by this myself to some degree, and I’m a pretty self-confident woman. There’s pretty much no doubt in my mind that I am one of the best retail industry leaders out there today. But on a personal note, about a year ago a really well-respected industry colleague called me to tell me she knew a couple of board members and was going to recommend me for a CEO role. My first response was, well, I’m not qualified to be the CEO at such a large company. I spent a week or two thinking about that and thought she was crazy to recommend me. Then I thought, you know what? If I were a man, the likelihood is I would have been saying, oh, thank you for the opportunity, here’s my CV. Can you present me and talk about it? My first inclination was I’m not qualified enough for it. I think that’s one of those things that goes back to an inherent difference between men and women, and it’s something we need to focus on and work harder at.

Fawn Germer [00:43:29]:
I do a lot of work on that, and study after study shows exactly what you say. If a woman is in an interview and is asked if she knows how to do something she doesn’t know, she’ll either say no or say no but I can learn. The guy will often say yes, figuring he’ll learn it and everything will work out. I don’t advocate lying, but I don’t advocate being meek and not going for things because we all learn on the fly. Competency is rooted in self-esteem, which goes all the way back. It’s a whole other thing. I started interviewing for my books these most accomplished women leaders and trailblazers. The 3rd interview was with someone not famous but highly accomplished. She started Nature’s Sunshine Vitamins with, I think, $150 and an idea. No college degree, seven kids, and she turned it into a company that this year will do over $400,000,000 in business. I asked, what’s your leadership strategy? She said, I get up and try to find something that fits me because I’m overweight, then go out and try to do my best. I said, you have a self-esteem issue, you’re on the cover of Bloomberg this month. She said, can you imagine what it’s like to be fat and stand in front of a vitamin company? I asked all those women about self-esteem and found out how universal it was. Now I have good self-esteem because I know how bad everybody else’s self-esteem can be. We have the power to take control over that. That’s been my mission: show people how to rewrite some of that negative and give them esteem which then manifests as confidence to do things they didn’t think they could do. It’s amazing how much we can surprise ourselves.

Sanjog Aul [00:45:40]:
And Janet, when we come back, how about looking at the IT leadership role which essentially has now become a business role. If somebody thought that IT is too esoteric or they don’t expect themselves to tinker with computers all day, guess what? That’s not what a CIO role is today at all. In fact, they’re moving away from that and talking more business and doing everything else but IT. With that said, do you think there is hope that people who are not in IT today, instead of trying to fill the funnel at the top, could be taken from business who have core competencies and be groomed into becoming technology leaders?

Sanjog Aul [00:47:44]:
So, Janet, since the agenda here is to see how we get more women in IT, and since we know especially at the leadership level it is less about IT and more about other competencies and business domain knowledge, do you think that’s an opportunity for us to get people from other areas who still have the core DNA and groom them into becoming an IT leader?

Bringing business people into IT leadership 48:07

Janet Sherlock [00:48:07]:
I think that’s a huge opportunity, Sanjog, not because women don’t have the inclination for core deep technical skills, but because there aren’t as many women receiving STEM degrees. You can have a career like I’ve had: a business background for the first 8 to 10 years of my career, then transition into information technology by taking on IT projects and some technology training. There’s an opportunity for women who have an inclination for technology yet don’t have a specifically highly technical degree. It’s important about being a successful CIO that you are business-focused. One of your primary jobs is to instill confidence in others (your business partners, executive leaders, board members) that you’ve got it, you’ve got everyone’s back, you understand what’s important to the business, and you’re going to help lead your team to deliver technology that makes a difference. If you can instill that confidence in those constituencies, you’re more likely to succeed as a CIO.

Sanjog Aul [00:50:07]:
Now Fawn, we’ve heard many times that women would say they would like to go to another woman since she will be able to relate better to get advice. Is that leaving some opportunities on the table because there is a lot more experience available overall, whether men or women, and things can be done where you can help that person with confidence, skills, competency, and approach to life if they opened up their minds? Do you think that sentiment prevails that women have to go to women?

Fawn Germer [00:50:39]:
Look, I don’t see that happening as an exclusion. I see women enjoying talking to women and using them as role models, but not to the exclusion of men. Having male mentors and sponsors is as advantageous and in many cases more advantageous. Almost all of my mentors for a very long time were male and I learned a lot from them; they had influence to make a difference. One thing we show is: don’t do it to the exclusion of men.

Sanjog Aul [00:51:26]:
Now one is to do networking functions in a professional setting. Where else could organizations or forums be created, or perhaps they exist, where women can go and get a totally different perspective than knowing the same set of people and not expanding their network? That’s true for men too. Sometimes we just say we are CIOs, so we go to places where IT people hang out. But where are other places? Go ahead.

Fawn Germer [00:51:51]:
There’s the Women in Technology Forum, which is an awesome group. I always tell people you network every day wherever you go (whether you’re in the sea kayaking group, a technology group, or your Weight Watchers meeting), you never know who’s in the room who’s going to change your life. I always laugh about an event in Boston: I had to get my nails done before I went on and I’m at the drying table talking to a woman. Afterwards we find out I’m a speaker and she’s the Executive Vice President of State Street Financial. I wound up doing an event for State Street and she got me something else in Boston because I had talked to her getting my nails done. Talk. Networking happens everywhere. At company events, C-suite people sometimes stick together and leave; many are introverted. Go up to them. Don’t miss opportunities. Create relationships, not just business connections. Meet people, find something personal that continues the relationship as friendship, and then leverage that for business results.

Sanjog Aul [00:53:35]:
Janet, one last question for you. Maybe 3 words that come to mind which will help women get better in the way they are leading their career path and also become leaders in business and IT.

Janet Sherlock [00:53:49]:
I think establishing a career direction and a career goal is very important. I think having a home life plan with your partner as to how you’re going to manage that balance is very important. And I also believe having confidence is important. If you’re smart, service-oriented, analytical, and a problem solver, you’ve got the foundation to be an IT rock star. All you need is the confidence to perform like the rock star that you are.

Contributors

Fawn Germer

Fawn Germer, Global Leadership Speaker, Author and Women's Leadership Expert, Bestselling Oprah

Fawn Germer is the bestselling author and international leadership speaker who will reach inside of you and pull out your best self by showing you how to get beyond the self-limiting behaviors that hold so many of us back. She once had a bo... More   View all posts
Janet Sherlock

Janet Sherlock, Chief Information Officer, Carter's, Inc.

Janet Sherlock is SVP & CIO of Carters in Atlanta, GA. Carter’s is the market leader of baby and children’s apparel under the Carter’s and OshKosh B’Gosh brand names. Prior to joining Carter’s, Janet was a Research Director ... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

TECHM - GENAI - MPU04 - 300x300
Fawn Germer