Cybersecurity • Digital Transformation

How to Drive Effective Fraud Prevention and Detection

How to Drive Effective Fraud Prevention and Detection

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Gary McCollum (United Services Automobile Association (USAA)), Steve Fletcher (State of Utah), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that fraud and cybersecurity are one holistic problem of protecting data and money, and that both crime and detection have risen as daily life moved online. Gary McCollum of USAA said cyber criminals go where the money and people are, cited the Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report finding that 92% of attacks were not difficult and 89% of victims subject to the Payment Card Industry standard were not compliant, and recommended a separate strong password for banking. Steve Fletcher of the State of Utah said states are an identity gold mine holding birth and death records, social security numbers, and medical data, and named the well intentioned employee whose stolen laptop leaks data as a top vulnerability. Both concluded it is a shared, interdependent team sport across consumers, organizations, law enforcement, and government, with security always balanced against doing business.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Gary McCollum, Vice President and Chief Security Officer at USAA, and Steve Fletcher, CIO and Executive Director of the Department of Technology Services for the State of Utah and President of the National Association of State CIOs, about how to drive effective fraud prevention and detection. They compare cyber fraud with traditional fraud, and financial services with state government, and weigh how much responsibility sits with organizations versus individual consumers. Both describe account takeover, identity theft, and the trade off between strong security and usable services.

Contributors

  • Gary McCollum, Vice President and Chief Security Officer, United Services Automobile Association (USAA)
  • Steve Fletcher, CIO and Executive Director of the Department of Technology Services for the State of Utah, and President of the National Association of State CIOs, State of Utah

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Gary McCollum, Chief Security Officer at USAA, says the rise in reported fraud reflects both more crime and better detection. He points to a society far more interconnected and online than ten years ago, and notes that cyber criminals go where the money and the people are.
  • Gary McCollum of USAA cites the Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report finding that 92% of the attacks it investigated were not very difficult. He argues that organizations which do the security basics well become much harder targets, and that 89% of victims subject to the Payment Card Industry standard had not achieved compliance.
  • Steve Fletcher, CIO for the State of Utah, says states are the biggest identity gold mine for cyber criminals. He explains that states hold the whole identity life cycle, including birth records, death records, social security numbers, addresses, and medical records, and must separate sensitive data from the information they are expected to make public.
  • Gary McCollum of USAA describes account takeover as a problem every financial institution spends resources to counter. He says skilled criminals probe with small amounts to stay undetected while institutions invest in behavior and transaction analysis, and he urges consumers to keep a separate, strong password just for banking.
  • Steve Fletcher of the State of Utah names the well intentioned employee as one of the biggest vulnerabilities. He gives the example of a worker who takes data home on a laptop that is then stolen from a car, and notes that the most secure system is one nobody can access, so security is always a trade off against doing business.
  • Gary McCollum of USAA frames fraud prevention and detection as an interdependent team sport across individuals, organizations, sectors, and government. He notes that the United States lagging behind the rest of the world on chip and PIN technology drives credit card fraud, and that security is a journey, not a destination.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: driving effective fraud prevention and detection
  • 2:31 Both more crime and better detection
  • 4:54 Security breach versus ongoing fraud
  • 7:56 Account takeover and anomaly detection
  • 10:06 Why government identity data is a target
  • 13:12 Identity theft and credit card fraud trends
  • 17:25 Growing awareness and the Verizon breach report
  • 22:37 Why security is still an afterthought
  • 25:18 Balancing security against doing business
  • 30:42 Making risk tradeoffs around member trust
  • 32:35 The well intentioned employee vulnerability
  • 41:13 An interdependent ecosystem and team sport

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: driving effective fraud prevention and detection 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:01:11]:
Today’s topic is how to drive effective fraud prevention and detection. And our guests for today’s show are Gary McCollum, who is the vice president and chief security officer at the United Services Automobile Association, also known as USAA. Good morning, Gary. How are you?

Sanjog Aul [00:01:37]:
So is life treating you well? Are you working 20 hours a day or any less?

Gary McCollum [00:01:43]:
Well, in this business and in the environment that we work in every single day, it sure feels like 20 hours a day.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:50]:
Hey. God bless you. I’m sure things will get better in coming days. At least that’s what the hope is. Right?

Sanjog Aul [00:01:57]:
And we also have Steve Fletcher, who’s the CIO and executive director of the Department of Technology Services for the State of Utah and is also the president of National Association of State CIOs. Good morning, Steve. How are you?

Sanjog Aul [00:02:11]:
So is life any different? Are you able to play golf and not work as hard?

Steve Fletcher [00:02:17]:
Well, there’s a lot of bad guys out there trying to access some of our data. So we’ve gotta keep a vigilant watch 24 by 7.

Both more crime and better detection 2:31

Sanjog Aul [00:02:31]:
Okay. So we should look at what is it that’s happening around us as organizations, as nation, as a globe, and a planet in terms of cyber security and cyber fraud and a regular in person traditional fraud and see what is to be done going forward at least. Whatever we have done is working to some degree. Perhaps there are some still gotchas and gaping holes. But going forward, what can we do to drive effective fraud prevention and detection? So now when it comes to the increase in fraud, which has been reported, every year there’s an increase in the amount of fraud that you see. So are we basically by going the cyber route in the way we have been living our lives and doing business and running nations, is that the one which is causing this increase or just there are more bad people, for whatever reason, getting churned out and put in the world out here? Gary, what do you think?

Gary McCollum [00:03:29]:
Well, I’ll tell you, it’s a great question. This is a little bit of a chicken and egg question. But I will tell you from my perspective, and let me first start off by saying, we talked a little bit about fraud at the beginning, but we’re gonna use the term cybersecurity here. And it really gets back to a subtlety that Steve just mentioned. It’s really about protecting data, and it’s about protecting financial information. And sometimes we’ll traditionally call that fraud, but in the most part, we talk about it in more broad terms. It’s about protecting information, whether it’s sitting on servers or whether it’s financial credit card information that’s in transit. It’s really a holistic problem. But back to your question, are things getting worse, or are we just getting better at seeing it? And I think the answer is really both. Certainly, if you look at our society, we are much more interconnected than we were 10 years ago. We are much more online. You can look at every metric out there. More and more people are turning to online commerce. More and more people are doing online banking. More people are using devices that have IP addresses in their everyday life just to live. And so, when you look at the interconnectedness, and what we’re doing to live our lives every day, we’re certainly more interconnected and on the net. But at the same time, cyber criminals go where the money is, and this is also where people are. That’s where they’re sharing information and conducting business. And so I think there is more crime out there, but we’re also more prevalent as a result of our lifestyle changes.

Security breach versus ongoing fraud 4:54

Sanjog Aul [00:04:54]:
So, Steve, typically, when people talk about a security breach, that means somebody unauthorized actually gets in and steals some information. But whereas fraud is something where a person and or a group or an entity starts leveraging the system, the process and or gaping holes in your network to get in there, latch on to that data, start siphoning off money, or doing something with that where an ongoing processing is involved and it is done under the radar. So are these not two different type of animals?

Steve Fletcher [00:05:33]:
The way you described it, I’m not sure that they are different because, and I’ll take it from a state’s perspective rather than from a business perspective. The states have a lot of sensitive information in their data stores. They have financial information, meaning that financial transactions are completed within the confines of their systems. But they also have identity information. And identity information, if you think about it, states have the whole life cycle. They have birth records, death records, social security numbers, addresses, medical records, all the sensitive information about a particular person. Both of those areas, both financial transactions and identity information are big business now. If you can make a fraud transaction, you can gain money. But the gaining of identity information can also be sold for money. So you’re seeing a lot of identity information that’s sold online. You’re also seeing a lot of passwords, specialized user accounts, that information is sold as well. And so all of those things, they’re fraud, they’re theft, they’re larcenous acts that should be prosecuted because they’re stealing information through fraud or through theft.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:21]:
Now, Gary, don’t you think that if me, as Sanjog Aul, sitting, looking at everything that I’m doing every day and or perhaps living my life every day, but not know that somebody sold my identity and that super secret password that I had, and somebody is very easily taking out pennies at a time or a couple of dollars at a time from my bank account, and I don’t come to know it for next 3 years. Isn’t that something that might be happening with quite a few people and we being naive in terms of at least as end users or end customers, we may not watch every penny at all times?

Account takeover and anomaly detection 7:56

Gary McCollum [00:07:56]:
Oh, absolutely. What you’re describing is what the financial services industry calls account takeover, and it’s something that every financial institution in the world puts some set of resources at trying to detect and counter on any given day. And it’s something that’s hard to do, because for a lot of reasons. One, the really good cyber criminals out there, they’re gonna do a really good job at understanding processes, and their goal is to try to remain undetected. And so they’re gonna try not to do the big bang type of transactions that’s gonna set off the detection systems and mechanisms out there. And they are gonna do probes and small amounts. And so in some cases, that does happen. But I will tell you that the financial institutions do invest a lot in behavior and transaction analysis. And so they try to look for the anomalies out there that start to point them to something that doesn’t look quite right. But account takeover is a problem.

Sanjog Aul [00:08:50]:
So do you think that we will have to kinda live with this problem, or do you see in terms of the very detection coming days?

Gary McCollum [00:09:01]:
Well, whether you’re talking fraud or whether you’re talking cybersecurity or whatever, it is always a journey. It is never a destination. Nobody’s ever gonna say, here’s the exact tool or the technology that’s gonna solve this problem. Because just as much as the industry adapts to the criminals, the criminals also adapt to security and fraud controls out there. So it’s always gonna be a bit of a cat and mouse game. But I will tell you, there’s a lot to be done and a lot that can be done, but it’s a shared responsibility. It’s a shared responsibility between individuals as much as it is the organizations and the overall industry. And to some extent, the government.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:42]:
So coming to government, Steve, I’m sure you must be living some of these nightmares. So if you were to really inventory, perhaps across industry and government or only, for that matter, government, where if you were to inventory what type of pattern of fraud that you see more prevalent and in which areas, then we could look at what is possible in terms of detecting them and preventing them.

Why government identity data is a target 10:06

Steve Fletcher [00:10:06]:
Well, I think what we’re seeing in government obviously is identity information is the biggest gold mine that cyber criminals are looking for because states have so much of that. States have another unique problem in the fact that with the exception of the information that is very protected, what states want to do is make most information available to the public. So we have to very clearly and carefully categorize our information for what it contains. And so we’re gonna make most of it readily available so anybody can come in and in the spirit of transparency look at what’s taken place or make it available. But sensitive information, obviously, you can’t. So you have even a double whammy there, that you try and build a fence around the sensitive data, but sometimes that’s melded in with other data that has to be released. And so I think you’re seeing a lot of effort at trying to protect the sensitive data and steer it away from folks that will access it and use it maliciously. But that provides a significant challenge. I think that’s where most of the government entities are putting their efforts into place is to protect that information. So they have to figure out how to separate it, how to understand what your information is, and then what is accessible and who has access to it. And we’re seeing lots of folks trying lots of different ways in which to get access to that so they can sell it or use it in some really nuisance oriented way. Sometimes a group will steal data, and then they will target a particular organization and then release all that data just to be a nuisance and to make it so that everybody has to try and figure out what happened to that information.

Sanjog Aul [00:12:36]:
So, Gary, based on what Steve mentioned here, there could very well be some publicly available information, and then the state could be utilized as a source of information in a malicious way. And then that information that’s collected about an average citizen could be used in the private industry. So now when you got different places where a person or an entity could go to look for data and then leverage and try to use that to attack at a different place, it’s like a wild goose chase just to figure it out where did this whole thing start. How do you handle all this then?

Identity theft and credit card fraud trends 13:12

Gary McCollum [00:13:12]:
Well, absolutely. Steve makes a great point. So if you ask me, what are the big fraud trends that we see or security trends we see in financial services, he just touched on one of them, identity theft. So we are concerned about individuals that would create an account or set up an application with our institution or any other financial institution. And we have to go through a process. Every financial institution has to go through a process to one, verify that identity is a legitimate identity, and then to validate the other person on the other end of the line or the other end of the computer that that person is who they say they are. And so that’s a very tricky process, because there is a certain amount that you can do and there’s some things you can’t do to go through that authentication process. But we do see and experience identity theft attempts all the time. The other thing that we see a lot of that’s also related to some degree with identity theft is credit card fraud. So credit card fraud is probably one of the biggest fraud areas that we deal with on a day-to-day basis, and it has a lot to do with what’s going on in the rest of the world. Just as a side note, the rest of the world is getting away from that magnetic stripe on the back of credit cards, and they’ve gone to a much stronger form of technology known simplistically as chip and PIN, but while the rest of the industrial world has gone to that, the United States is still behind in adopting that technology. And so that’s driving a lot of credit card fraud our way as well.

Sanjog Aul [00:14:37]:
Let’s look at, while, of course, we, to some degree, inventoried the problems, but let’s also see what are we trying to do. What have we tried so far? What’s working? What’s not working? What’s being researched today without, of course, divulging the classified information?

Sanjog Aul [00:17:06]:
So, Gary, we’ll start with you. What do you think we today are trying to do with all the problems that we know about in terms of preventing and or fixing them and then perhaps finding out a way to be a little more proactive? And what’s working and then what’s not working?

Growing awareness and the Verizon breach report 17:25

Gary McCollum [00:17:25]:
Well, that’s a great question. I think the biggest thing that’s happening today is there’s a growing level of awareness. And I kind of compare to where things were 10 years ago when I was back in the Department of Defense working in this career field. There was a very low level of awareness, not just within the sector that I was in, the defense sector, but there was a low level of awareness of the threats and the concerns within government, and then even at the private citizen level. And so what I’ve seen is, steadily over the last 10 years, is just a growing awareness and a recognition that actions have to be taken. So the first step in any problem solving situation is awareness of what you’re trying to do. So I give good news on that front. I just see a lot more awareness, a lot more media attention on this, which is all good because it raises individuals’ awareness. When you ask about what’s being done and what can be done, I’m gonna refer back to a really interesting report that I just read not too long ago. You’re probably familiar with Verizon. Verizon puts out a report every year called the Data Breach Investigations Report, and they do that in conjunction with the Secret Service and some other organizations. And what they do is they provide insights onto data incidents that they’ve investigated over the previous year. And this one that they’ve just put out for 2011, it’s fascinating because some of the statistics they show are revealing. And one of the things that popped out was that 92% of the attacks that they investigated were not very difficult. In other words, if organizations just do the basics very well, they have a higher probability of being a harder target than those that don’t do it. So one of the things I learned back in my Department of Defense days was before you start talking about really complex and sophisticated technologies, you have to put the basic security controls in place, and you have to do those very well in order to build on those just to start to deal with the most sophisticated problems. So I would tell you the security controls of today in the industry, they’re not necessarily sufficient for every type of threat out there, but they’re certainly good enough when they’re properly implemented to knock away a big chunk of the problems that we’re dealing with. And then the third thing I would mention to you is individual responsibility. In the financial services industry, most of the things that impact consumers end up being the liability of the financial institutions because of the way regulations are set up today. And we understand that, and that’s the way it is. But when you look at the problem from an end to end perspective, an organization, a bank, a financial services organization, they can do everything right on their end. But if the individual doesn’t take some responsibility and do some proper security measures on their end, it’s gonna eventually impact both the institution and the member. And so there is a shared responsibility. And then there are things that people can do from a basic security mechanism, but again, that level of awareness is growing to get people to start doing that.

Steve Fletcher [00:20:19]:
Let me just follow-up a little bit on that. I think Gary stated it very well, but I think we would even put more emphasis on this awareness, the citizen awareness, the employee awareness. What are things you need to be doing? As you said, the responsibility. Because we have a lot of awareness training, we have a lot of information on our website to say be aware of this, make sure that you understand how to recognize a phishing site, what it means, don’t open any email that you don’t know who the sender is. All those things that many years ago, as Gary was saying, weren’t there, people have to be aware of. Particularly if they’re gonna be using these online services, you have to know what it means. And I think that’s where we started talking about fraud. That’s many times how it is perpetrated is because the user doesn’t understand what the environment is, and to be able to take some of those controls or put those things into play. So I think that’s a huge part of trying to put controls in place, is making the user, the citizen aware of what the environment is so that they can take steps to ensure that they aren’t duped or defrauded in any way.

Sanjog Aul [00:21:59]:
Now this brings up an important point here because we did other security shows, and everywhere, we did give a lot of emphasis on user awareness and totally agreed that, yes, people should be aware about what environment they’re living in, etcetera, etcetera. However, each average citizen, my grandma would not understand the intricacies of the environment either, but they still are going to be doing the transactions. And half knowledge is dangerous. So do you think we can wash away our hands saying that we made our average consumer well aware and that’s gonna significantly reduce the probability of them being vulnerable to such threats?

Why security is still an afterthought 22:37

Gary McCollum [00:22:37]:
Oh, Sanjog Aul, that’s a great point, and I would think Steve would say the same thing, but there is a long way to go. I don’t think overall, even if you have a high level of awareness, that collectively, industry and others have done a good job making security transparent and inherent in the systems and the technologies that consumers are using every day. Typically, security is an afterthought. It’s been a bolt on, and a complex thing that people have to worry about. And most of the time, they don’t have the time nor the knowledge to deal with it. My mother-in-law is a great example; she had a computer and she didn’t know too much about it, and she said, hey, could you take a look at that? And she goes, it’s not working very well. And when I took a look at it from a security perspective, patching wasn’t turned on, antivirus had expired, there were several issues with it. She wasn’t running a firewall, things that from a security perspective you would automatically think to look at. And I mentioned those to her. She says, well, I don’t care about any of those things. I said, well, mom, what do you use this computer for? She goes, well, I use it for banking.

Sanjog Aul [00:23:48]:
See? No, that’s exactly what I was referring to.

Gary McCollum [00:23:50]:
And that’s where I highlight the problem. So you do have to take a very methodical, basic approach to educate people and give them tools and knowledge so that they can act on it. And I’ll tell you, one of the ones that we do in financial services, and many banks do this, we highly recommend as a first step to members and consumers, you should use a different password than you use for your social media and your online activities than you do for your banking account. Keep a separate password just for your banking account and make it really strong. Start off by doing those little things like that. Start to build on what I think is a level of education awareness out there today that you can work with. So that by itself is not too hard to do. And just by educating them on the fact that, if you use a different password, you’re gonna really make it harder for the bad guys to get into your banking account if they’ve compromised your password some other way.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:45]:
Now with that said, Steve, so now again, I will reiterate this point. So we still took the ownership and the onus of making the fort secure and prevent and detect timely the frauds to some extent or to quite an extent on the end user versus us being able to, as organizations who are safeguarding that data or expected to safeguard that data, to really step up to the plate and say, I will take care of it. So is this a mindset or is this the best we could do?

Balancing security against doing business 25:18

Steve Fletcher [00:25:18]:
I think that there are lots of very, very strong controls that can be implemented. I think the banks in particular have done an excellent job of really making things more and more secure in order to protect their data. But as Gary has said, the technology, everything is evolving and the awareness is evolving. And you always have to balance that against the business and being able to do business functions. Because the most secure system is one that is never accessed. That means nobody will be able to get at it. You’ll never breach it because nobody accesses it. Although from a business standpoint, that’s really, really difficult to justify. I got a system that nobody can access, but it’s very, very secure. So you’re always in that balancing act. And the business said you can’t constrain our citizens or our users too much because if it takes you an hour and a half to do your business at a bank, just to log in, verify, do your retinal scan, and so forth, then that becomes counterproductive to the business. So you’re always doing a trade off in that regard. So I guess I would say there’s lots of great controls out there, and as Gary illustrated, we ought to do the basics first, because those generally cover most of your activities. Nevertheless, you can make them as strong as you would like, even down to some really, really detailed biometrics activities in order to verify who that person is and so that they can get on. Those happen to be fairly expensive and they’re not necessarily available to everybody. So again, it’s the trade off for how much security do you need for your business according to your business rules and how you’re going to implement that is one of the great debates that takes place every day in modern America.

Sanjog Aul [00:27:40]:
And Steve, to your point about the trade off, Gary, we’d love to start with you and talk about how do you differentiate between the acceptable risk definition that a consumer has in his or her mind and an organization which has got a responsibility to secure that. So if we say that the trade off is required because at some point it becomes an overhead, but when somebody’s dollars and their years of earning and or their whole livelihood is at stake, is there something known as an acceptable risk that somebody is willing to have?

Sanjog Aul [00:30:15]:
So, Gary, based on Steve’s last comment about we have to make trade offs and rightfully so because at some point, it’ll become cost prohibitive for it to remain a business proposition. But then when you look from a consumer standpoint, they do not typically want to listen to this concept of acceptable risk when their livelihood and or their savings or their daughter or son’s education funds are at stake.

Making risk tradeoffs around member trust 30:42

Gary McCollum [00:30:42]:
I think that’s a great point. And I would tell you, trade off decisions get made by individuals and organizations every single day from a risk perspective. When an individual gets in a car and they drive somewhere, they make a decision whether or not they’re gonna put the seat belt on, etcetera. And it’s not a whole lot different on the security side of the house. Organizationally, I think you asked the question is, how does an organization make those risk tradeoffs? And it’s always a balance. Because if you had unlimited resources, it wouldn’t necessarily be a big, hard conversation to have and a decision to reach. But no organization has unlimited resources. But it really starts with the individual organization, their mission, and their core values. And for us, in the business I’m in, it’s about trust and confidence of our members. And so, we have a very low tolerance for risk when it comes to trade offs that would impact our members and protection of their information. That being said, there’s lots of things from a security perspective. If I could wave a magic wand that we would like a member to do if they’re banking online with us or any other financial institution. But some of that technology is not necessarily as user friendly as it needs to be today. And so going back to a point that you made, if you put a lot of security controls in place, or impediments for somebody to have to work around, they either won’t use your product or your service, or they’ll bypass the security controls and create more risk. And so it really is a balance between the end user experience and the organization’s mission on a day to day basis. And that can be a difficult conversation at times, but it really is rooted back into the mission objectives of the organization.

Sanjog Aul [00:32:21]:
Now we know that we have been trying to secure the fort, but are there any chronic vulnerabilities that exist which you think a fraudster might want to capitalize on? Steve, what do you think?

The well intentioned employee vulnerability 32:35

Steve Fletcher [00:32:35]:
There’s probably one of the biggest vulnerabilities we have is the well intentioned employee who knows what the acceptable use policies are and has then determined that they want to take some work home, with the assumption that they’re gonna be a good employee and work at home, and get some extra work done that they weren’t able to accomplish during the day. They load that work onto their laptop. They go home, and on the way home, their car is broken into, and the laptop is stolen. And all that information with all that sensitive data is now in the hands of somebody who it shouldn’t be. Now all those things are, it was a well intentioned employee and they were actually trying to do some overtime. However, they violated the acceptable use policy and how they protected that data. And I think that’s where you see most of the vulnerabilities, where employees don’t follow the rules, they don’t follow how things should be portrayed or protected, and they don’t take steps to protect their password. They don’t take steps to, as citizens, they may not understand all the controls that Gary pointed out, and those are the most frustrating breaches that you have is for people not being aware, people not paying attention, and people not following the rules. I think that’s where much of our fraud has been perpetrated is through compromising those either uninformed or even well intentioned citizens and employees.

Sanjog Aul [00:34:44]:
Now, Gary, if for any organization, when we look at this whole department of so called fraud prevention and detection, suppose it was a department, is there a blueprint of where they have to go? Is there a defined road map? And is this a truly planned activity versus more seat of the pants? Not exactly seat of the pants or ad hoc, but a little more played by the ear because we are kind of maneuvering in the dark.

Gary McCollum [00:35:12]:
Absolutely. Any financial institution, there’s not gonna be a cookie cutter approach. It’s gonna be based on an architecture. It’s also gonna be based on requirements. So, for example, if you’re gonna process credit cards or issue credit cards, you gotta be compliant with the Payment Card Industry security standard that’s out there, and there’s certain things that you have to do and have to have in place. But holistically, what the secret sauce is gonna be is that particular organization’s architecture, what they’re doing from a business perspective in terms of products and services and the channels that they interact with, and what are the overlying systems, the people, and the technologies that overlay on top of that architecture to support anti-fraud and detection efforts?

Sanjog Aul [00:35:57]:
Now you mentioned about security standards. Do you think if the security and a fraud prevention and detection standards were being followed to the tee, or if we are indeed following them to our best possible level, and still we do not see any stop and or slowing growth of fraud, that means there might be a flaw in the very standards. Do you think we can make that assumption and or draw in this inference?

Gary McCollum [00:36:26]:
No. I think that standards have to evolve, they have to evolve over time as well. But I will tell you, I’ll go back to the Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report. And one of the statistics they put out in this year’s report, they said 89% of the victims that are subject to the Payment Card Industry security standard, for example, 89% of those had not achieved compliance. And so, you can tell if you do the things that you need to do and do the basics well, and take an end to end approach, you will be a very hard target. You’re not gonna stop all the problems. You’re not gonna eliminate fraud, but you will have a very strong system in place to work with and build on.

Steve Fletcher [00:36:52]:
And to follow-up with that, I think what Gary said is correct, and what you also do is you are creating a culture of security. And once you do that, you have folks that are really paying attention to the new methods, the new ways in which you would compromise a system, and so your whole team is looking for that. And so you do, while it’s a struggle to keep up, you have your whole team paying attention to that. They are looking at the ways in which it is evolving, how they are attacking you, how they are looking for ways to breach your security. And I think once you implement that, you have a whole, I would say, a culture of security throughout your organization. And that’s kind of what will help you fend off a lot of these new attacks as it evolves as you go forward. But if you don’t have that culture of security, there’s lots of places where you’re not paying attention. There’s a development server that’s out there that’s unprotected because you don’t have that whole culture to pay attention to it.

Sanjog Aul [00:38:22]:
When we do talk about the entities that have to come together in order for them to deliver the required level of security and perhaps the fraud prevention and detection capability. They may not always be running at the same speed. If there are two wheels of a bicycle or the rear two wheels of a car, if they are spinning at different speeds, God bless us, what’s gonna happen to the car? So what do we do here so that all wheels are spinning at the same speed with all the different entities involved? Is that even realistic for us to claim that it’s happening right now as we speak? Steve?

Steve Fletcher [00:39:02]:
I think in some areas, it is. And, in some areas, it isn’t. It’s kind of the culture that I was talking to. But I think that it goes beyond your immediate organization, because at some point you need some intervention by law enforcement. I think some of the other entities that you might wanna bring in, I think banks do a phenomenal job of kind of backstopping some of your financial transactions so that they have controls in place so that if you are perpetrated, that it typically goes to another bank, and they have some great controls in place that they look at. And so getting help from financial institutions, from law enforcement, from your policy folks, from government, all are important in order to be able to make sure that all wheels, as you say, are going in, at the same speed so that you can have, again, you layer your security protection. Those are all parts of the layers that are tools that you can use.

Sanjog Aul [00:40:23]:
Now, Gary, with all the different examples that we have or the answers we got during the show today, financial services looks like a hero where they have really aced it and are able to do whatever they have to do in order to have the right controls in place and be able to prevent fraud and perhaps detect proactively. With that said, there are so many other industries that we work with as individuals or as institutions, maybe insurance, health care, transportation, etcetera, etcetera. And everywhere, we, in some form or fashion, divulge some of our identity information and perhaps even financial data. So are financial institutions supposed to be the final cops who are going to detect after the fraud has happened at these other entities which are not as safe and secure because they may not have the right directives in place?

An interdependent ecosystem and team sport 41:13

Gary McCollum [00:41:13]:
Well, it’s a great point. Steve made the point as well. I would just say the ecosystem out there on the network, and it is an ecosystem, it’s individuals, it’s organizations, it’s different sectors, and it’s different agencies. It’s an interdependent team sport. And I think the financial services industry has done a very good job with security and anti-fraud. However, nobody is complacent. Nobody thinks that we’ve got it licked because we see how adaptable cyber criminals are. We see how adaptable the threat is. And so it’s a continuous state of evolution. Oftentimes, much of what happens somewhere else in the ecosystem out there does end up in the financial services industry, because that’s where the money is, but not all the time. And so I think that different sectors are in different states of evolution and where they’re at. The government is talking a lot about what are we doing as a nation and as a society to protect our critical infrastructure, whether that’s the power grid, whether that’s the transportation industry, you name it. There’s a lot of focus on that. When I look at things like healthcare, there’s obviously a correlation there to what the financial services industry is doing with the evolution of electronic medical records, and the implications there, protecting personal identifiable information and health information. So there’s a lot of interdependencies, and I would tell you it’s a journey, and no one sector has got it licked.

Sanjog Aul [00:42:41]:
Now, with that said, if we were to say that we are not 100% dependent on just computers, we can make the computer smarter, and we can keep going with that crusade. However, the people are the ones who are handling these computers. So do you think we need smarter people going forward in order to run these even smarter computers? Or people are the weakest link.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:59]:
So we have this so called trick question where we are trying to make us better in terms of preventing and detecting fraud. And the premise is, since the technology is becoming smart, but the people who are to use technology or manage this technology, if they remain not as smart, then it’s gonna be not going to provide us the end result. So, Gary, do you think we need smarter people as a user and or as the people who manage those technologies in order for us to reach the holy grail that we are striving for?

Gary McCollum [00:45:37]:
I think on the end user side, the end users deserve to have security more integrated into the products and services that they’re buying so they don’t have to think about making decisions about how to configure a firewall or how to make a particular security setting more secure on their browser. I don’t think they should have to worry about those. So I think security needs to be better integrated into products and services. And then the end user has to be a little smarter about what they do on the network and how they interact with it. On the organizational enterprise side, I definitely think that you have to have a workforce that’s more skilled and evolves with the technology. You don’t need a bunch of people that are really experts on mainframes from a security perspective as much as you need people to understand mobile technologies today. And so you have to be able to evolve your workforce and the skill sets with what’s going on the technology side, or you’re gonna be very quickly behind the security power curve.

Sanjog Aul [00:46:30]:
Steve.

Steve Fletcher [00:46:32]:
I would agree with that. I think you need a combination of both things. The user needs to be aware. He needs to understand the environment that you’re in and the threats, but you do have to make technology easier for them. And there’s lots of vulnerabilities in, say for instance, browsers. But the browser that generally comes with your machine, it is what it is, and so trying to get a specialized browser or something that would be very secure is kind of a pain in the neck for most users to be able to do online transactions securely. So there’s got to be a better way to integrate that, to make it so that you don’t have to understand all the technology, but it is available for you easily so that you can use it. So I would agree with Gary on that.

Sanjog Aul [00:47:37]:
So question is here that security typically gets, I would not say in all cases, but in many cases gets a stepchild treatment when it comes to budgeting because we are not able to always show a tangible ROI. And that’s why we are told that you’re kinda selling insurance or selling fear. With that said, if you as a business need to be making your consumer or the end customer warm and fuzzy, you got to be able to figure out a way to connect that to the type of investment required for us to be able to prevent the fraud and detect fraud because otherwise, the lawsuits and other things that you will pay money anyways could be far bigger bill that you’ll end up paying. So, Gary, what is the business case that you make, and what battles do you think your counterparts and you have to fight in order to make sure that you’re able to invest adequately?

Gary McCollum [00:48:26]:
Well, you asked a great question. On the fraud side of the house, since I own both the fraud team as well as the information security team, it’s sort of almost two different hats, but really, at the end of the day, it’s just one hat, and that’s the case that I have to make. On the information security side of the house, we’ll typically talk about the decrease in risk. We’ll put the ROI discussion in terms of decreased risk, and also some avoidance of regulatory concerns, because there’s some things that you have to do. On the fraud side of the house, it’s much easier to show a business case ROI because, again, fraud typically deals with real dollars being lost or going out the door. And so we have a much better connection between our systems on that side of the house and the sort of impact they can have from a business case perspective. So my challenge is how do I integrate all that into a cohesive story, during the budgeting and the strategy process? But it can be done.

Sanjog Aul [00:49:22]:
Steve, if you feel in the government, especially when dollars are fewer in terms of overall IT budget, do you get special sanctions for the security and fraud related investments you have to make?

Steve Fletcher [00:49:40]:
I would like that, but it’s kinda sad. Sometimes in the security world, you gotta have dead bodies before people pay attention. You gotta have some significant breaches before they say, oh, yeah. I guess we ought to pay attention to this. But on the other hand, in a political arena, that’s really not a good thing either because that generally means loss of somebody’s head as who’s responsible for that. So it is always a fight. But I think that we’ve gotten in government to the point where we can say, now wait a minute, this is really a bad thing that’s gonna happen if we don’t protect it. So we do need to spend some money on this as part of our overall systemic approach, we gotta have these controls in place. So any new project that’s coming up, we have to say, here’s the issues. From a business standpoint, we have to reduce our risk here because we can’t have this data being perpetrated. And that really is how you state your case. But nevertheless, there’s a huge education process that has to take place to say, no, you really want to pay attention to this, and we’re gonna have to spend some money here because this is very, very sensitive information. And, as you say, you kinda scare them a little bit to say, you really want to do this, because you don’t want your name in the paper as somebody who neglected to put a proper control in place.

Sanjog Aul [00:51:26]:
Now these frauds are, to some extent, being created because we introduced technology. And when we talk about technology, the IT departments come on the spotlight. So Gary, do you think you are able to say I’m not responsible for it if at all fingers get pointed on your group? And what do you think about the rest of your counterparts doing in their respective companies?

Gary McCollum [00:51:49]:
I think it’s gonna be a little bit dependent on organizational structure in companies and a little bit on organizational culture in these different companies. At this particular company, the security function is separate from the IT function. We have an excellent working relationship with the CIO. And at the end of the day, I know that our CEO would say everybody’s business is about protecting information and ensuring the trust and confidence of our members. So I think I live in a little bit different world, but I would tell you it’s probably different company to company to some degree.

Steve Fletcher [00:52:18]:
And I would say from a government standpoint, we kinda have to partner with the business, because the business is the steward of the data. The IT department and the security department execute the policy according to the business. And they kinda have to work together as a team to go forward. Then the IT department has to tell them, or the security department has to tell them, alright, if you make these decisions, this is what the impact is gonna be. If you don’t spend the money there, you are going to be exposed as risk is gonna increase. But you have to partner with the business because the business is going to be the one that’s going to set the rules for who has access to the data, how we protect it, and how we use it in our normal course of business.

Sanjog Aul [00:53:13]:
Fifteen seconds each. What do you think you would like to appeal to the individual consumer organizations and government in order to get them a better assurance against the fraud that is happening all around them?

Steve Fletcher [00:53:28]:
Two things. One is, better awareness from the consumer industry, and I think that is taking place, but it’s continual training. The other thing is working with law enforcement; they’ve got to be empowered to be able to go after those bad guys, so that would be a huge deterrent also if there was more penalty that was gonna be imposed for perpetrating these frauds.

Sanjog Aul [00:54:06]:
Fifteen seconds. Gary.

Gary McCollum [00:54:08]:
Ditto on the first one. I would encourage individuals to, whether they’re banking or social networking, whatever, take the time to at least understand to some degree what are the privacy and security capabilities of that particular interaction that you’re having. And at least take time to understand it and do the minimum. Organizationally, I would say it’s a team sport. It’s an information-sharing opportunity with others within your sectors and law enforcement, and also to focus on doing those fundamentals well.

Sanjog Aul [00:54:38]:
The questions here were around how can we drive effective fraud prevention and detection? And it looks like it is supposed to be a team sport, as Gary rightly said. Everybody needs to get involved, and perhaps we will see a little more secure and a little more fraud preventing type of proactive environment that we will all start living in.

Contributors

J. Stephen Fletcher

J. Stephen Fletcher, Chief Information Officer and Executive Director of the Department of Technology Services, State of Utah, and President of NASCIO

J. Stephen Fletcher, was appointed by Governor Jon M. Huntsman, Jr. in April 2005 to serve as the state’s Chief Information Officer and Executive Director of the Department of Technology Services. Under his service, the State has consolid... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

TECHM - GENAI - MPU06 - 300x300
J. Stephen Fletcher