Leadership • Talent Development

How Does an IT Leader Bounce Back?

How Does an IT Leader Bounce Back?

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Chris Patrick (Egon Zehnder International), Dr. Salvatore Armati (UC Irvine), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that a career setback for an IT leader is better treated as an interaction between the person and the situation than as personal failure. Dr. Salvatore Armati of UC Irvine argued that life is by its nature stressful, that hardiness can be trained, and that denial and avoidance do not help. He cited a human resources vice president who lost his job in a downsizing, then started his own firm and made the former employer who fired him his first client, later moving to another state and earning more than before. Chris Patrick of Egon Zehnder International said the average CIO tenure runs 2.5 to 3 years, that past performance is the best predictor of future performance, and that candidates should be open about what happened, build a network before they need it, and consider interim roles to stay in the flow. Both urged leaders to keep growing while still employed.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Chris Patrick, global CIO practice leader for Egon Zehnder International, and Dr. Salvatore Armati, professor of psychology and social behavior, School of Social Ecology at UC Irvine, about how an IT leader bounces back after losing a job or a title. Patrick explains how executive search views candidates in transition, arguing that past performance is the best predictor of future performance and that employment status does not equal capability. Armati describes resilience, which he calls hardiness, as something that can be coached rather than only inherited, and tells the story of a human resources vice president who turned his own layoff into a new company. Together they compare how to stay in the flow during a long search and how to separate the individual from the title.

Contributors

  • Chris Patrick, global CIO practice leader, Egon Zehnder International
  • Dr. Salvatore Armati, professor of psychology and social behavior, School of Social Ecology, UC Irvine

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Chris Patrick of Egon Zehnder International argues that a candidate’s employment status does not equal capability. He tells clients that bad companies happen to good people, and that the best predictor of future performance is a track record of delivering results and building high performing teams.
  • Dr. Salvatore Armati of UC Irvine holds that resilience, which he calls hardiness, can be coached rather than only inherited. He says people who handle setbacks poorly usually were not coached well, and that hardiness can be trained, even online.
  • Chris Patrick of Egon Zehnder International reports that the average tenure of a CIO runs between 2.5 and 3 years. He calls the CIO role one of the toughest executive positions, where nobody notices when things go well but the leader is first in line when something breaks.
  • Dr. Salvatore Armati of UC Irvine recounts a human resources vice president who lost his job in a downsizing and treated it as a growth opportunity. The man started his own human resources firm, persuaded the guilt-ridden employer that had fired him to become his first client, and later lived in another state making more money than before.
  • Chris Patrick of Egon Zehnder International advises that the time to build a network is not when you are out of a job. He says relationships need care and feeding throughout a career, and that leaders should manage their own path rather than let a career just happen to them.
  • Dr. Salvatore Armati of UC Irvine defines a successful bounce back as feeling better about your life, whether or not the new position is stronger than the last. He also argues leaders should keep growing while employed and prepare for the worst circumstances, because at that level there is no job security.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: how an IT leader bounces back from a setback
  • 2:19 Title-derived strength versus inherent strength
  • 4:40 Employment status does not equal capability
  • 6:22 Whether resilience can be coached
  • 7:54 Being open and honest about what happened
  • 12:32 The CIO role and its short tenure
  • 19:41 An HR leader who turned a layoff around
  • 35:06 Build your network before you need it
  • 36:57 The future state CIO model
  • 39:53 Staying in the flow during a long search
  • 47:47 Separating the individual from the role
  • 55:11 Defining a successful bounce back

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: how an IT leader bounces back from a setback 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:01:05]:
Today’s topic is how does an IT leader bounce back? And our guests for today’s show are Chris Patrick, who’s the global CIO practice leader for Egon Zehnder International. Good morning, Chris.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:44]:
Now we also have Dr. Salvatore Armati, who is a professor of psychology and social behavior, School of Social Ecology at UC Irvine. Good morning, Sal.

Title-derived strength versus inherent strength 2:19

Sanjog Aul [00:02:19]:
So the topic that we have picked up today, this is an interesting topic. Some people actually, a lot of people experience this, but very few people have been able to get an idea about what they should do when they face a setback of sorts. And we have picked up this specifically for an IT leadership community, given that there are people who lose their jobs and or face a setback within the organization, or when they are let go where it may not be truly their problem. But then we also have to look at what they were brought on board for, that is to handle these issues successfully, and many of them do. But when it comes out to be themselves who faces the setback, in the sense they lose their job, then they’re not able to cope as well, and perhaps they do not know where to go from there. Does that essentially mean that an individual is deriving all their strength from the title they carry, or is it supposed to be an inherent strength which they could demonstrate even when they did not have that title, or they were stripped off from the title? Sal, what do you think?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:03:25]:
I think the latter. Needless to say, life is by its nature a stressful phenomenon. Even if you feel your job is fairly safe, it may not be, so life is by its nature stressful. That has to be taken into account by the person, and if that’s taken into account, the person keeps trying to learn from what happens all the time and grow and develop in the process. And that’s what needs to be done.

Sanjog Aul [00:03:54]:
So if you are saying that it has to be done but it does not happen the same way, because one is, I would say, the theoretical view. Another is what we see happening out there with some of the most effective leaders who, in their respective jobs, have really done wonders for the organizations, but they have had issues dealing with that setback which they have experienced in their personal lives.

Sanjog Aul [00:04:18]:
I will ask you, Chris, when you deal with folks, I’m sure people who are looking for the next CIO job or an IT leadership job, that means, for the most part, many of them might not be having a job. How do you compare that to someone who you pull from another organization and they’re doing stellar success? What is the mind change and difference in mindset that you see?

Employment status does not equal capability 4:40

Chris Patrick [00:04:40]:
That’s a good point, and it’s something that we deal with every day. And what I’d say is, there are some of our clients, and this is a minority, so I think there’s a positive message here, that some of our clients have a built in bias against, lack of a better term, job seekers. Those folks that may not be currently employed. However, our advice has always been that we’re looking for individuals that have certain skills and competencies, and their current employment status may or may not be a reflection of their capabilities. So we will often bring candidates to a search that come from existing roles or might be in what we call a transition. And the key for us is understanding, one, what happened, and to the degree that this person has learned from or maybe could have prevented it, or what I’ve described as, bad companies happen to good people, and sometimes for no fault of their own, they find themselves in a situation. It could be an economic one that means there’s downsizing, there’s a change in direction, or a company just doesn’t make it. So I don’t think you can make a blanket statement that says employment status equals capable or not capable.

Sanjog Aul [00:06:01]:
So, Sal, when you look at this, and when you mention that people have to do it and they don’t do it, is there a problem in terms of they have not been coached? Or is it something that doesn’t occur to them, or it is just an inherent weakness in that individual who’s not able to cope with a personal setback?

Whether resilience can be coached 6:22

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:06:22]:
In your terminology, I would say they have not been coached. I’ve done a lot of consulting work for organizations and the individuals in organizations, and it’s pretty clear that some people are much better able to learn from what’s happening and to make changes when the changes are necessary, in fact, maybe even anticipate the changes and bring them about, whereas others don’t do that very well. But I know that we can train people to do it better. It isn’t something that you’re just born with. So basically the long winded answer to your question is that the people who don’t do it well haven’t been, quote, coached well.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:13]:
Now with respect to a person who is losing something or has a setback, there are people who would totally be hypercritical about their own shortcomings, and or they would attribute every success and or failure to themselves. And many times, you will also find people who would say the rest of the environment was responsible for it. So, Chris, when you go about looking at individuals and are trying to keep them in your pipeline as part of executive search, what do you see as a typical way a successful or a good professional thinks about this? Where does the person strike a balance?

Being open and honest about what happened 7:54

Chris Patrick [00:07:54]:
I think it’s a great point, Sanjog. And it’s not healthy. I’m sure Sal can add a lot of the thoughtful context, to go one way or the other, to blame somebody else or to be, as you said, hypercritical about their own capabilities. I think what I look for is somebody that is open, direct, and frankly honest about the situation. And they’re realistic about what could they have controlled, what might they have been able to change, versus what was a situational problem that for whatever reason they couldn’t control. And then the second point, and this is what I’d encourage any of your listeners who might be in this situation, is I tend to reach out to references. I’ll reach out to people who worked with this person that also have a perspective of what happened. And I think that’s an important and powerful way in which to provide additional context that may be less biased, or at least perceived to be less biased.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:05]:
So, Sal, if you looked at a person or perhaps spoke to a person, do you think what they say is what’s on their mind typically when it comes to handling setback, or they’re just trying to be stronger than they truly are?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:09:17]:
Some people try to be stronger than they truly are, but if they’re able to say what’s involved in being stronger, they at least know that. Otherwise, they wouldn’t know what to tell you. So the thing is, what you need to do is to encourage that phenomenon, even if you think they may not be telling you the real truth about themselves. People have to be very careful not to just blame the situation or themselves, but rather to see themselves in interaction with the situation, and then ask themselves, how could what’s going on be even worse than it is? How could it be even better than it is, and how can I help it go from being worse to being better? That’s what they have to do, and if they talk that way I usually believe them, because even if they’re just trying to present themselves in good light, the point is they know what the best way is.

Sanjog Aul [00:10:30]:
Do you think, Sal, in your view, when people attempt to talk themselves out of that misery and or when they’re down, that’s the only way they could handle this, or there would be something better that someone can do in order to deal with that down phase, if you will?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:10:50]:
It’s never the right thing to just blame the situation or, for that matter, just blame yourself. It’s always a complex interaction between the situation and yourself, and you may feel that you haven’t done what you could have done, but if you look at it as an interaction, you can learn from the process. Some people are quite able to learn even from failures.

Chris Patrick [00:11:18]:
And I think that’s a great point that Sal makes, and what I look for in interviewing senior executives is, and I’ll ask the question, what did you learn? What would you do differently next time? And what I’m looking for is not somebody to, as Sal said, place blame whether on themselves or on others, but to step back and say, life’s a learning experience. And you learn from failures and successes. What would you do differently, and how does this make you potentially a better leader, a better CIO? Because inevitably, we’re all going to fail at some way, shape, or form, personally or professionally, and not allowing that to knock you back too far but using it as a way to continue to build your career and build up your experience base.

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:12:09]:
That’s a great statement, Chris. And basically, what it involves is the recognition that life is by its nature a stressful phenomenon. Even if you’re a CIO, that doesn’t mean that life isn’t going to be stressful. The situation is sometimes unpredictable, who knows what’s going to happen, you have to grow and develop in the process.

The CIO role and its short tenure 12:32

Chris Patrick [00:12:32]:
I contend, and again, Sanjog, some of your listeners may agree with this. I think the CIO role is one of the toughest executive positions out there. And if everything goes well, nobody notices. But the minute it hiccups, you’re right on the top of everybody’s priority list. And it’s being able to walk that line between managing expectations, delivering on high expectations, but also anticipating and being able to react to those problems is key. And there’s an example of a big oil company CIO I know quite well, and their operations in Russia were seized by the government, which was for whatever reason investigating. And he was up in the middle of the night talking to his folks on the ground as these government police were carting out computers and other information. Nothing prepares you for problems like that, and it’s being able to adjust and react to those. And the CIOs are right in the crosshairs of a lot of people’s priorities, but also their frustration when it doesn’t go as planned.

Sanjog Aul [00:13:47]:
And look at the fact that the individual, the CIO or IT leader in this case, is controlled, or in fact is in the hands of the external environments, the stakeholders, their own team. So this person wants to be Hercules, and or wants to be a Pied Piper, but for the most part, it doesn’t look like they have overall control. So at most, what they can do is they can handle influence management. And that influence management comes with the title and authority and empowerment given by the company. Now imagine that taken away because you’re no longer the CIO, but the world out there still remains, which you need to influence to get the things done or move back into the game. How does one handle that? So is the influence management again related to what their title was, or can they truly create, maintain that influence even when they come back?

Sanjog Aul [00:17:03]:
So the question that we are putting out there is that when we had to deal with the world out there, even as an IT leader, we were not truly in control. We were at most using our influence management skills to get the jobs done. And that influence was available due to the title that you own. So now when you’re out there, you still want to not control the world, but influence in some form, but it does look like that you are a lone warrior standing there without an army or any weapon. How does one handle that? And so, Chris, I’ll start with you, and I think you had another point that you wanted to add as well.

Chris Patrick [00:17:42]:
The one just from our prior conversation that I wanted to add is an interesting fact, through our research, that was maybe surprising, maybe not, is the average tenure of a CIO is anywhere between 2.5 to 3 years. So it is a function that tends to turn over fairly rapidly. So I think the topic is quite timely, as many people, if they haven’t, might find themselves in this situation. You asked about title, and I think just briefly to comment on that. I think the thing that people have to be careful of is the title gives you access. And it gives you a seat at the table, and that comes with high expectations, and it also comes with your ability to contribute. And I caution CIOs that I work with to say, if you’re demanding that spot at the table, be prepared, because the expectations of how you contribute in a business context to the strategy and direction of the company are high. And if you don’t deliver, you’re not gonna get that opportunity and you potentially set yourself up for failure.

Sanjog Aul [00:19:06]:
So the question here would be, if a person does not have the influence left just because there was a title available, and now they are the same ex IT leader, but the world outside of their own self has changed totally. And they have to handle this and they really have to get back on their feet. One is to just handle themselves from an emotional standpoint. But frankly, they have to get out, do the job, bring money home, feed the family, and walk with head held high.

An HR leader who turned a layoff around 19:41

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:19:41]:
Absolutely. There’s no question about that, and it happens to very many people. Maybe not everyone in the work world, but it happens to very many people. I have an example that might be helpful for listeners. This was a fellow who was, at the time I met him, vice president in charge of human resources in a large company. I was actually doing some training on resilience, or what we call hardiness, for the human resources department in that company. And in one of our meetings, the vice president didn’t show up on time. He showed up late, which was very surprising for him. But then when he came in, he apologized for being late and pointed out that he had just been told by the decision makers in his company that he and the others in the human resources department no longer had their jobs. The company was having to downsize for financial reasons. Tears were almost in his eyes, and he presented himself as if he was the victim. He was the victim. He said, these people, I’ve worked with them for 15 years. I thought they were my friends, and they called me in and fired me. Now, I worked with them on how to deal with that effectively, how to see what the situation was and how it could be made better. And so instead, he tried to figure out what he could do, he didn’t victimize himself. He let himself realize finally that the decision makers who mentioned that to him had been forced to do it by the people on the board of the company, because they were concerned about money. And he then realized that these people were feeling terrible about what they had to do to fire him, rather than doing it on purpose to get rid of them. So one thing led to another, and pretty soon he began to realize that with his 15 years of experience as the head of human resources, if not only that company but other companies were downsizing, he could probably offer human resources functions to those companies, because they were going to need them even if they no longer had human resource departments. So he wanted to start his own company. Now he didn’t have the money to do it, but he realized then, since the decision makers who had to fire him probably felt guilty about doing it, he went back to them and said, look, I’m going to start my own human resources company, and you’re going to need human resources functions since you no longer have a department there. Do you want to be my first client? And they were delighted to do that, because they had been feeling so guilty about what they had to do to him. They became his first client. He got the money to start the company. Last I heard from him, he was living in another state, making more money than he made before, and is very happy because he was able to send his daughters to college, and all those kind of wonderful things.

Sanjog Aul [00:23:27]:
Now when you say this, this one example, which is a good example for people to take a look at, but people think, I’m not lucky enough to be able to take that example and think that the rest of the world will turn around and help me out. So if they have to truly, almost hypnotize themselves into feeling and or thinking that everything is gonna go well, then that, do you think, is almost foolish, or would you say that’s the only way left?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:23:59]:
If they hypnotize themselves, it’s foolish. The point is they have to recognize that life is by its nature stressful. The job you have, however wonderful it may be, you may not have forever. At that level, there’s no job security, economic downturns, companies changing, whatever. So you have to keep that in mind always, and then you have to prepare yourself for whatever could be the worst circumstances. You have to recognize that those worst circumstances may very well happen, and prepare yourself for it. So if and when it does happen, you’re able to take advantage of it and go on with your life in at least as good a way, if not better.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:51]:
Chris, it’s an interesting situation where, perhaps through your network and or you might have even known people who really did a stellar job at their organization when they were the IT leaders there. Now they lose their job, and then you’re looking for a potential candidate for yet another company. This person, when you meet, and you might have seen this person in action, but now when you meet this person, he’s in that transition and perhaps not in the best state where they’re feeling good about themselves, and given the same emotional trauma somebody goes through when you have a setback. Would your decision change because of their current state, that, hey, while this guy was great, I don’t think that he can handle it, while you also know that this person had done a stellar job at the previous stint that he had? What’s your mindset, and what do you think is the management’s mindset when they know that this person currently is not, I would not say stable, but at least not having his emotional side of things together?

Chris Patrick [00:25:52]:
I think, and I can distill it down to one thought that is consistent in how our firm operates, and really our belief on candidates and how they develop, is that the best predictor of future capability and performance is past performance. And when you look at the track record of individuals, if they have a track record of success, if they’ve shown an ability to deliver results, build high performing teams, those are the best indicators of what they’re capable of doing in the future. We all get knocked down. And I think the key, as Sal said, is being able to get back up, is to be thoughtful about understanding what happened, what could I have done differently, but then face forward. I think it can be unproductive to overanalyze why and woe is me. But to realize it happens. It happened to me. And now I’ve got to move forward. It doesn’t define me as a person. I’ve got strengths and capabilities, and where can I best leverage those? Is it in the same industry? Is it with a similar company? Is it with a smaller company? I think those are all healthy discussions that an individual should have with people they trust and individuals who have observed their capabilities in the past.

Sanjog Aul [00:27:18]:
So when you meet someone who truly has been a performer in the past but is not showing the most emotional stability and or strength at the time when you’re talking to that person, perhaps formally or informally, would you discount that totally and say, the person has a great performance track record, and while this is a temporary setback, he’s gonna get over it and gonna perform it all over again? So are you officially and even on a personal side ready to actually ignore and or discount that totally?

Chris Patrick [00:27:49]:
I would say I don’t overweight it. These are individuals that we’re dealing with. So they’re not machines. They’ve got emotions. And I completely recognize that people at various times can be fragile and you don’t want to be insensitive to that. So I don’t completely discount it. But my point is I don’t let that overly color my perspective on an individual, because I’m going to look at their track record. They may be in a dark place right now, but I know what they’re capable of, and sometimes maybe I can provide that perspective and say, listen, this is difficult, but you’ve been successful before. I’ve seen what you can do. You can do it again. Let’s go find that right one or that next one that’s going to leverage the strengths and capabilities that you bring.

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:28:40]:
And if the person needs it, we know how to train them to be able to do better.

Sanjog Aul [00:28:49]:
So, Sal, question for you is, this is something where a person who is in that emotional state, but the person cannot just sit on a recliner and flip TV channels and mourn, they have to go out. They have to network with people, and they have that particular fragility existing there. Do you think, what should be the stature of that person, or what should be the approach that a person should take when they’re going out and trying to connect with other people, have conversations? Should they leave that side of it masked totally or work very hard to mask it, or let that be available as a vulnerability that exists, but it’s only temporary?

Sanjog Aul [00:32:02]:
So, Sal, question is, when you go out, basically, you have to go out and meet with people and mingle and do the things required for you to get back into the game, but then you know that you’re emotionally fragile. So is it okay for people to show their emotional fragility and or mask it heavily in order to create the right first impression, which is, I think, overrated sometimes, in order to get back into the game and really build a network or sustain that network that they might be building or perhaps not building?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:32:32]:
I think it’s best if they express the difficulties they’re having, because after all they just lost a big job. But they also have to be able to show ways of using that experience to grow and develop. So that’s what you need to look for, not that they shouldn’t say that they’re in terrible shape because now they don’t have a job anymore, but rather what’s the next step? What are they trying to do and how are they trying to do it? That’s what you have to look for. Now, sometimes people can’t do that. Sometimes they get into what we call denial and avoidance. They just don’t want to have anything to do with what happened or talk to anybody about it, or if they do talk to other people, they make it sound like it’s okay even though you know pretty well it isn’t for them. So denial and avoidance doesn’t help at all. What you need is the ability to think carefully and fully about what happened, what your role was, what the company’s role was, what can be done now to actually turn that loss of a job from a potential disaster into a growth opportunity instead, and then try to carry through on that. And if they sound like that when you talk with them, that’s great. If they don’t sound like that, they need some help, and we do a lot of hardiness training, resiliency training for people. Actually it can even be done online now. They can just go online and take the course. And we have a book, my collaborator Debbie Koshaba and I have a book called Resilience at Work, subtitle How to Succeed No Matter What Life Throws at You, which can be helpful too.

Sanjog Aul [00:34:34]:
So, Chris, when you look at such people and when they go and approach and they are asked this question, so what happened? Tell me more about it. And what are you doing nowadays? The typical questions that you will get asked, and people are seen in all different states of facial expressions and nervousness, etcetera, and give kind of crazy answers sometimes. What do you think would be an answer that you would have expected from someone who’s got it covered, or perhaps not got it covered but is gracefully handling what’s happening to them?

Build your network before you need it 35:06

Chris Patrick [00:35:06]:
That’s a good point. And there’s two things. One is, I think the most effective way is to hit head on. It’s to be open, honest, and direct about what happened and what you’ve learned from it. So back to the earlier points made about using it as an experience to gain insights about your capabilities, but also about how you might act or react differently in the future. And if you need to, rehearse it. Be prepared. You should have a crisp, clear, thoughtful, and good answer to that question because you’re going to get it from everybody. And it shouldn’t be an uncomfortable point. It’s a fact, deal with it and move on. The second thing I would add to that is the networking piece. If your listeners walk away from this with one thing, I’d say the time to build your network is not when you’re out of a job. Networks require care and feeding and you need to build them throughout your career. And if the only time you’re reaching out to the people you know is when you need something from them, that’s the wrong time. You’ve gotta manage those relationships, because they need you, but you’re gonna need them and you don’t know when that’ll be. But if you’ve let it atrophy, you’re gonna pay the price and you’re gonna spend a lot of time trying to make those connections again when you should have been managing them throughout.

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:36:35]:
I couldn’t agree more with that. We actually tell people that your relationships with others, your social network, should be characterized by giving and getting assistance and encouragement, giving and getting assistance and encouragement, to do the hard work of dealing with life stresses.

The future state CIO model 36:57

Chris Patrick [00:36:57]:
And one thing I’d add to that, Sal and Sanjog, one of the things that I think anybody in these senior level positions should be thinking about is, what am I doing to continue to develop and progress my career, my capabilities, my skills, so that I am more marketable if and when there comes a time, either through my choice or through the choice of a company, I need to look for that next opportunity. What have I been doing to build those skill sets? And we did extensive work with the CIO Executive Council and CIO magazine to develop what we call the future state CIO model. And what that looked at was the progression of the IT function from individual contributor to really strategic business partner, and it talks about the relative competencies that the leader needs to develop, from market orientation to strategic orientation, functional expertise, etcetera. And I encourage, if any one of your listeners can see that context on cio.com, take a look at it. It’s a great model, I think, that anybody in this function can look at and see, this is what our clients, this is what the executives that retain us to find senior leaders are looking for. And that’s what you should be aiming at and preparing yourself for, either a planned or maybe an unplanned transition in your career.

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:38:27]:
I couldn’t agree with you more, Chris. The point is when people have a wonderful job and they’re an executive and whatnot, they shouldn’t just relax. They need to keep growing and developing as a result of what happens, because who knows what the next situation is gonna be like.

Sanjog Aul [00:38:50]:
Now one is that when you have had this event, which is you lost your job or you faced a setback related to the business, and primarily we are looking at a lost job and losing that title. One is that it is fresh and the wounds are fresh and then you’re trying to heal. But then it could be 7 months, 8 months, even a year, 1.5 years before you will get the next opportunity. Initially, yes, you could be all ready to go, perhaps deal with your stress and go about networking. But after some time, you say this is not working out, but I have to keep at it. So you become tired and or you start looking at life differently, say, I don’t think it’s gonna happen. So how does someone keep their emotional strength, if you will, intact for that long, grueling waiting time before they could get back into the game? So, Chris, what have you seen people doing in those elongated period of wait?

Staying in the flow during a long search 39:53

Chris Patrick [00:39:53]:
I think you make a good point. And one thing that I will often mention to the executives that I’m talking to is, prepare or manage your expectations. This could be a 6-week process or it could be a 6, 12, 18-month process. And you should be prepared for that, just mentally and emotionally. I think the key thing is you’ve got to stay in the flow, and that goes back to our earlier point around the network. I’ve seen some CIOs that are in transition that take interim roles, that take consulting roles with early stage companies. I think that’s a good idea because it keeps an edge. It keeps you in the flow. I think if there’s too much time where you’re not meeting with potential employers, where you’re not dealing with issues around IT technology, whatever that might be, I think you have the risk that you can become a little tired, you can become a little dull. There are interim CIO consulting companies out there. Tatum is one of those, where that might be an option for somebody to consider if they’re finding that they’re just not getting traction in a particular area. The other is you might think about moving into a different industry. I think that brings some risks that you might want to talk about, but that’s another consideration as well.

Sanjog Aul [00:41:22]:
Now, Sal, when you are looking at these people who may be waiting for too long, is there a progressive approach to hardening themselves, or is it something the same formula should be utilized and you just practice the same?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:41:36]:
The thing is, growing in hardiness is a progressive phenomenon. What it means is, whatever happens today, you have to evaluate, see where it fits into your growth and development, and then take the next step that will lead you further on. And you have to have an overall plan. So I agree with what Chris was saying, that in the meanwhile, you could do temporary jobs or even change your job seeking. But basically speaking, it’s a gradual process of growth and development that goes on. You can’t just do it all at once, but you just have to make sure to keep trying, keep trying. And in order to keep trying, you need a plan, you need an overall goal, and the instrumental steps you need to take to reach that goal. And some of those instrumental steps may be earning some extra money or keeping in the job area by doing temporary work or whatever it might be.

Sanjog Aul [00:42:57]:
So, Chris, in your view, if a person has been waiting for this long, and as they go about looking for a job and or interviewing and or networking, what are the typical do’s and don’ts if we were to inventory those?

Chris Patrick [00:43:11]:
I think the thing that anybody should be aware of is, if there is a significant amount of time and you’re plus 1 year, any employer is going to start asking the question of, why is this person not finding a role? Why have they been out of a position for so long? And there could be some very plausible reasons. It could be the economy we just came out of was unprecedented, and we saw individuals who are very capable, quite good, who just were not finding the roles because those roles just weren’t out there. Now the good news is we’re coming out of that. We’re seeing much greater demand. We’re seeing our clients starting to go back into the market looking for talent, making investments in IT, etcetera. So I think that phenomenon is hopefully behind us. But I think anybody should be cautious that the longer you are on the beach, it can be a concern. And you need to step back and decide, am I being unrealistic in what I’m looking for, whether it’s compensation, whether it’s title, whether it’s industry? And does that warrant a rethink, or maybe I need to take a step lateral or even back in order to get back into the game? All considerations I think at the right time somebody should think about.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:37]:
See if there is a way we could differentiate between I and it, which is the role that we played as a CIO and us as an individual. It seems that many times when a CIO loses his or her job, they think that it is their failure. And then even when they meet someone, they say, how are you doing? So tell me a little bit about yourself. And they say, I’m the CIO of x y z company, and I’m responsible for this, this, and this. But when they lose the job, they still say, I was the CIO of x y z company, and I used to do this, this, this, and this. Instead of focusing on what their true brand is and what are their capabilities, which can then be utilized somewhere else. So how can you separate the two, or should you separate the two?

Separating the individual from the role 47:47

Sanjog Aul [00:47:47]:
So the point that I raised was that people connect themselves as individuals to the role they play, to an extent that their introduction becomes the title that they assume today or they had in the past. And that’s about the only thing they are able to tell about themselves. So, Sal, if you were to look at this and critique this particular area, do you think that’s the right thing to do? Because are we not kind of becoming our role versus remaining an individual?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:48:21]:
Yes, I think we need to remain an individual rather than just become a role. Now individuals play roles, but they don’t define themselves in terms of the roles. So that’s what I think. They need to come up with some sense of who they are, where they’re going, where their life is leading, and how to get there.

Sanjog Aul [00:48:46]:
So, Chris, what kind of an introduction would you like to hear from an individual who you might know has been a performer, but then is meeting you in a networking situation or environment, and still is remaining as an individual versus just doubting what they did in a given company or as a CIO?

Chris Patrick [00:49:07]:
I think this is a great point, because I will often press the individuals I’m meeting with, sometimes they’ll talk about the company and what the company has done. And I think that’s important in some context. But what I want to know is what influence, what impact have they had. So tell me about what you did. What did you inherit and where is it today and how did you drive that positive change? And I think we’ve kind of drilled it into people’s heads that using I is a bad thing. It should always be we. And we all know that teams are usually involved in this, but it’s important, especially when I’m assessing a senior executive, I want to know what he or she did. And I want them to tell me, tell me what you specifically were able to accomplish. And I think that’s important in delineating the title from the individual. They’re not mutually exclusive, but there’s an individual in that role and that individual has an impact and has been able to create opportunities. And that’s what I want to know.

Sanjog Aul [00:50:20]:
Now it’s always been easier to get another position that’s equivalent to or better than our current position. But then we would not know what the next position is gonna be. So do we actually remove any prejudices that may exist with respect to the position that we had, or if we got rejected by another company, or for that matter, we are in a role where we are assessing other candidates? So, Sal, if you were to look at that part of it, where because a person had a bad history or perhaps he lost a job, does that mean the person had something wrong in them?

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:51:03]:
It could mean that, but it doesn’t necessarily mean it. You need to know a lot more about the situation. For example, the example I gave you before about that fellow, the vice president who lost his job as the head of human resources, that wasn’t his fault. The company was simply downsizing by getting rid of their human resources department because they needed to do better economically. So that presumably wasn’t his fault. Anybody in his position would have lost his job, but he needed to know that that was something that can happen to you even if you’re doing a good job. So he needed to be able to see what the next step in his life was developmentally, and that’s why he ended up starting his own company, because he assumed that other companies like the one that fired him would be getting rid of their human resources personnel as well, and then they’d have to reach out somewhere to get human resources help, and of course they’d reach out to a human resources company like his.

Sanjog Aul [00:52:15]:
So, Chris, in your view, if we had to actually prepare not only the people who may be in transition or they might have a role of an IT leader, I would say even going to the point where you try to have the people who are step up candidates, who are wannabes and they’re preparing themselves to become the next CIO, what is your suggestion in terms of how do they prepare, how do they harden themselves for this role going forward?

Chris Patrick [00:52:43]:
I think it’s a great, great question. And one of the things that I advise and would advise anybody is, look for good companies, companies that have reputations for developing strong leaders. And there’s some obvious ones out there. General Electric, Procter and Gamble, IBM. These are marquee companies that are known to invest in people, invest in development, have high standards. And frankly, when I see that background, that’s a real plus. And certainly you need to understand what they’ve accomplished there. But one thing that I’d encourage anybody listening to think about is, manage your career. It’s surprising how often I’ll meet individuals and it becomes very apparent that their career has kind of just happened to them. Take ownership, take control of it and chart a course. And back to my earlier point about the future state CIO, I think that’s a great roadmap to use as a yardstick for where you may be trying to get to and what are some of those skills and competencies you need to develop, and find yourself in good companies with good leaders and good mentors. And those will present tremendous opportunities to step up and move forward in your career.

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:54:16]:
It’s obviously a great goal. If you find it being difficult to do, then try going through hardiness training, because that can help you get the strength and capability to do that hard work. Hardiness training is available online at www.harditraining.coursehost.com.

Sanjog Aul [00:54:54]:
So one last question, very quick one for you, Sal. If people are to truly call themselves as bouncing back, and they had to define what bounced back means, as a successful bounce back, what would that be? A very quick definition, 15 seconds.

Defining a successful bounce back 55:11

Dr. Salvatore Armati [00:55:11]:
It means feeling better about your life, whether or not the bouncing back meant that you now have an even better, even stronger position than you had before. But it basically means feeling better about your life and being able to do the work that you need in order to carry on your life with the people in your family.

Contributors

Chris Patrick

Chris Patrick, Global CIO Practice Leader, Egon Zehnder

Chris is based in the Dallas office of Egon Zehnder International. He is a core member of our Global Technology Practice Group and led the North American Technology Practice. Chris also leads the Firm’s Global CIO Practice. He has le... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

Hexaware 4 - Automation to Autonomous MPU 250X300
Chris Patrick