Digital Transformation • Healthcare • Leadership

Here’s $19 Billion, Now Make Healthcare IT Work!

Here’s $19 Billion, Now Make Healthcare IT Work!

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Tim Zoph (Northwestern Memorial Hospital), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that the $19 billion in stimulus money, in Tim Zoph’s view, is a down payment that buys infrastructure but not results. Zoph, who leads IT at Northwestern Memorial Hospital, said only about 2% of hospitals are fully automated, and that his own institution invested about five years ago and will be paid back through the incentive plan. He argued the industry is capital constrained, with electronic records costing $40,000 to $50,000 per physician and hospitals facing several million dollars, and that healthcare spends only 2% to 3% of operating expense on IT where 5% to 7% is warranted. He tied real progress to meaningful use, to data standards for information exchange due by year end, and to process change that cut avoidable harm to patients by over 80% since 2004. He warned the incentive turns into a Medicare and Medicaid penalty in 2015.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Tim Zoph, Senior Vice President of Administration and CIO of Northwestern Memorial Hospital, about using a $19 billion federal stimulus to make healthcare IT work. Zoph explains why the US system is fragmented and hard to measure, and why national data standards would act like a highway for health information. He describes the money as a down payment that funds infrastructure but not the harder organizational change. He compares the incentive, which becomes a penalty in 2015, to paying a contractor only after the work passes inspection.

Contributors

  • Tim Zoph, Senior Vice President of Administration and CIO, Northwestern Memorial Hospital

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Tim Zoph, CIO of Northwestern Memorial Hospital, says the $19 billion stimulus is only a down payment on healthcare IT. He argues the real institutional investment is the organizational change that begins after the infrastructure is in place.
  • Tim Zoph of Northwestern Memorial Hospital says US healthcare is fragmented and poorly measured, leaving patients as the custodians of their own records. He notes the industry lacks well reported standards on quality and service, so consumers cannot easily tell who delivers the best care.
  • Tim Zoph, CIO at Northwestern Memorial Hospital, says only about 2% of hospitals have fully automated, digital systems. He explains that Northwestern made those investments about five years ago and will be repaid through the incentive plan, while most hospitals must still fund the build out first.
  • Tim Zoph of Northwestern Memorial Hospital says healthcare is capital constrained, with electronic records costing $40,000 to $50,000 per physician and several million dollars for hospitals. He warns that well meaning physician practices may not get bank financing because they lack equity in the practice.
  • Tim Zoph, CIO of Northwestern Memorial Hospital, says meaningful use means proving the data drives measurable improvement, not just buying technology. He points to a reduction in avoidable harm to patients of over 80% since 2004 by pairing technology with process improvement.
  • Tim Zoph of Northwestern Memorial Hospital says the incentive becomes a penalty in 2015, when Medicare and Medicaid payments could be reduced for organizations that have not changed. He also says healthcare has under invested in IT, spending about 2% to 3% of operating expense where 5% to 7% is warranted.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: putting $19 billion into healthcare IT
  • 2:09 Why the healthcare system falls short
  • 4:32 Building a national highway for health data
  • 7:34 Meaningful use over buying technology
  • 11:14 The capital hurdle for hospitals and physicians
  • 13:12 Why healthcare stayed on paper
  • 18:16 IT as a partner in safer care
  • 21:43 No clear blueprint for the end state
  • 30:04 Pitfalls that stall healthcare IT projects
  • 43:19 Sustaining change after the down payment

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: putting $19 billion into healthcare IT 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:48]:
Today’s topic is, Here’s $19,000,000,000 Now Makes Healthcare IT Work. Our guest for today’s show is Tim Zoph. Tim is the Senior Vice President of Administration and he’s the CIO with Northwestern Memorial Hospital.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:25]:
But then so the topic that we have selected here, I’m sure it’s on your mind and then so is with both healthcare IT leadership. So with respect to the $19,000,000,000 of course, we will talk about it. However, we have seen healthcare not coming up to satisfaction of the consumer side. They’re always saying that we don’t have healthcare up to speed. And it is very expensive and also the delivery is inefficient etcetera, etcetera. So there are a lot of complaints about it and it’s not now, it’s happening forever. So what do you think are basically the major factors which may be causing this to remain the same and even worsen in some situations?

Why the healthcare system falls short 2:09

Tim Zoph [00:02:09]:
Well, the dichotomy with healthcare is that although in very specific areas, healthcare delivery is the finest in the world that is for any given procedure or any given test, the diagnostics and technology are really second to none. The issue with our healthcare system is it’s very fragmented. And as patients go from physician to physician, hospital to hospital or navigate their way through what may be a lifelong disease, it is a very fragmented experience for which that information and the knowledge of their care, they are the ones who become the custodian for that and the system oftentimes has no knowledge from place to place. I think the second part of that is it’s very difficult for a consumer to really understand where to get their services from and who performs those services in the highest quality way. This is an industry that has not been measured very well, doesn’t have well reported standards on quality and service and patients are often left questioning how it is that they can go about really understanding who can provide the best care for them in the appropriate way. And I’d say the final thing about the healthcare system is that one of the things we discovered is it’s really important that patients be empowered with information to be able to manage their own health and particularly for issues like lifelong disease whether that be diabetes, cholesterol management and therefore the health system needs to work for them. That is provide them information, knowledge that they can make the next right decision about their health when they are not with us. So in other words, we created a dependency on the healthcare system when in fact right now what we need is a lot more wellness and health management. There really ought to be directly in the hands of patients and families managing their care.

Sanjog Aul [00:04:06]:
Now let’s compare this to the highway system we have. That is also very, very it’s actually supposed to be rated very highly in terms of how we connect every state. And so there was some good foundation laid out for that highway system. That’s why we’re reaping the benefits today. So what was that foundational flaw, if you will, that resulted in this day and age the way the state of healthcare that we see today?

Building a national highway for health data 4:32

Tim Zoph [00:04:32]:
Well, the highway analogy or the rail system analogy and it’s a very good one for healthcare and it speaks a little bit to what the intent of the stimulus package is that the highway system was really to be able to provide a common infrastructure to be able to link suburbs with cities and serve as a standards based way of saying here is how you get place to place. What’s been lacking in healthcare is one is just overall automation. The healthcare industry still by any measure is not very automated, but it certainly doesn’t have its highway system. One of the intents with the stimulus plan and the Obama plan is to say we are going to set standards. That is the highway analogy is that healthcare now will have standards for content, for information sharing and part of the purpose of this $19,000,000,000 is to have communities start to be connected that is build their own highway systems so that healthcare information can be more efficiently exchanged. I think one thing we’ve learned from any industry that has said that we need national infrastructure is that standards are incredibly important and it has to be just like the way we put traffic signs up and the way people understand a freeway system, there’s got to be some common language and there’s got to be a method for which we can connect place to place. Healthcare has lacked that to date but the stimulus plan is meant to be the beginnings of laying down some infrastructure to create a national highway system for healthcare.

Sanjog Aul [00:06:06]:
Do you think it’s realistic for us to expect that we can keep the house intact and change the basement or the foundation?

Tim Zoph [00:06:13]:
Well, that’s a great question. My own sense is that you’re going to have to do both of those things simultaneously to really create the healthcare infrastructure. So in other words, building the foundation means remember that probably 2% of the hospitals in this country, one of them being Northwestern Memorial really has fully automated and digital systems. So we are still having people build the foundation of their houses by just getting automated. And simultaneously we will need to build the highway system. So I think in order for this to work, you’re going to have to do those two things simultaneously and even in the foundation system those that have made some early investments in technology first generation systems as those highway standards if you will are established there may be some of these early generation systems or self developed systems that will have to go through fundamental change in order to be able to hook on or fully integrate with the goals for our national healthcare infrastructure.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:12]:
Now would you have any other if you were to basically do an inventory of the foundational elements if you will of healthcare which are supposed to change in order for us to see the desired results. Besides this digital highway of sorts where the information moves fast across different constituents, what else is left to be fixed if you will?

Meaningful use over buying technology 7:34

Tim Zoph [00:07:34]:
Well and just to carry this on a little bit and we see this in our own health system and the work we are doing here at Northwestern in our academic system is that technology in and of itself is important, but the hardest work is changing and changing the way we work and changing the healthcare system. So the heavy lifting in all this in my opinion is not only getting the investment side of it right, but really working practice by practice, physician by physician, hospital by hospital to have them not only install the technology, but embrace it in such a way that they become more efficient, that they measure their outcomes and they turn all of this back into process improvement and redesigned health system. One of the very interesting discussions going on nationally now is how we are going to measure whether or not this $19,000,000,000 has been effectively spent and how we will apply the incentives to those that have gone ahead and spent the money. And a lot of the discussion is around a term called meaningful use and what they’re really saying is meaningful use isn’t enough just about buying the technology. You’ve got to be able to demonstrate that you can use this data, that you can use this data for improvement and actually have measurable outcomes. So for me the risk in this is less so in buying the technology, far more in executing changes in the healthcare system that allow that technology to enable higher quality safe and efficient care. And those are things that take time, actually far more time than just the initial installation of the technology itself.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:10]:
Now the checks and balances that they put in place, let me throw in another analogy. Like you suppose you do a commercial build out of an office space, you have to have the bank who is going to provide that money to the contractor will only be provided once you’ve done the contractor has done the job. This bank comes, sends their own inspectors, see if everything is good, then they will trickle in the money and give it to the contractor. This way, the people who are trying to bring about change or at least promise that they will have a good looking office build out will not be able to get away by promising thing, by giving a lip service to the whole project. And at the end of the day the consumer, which is the consumer of healthcare and or the customer who is getting office build out done will be able to get a product without giving away money first and then getting frustrated that why the change is not happening.

Tim Zoph [00:10:01]:
Yes, in a sense that’s the way the program is set up. This is an incentive structure. So you get paid back at the end. You don’t get paid in the beginning. And so what they’re determining now is back to this consumer, how we’re going to measure the outcome of this, how we are going to measure the meaningful use of this investment in information technology to make sure that the consumer, in this case the taxpayer, is getting the benefit of the $19,000,000,000 One of the big issues though is this is a capital constrained industry. So the way the plan works is that hospitals and physicians need to come up with the initial investment and then they get paid back later on. That’s a particularly tough challenge in a capital constrained industry. So although there are incentives there at the end, nobody is fronting the build out cost.

Tim Zoph [00:10:52]:
The developer is not there with the money at hand to say do the build out and I’ll invest this for you upfront and then we’ll determine how to pay you back at the end.

Sanjog Aul [00:11:01]:
Now you represent a hospital, isn’t that a big turnoff that you have to put the bill first and then you figure out whether their inspectors will deem this to be something which is up to their expectations and then they will dole out the money.

The capital hurdle for hospitals and physicians 11:14

Tim Zoph [00:11:14]:
Yes. And it’s and I do believe though fundamentally, bringing this back to for a very concrete for the industry, I believe that to a physician, to a hospital, people believe that information technology is a fundamental infrastructure for healthcare. In other words, without these investments, you can’t get through the transition and this transition is one to higher quality and safer care. So people know they need to make these investments in order to come out the other side of this healthcare transition. The issue is how do people especially for physician practices that don’t have the upfront investment sometimes $40,000 to $50,000 per physician or hospitals which could be several million dollars even though they may believe it’s the right investment. The bank may not give them the money if they are a physician practice because they may not have the equity in the practice and hospitals have to then trade off these investments with IT with other fundamental investments they feel they need to make in facilities or diagnostic technology and so on. So it’s going to be a tough hurdle to get through that initial investment stage. We have made those investments. We did that five years ago. We were fortunate enough to have the amount of capital it took to get through those initial investments and in fact will be paid back through the incentive plan. But a lot of hospitals that are at, if you will, at physicians at the starting point, it’s going to be difficult for them to come up with the initial capital investment to get the down payment in place if you will.

Sanjog Aul [00:12:49]:
How long ago did you think the wake up call did come to you where I said, okay, let’s invest in IT and let’s say Northwestern, your organization was proactive, but I think most of the organizations are not. And what is preventing all along while knowing that IT can really help, but still we are not embarking upon it, we are not opening up our checkbooks towards the investments there?

Why healthcare stayed on paper 13:12

Tim Zoph [00:13:12]:
One could point to a number of different markers in the industry that pointed the technology was clearly an investment that needs to be made. I could take you back to studies by that have come out at a national level, one of them crossing the quality chasm came out back in the early 2000s that really pointed out the safety risks in healthcare because we are not appropriately paying attention to quality and safety in the industry and it was very clear in that report that you can’t measure what you do, you are not going to be able to make fundamental improvements in healthcare and a paper based system is not going to get you there. And this was in early 2000s. Our own strategic plan in 2002 had a concept of best patient experience and we’ve targeted higher quality safer care. We recognized at that point that in order for us to achieve our strategic plan we had to make the investments in IT in order to realize the improvements that we wanted to see for our patients. And so the healthcare industry in some ways is not automated I think for a couple of reasons. One is just the capital that’s required to do it. Secondly, the solutions haven’t been great. This is an industry that doesn’t write its software, it buys it. Many of the solutions in the marketplace were very early generation required close working relationships with vendors. So there was a lot of risk. And the third is this is the technology side of it, this is about fundamental change and transformation. So I’d say one of the barriers in the industry is just sort of the capability of executing large scale change. It represents a lot of risk to undertake these investments and to change your organization. And you have to have the know how and the leadership to be able to march your way through what is for us was a multi year transition to get the technology and get the improvements in and really change the way we deliver care.

Sanjog Aul [00:15:14]:
Now would you say that this is also weakest link issue because while the organization may have embarked upon this IT and has a strategic investment and did it, but then you’re surrounded by entities who may not feel the same way. And frankly, the consumer experience is not only delivered by you, it is also connected to insurance, it’s connected to physicians, it’s connected to hospitals, etcetera, etcetera. So how do you bring all of them together? So your own investments in IT siloed, would you think?

Tim Zoph [00:15:47]:
Yes. In some ways, yes, some ways, no. I think for us we’ve recognized that as a health system that it was not just about the hospital, but also about our physicians. Right now we have in our hospital we have over 1,500 physicians affiliated with our institution. Half of those are in a large group practice which is already automated on electronic records. But we have over 600 physicians that are tied into us that are basically community practice, private practice physicians in groups of 10 or less. We have said that as a hospital that has both the know how and would have resources that we are stepping up to helping support these practices get through this electronic record transition and also at the same time tying these electronic records to a broader patient experience so that the information can be shared practice to practice and with the hospital for coordination of care and we can also aggregate that data for ongoing quality reporting and research. So as hospitals in this transition my mind have a special responsibility because we are such a large player in the health system and can really work with our physicians effectively. Back to how we work with insurance companies and where we started with the highway analogy, with the digitized health system our goal is to work closely with payers and certainly closely with our patients and families so that we can create a more coordinated experience for them That is give them the information they need, have them interact with us far more online than they interact with us today and really empower them to manage their health through time. So we are working on this if you will from concentric circles out, the hospital is by and large automated now. We are working on our physician practices and we will be demonstrating how we share health information effectively. So we can bring in our payers, bring in our employees and bring in the broader Chicago community into what we want to see as evidence of a coordinated healthcare delivery system in Chicago.

Sanjog Aul [00:17:53]:
Now before this $19,000,000,000 incentive or now, how did you how do you rate IT was looked upon by your business counterparts and or by your executive management? Were they looking at you an enabler, someone who is driving the change or someone who is a cog in the wheel who just get who is an order taker?

IT as a partner in safer care 18:16

Tim Zoph [00:18:16]:
I believe especially as we embarked on this journey of delivering a digital health system here at Northwestern is that IT was viewed as a true partner in enabling the change. And as I mentioned before, the technology is an important infrastructure, but equally important is the work that we did in embracing process improvement, embracing a culture of safety and really using the technology to change the way we deliver care. So an example of that, we really focused on patient safety. We measured how it is we were treating our patients and then have been able for example with both technology and process improvement to reduce avoidable harm events to our patients by over 80% since 2004. So it is the technology coupled with process improvement, coupled with a new vision of healthcare. But we were really a partner, not an order taker, not fundamentally the leader. We didn’t say it was about the technology, but we were certainly a partner to the organization to say the technology we are delivering is going to fundamentally deliver the change that is incumbent upon us in delivering a new healthcare system of the future.

Sanjog Aul [00:19:34]:
Now when you had your typical days where this incentive had not been provided or it was not in sight, how was that how a typical physician and or an IT person and or health care person including your crew were spending their day versus now. Has there been any fundamental change in the way the speed may have improved, the efficiency or your outlook towards the whole healthcare delivery has changed, would you say?

Tim Zoph [00:20:04]:
Yes, for us because we made the investment in advance of the incentives, but we are a small handful of hospitals in the country that actually said about 2% that have actually made these investments to date to really automate digitize their health systems. We made it because we saw it as a strategic investment enabling a vision of our healthcare future. But what has quickened the pace for us with the incentives is automating and assisting our physicians in the automation of their practices, because there are incentives that are out there that begin in the government year of fiscal 2011. We have got over probably 350 to 400 physicians that are clinically active that we believe will want electronic records in some 50 to 60 practices. We have quickened the pace because we believe the incentive dollars that are out there up to $40,000 per physician. We certainly want to get our physicians in position to take advantage of these national incentive programs and therefore even help us accelerate the pace of if you will automating our full healthcare enterprise. So in a sense we have now stepped up our pace and are looking at ways to instead of do things maybe in a two to three year period look at doing them in an eighteen month period.

Sanjog Aul [00:21:26]:
Now do you think with such I would say fundamental change that has to be brought about, should we have a blueprint and or a role model that we should follow so that we know what the end state will look like? Are we clear about what the end state should be?

No clear blueprint for the end state 21:43

Tim Zoph [00:21:43]:
Great question. We’re not clear today about what the end state should look like. One of the elements of the stimulus package is that the federal government really in partnership with private industry will deliver healthcare standards that will enable broader information sharing and those are due out by the end of this calendar year. So what’s missing in the blueprint is what is the blueprint for information exchange, what are the data standards that are that accompany that. So once that is in place, it will allow us and be clear to those that are going through stages of automation, what data we need to be prepared and structure for broader information sharing. The second element of that is that stimulus package is the federal government will also provide grants and also provide some funding for communities like Chicago both at the healthcare level and through some of its broadband funding to begin to have demonstration projects that will use these new standards for broader information exchange. One I can tell you about that we’re working with the City of Chicago on is they are looking at a we’re participating with them in a grant application for extending broadband into the Chicago community. What’s important about that is we want to connect and provide broadband connections to underserved areas of Chicago for which there is pockets in our urban area for which nobody has high speed Internet connection and the broadband connection grants will allow us to do that. If you think about that, if we couple that then with broader information sharing and we’ve got very active diabetes programs in a number of these areas and so on and so forth. So what will allow us to put the community online and have patients really have access to their health information and we can then use automation and these broadband connections to really connect and engage patients in their health in ways we did not have the opportunity to do before.

Sanjog Aul [00:23:58]:
One of the mindset which actually is more innovation oriented is that you do not produce and then try to sell something, you only produce what sells. So in order for us to know that, we have to have a firsthand input from the consumers, who are having us like an ideal state of health care and that should be derived that from that only we should derive the blueprint of what IT should do and what other business processes should do. So do we have a laundry list of wish list of consumers who essentially are at the receiving end of what you’re delivering?

Tim Zoph [00:24:37]:
Yes, that’s a great question. And you talk about what will change and how the system will be influenced with the digital healthcare enterprise and with going online now for what was the early stages of what will happen and we’re certainly doing this right now is being very transparent for with our quality and clinical outcomes of the products we deliver. Once you go online and it’s true with any service industry, you’re going to get a lot of feedback and consumer behavior will change and fundamentally that consumer behavior will drive how the system ultimately what it delivers and what is valued. If you follow any other industry, any other service based industry fundamentally the consumers are ultimately in charge of the products and what gets delivered. Again what’s different about healthcare is that as you know you have a number of intermediaries, you have both the federal government and payers that actually become the brokers in healthcare. But I fundamentally believe not unlike any other industry that once consumers get more online, get more engaged, there is more transparency around quality and cost in healthcare. It’s fundamentally that will change and how it is we go about delivering our services. Consumers ultimately will champion change in the industry and I believe for the better.

Sanjog Aul [00:26:02]:
What are the areas where the organization health care organizations have been lacking in terms of whether it’s infrastructure, in terms of IT infrastructure, in terms of physical infrastructure, which requires attention and it could somehow be utilized this $19,000,000,000 could somehow be utilized to come up to speed and then get the desired results?

Tim Zoph [00:26:29]:
A couple of things I’d observe for you on the infrastructure side. It’s not only that the IT infrastructure has been lacking. When you look at any measures, our industry has probably spent somewhere 2% to 3% of its annual operating expense on IT where that number given the intensity of how we use information probably should be in the 5% to 7% range. So we’ve been under invested in just the fundamental IT infrastructure. But the other thing that is aging in healthcare is its physical infrastructure. We’ve been fortunate to go through and replace all of our clinical facilities in the last decade over 3,000,000 square feet. But it and actually in doing so then have put the digital infrastructure necessary inside of these buildings for the broader information sharing that’s required. But yet the healthcare industry has an aging physical plant. And so concomitant with these IT changes, you will be also seeing a lot of physical infrastructure changes in healthcare. So I think both the facility changes and the IT changes will need to be coupled in order for this transition to really occur effectively.

Sanjog Aul [00:27:38]:
Do you think the speed at which we would want to change is it practical? Are you able to mobilize your crew at a dizzying speed and say we got to get all this thing done yesterday? What kind of communication are you as an IT leader getting involved in, so that people who are supposed to bring about change, which is your crew and you as an IT leader can only be as good as the crew, are they understanding this or they are lost?

Tim Zoph [00:28:08]:
Well, for our team here, we’ve been carrying this message of the sense of urgency about this digital transition since 2002. So our team is on board and we’ve made those fundamental transitions. I as a leader to the industry carry a sense of urgency to the industry about making these changes because we’ve lived through this transition and know that a paper based process in healthcare is not a pathway to higher quality and safer care. So I continue to carry that message to the industry. But the second message I carry to the industry and it gets to your issue of pace is it’s important for the industry to understand that the technology infrastructure is but stage one. What’s really important and what’s really hard to do is changing your healthcare organization that is the process improvement and the optimization that comes once you have the information technology in place. So we realized even with the digital infrastructure in place in 2005 that we really started to yield the benefits from that digital infrastructure several years after that. So this is analogous to the two technology changes that occurred in other industries. The value side of this and the optimization side doesn’t happen upon the technology implementation. It happens post that period of time for which the organization now gets comfortable with its technology, ramps up its process improvement and actually drives the technology deep in the business in ways that makes a fundamental difference in how the business works.

Sanjog Aul [00:29:36]:
So while I think your organization is lucky to have you, have you seen your counterparts in other industries, you don’t have to name them, but are they making some mistakes which would come and haunt? And are are there any specific pitfalls which they are unaware of and then that’s what is causing them to not be able to reach the goal or they may not reach their goal if they don’t take a step back, look at the whole landscape and see where the pitfalls are and just maneuver in a careful way?

Pitfalls that stall healthcare IT projects 30:04

Tim Zoph [00:30:04]:
Great question. And the pitfalls that I do see and that have been played out in our industry, I think it played out in other industries is that you have to really start at the top and it sort of starts with governance and the CEO and so on is that these technology changes are about fundamental organization change and you have to commit the organization to it and not for a one year period, but a multi year period. So you’ve got to have the message come from the top that in fact this change is important and this may be one of the most important strategic goals or initiatives that you will undertake while this technology transition is in place. The second is a talent issue. Key to making this change is having the talent on the IT side and the talent on the operational side that has the know how and commitment to be able to make these changes. So organizations that don’t really assess their talent, assess their skills, assess their ability to do large scale projects of this sense and start without the talent side, put themselves at risk. And I think the third issue on this one, I call it an issue of pace. Although there is a sense of urgency to install the technology, you can go about it too rapidly. That is you can try and put it in place without appropriate testing, without appropriate configuration, without appropriate training. So although I have a sense of urgency for the industry to embrace technology it’s got to be able to do it in the right way so that in fact these projects don’t fail. What you have seen in the healthcare industry for organizations that have embraced early stage technology implementation is that you get to a point of part in many organizations get to the point of partial implementation that is they start but then these projects stall. And I think they stall because either this talent issue I talked about, the leadership changes, the institution loses its appetite or commitment or sees risk on the horizon. So you’ve got to be able to commit the institution to finish what you start and be able to commit to a very large scale project like this. So as I have observed the industry, you have got to make sure that your organization is really lined up that you do the gut check and assessment of where you are before you go down this path.

Sanjog Aul [00:32:23]:
Do you think this $19,000,000,000 has acted as a catalyst or is it because the money was, yes, they were we were constrained, but then anyways we have to spend upfront and if you don’t deliver well we will not get the money. So is this truly making a difference?

Tim Zoph [00:32:39]:
Only time will tell. I think it will, because the definitions are still how we are going to measure whether you get the money or not still under discussion. It would be interesting to see if incentives are loaner enough to stimulate the kind of large scale change that we need in the industry. The other thing that is not talked about as much, but this is projected as an incentive plan beginning in 2011, but it turns into a penalty plan in 2015. So part of this is there’s both carrot and stick. So healthcare organizations I think are looking at this both ways that is what are my incentives but understand that their payments could very well be reduced Medicare, Medicaid in 2015 if in fact they’ve not gone about this change. So the other half of this is incentives are time limited and at some point you may be penalized as an institution if you are in fact not embracing information technology as a tool in your organization.

Sanjog Aul [00:33:44]:
And would you agree that stick has usually worked better than the carrots because we see the compliance mandates get we will follow-up on them, we put the right things and change and if one person or one organization gets penalized everybody rushes to do whatever it takes for them to comply.

Tim Zoph [00:34:03]:
Yes, and we’re an organization that is highly regulated and has an enormous amount of compliance activity underway at any given time. So in a sense we’re a compliance based industry. It will be interesting to see if the incentives really work. And as I mentioned to you the incentives are very attractive if you have the initial money to invest. What I worry about and as we talked about earlier in the program is that this industry is capital constrained. So even well meaning hospitals and well meaning physicians that recognize that these incentives may be very useful to them may simply not have the capital or the talent to get themselves through the transition.

Sanjog Aul [00:34:52]:
Do you think that a company or organization, a healthcare organization require an outside help for them to bring about this change for someone to come and play the mediator between the IT and the business for them to be able to come up to expectations and actually enjoy the incentives that are being doled out here? Or you think that the people since it’s a change management issue, the people who are living it are the best ones to make this happen?

Tim Zoph [00:35:24]:
This is in some ways the stimulus package has become a full employment act for every consulting and legal firm in the industry about how to use their resources to help you get to these incentives. My own opinion is that outside expertise whether that be vendor expertise on the technology, some consulting expertise that can help with some of the key talent deficits you might have are important, but you can’t outsource this change entirely. To your point in the question, it’s important that people that will embrace the change need to be the agents of that change and you’ve got to have the balance and you’ve got to have the internal leadership to fundamentally carry that message into the organization. And frankly, in healthcare organizations the people that work in those organizations know its culture, know its people, know its processes best. So outside support helpful and over reliance on it very risky and you’ll end up with somebody else’s plan and program and you may end up not having your organization embrace the change because the leadership hasn’t come from within.

Sanjog Aul [00:36:40]:
Who other than IT has enough skin in the game within the organization who would want to get this done yesterday and give you all the support?

Tim Zoph [00:36:47]:
Well, you get a lot of I think where you get support, you get it from your caregivers, your physicians and your nurses that live with inefficient processes, live without the quality reporting and outcomes data that if they had it they use it and they improve what they do. And having gone through this even with our physicians and nurses, the technology really helps make the whole care process efficient. It brings information and knowledge to the point of care that here before you had to try and shuffle through paper records or was simply absent. And we’ve actually made the system more intelligent. So we have hundreds of what are called order sets in the system, which actually give standard based protocols that actually enable the ordering conversation, so that a physician will know what are the fundamental elements, what are the protocols, what are the best practices around this procedure and test that I am ordering. And we’ve actually built hundreds of rules and alerts in the system and we don’t over alert, but we find we use the intelligence of the system to make connections between information and procedures and knowledge that actually brings better decision making to the point of care. So if you talk to many of our clinicians now that have gone through this, nobody would go back to a paper based system. They absolutely embrace the digital world. We can constantly improve it every day. But at the front lines of care is really where your motivation for change ought to come. I think you’ll find it in your quality departments. I think you’ll find it for us in our ancillary areas, laboratory, radiology. People really embrace this digital future. We’re in some ways blessed because we live in an academic setting. So we have students and others that are pushing for digital change and we’re an environment that likes to do leading edge work. I think right now in the healthcare industry that there is enough belief and fundamental motivation for change in the frontline of care that you can look for it, find those champions and get the organization to the point where it’s got the requisite amount of momentum and change to move forward.

Sanjog Aul [00:39:05]:
Would you say that you’d consider yourself lucky because of those different factors where people do not have as much inertia to change or in fact they are looking forward to doing it and they are helping you become the catalyst for the change. There are most organizations in fact out there who have this inertia and that one individual, the IT leader who even wants to be the Hercules is not able to do anything over the last so many decades and they are just sitting there wondering what on earth can I do with this additional money that’s going to trickle in? If money was the problem then I could have figured out to find money and get the change done anyways.

Tim Zoph [00:39:42]:
And one of my fundamental beliefs about CIO leadership is it’s about really educating and telling the story in the organization and getting others to help embrace the change. So my message to healthcare CIO leaders is that it’s part of your role and job to educate the organization on what the benefits are of doing this and to find the champions and leaders for change because technology in and of itself can lead this change. We can enable the technology, we can deliver it, we can put it in the hands of clinicians, but fundamentally that message of change has to come from the institutional leadership most broadly. And so CIOs need to cultivate that, cultivate the literacy, cultivate the change and actually create the momentum in the organization that allows others than just the CIO to be pushing the message of technology and technology change.

Sanjog Aul [00:40:40]:
So when you’re talking about CIOs can bring about change, whose support do you feel you need so that you are empowered enough? Do you think a healthcare CIO today is empowered because we’ve also seen CIOs who are working in supposed state governed hospitals and or healthcare institutions and there are different environments where politics comes into play. And then other policies and other stumbling blocks and or you can say hindrances, which prevent them from doing the job. Is that a CIO playing victim there or is that a true problem?

Tim Zoph [00:41:17]:
Well, I can’t speak to everybody’s own environment. I used to think five years ago that talking about technology and a digital healthcare system was far more of a challenge on CIO because you did not have a lot of examples you could point to left and right. You were really out there asking your institution to do pioneering work. Today I believe that fundamentally CEOs and CIOs believe that this digital transformation is a survival strategy for their organizations. So there is no question that in fact the technology is required in order to have in order for you to deliver on a digital healthcare system in the future. So that momentum for change is out there. That doesn’t mean that organizations aren’t risk averse. It doesn’t mean that this is easy to do. But this is a time that CIOs need to be cultivating this message and getting their organizations to the starting line and carrying the message of what information technology can do to help improve their organization. So I think fundamentally this is a leadership challenge. I like to think I believe my CIO colleagues in healthcare are up to the challenge. But it’s not easy. Change is not easy. There is risk with this, there is uncertain outcome, but CIOs are stepping in now to this leadership challenge and really getting the organizations positioned to embrace technology. So we hope that this $19,000,000,000 incentive or grant would help trigger the change.

Sanjog Aul [00:43:04]:
What do you think would be needed to sustain that change? And once we are there, we just don’t get you can say lured into falling into that same state of complacency?

Sustaining change after the down payment 43:19

Tim Zoph [00:43:19]:
Yes, it’s I do think the $19,000,000,000 is just a down payment. And because the as I mentioned to you, the down payment will help with the initial infrastructure spend that’s needed as we talked about to build the roads and highways. The real institutional investment is going to be on the organization change and our improvement and really allowing organizations to work in a different way. That is use the technology to embrace evidence based care, use the technology to measure and report on your outcomes, Use the technology to fundamentally improve how your organization works every day. Use the technology to connect your physicians, connect your patients. The technology once you have the infrastructure and the hard work really begins and the work of saying, gee, we can now operate differently. We can improve what we do. We can connect our enterprise. That is the kind of momentum you want to have come out of this $19,000,000,000 If you just invest in the infrastructure, collect your incentives and say we are done, you haven’t done much, because the hard work is after the infrastructure is in place and it’s about fundamentally using that technology each and every day to constantly challenge yourself for how you can improve the care that you deliver.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:46]:
On behalf of the show and our listeners, I’d really like to thank you, Tim. I think you had some great insights as to how can an organization can use these $19,000,000,000 to trigger a change which is so people were longing for and then keep continuing that good work so that we see the healthcare that we want to.

Tim Zoph [00:45:06]:
I will tell you I think it’s a very exciting time for the healthcare industry. It’s a very sobering but very exciting time for the healthcare industry. And the idea that now technology and healthcare has national attention, I think is bringing special focus on the industry which ultimately I believe will be good for the industry. And as consumers, patients, others get more engaged in this change, the healthcare system will be better for it.

Sanjog Aul [00:45:39]:
Now we all have longed for the sufficient effective and affordable healthcare which is actually a complex electronic problem involving multiple entities. IT leadership in healthcare organization have really worked hard with limited budgets over the years and get try to get buy in from the executive management and help leverage IT to bring about top line growth as well as bottom line savings. However, there’s a lot more that is required to reach the nirvana, that’s the end state. And interesting part is we truly don’t know what the blueprint is supposed to look like. So that $19,000,000,000 infusion is going to be a positive sign where government is doing beyond just offering lip service regarding turning around healthcare. The money is going to trickle in and will have to be earned by these healthcare organization as they show results. What impact will this have on health and the fate of healthcare in fact? Time will tell.

Contributors

Tim Zoph

Tim Zoph, Senior Vice President, administration and Chief Information Officer, Northwestern Memorial Hospital

Tim serves as the Senior Vice President, Administration and CIO for Northwestern Memorial Hospital. This year marks his 16th anniversary at Northwestern Memorial and 22 years as a CIO in the health care industry. Through Tim’s leadership,... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

FWS - AWSMarketplaceFreshservice MPU 300X224
Tim Zoph