This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.
About this conversation
A CIO Talk Network conversation with Kevin M. Campbell (Accenture), Simon Telfer Smith (Elekta Group), Mindy Blodgett (Yankee Group), James A. (Jim) Fortner (P&G), hosted by Sanjog Aul.
What the conversation established
The conversation established that homogeneous delivery is not here yet, and that the causes are structural rather than accidental. Kevin M. Campbell of Accenture said locations mature at different rates and that the industry must invest to raise skills to a common level, citing a review of Accenture’s top 100 engagements and the 1995 DuPont deal where Accenture and CSC worked side by side. Simon Telfer Smith of Elekta Group valued vendor process maturity over location and noted an 18-month span from first engagement to go-live. James A. (Jim) Fortner of P&G, in its fifth year of outsourcing, described a joint business plan, a connect-and-develop approach and the Gillette acquisition where exiting vendors stayed professional. Mindy Blodgett of Yankee Group tied the problem to a global labor shortage and to customer perception of security by region. Campbell added that quality, schedule and cost must stay in balance.
Host Sanjog Aul talks with Kevin M. Campbell, Group Chief Executive for Outsourcing at Accenture; Simon Telfer Smith, Vice President of Information Technology at Elekta Group; Mindy Blodgett, Analyst for Enterprise Research Business Process Outsourcing Strategies at Yankee Group; and James A. (Jim) Fortner, Director of Global Business Services, Infrastructure Services and Governance at P&G, about whether IT outsourcing delivery has become standardized across providers, locations and vendors. The panel compares why delivery stays uneven, from locations that mature at different speeds to a looming labor shortage. They describe managing vendors through SLAs, joint business planning and expectations management rather than cost alone. They also weigh multi-vendor sourcing, mergers and acquisitions, and data security as factors that keep delivery from being uniform.
Contributors
- Kevin M. Campbell, Group Chief Executive for Outsourcing, Accenture
- Simon Telfer Smith, Vice President of Information Technology, Elekta Group
- Mindy Blodgett, Analyst for Enterprise Research Business Process Outsourcing Strategies, Yankee Group
- James A. (Jim) Fortner, Director of Global Business Services, Infrastructure Services and Governance, P&G
Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network
On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript
Key takeaways
- Kevin M. Campbell of Accenture argues that outsourcing delivery is uneven because delivery locations mature at different rates. He says some sites can provide global service soon while others need two or three years, and the industry has to invest in bringing skills up to a common level rather than expecting full capability on day one.
- Simon Telfer Smith of Elekta Group says a customer should buy vendor process maturity, not a specific location. He cares less about where service is delivered than whether the vendor’s processes are consistent, predictable and stable, which he says a relatively small industrial company could not achieve internally with vendors such as Accenture and Unisys.
- James A. (Jim) Fortner of P&G says outsourcing success is hard work built on relationships, not luck. Now in P&G’s fifth year of outsourcing, he uses a joint business plan and a connect-and-develop approach, holds vendors to strong SLAs and cost reductions, and says one vendor cannot provide all the resourcing a global program needs.
- Mindy Blodgett of Yankee Group says a looming global labor shortage means chasing cheaper talent around the world will not work in the long term. She argues customers are now better informed and more demanding, and that communication technology linking delivery centers can reduce the need for redundant talent in every location.
- Kevin M. Campbell of Accenture says managing expectations is the critical discipline, in steady state and during mergers. He warns against a procurement department gone wild that treats service like buying a pencil, and applies a manufacturing rule of quality, then schedule, then cost, noting you will always have problems in a deal and what matters is how you fix them.
- James A. (Jim) Fortner of P&G says strong executive, finance and procurement involvement is required, not IT alone. He describes running IT as a business tied to business strategy, cites the Gillette acquisition where exiting vendors stayed professional to the end, and says P&G now does more business with some of them.
Chapters
- 0:00 Introduction: whether IT outsourcing delivery is homogeneous yet
- 1:57 Maturity and uneven investment across delivery locations
- 2:53 Why customers rely on vendor process maturity
- 5:16 Impatience and the transformation glide path
- 8:59 Managing expectations against aggressive bids
- 10:53 Co-sourcing versus a hands-off relationship
- 13:41 The global labor shortage and following talent
- 16:54 Working with multiple providers who also compete
- 25:36 Standard services against varied business reality
- 34:13 Running IT as a business with finance and procurement
- 37:41 Keeping delivery stable through mergers and acquisitions
- 48:01 Security, privacy, and intellectual property
Explore more
- IT Outsourcing: Why and How?
- Bargain Hunting in IT Outsourcing: What are the Savings?
- New Delivery Models & The Economics of IT
- Should There be an IT Leadership Maturity Model?
- Is There a Staffing Crisis in Healthcare IT?
- IT Delivery Process Vs. Agility: A Balancing Act
Transcript
Introduction: whether IT outsourcing delivery is homogeneous yet 0:00
Sanjog Aul [00:00:20]:
Today’s topic is homogeneous IT outsourcing delivery. Are we there yet? Our guests for today’s show are Kevin M. Campbell, Simon Telfer Smith, Mindy Blodgett and James A. (Jim) Fortner. Kevin is the Group Chief Executive for Outsourcing at Accenture. Simon is the Vice President of Information Technology at Elekta Group. Mindy is an Analyst for Enterprise Research Business Process Outsourcing Strategies at Yankee Group and Jim is the Director of Global Business Services, Infrastructure Services and Governance at P&G.
Sanjog Aul [00:01:21]:
This topic of homogeneous IT outsourcing delivery has been quite a pain point and the reason we brought this up is because we are not there yet to some extent. All these people say that we are not able to see that homogeneity that is expected and many times we say because we spread out in so many different countries, so many different cultures. That is why that is happening. Now when we go to the due diligence side of it, we try to very carefully choose the destinations and we very carefully try to choose the vendors, but still this is not happening. So what do you think is missing here?
Maturity and uneven investment across delivery locations 1:57
Kevin M. Campbell [00:01:57]:
Some of it might be a natural just maturation of how the process works and the different areas. From my experiences in a lot of different places, there are some locations that you’re going to pick that are going to be ready immediately or soon to provide the global service. There are other ones that aren’t going to be ready for two or three years. And part of our problem is we all are impatient, right. So we pick a two or three year one, because it’s got the best long term demographics, but then we expect it to have all the skills, all the experience and all the practice that we need. So, I think the biggest thing we got to do is invest more and understand as an industry we got to invest more in some of these locations and bringing the skills up to a common level.
Why customers rely on vendor process maturity 2:53
Simon Telfer Smith [00:02:53]:
I think from the customer perspective, I’m looking for the vendors to address this particular problem. It’s something that’s too big for me and a relatively small industrial company to attack. So where we rely on the vendors and one of the drivers for us to get involved in vendor agreements, from my point of view, do I care hugely about where the service is being delivered from? Well, I do to a degree, but I’m much more interested in the processes that are involved within the vendor, how mature they are and how stable they are. So that what we get out from vendors such as Accenture, Unisys, I’ve been working with recently, it’s something that’s consistent and predictable and something that I couldn’t really achieve internally.
Mindy Blodgett [00:03:46]:
I would say that it’s a very hard balance to strike between the labor arbitrage, the cost efficiencies, the quality of the work, the skills needed for the workforce in these various locations and it’s definitely a challenge for the service providers. But I’d like to echo a little bit of what Simon was saying. I think that the customers are becoming much more demanding and much better informed about their needs and what they’re going to need from the service providers. And it’s up to the service providers to start to step up to the plate I think at this point and start delivering on some of the promises they make when they sign these contracts.
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:04:31]:
Yes, Mindy, that’s absolutely right on. At Procter & Gamble, we’re in our fifth year now of outsourcing. And we have, to a large part, what Simon said: we’re relying on our vendor to really drive low cost computing and support whatever is strategic to them. Now we work with them to make the transformation smooth, but really that’s their responsibility and they must deliver that. Our focus is really on the output measures. So we want strong SLAs, we want a reduction in our cost and we also want strong people to be working with on the innovation ideas and those kind of things.
Impatience and the transformation glide path 5:16
Sanjog Aul [00:05:16]:
There was a word used by Kevin, impatience. Why do you think the customer side is impatient to make this happen? This was never supposed to be happening overnight in terms of maturity, the quality of delivery?
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:05:30]:
I’ll speak maybe from a customer side. I don’t know if it’s impatience, but when we sign this deal, we have a glide path, a very finite glide path on where we’re going to be in terms of the transformation. And we’re ruthless on that glide path. We work very collaboratively with our partner and we ensure that we’re hitting on all cylinders. So we work together to deliver the promise. In some cases, we might have to make a compromise here and there because when the vendor signs the deals, I think it’s somewhat unrealistic to think they’re going to be able to deliver on everything, but certainly the big things we have to hold them accountable to. So I’m not sure if it’s impatience, but frankly the shareholders are expecting us to deliver what we committed to and that’s almost a given.
Mindy Blodgett [00:06:29]:
I think in some ways there’s more realism on both sides of the equation these days. In the early days of outsourcing there were some overpromising done on the part of service providers and too high expectations on the part of customers. And I think that interestingly service providers are now stepping away from deals that they know they can’t deliver on whereas in the old days they would say, sure we can do that and then fail. So in that way, I think things are better, but there are still problems with delivery and quality and this is what we were saying earlier about the need for service providers to step it up a bit?
Sanjog Aul [00:07:16]:
Kevin, do you have a point here?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:07:19]:
It goes back to one of my own longstanding arguments that I’ve made with people and we sampled our top 100 outsourcing engagements and did some significant medical testing and absolutely determined that we correlated signing an outsourcing contract with amnesia. And it’s never so good as the day you outsourced it to somebody else. And then that said, I’m all for what the other panelists are saying about putting the onus on the providers to step up and I think they need to do it. I think that that’s a challenge that we have as an industry. I think we do get impatient in the fact that it took us years to develop the models that we had in the geographies we had and it had all of its good spots and bad spots. And then as we’ve tried to go around the world and really try to deliver globally, which is the future, we’re just following the same trend as the manufacturing and engineering companies and now we’re globalizing services. And it just takes a while for the education systems and the rest of that to catch up.
Sanjog Aul [00:08:42]:
So, do you think we might be biting off more than we can chew, because as a large outsourcing provider, if you are supposed to land a $4,000,000,000 contract, there would be a lot of internal push from the company itself as a vendor, execs, let’s back this deal, but you may not be ready for that yet. How do you balance that?
Managing expectations against aggressive bids 8:59
Kevin M. Campbell [00:08:59]:
One of the things that we find is absolutely critical is managing expectations, because I think it was Mindy who said people as you go through the process and people run highly competitive processes oftentimes people are trying to compete with talking about what they can do and where they are and there is a fine line between being aggressive and then being unrealistic. And I think that we need to continue to balance that line with experience and make sure that we are challenging ourselves hard. That’s how innovation happens. That’s how we move frontiers forward. We need to push ourselves and the partners on either side of the equation hard to try to get there. On the other hand, we have to be realistic that if it’s in new parts of the world that haven’t been there that we need to solve those problems like we have before and it needs to be fact based and we need to have the SLAs and the metrics and the facts and drive down to the root causes. And I’ve always said to people, you’re always going to have problems in an outsourcing deal and the real key is how you react when there are those problems and how you fix it and can you get it smooth over time?
Sanjog Aul [00:10:17]:
Now, we did see a term coming up, which is a phrase used by Jim saying that it is their responsibility to deliver. We are just going to manage them by metrics and reporting because that’s what the shareholder asked them to do. Sometime back we coined a term known as co sourcing, which is synonymous with outsourcing and that by definition said that both parties have to extend hands towards each other to make this work versus a hands off approach. So Simon, can you share what have you tried to do whether have you had a hands off approach work for you better?
Co-sourcing versus a hands-off relationship 10:53
Simon Telfer Smith [00:10:53]:
I think that not many customers would just waive a contract under the nose of a key vendor and ask them to dance and perform according to it. So, my experience is that it’s always been a very close working relationship at a joint team level and the only realistic way to implement things that tend to be this complicated is by working in good faith from the outset and then, kind of back to what I think Jim said, inevitably you’re going to get problems along the way. But you certainly don’t want to start off such a critical piece of work by setting opposing camps and trying to play the commercial issues before you can solve the technical or organizational change problems. Because I think that you mentioned the word impatience, the issue for me is that the time that it takes to actually execute a deal within IT is enormously long. And from engagement through the bid process into planning to go live, Kevin will probably give better statistics, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s a sort of 18-month period between first engagement and go live for major service. And of course, within a business that does a lot to unsettle an IT organization and the people within it. So, yes, there is a real attraction of a more kind of margin approach to it, because I’d say one of the spin-offs, one of the main benefits from that is that you could actually compact the time that it takes. And I’d certainly be interested in any way that the industry could change its kind of process through that lengthy period because it does damage to the organization.
Sanjog Aul [00:12:54]:
Now, talking about the talent that we see as concentrated and given destinations and when we try to get moving on other destinations because they are cheaper, then we do not find that talent. So we are forced to come back. So either we pay more for the quality or we say, okay, we are going to follow the cents or pennies and we’ll live with somewhat inferior quality for the time being and we’ll wait till the talent is available in that new destination country. But is it worth going in that direction? Mindy, why don’t you take this?
The global labor shortage and following talent 13:41
Mindy Blodgett [00:13:41]:
I think everyone is very aware that there’s a looming global labor shortage. It’s happening now. It’s only going to grow ever more acute as a challenge in future years because of various demographic changes and etcetera. So recruiting talent is not going to get any easier. So hopping around the world and following the talent really isn’t going to work in the long term. And I don’t think most of the service providers are really seeing it that way. And at Yankee Group, we talk a lot about technology and how technology can help, communications technologies can help with challenges like this. If you can get in place innovative technologies that allow communication amongst various centers, you don’t really need to worry quite so much about having redundant talent in some of these locations. I expect that there will be more and more developments on that front I think as one solution. So we’re talking about service delivery being globalized in a way.
Sanjog Aul [00:14:54]:
Globalized in a way. Kevin, that’s what you were saying?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:14:58]:
And I think, again, I was trying early on to get the notion of what we have to do is incubate some of these locations that we’re going to move to down the road. I mean, I think the ability to offshore is a core competence that all suppliers and the ability to work with them is key for all of the companies that are going to work with them. And so that ability to use the offshore labor arbitrage I think is a critical skill. I think you have to though in layers then say, hey, there are some countries that are there now and are ready or pretty close to ready and there are some that are going to be two years. And I think the problem is when we go try to put 1,000 people’s worth of work in a place that’s two or three years or four years out and we need to start smaller and grow it. And in a lot of times and this is going to happen back to all over in business, more and more the people aren’t going to be ready when they come out of college or high school or wherever to do the jobs that we need them to do. So we have to take on more of that responsibility of training those people. And as Mindy points out, that’s going to be a bigger and bigger challenge with the labor shortages coming up. And we’re just going to have to take more ownership as individual companies and as an industry to try to get people ready.
Sanjog Aul [00:16:22]:
Now talking about the fact that we have got competitors, you would as a customer pick up maybe multi-vendor outsourcing kind of approach, so that you’re kind of hedging your bets and you have a multi-competitor way of doing outsourcing. How friendly are these competitors working among themselves, because there might be some touch points where they have to interact with each other? Jim, do you want to take this?
Working with multiple providers who also compete 16:54
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:16:54]:
This is the state of the business. This is what’s out there. Everybody is doing multi-outsourcing. I don’t really know anybody that’s got a single source partner for the ITO and ADM space. So, companies are always going to have touch points and the service providers are pretty good about this. I think they’re pretty mature, they realize that this is the way it is, sometimes they win, sometimes they lose. And it’s really, I find it interesting because the people that they compete against one day, they partner with another day to try to get another piece of the business. So, I think the industry itself is more collaborative than we might think. We do multiple RFPs. So especially in the ADM space we will RFP work to our main service provider, but also to other companies to ensure that we’re getting the best deal. And we are careful on the operation side to have multiple vendors playing in the operations. I think that’s when it gets a little bit dangerous, but
Mindy Blodgett [00:18:00]:
Because you want to have some consistency and delivery of tools and that kind of thing.
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:18:01]:
But that’s to some degree we have a retained organization that really provides the governance and the governance responsibility and those are resources within the company itself within our company. So I do see this pretty positive and I think it’s a good it provides some value back to the customer.
Sanjog Aul [00:18:25]:
Do you think this could very well be the reason though because of which the homogeneity is missing or this could be an attribute which is contributing towards that shortcoming that’s the only shortcoming in this environment in global outsourcing?
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:18:42]:
I think we would have a multiple sourced environment anyway. I don’t think it’s naive to think one company can kind of deliver this stuff globally, the full spectrum of IT. So, it’s in all of our best interest to have different vendors for different competency areas that we really leverage. And from a service operation standpoint, we’ve personally been very pleased with our outsourcer from a global delivery. So I guess I don’t sign up under the premise that we need to have multiple, call it an ITO or an operations vendor globally because one provider can’t do it. We look to that provider to partner with other companies to deliver those services and we manage that vendor with SLAs and with strict agreements. So it’s up to them to where they are weak at, it’s up to them to get the right partner and to help.
Sanjog Aul [00:19:43]:
So mainly based on the research that might have been carried out under your group, if you were to do an inventory of the reasons why there would be a lack of homogeneity and what are the factors that are contributing to it, what would those be?
Mindy Blodgett [00:19:58]:
I think there is an inherent friction here between all of the competing needs and the service provider needs to follow the market, try to look ahead, try to figure out the future, and try to plan for which work is going to grow, which services the service needs are going to be, which industries are going to be interested, which regions are going to be interested. It’s very multifaceted and complicated and that’s something Kevin can certainly speak to, trying to weigh all of that. And on top of it, you have this issue we’ve been discussing of the war for talent, which is just across the board and across every industry and it’s a pretty tough industry to juggle.
Sanjog Aul [00:20:51]:
So for the companies which are not as successful and lucky I would say as Jim’s organization is where he is very pleased with the whole arrangement with the multiple vendors helping them meet their needs. What is going wrong and why? Kevin, can you contribute towards that?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:21:15]:
I guess probably not without some of the other specifics, but I think one of the things we both owe each other is to always have honest expectations about what’s going on and to work on what some of the issues are and what some of the challenges are and work those together. And all companies go through cycles of expansion, stretching their capability and then learning how to deliver in new areas and new promises from where they are. On the collaboration point, I think that back in 1995 when DuPont selected both Accenture and CSC to do some very major work for them and was side by side, I think everybody learned that you really have to be able to collaborate and compete with people and you have to be smart enough. So there is another major provider who won a big contract that a lot of people thought they would fail on and was very difficult and afterwards they shortly called us and asked us for some expertise to help them along the way. And I think being self critical and knowing where you need help and being willing to team with somebody, even your competitor, for the overall benefit of the client, I think it’s something you got to keep in mind.
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:22:47]:
This is Jim again. I think that’s very well said and is exactly my experience and our experience, which is these are hard work and that’s the other thing which is you can’t afford to have 100 of these relationships, right. I think nobody wants to have one, but you have to have enough that you can work them together and spend time and invest time in it. And I think that’s absolutely critical and it requires up and down both organizations a commitment. And provided exceptional expertise in a very specific area. And we worked with our service provider to bring you in and to augment their current skills. So, I just don’t think one vendor can provide all the resourcing that you need and you really need to adopt a connect-and-develop kind of a strategy where you’re out surveying the marketplace looking for who’s really good at this. But I guess coming back from a point, I don’t think it’s luck; it’s really hard work working with a service provider. We leverage a tool that we call the joint business plan. It’s really sitting down and getting very strategic on what are the things that we have to deliver together. It’s not hands off. We just don’t kind of push it off to the service provider, but it’s a very strategic commitment at the top of both companies to make this work because failure is not an option.
Mindy Blodgett [00:24:22]:
I actually kind of disagree a little bit with the premise here that customers as a rule don’t care how many vendors are involved. I mean I think that’s true to a certain extent, but some customers have had enough bad experiences with situations with multiple partners and multiple vendors either because of various agreements they’ve signed or because a partner they’re working with has multiple vendors that it’s an important thing for enterprises to examine before they enter into an agreement with a service provider. It’s one of those things they need to probe, how exactly is the service provider going to do this work, who are they going to be working with and that sort of thing. It really should be all part of the due diligence upfront.
Sanjog Aul [00:25:09]:
So, Simon, when you are out there and trying to get this your global outsourcing initiatives taken care of, are there any areas that you saw were weaknesses from a vendor standpoint or from your own management standpoint, which would have caused the issues or the loss
Standard services against varied business reality 25:36
Simon Telfer Smith [00:25:36]:
And I can see a conflict of interest almost where obviously a vendor is interested in delivering as standard of service as possible into a standard as possible environment. But the business reality is very different. We’ve got a variety of different job roles with different people, with different IT competence using different systems in different places. And I just think that it’s unrealistic to think that you can lap a standard service onto that kind of environment. And I think that one of the things that takes an extraordinary amount of time is going through this sort of joint responsibility planning where you do work out the boundaries of responsibility. And it’s all mixed up into the same discussion around multiple vendors. You’ve got to make a call on how many vendor agreements you want to work with and strategically, how do you put the stake in the ground to separate them? In my own case recently, we entered into a global service contract for desktop services. So we drew the line that the wide area network that we consider we needed to control strategically within the company, so that we can make sure that we can maximize the value of both agreements and not be reliant on one vendor to manage that for us. I just think when you get into the detail and when you have to anchor from an IT perspective, when you have to rank what you’re doing with the business, who have all got a lot of IT experts in their own organizations, particular company such as Elekta. And inevitably, it’s going to be a difficult and time consuming process. But I think the key would be to try and almost split it into easier to digest components where you could build on different kind of service elements or service towers. So, you can kind of put your own meal together from a variety of different components that are relatively standard.
Sanjog Aul [00:27:57]:
Now, if you were to look at the typical pitfalls that you may have in with respect to the governance that goes in there, the operational and the relationship management related issues in an outsourcing relationship, what would those be, which would be preventing us from getting there? Mindy, you want to see that from an outside perspective?
Sanjog Aul [00:28:21]:
Because what are the typical mistakes people make because of which in terms of governance or operational or the relationship management, which kind of demotivates the customer and or the vendor?
Mindy Blodgett [00:28:32]:
It’s back to what we’ve been touching upon throughout the show which is making sure you understand the responsibility of the enterprise, the responsibility of the service provider, understanding who does what, when and where. Change management is a huge challenge for enterprises entering into outsourcing relationships. They often don’t know what to do and how to get it right and they often need help from service providers with it and it’s benchmarking before you actually enter into an agreement is an important thing to do, so you really actually understand what you’re seeking here, what your goals are, how your process actually worked before as opposed to how it’s going to work after the outsourcing is going on, really looking at your retained organization and making sure that the retained organization is well integrated into the process with the service provider as well as with your organization.
Sanjog Aul [00:29:43]:
Kevin, would you have a list of pet peeves, would you say, which prevent you from being able to do the best job that you can as a company as a service provider?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:29:52]:
I would have a list of those things and I think I’d prefer to list characteristics for successful service delivery. And I think it starts with them making sure your expectations are matched. So as we talked before, if you have standards the worst thing is if you want to buy a standard price and you want to customize service. That’s where the misconception or the disconnect happens often. And so I think laying out what those expectations are and being honest with what customers truly want and then working the service provider to get it, I think makes an absolute difference and the personalities of different companies are wildly different, right. Some have a hard time letting go, some let go very easy and want to do it. But I always tell our teams that I want to make sure that we have a clean list of what we need to do and a clean list of what we expect the other company to do because very seldom do you just throw stuff across the wall and somebody else runs it forever. That may be different for infrastructure which can kind of run on, but whether it’s applications or business processes or so on, there’s a lot of tight connections back there and those connection points are the ones that we got to make sure are tight.
Sanjog Aul [00:31:38]:
Current or the new one, new prospects, they would always be looking for the most value that they can derive out of each dollar that they spend. So would there be a natural temptation that you see that they have and you have to kind of go and educate them to not go in that direction? Or do you think the customer base is becoming a little more aware that they cannot just go totally squeezing the juice out of every penny that they’re going to spend and try to drive the service provider against the wall?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:32:07]:
I think it really depends and people are all over the map. I think there are more people today than ever that understand that have had experiences or are smart enough to understand that you can’t squeeze the last juice out. I did a review for the CEO of a major company of one of my competitors’ agreements and he said, hey, I don’t think we’re getting what we want, I’m missing these three things. And I went and spent at his request a couple of weeks looking at it, came back to him and said, sad to tell you, you got exactly what you paid for, right. And so there’s a disconnect between what he wanted and what his team wanted. There still are cases, though, what we call the procurement department gone wild, where people are deciding that it’s just like buying a pencil. So I might as well just keep bidding it to get to the lowest cost possible. And all of our companies, right, we’re all in competitive environments, so all of us can fall into the same trap with people we use as suppliers. But I always tell people in manufacturing we learned that it’s quality, schedule, cost. I got to get the quality right before I can get on schedule and if I can’t get on schedule I can’t deliver it at the right cost point. So you got to keep those in balance and competition is good for everybody and keeps people sharp, but you’ve got to remember that there is a balance there.
Sanjog Aul [00:33:40]:
Now, we’ve heard about a title which is CFO for IT. How connected is this person with the actual IT priorities which are to be met? And that’s a person who would work with the procurement department or would be signing on the dotted line for the check and the contract, so that the actual needs are met. How is that whole, you can say, role defined and how well are they going back and communicating with the IT group that they are trying to support? Jim, would you have a thought on that?
Running IT as a business with finance and procurement 34:13
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:34:13]:
We would classify this as running IT as a business. And when you run IT as a business, you get real clear on your projects, your deliverables, the priorities, your strategies and how your strategy is really tied to the business strategies. So there are no surprises. So for instance, if the business strategy is to grow in developing markets and they need capability there from an IT standpoint, what are we doing to drive that capability? And if we have a cut in some of the work and new work coming in, it’s a simple exercise, because the data speaks for itself and we lay it out on the table. I think having a strong partnership with finance is absolutely critical. So, if the IT organization doesn’t have that, what you’ll generally find is they’ll talk more in techie terms about the value of the work, but they really can’t put it in terms that the business can understand.
Sanjog Aul [00:35:22]:
So, you would always like to have the finance guy front ending vendor versus a tag team or would you do that?
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:35:30]:
No, absolutely not. And I think one of the panelists said it before, you don’t want either purchasing or finance or even IT working the vendor alone. This is really you need multiple functional leadership here. So, finance will help keep us all honest in terms of what’s the real value and let’s see whether it’s real dollar savings direct to the budget or it’s kind of indirect savings showing up in the business unit’s budget, but they’ll produce more of the value equation. IT will help provide some of the governing in terms of what this does from an architecture standpoint, complexity and all those kind of things and then purchasing will drive the best deal. And those are the three functions that really need to be locked arm in arm with negotiating and dealing with vendors.
Mindy Blodgett [00:36:20]:
I think service providers would tell you that they are concerned about entering into contracts with companies who don’t have strong executive business-side buy-in on any of these contracts. Because it’s just a recipe for disaster.
Sanjog Aul [00:36:39]:
So talking about the stable state for an outsourcing engagement where one or more service providers are engaged and everything is going well, if that stability is disrupted and then comes any kind of merger or acquisition kind of disruption and it takes away that stable state, puts you in an ionized state and then you go about reprioritizing everything. And by the time you are stabilizing the field, you see that typical challenges or I would say instead of challenges, what are the strategies that could be used so that we do not have disruption because frankly, customers do not care. A company which is serving its own customers and it’s trying to outsource some of the services that it’s trying to use, their customers don’t care how and where you’re getting your things done. So how do you keep that stable, while internally it cannot be stable just because of the way business changes? Simon, you want to take this?
Keeping delivery stable through mergers and acquisitions 37:41
Simon Telfer Smith [00:37:41]:
I just think that it’s a business reality that it must be a very fortunate business that could stay stable. So, the fact that M&A activity is on the radar for the majority of businesses or change to some degree is on the radar. You’re aware of that when you go into a contract and an agreement and it’s a key part of the thinking that must take place when you’re starting to scope out the services and the flexibility that might be needed. And from my perspective, it’s actually one of the attractive benefits of working with a service provider that’s got good global reach, because it is more scalable than could be hoped to achieve internally. And I think the other thing that it could do that it does, and again one of the key attractions for me, is that it provides a structure, a framework, a process and standards and governance kind of automatically. So, you can imagine acquisition discussions are probably a lot easier from an IT perspective if you’ve got good visibility of service that would be available once that business has been bought into the company. And in our own industry, we’ve tended to be involved in acquisitions of smaller businesses rather than mergers. And it’s the way that you can quickly mature a smaller business who hasn’t got the IT systems or standards in place. So, yes, I vote for it as a benefit. I don’t see it as so much of an impediment as long as you’ve got the contractual flexibility and the terms allow you to scale up, scale down on demand and that’s certainly something that I’ve been focused on in negotiation discussions.
Sanjog Aul [00:39:41]:
Kevin, in your case, being a service provider, when you are in a situation where some one of your key customer gets through an acquisition or gets acquired or has a 50-50 merger, so that there’s no specific say in terms of who would be the end provider after that merged entity. How do you handle it and how do you go about keeping the service quality levels along the same levels basically when you are going through that transition?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:40:16]:
Reputation is everything in the business and we want to make sure that we deliver service to the last day even if we’re not chosen as the ongoing service provider. That said, during the whole process of a merger there’s a lot of activities going on and it’s high risk, high reward, right. You can either end up with the whole thing or only parts of it or nothing. But the first thing you got to do is remember to deliver every day. And I remind our teams all the time, right, that what we do today, this minute, this hour is what makes a difference in the longer term. So, no sense worrying about the future and what could happen, just stay focused on the service delivery. And I think if there is a decision that one provider or another are not going to be around, I think then you have to think about what does that mean for those people’s careers and do you want to do something with retention.
Sanjog Aul [00:41:25]:
How do you handle that disruption from a business standpoint, while not reducing the quality levels? What is the type of framework or strategies that you help implement in collaboration with the customer? And do you get the required support from the customer? Because even the decision makers might be changing in the merged entity?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:41:45]:
And then I come back to, I’ll sound like a broken record, but the expectations management which is as critical during the time of a merger as anything else, which is you’ve got to make sure you get with the key executive people and say, hey, this is what our expectations were and what we are delivering to, is that going to change or not. So that you got that baseline about how it’s going to work and use that as a framework to drive the agreement. During those times we try to be extra responsive, extra flexible to try to get focused. But we want to make sure we understand the business objectives of the merger, so that we can make sure that all our activities are focused on the combination of cost reductions and other synergies that they might have to try to drive that forward. And we have been through numerous of these and have a whole set of best practices whether it’s from how to deal with systems decisions to how to handle people issues to how to handle all the licensing and other types of agreements you have.
Sanjog Aul [00:42:57]:
Jim, when you are faced with such an issue, how do you handle the portfolio of vendors that you have, the relationship, the governance side of things?
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:43:04]:
This is a very good question, because a lot of the, I think outsourcing is all about relationships. That’s the foundation and you have to be very respectful and open and honest with the various service providers and let them know what’s going on. When we, for instance, when we acquired Gillette, Gillette had several vendors that we were not going to use as part of the going forward state, but we worked with them, we told them here are the expectations and the vendors just did an absolutely outstanding job. I was amazed at their level of professionalism all the way up through the end when we turned the switch over to our service provider. And the nice thing about that is from a customer standpoint, if they behave professionally all the way up to the end, we’re now doing business with some of those people and actually we’re doing more business with them now than we were doing before. So this is a very small industry in some regards. We negotiate deals 5 to 10 years out. Service providers are very astute in terms of they realize what they may lose something today, but it may come around 3 or 5 years from now.
Sanjog Aul [00:44:23]:
Now in the research that has been conducted by a few associations, there was a trend that was seen that every year newer players, relatively smaller players are gaining the market share over the big guns in the outsourcing space. What is triggering that? Is that like people want to try smaller companies where they may have more leverage and or the service quality maybe not as good? And since the concept of using multi-vendor outsourcing is not new and people are comfortable, then they want to give a try to the new ones to see what’s out there, which is better and more competitive in terms of rates? Mindy, do you want to see that?
Mindy Blodgett [00:45:07]:
It’s interesting. There definitely have been some studies and numbers showing that there’s been an increase in a trend to a larger number of smaller contracts being signed and those tend to be with smaller niche players. But there are some competing numbers that show that the bigger players are still going strong. So there is a little bit of disconnect I think in some of the market numbers that have been thrown out there. But I think there are a couple of things going on here. I think as I said when an enterprise is starting to dip their toe in the water and looking at some kind of outsourcing, they are often reluctant to go with a large big-bang multi-process outsourcing contract. So they will try a smaller single function approach and sort of see how it goes and maybe build from there. I think this is the approach that a lot of the Indian providers have taken. They’ve had a lot of good luck at landing some of these smaller deals and then using them to leverage for bigger deals down the road.
Sanjog Aul [00:46:20]:
Simon, what has been your experience with respect, would you in coming years want to try new vendors just to see what they’re all about?
Simon Telfer Smith [00:46:31]:
My current perspective is that I’m interested in creating a more global IT environment for the business that I’m working with. So, I’m trying to move away from smaller local-based vendor agreements to deploy the standards that we think we need to drive the business forward and drive the growth. Having said that, I think that you’ve got to find a good fit between potential supplier, both parties have got to be seen as interested and that it represents a good opportunity. And for that reason, I could see that a couple of the larger players in the market would have struggled to engage fully with Elekta at the moment, because it doesn’t represent anything that can make the margin and provide an opportunity for them. So, we had to find partners that we’re both comfortable that there’s some mutual benefit there. To me, that’s the important thing. And from a management point of view, of course, you’ve got to get that balance right of how many vendors do you deal with and where do you deal with them, because the transition to a managed service is only kind of opening the door on a whole new world there where you’ve actually got to manage what happens from that point on. So certainly, you’ve got to take those practical considerations into account.
Security, privacy, and intellectual property 48:01
Sanjog Aul [00:48:01]:
And we already see that security and privacy and intellectual property issues have been paramount for specific industry types like financial services, healthcare, or insurance who may at all be doing such outsourcing or maybe involved in such outsourcing initiatives. Now when you go into the global IT outsourcing space where a multi-country, multi-vendor environment is created, this would, I would say, have a cumulative effect on the issues that we may see or we may be fearing about. So, from a vendor’s perspective, Kevin, what are you doing to make these people feel safer?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:48:46]:
Can you give me a little more kind of what you mean?
Sanjog Aul [00:48:48]:
Kind of like security in the sense they should see intellectual property issues or privacy issues and things of that nature where nobody would just pick up a piece of code or some sensitive data and post it on a blog or a website or through whatever other channels and people get illegal access to data.
Sanjog Aul [00:49:13]:
How would you as a company, as a service provider, when you are trying to approach a customer, which may be sensitive to such leakages and you’re saying we are pitching the multi-region outsourcing, how do you and your competitors who have to work arm in arm with you deliver on something and still keep these people comfortable that yes, things will not go out of hand?
Kevin M. Campbell [00:49:43]:
With the much publicized incidents all over the place, today it’s kind of, you hit on the topic de jure, right, as something that has always been a concern, but now is a heightened concern to people. And we have a very extensive program in place that top to bottom addresses how we address data security, what standards we have, what rules we have for physical security and so on. And it’s a pretty complex area, because some of what we’ve allowed and the benefits we’ve enjoyed from technology such as flash drives or cell phones and stuff like that are all things we have to take away in order to get back to the security that we need or handle in a very different way. So we have a comprehensive program that we talk to people about and talk about how we’re working and how we’re developing it. Like all the other people in this space, my competitors and teaming partners in this space are taking this seriously given all the highlights. And I think probably the most disturbing thing I heard recently was an interview with a guy who said I can go work all week and make $1,000 or I can go on the Internet in an hour and make $10,000. So as long as those motivations are there, this will continue to be a hot topic. So we’re all looking at that and trying to drive it. I think the thing to not forget is the hardest stuff to detect and prevent is the stuff that’s done in collusion with multiple people and multiple companies. And as these rings, so to speak, get more and more sophisticated, we’re really going to have to work as teams with joined up security procedures and ongoing monitoring to make sure that it doesn’t happen.
Sanjog Aul [00:51:51]:
Jim, do you have such issues where people may not be coming up to your expectations in terms of vendors providing such services and not being able to handle your security concerns and things of that nature?
James A. (Jim) Fortner [00:52:02]:
No. Frankly, we see the vendors are a key enabler for us, because they’re able to stay on top of the technology and the best practices in this space. IT companies like ours and others. It’s a significant investment to purchase the capability to really drive regular audits every year. We have a whole cycle of audits that we do on the processes and practices of our vendors to ensure that they’re following our policy.
Mindy Blodgett [00:52:46]:
I think there are two things going on here with this very important topic. There’s the reality of the security challenges and then there’s the perception and it’s definitely a huge issue for a lot of customers and enterprises. In our surveys, it always pops up as one of their main concerns. When they consider outsourcing, when they consider outsourcing to a particular region, there are different regions of the world that have better reputations than others for protection. And so it’s something that their customers need to have their concerns assuaged about and they need to be educated as part of the whole process of entering into an outsourcing agreement.
Sanjog Aul [00:53:34]:
Simon, any last thoughts?
Simon Telfer Smith [00:53:36]:
I completely agree with Jim’s perspective of the customer; it’s one of the drivers for considering an outsourcing agreement with a professional vendor. And when you look at the risk, the inherent risk probably feels safer with that kind of arrangement in place than the alternatives where we know how people behave when they leave companies through various surveys. We know what happens to electronic data or intellectual property within businesses. So I see it as a step forward.
Sanjog Aul [00:54:40]:
Now as discussed, customer does not and should not care about where the services are being delivered from and it needs to be a seamless experience. Selecting one or more global outsourcing vendors with complementary offerings and a strong presence in those outsourcing destinations may be a very good idea. Vendor selection and relationship management should not be based on cost savings alone. And running after the next cheapest outsourcing destination may be myopic since that could lead to bigger problems and losses due to opportunity and, say, goodwill losses as quality may suffer. We are not there yet when it comes to homogeneous IT outsourcing delivery. However, there’s awareness, and the customers as well as vendors are on the job to make this a reality. How soon will we get there? Time will tell.


