Talent Development • Leadership

Global IT Talent Crunch: What’s The Plan?

Global IT Talent Crunch: What’s The Plan?

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Rick Davidson (Manpower), Diane Morello (Gartner Research), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that the IT talent crunch had been building for a decade and should surprise no one. Rick Davidson of Manpower cited 76 million baby boomers retiring over 10 to 15 years and roughly a 50% drop in US computer science graduates over five to six years. He said power was shifting from employers to employees as jobs grew abundant and skills scarce, and that Manpower sources on demand talent offshore in the Czech Republic, Argentina, and India at lower cost than its Milwaukee headquarters. Diane Morello of Gartner Research argued the real question is whether companies lack people or only lack people who fit a full time, permanent model, with culturally aggressive firms building diversified sourcing portfolios while conservative ones get burned. Both said IT unemployment was at a record low, more IT jobs were created in the US than sent offshore, and about 30% of new CIO hires would come from business backgrounds or new recruits.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Rick Davidson, CIO with Manpower, and Diane Morello, Research Vice President and Fellow with Gartner Research, about the global IT talent crunch and what companies can do about it. They compare on demand and full time employment models and discuss offshore sourcing in places like India, Argentina, and the Czech Republic, where Manpower runs much of its on demand work. They weigh why some companies manage the shift well while others get burned, and examine declining computer science enrollment, the baby boomer retirement wave, and new roles opening up in information, business process, and sourcing.

Contributors

  • Rick Davidson, CIO, Manpower
  • Diane Morello, Research Vice President and Fellow, Gartner Research

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Rick Davidson, CIO with Manpower, said the IT talent crunch should not be treated as a wake up call because it has been building for a decade. He pointed to 76 million baby boomers preparing to retire over the next 10 to 15 years, declining birth rates, and about a 50% reduction in US computer science graduates over the prior five to six years.
  • Diane Morello, Research Vice President and Fellow with Gartner Research, said the real question is whether companies lack people or only lack people who fit a full time, permanent employment model. She found that culturally aggressive companies plan ahead and build diversified sourcing portfolios, while culturally conservative companies, whose risk models aim to avoid risk entirely, end up in severe pain.
  • Rick Davidson, CIO with Manpower, said the balance of power is shifting from employers to employees as jobs grow abundant and skills stay scarce. He expected new labor models such as shared talent pools and employees auctioning themselves to the highest bidder, and noted that firms like Ernst and Young already rehire former staff regularly.
  • Diane Morello, Research Vice President and Fellow with Gartner Research, warned that many companies jump into offshore sourcing without the maturity to manage it. She said conservative firms often lack experience with offshore contracts and negotiations, get burned on the first setback, and retrench rather than treat it as a learning curve.
  • Rick Davidson, CIO with Manpower, said IT unemployment in the United States was at its lowest level ever, matching the end of the 1990s, and that more IT jobs were being created at home than were going offshore. He urged experienced IT professionals not to switch careers but to upskill, and called for changing IT’s image so young people pursue it.
  • Diane Morello, Research Vice President and Fellow with Gartner Research, described Gartner’s Versatilist concept, people who range across disciplines rather than stay deeply specialized. She said Gartner surveys showed about 30% of the people CIOs expected to bring in would come from business backgrounds or the new recruit world, a share Gartner expected to grow.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: the global IT talent crunch and the plan
  • 2:36 Why the crunch is no surprise
  • 5:52 Being prepared and declining CS graduates
  • 8:54 Power shifting from employers to employees
  • 11:17 Rehiring alumni and the boomerang community
  • 16:05 Paying full time rates for on demand talent
  • 18:13 Building a global workforce arrangement
  • 22:18 Maturity to manage offshore sourcing
  • 27:24 US graduates turning away from computer science
  • 33:39 New roles in information and business process
  • 40:48 Consumers versus creators of technology
  • 47:10 Retirement and knowledge transfer

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: the global IT talent crunch and the plan 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:24]:
Today’s topic is Global IT Talent Crunch, What’s the Plan? Our guests for today’s show are Rick Davidson and Diane Morello. Rick is the CIO with Manpower and Diane is the Research Vice President and Fellow with Gartner Research. So, we are already towards the tail end of the first quarter of 2007. How did it go so far?

Diane Morello [00:00:58]:
Well, among the clients that we talked to and we talked to probably couple 100 a month about some of the issues that they’re facing around workforce and we’ve noticed a sharp spike as companies start to really get a grip on what they can expect not only over the next 6 months, but starting to really look at how do they start to forecast their demand for people and fill that demand over the next 3 to 5 years. And that raises all sorts of issues around the crunch and how nervous they ought to be etcetera, but the increase in interest is clear. Rick?

Rick Davidson [00:01:36]:
Yes, I agree with Diane. Many of my peers, other CIOs in the industry are just now starting to get their heads around what’s going to happen over the next 3 to 5 years with regard to IT talent. And you’re starting to see some real concerns amongst my CIO colleagues about how we’re going to fill some of these critical positions that we have in our companies. And certainly offshoring has been a way to address or mitigate that, but there’s some other ideas as well that we need to get creative on and pursue.

Sanjog Aul [00:02:07]:
Now, when we talk about the fact that we are trying to get things done cheaper wherever possible, wherever you can get access to the workforce, this baby boomers retiring and other aspects of too much demand in a small location where it’s only so many technology folks you can churn out in a given period of time. Wasn’t this kind of already anticipated? So is this a wake up call, which we did not look for and then we did not have solutions, now everybody is rushing towards this?

Why the crunch is no surprise 2:36

Rick Davidson [00:02:36]:
Well, it shouldn’t be a wake up call. This issue of the talent crunch has been creeping up on us for the last decade. When you look at what’s going on with the baby boomer phenomenon, 76,000,000 of us getting ready to retire in the next 10 to 15 years and also declining birth rates around the world.

Rick Davidson [00:02:55]:
We see population starting to stagnate a bit. This shouldn’t be a surprise. These kind of statistics and trends have been well reported in the past and maybe what helped early on particularly at the beginning of this decade in The U.S. is we had significant rise in productivity which helped to mitigate some of the talent shortage. But I think in the next few years we’re really going to see this talent crunch begin to hit and we’re going to need to be smarter about how we address it.

Diane Morello [00:03:24]:
And Rick, you’re absolutely right. There is no reason that any of this should be a surprise for organizations. But Sanjog Aul, if I could go back to your comment about why this hadn’t been anticipated, it has been very clear, but most of the clients that we talk to, most of the companies that we encounter actually have very short memories. And so many of the things that we’re seeing right now when it comes to the workforce are a change that they might have anticipated a year ago, three years ago, five years ago, especially if you start looking at the notion that economic cycles rise and fall come and go. The thing though that I think that’s interesting about this is that some of the analysis that Gartner has done has started to really tease out the differences among some of the companies that we might talk to. So for example, the companies that we call culturally aggressive companies really are at the forefront. They are, their business is about anticipating what trends, what events, what things are going to happen and that trickles down into their IT organization as well. On the other side of that spectrum are the cultural conservative and they for some reason it’s just built into the DNA perhaps, but within those cultural conservative enterprises, they are in severe pain. So a lot of the things you’re talking about with the global crunch people getting nervous about it, if you actually mapped it mostly, many of them would match those attributes of more conservative companies, whereas I suspect that the much more aggressive companies have been anticipating planning for this for a long time and have adopted approaches towards mitigating any concerns towards reducing levels of risk and toward broadening their imagination around how their workforce is going to get supplied?

Sanjog Aul [00:05:21]:
See, whenever we talk about the strategic planning of a company of IT and resource management and resource acquisition, it’s more and more shifting to on demand or at most they would like to plan for a quarter or six months. With that being said, even if we wanted to look 5 years ahead and say, we’ll have a panicky situation and we’ll have to deal with it. It is sheer paranoia or it looks like one. What are your thoughts?

Being prepared and declining CS graduates 5:52

Rick Davidson [00:05:52]:
Well, I’m not sure that we need to be paranoid, but as Diane said we certainly need to be prepared and those companies that aren’t prepared do so at their own peril. I talked earlier about the boomers retiring and declining birth rates and we’re also starting to see challenges at the university level and even at the middle school and high school level where we’re just not graduating enough science, math and IT literate people. In fact in the last 5 or 6 years we’ve seen about a 50% reduction in computer science graduates here in The U.S. So these trends aren’t going to change overnight and I think we started to look at other options offshore being one of those options as a place to deal with that on demand talent requirement as you describe it. But we’re going to have to be very, very creative now and really think about how to create employee value propositions and be seen as companies that get it, that understand it, and then react now to this impending talent shortage.

Diane Morello [00:06:58]:
And to me much of this that some of this paranoia, well, let’s actually go back and challenge the notion of on demand, because what I do believe that clients and companies that we’re talking to are really looking for is how to become more agile, so that their organization itself isn’t the constraint in growth and seizing opportunity. And for that to happen, they actually have to take a very different look at how they build their organizations, where they get their talented people, where they shop for skills. And that’s one of the things that I think we’re going to start getting teased out over the next 5 years or so is a real much more of a diversified portfolio around sourcing with some of the people being found being those people who are the most talented folks that you really want these people you cannot do without and they belong in your company. But a much more aggressive and perhaps even more smart way of using all of the sources that are out there in the base of labor markets whether they’re offshore, onshore or project teams or Hollywood models or all sorts of things. I think that some of the constraints that we’ve seen and this one I would imagine many people would actually challenge me on, but some of the constraints we’ve seen have come from the notion that the only way to fulfill this adequately is through maybe full time and permanent employment. And as Rick’s business knows and the clients and the companies we talk to know, the more aggressive companies and moderate companies are starting to explore different options. Some of them because they’re afraid and they have to do so, but others because they realize it gives them a bit more flexibility in solving and responding to business dynamics and business problems than they would have if everything was done only inside.

Power shifting from employers to employees 8:54

Rick Davidson [00:08:54]:
Yes. Diane, you raised an interesting issue here. The fact that some companies think that they’re still going to be able to control the labor market and even bring in people as permanent employees. If you remember 20 or 30 years ago, jobs were scarce and talent was in abundance, but we’re starting to see that change where jobs are in abundance and skills are scarce. And so you’re seeing the locus of power shift from employers to employees and some employees I think are going to start defining the rules in terms of how they’re going to work. And I think you’re going to see some interesting labor models start to develop. Whether companies share labor pools or share talent or employees even auction themselves to the highest bidder. I think it will be a luxury to have a bench of talent that’s permanent staff. I think companies are going to look at other models, they’re going to be forced to look at other models because that’s just going to be the new reality that we face.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:49]:
So then could you very safely say that if you were to go on an on demand fewer full time employees and more contractors or other types of models that Diane just mentioned, then this whole idea of scarce resources would be a moot point?

Diane Morello [00:10:07]:
Well, that’s a really interesting question. I think there might be some basic issues around whether or not we’re getting entry-level people who might come out of college. That’s a difficulty that’s outside of this one. But your question about whether or not that shortage’s moot, I’ve been wondering that and thinking that for a number of years, the idea that, do we really lack people or do we really just lack people who match your particular employment model? And I think that’s the closer one there is that there are many companies who tend to have a pretty standard view that all people who work for the company should be employees. And that’s getting busted up in location after location. And when people are being recruited or being looked at for the workforce and don’t have the other options, then I think that the company will end up finding itself with a fairly narrow and constrained view of whether or not there is talent available for them.

Rehiring alumni and the boomerang community 11:17

Rick Davidson [00:11:17]:
As a quick example of that, it used to be taboo to rehire people that left the company. The thinking was well they’re not loyal, they left the company, they’re pursuing other interests. But I think you’re going to see more and more companies now look at the alumni community and want to bring people back into their company that left. Some consulting companies like Ernst and Young do this fairly regularly now. So you’re going to see models like that start to develop that break the old taboos and companies that aren’t willing to think differently about the workforce are going to find themselves without having the talent that they need to manage their business.

Diane Morello [00:11:53]:
And that’s a great example of how this kind of imagination and the real issues need to change and we call those people almost the boomerang community. And you’re right, I think many employers kind of take it personally when someone leaves. And the reality is that in some cases they ought to. There’s something that’s missing there. It could be leadership. It could be substantial mismanaged change. It could be boring work. But I think that all of these things start to open new ways of looking at who do you really want to be working with you and in what form do you want them to be working for you?

Sanjog Aul [00:12:33]:
Now, when we talk about this issue of people being used for contracting and people having this still issue of skills not available, part of the problem that has also been seen is that while you want to use the on demand resources, you don’t want to pay the premium which comes attached to it. They still want to use the dollars that they want to spend on a full-time employee and convert that divided by 2,080, which is the number of hours allowed and try to put a rate on that. And then they sit there fishing forever trying to find a candidate with that specific skill set who they are not going to find. So that’s an opportunity cost, which most people are not realizing. Now in addition to that, we’ll talk about that, plus also let’s look at the fact that now that we are going to offshoring destinations and other forms of outsourcing, we are in a way shifting the pressure from our plate to an offshoring destination where we are trying to have them turn out a lot more talent and trying to get it yesterday. And how can that be possible? If not, and then they’re having freshers come and work, do the same thing as an experienced person will, and that is going to degrade the quality. So how are we going to manage this pressure

Paying full time rates for on demand talent 16:05

Sanjog Aul [00:16:05]:
So before the break, I asked a kind of long winded question. Let me split it up. The first one was basically the fact many of the companies who are trying to use this on demand resourcing model, what they are doing essentially is trying to find an on demand resource, but they want to pay the price for full-time. And they will put 20,000 skills as a 1-man army kind of requirement in place and which they will never find. So they lose out in that wild goose chase. So is there something which is inherent with such organizations? Can they change? Can they be educated in some form that they are just going to not go anywhere with this?

Rick Davidson [00:16:56]:
Well, the market will educate them certainly, because going to an on demand model means that the talent that you’re bringing on board in an on demand model has some risk of not having full utilization. In other words, within a company you may be able to use an individual at 80% or 90% utilization. The on demand provider has to take on that risk that they can find somebody else when you’re done with that resource. So they place a premium on that.

Sanjog Aul [00:17:27]:
One of the models that seems to be predominant as it goes forward is the on demand model.

Rick Davidson [00:17:28]:
I think those companies will be able to get away with that premium because they’ll be able to better utilize those resources across a wide variety of customers and mitigate their risk across those customers. But they’re still going to charge you a premium for it. So maybe what you ought to do if you’re an employer looking at that model is look at other locations of labor. As an example, we do use onshore talent in an on demand model, but a lot of our on demand is done offshore in places like The Czech Republic, Argentina and India. And so we are able to access on demand talent, but at a much lower price point or cost point than somebody here at our corporate headquarters in Milwaukee.

Building a global workforce arrangement 18:13

Diane Morello [00:18:13]:
So it sounds to me as if in your company and a growing number of companies out there, what we really have is a global workforce arrangement out there that really starts to, let’s say, pick up some of the asymmetries that exist out there globally that you can get good talent in The United States or in Mexico or in Czech Republic or Argentina and build those together and consider them all part of your resource pool. The interesting thing that I’ve seen with companies is that they do tend to look for that kind of a balance although there’s still a great deal of caution and risk associated with this market, with this kind of global labor market and global workforce. They look for that kind of flexibility, but then they actually get disrupted or concerned that the people that are assigned to them by the service providers are actually not acting as full time and permanent employees that they have to now balance and manage that kind of arrangement differently than they would with employees. They have to manage the idea that some people will come into a work environment. They may be there for a little while and they’ll depart and somebody else will come in. So all of these things start to add some different complexity to the workforce arrangements. The full time permanent employment has its risks in the idea of whether or not you can actually get the number of people you need. The other type of one with the on demand market has its risks in whether or not you as a company are mature enough to manage that kind of a setting. So it’s really a very interesting way but there’s risks and rewards associated with both neither one of them is a perfect approach.

Rick Davidson [00:19:56]:
As a provider of IT labor, the company I work for Manpower, we look at the on demand model and that’s our business basically and we look at it kind of in a different way. We look for engagements where clients want to have kind of this virtual bench but they don’t want to pay for it full time, they want to use resources as they need them and then have them go away and then have the same resources come back 4 or 5 months later when they need them again. So what we do is we look for short cycle engagements, engagements that have just 3 or 4 month term. So, we know ahead of time that that employer is looking for a specific individual to come back in a few months. So, we’ll put that individual out on another engagement that has a limited duration. And that’s another way to be creative in terms of how we address this because they want the benefits as Sanjog Aul said earlier, they want the benefits of having that person as almost a virtual bench, a virtual employee, but they don’t want to pay a premium and they want that person to have all the previous knowledge that they acquired when they worked on the engagement with that company or on a previous engagement with that company. And so we see that demand in the marketplace and we’re trying to find creative ways to address it as the way that I just mentioned.

Sanjog Aul [00:21:11]:
Talking about the fact that the offshoring destinations as we said, almost everybody is trying to use offshoring in some form or fashion. And countries like India or China or The Czech Republic as we just discussed, these are places becoming a convergence point where all the pressure is kind of being shifted. And you’re saying you guys go ahead, churn our talent at the fastest capacity that you have and then deliver to us as an overnight and we will give you more work, more work, more work. With that being done, that being said, it’s not practical, it’s not realistic. So what’s ending up happening is that they are picking up pressures and having them do work, which is supposed to be done by somewhat more experienced people. So degradation happening, people get all disappointed and they pull the plug on such engagements. So nobody wins. So the management of growth or management of shifting pressure to an offshore destination is also very critical, but it seems that people are not realizing it or are they realizing it?

Maturity to manage offshore sourcing 22:18

Diane Morello [00:22:18]:
That’s a great question and I have encountered this when I’ve spoken to numerous CIOs and their executive teams, there’s an interesting balance here and that is that when companies are looking solely for outside low cost labor sources and when they do that, they take some steps along the lines regarding contracts and negotiations and the like that maybe an organization that’s been working at it for many more years is more mature at. So when I see something like this go on, when I see an organization who’s looking at an outside service provider whether offshore or onshore and very unhappy with their work, I could also look and say what’s your familiarity with this kind of business model. I think that there’s a significant number of companies that have really jumped into the offshore model and themselves are not that sophisticated in managing this complexity of much less people on the other side of the earth, much less even people who might be located in another city in the same time zone. So there’s a balance here that says if you’re going to be looking and going all the way that distance simply for labor cost issues, do you know how to manage that kind of a contract effectively and are you mature enough in this kind of a sourcing model? I think you’ll find more people who aren’t that mature in that model and then they get burned by that.

Rick Davidson [00:23:47]:
Yes, and to pick up on Diane’s point, I think some companies will look to the offshore model as being the panacea without realizing that the same challenges we have with the quality of labor in The U.S. or in Europe we’re going to see in other geographies as well. In other words, it’s not a unique challenge of offshoring, it’s a supply and demand imbalance, so that we end up having to find talent in unique places and they may not be experienced or they might be the freshers as you called it, they just don’t have the requisite skills. So it’s not offshore that’s the challenge, it’s the issue of the demand is outpacing supply and we’re just having a hard time finding the right people. It always comes back to the resume. And I think if you’re an onshore company looking for offshore talent, buyer beware, you need to be smart about that as Diane said. You have to be mature. You can’t just assume if you go offshore, you’re going to get exactly what you want. You have to be as smart about that as you are about how you manage contingent talent onshore.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:51]:
So it’s got like a snowball effect happening because each individual company is making somewhat the same mistake of asking way too much from their offshoring counterpart and it’s all coming together and that’s what maybe is causing the labor that you’re looking for?

Diane Morello [00:25:10]:
I think that’s true to some degree. But if I go back to the model that I introduced and was talking about earlier about the side of these really culturally aggressive companies, many of those companies actually can balance this kind of complexity because they really do have some good risk analysis and risk management programs in place. Whereas a lot of the more culturally conservative companies, which I would argue probably represent a significant number of the companies that you’re saying are very unhappy with this model, they have not had any experience in this. So their risk management models, their ability to analyze risk and be able to zero in on what’s appropriate, their risk management model is basically about how to avoid risk entirely. And the first time something shows up that might be almost indicative of their learning curve as opposed to an indictment of the offshore outsourcing. Those people will be, they will avoid that risk and they’ll pull back, they’ll retrench. So I think about it, it’s not as absolute or as 100% as your comment implied on that one, but rather that it will vary based on the enterprise personality profile.

Rick Davidson [00:26:19]:
The market that I really have a concern about is the mid market, medium sized companies that would say are $500,000,000 to $2,000,000,000 in revenues that don’t yet have the sophistication to go offshore and may not have the process maturity within their company to manage distributed IT software development as an example, what do they do? This is a market that is experiencing the same talent shortage, but may not be as sophisticated as some of the what Diane calls culturally aggressive companies, some of the larger companies and size is not everything but some of the larger companies have figured this out already. How does that mid market tap into this offshore labor? One of the things we’ve done at Manpower is develop a model that allows those mid market companies to be effective in how they use IT talent. It’s about process discipline, it’s about tools and it’s about being smart about the kind of work that you do offshore. Work that has a high collaboration content is the worst thing to offshore. Work that can be specified easily and managed more in a kind of a factory mentality is ideally work that should be sent offshore.

US graduates turning away from computer science 27:24

Sanjog Aul [00:27:24]:
Now when we talk about any of these things happening, there’s a strange phenomena that’s been seen at one end, countries like India, where you got, I don’t know, millions of jobs being created and there’s a dearth of people who can join those jobs. And now let’s take the United States. We have seen a pattern where some of the fresh graduates or people who are about to graduate or they’re about to choose their major, they are voluntarily not choosing computer science as a major. And because they see not great hopes, if they were to live in this country that is a place where they will be able to sustain, because all the development or the early jobs that they would get after they come out of the school, they may not be available to them, because most of them would have gone overseas. And also at the same time, we will see even at mid management, that’s another area where more and more well, earlier we had developer jobs going out. Now even mid management designing and database administration, anything which was somewhat highly paid, but they did not feel that the person needs to be here. Even that is being sent. So people are either shifting their careers or they’re moving to other greener pastures where those countries like India or China or other places. So we are creating a huge vacuum because of this whole notion of suddenly shifting all our IT work and all our IT talent needs to a different country.

Sanjog Aul [00:31:23]:
Before the break, we touched the point where we are talking about the sudden shift of jobs and opportunities in different offshoring destinations and because of which there has been a trend which is noticed for the fresh graduates or people who are about to choose their major to not choose IT as their major and not want to graduate with that major. And at the same time, seasoned IT professionals are either changing their careers if they choose not to leave the countries from where the jobs are being offshored or they are looking for expatriate assignments or move to another country where greener pastures and they want to move there for good. So how much truth is there to this trend and should this trend be stopped, should there be something done about it or this is actually the way the world is going to work going forward?

Rick Davidson [00:32:22]:
I think Diane and I are probably in agreement on this one. There is a PR problem. The reality is that we are creating more IT jobs in The U.S. than are going offshore. IT unemployment is at the lowest level it’s ever been in The U.S. It’s at the level it was at the end of the 1990s. And so the demand for IT talent is very high in The U.S.

Rick Davidson [00:32:49]:
And so as young people determine what degrees they want to pursue, we need to change the image that IT has in the minds of our young people. So they see this as a secure financially rewarding and a good career. And we need to kind of stop the demagoguery that’s taking place on some of our national media around the fact that all these IT jobs are going offshore. Certainly you’ll hear that IT talent that is in The United States as an example where we have foreign nationals living here, some of them under H-1B visas are returning to their home countries as domestic demand is increasing for IT talent and frankly they want to go home. And so we’ll see some of that take place which does create even more opportunity here in The United States for IT talent as those individuals lead to go back to their home countries.

New roles in information and business process 33:39

Diane Morello [00:33:39]:
I think there’s another aspect about this Rick that you’ve made me think of as you’re speaking and that is the notion that some of the ideas of what really will constitute the most talented levels of talented and qualified people and the kind of work they’re doing is itself in a state of uncertainty and re settling. So for example, if we look at the notion of service industrialization coming in and actually affecting how work gets parsed out and then enabling it to actually be spread around multiple geographies, that’s one thing. But we can also see a tremendous increase in the number of businesses out there that have over the past 10 years, put a hefty amount of their future into innovation in IT. Now there is a fair amount of that innovation in IT that is not synonymous with what’s going on in the operational intensity of keeping a business running on that one. There are some areas

Diane Morello [00:34:34]:
that are about innovation that I would suspect and suggest are other people from other domains. Now when you say that engineering is declining, our data also has said that, engineering for example is one of the only class fields of study that is declining over the past 5 to 10 years. But also you take a look there is women overall are leaving the industry quite rapidly. They’re leaving the occupation very rapidly. So this is, it’s spread around a lot of different areas. But the opportunity also exists and we believe it exists in ways that are outside maybe the historical vantage point of technology infrastructure and services that many IT organizations built their base with and historically have focused on. If you start to look at the impact of information technology on business process. There’s a huge opportunity that exists for people to get smarter about industry based processes and forces that would enable them to position themselves for a future market. Same thing with information. We are, I would say we are perpetually on the cusp, if you will, of companies starting to understand that they really must get a grip on their intellectual assets and their intellectual capital and that the next 20 years will start some really big differences in that from those companies that are good at it to separate those that are good at it from those who are poor. You can also start to see more opportunities emerging in things like sourcing and relationship management. There’s a whole new field that comes in and roles and jobs that step in that are designed from scratch to bridge the boundaries between multiple stakeholders and constituent groups within a company and across companies. So the focus of technology infrastructure and services remains, although it may shift around, the work may migrate to different groups or different people. But there’s also new opportunities emerging in information and in business process and in relationships and sourcing that I think really could captivate and attract a lot of people who right now might not be interested in the infrastructure and services area.

Rick Davidson [00:36:54]:
Yes, the truth is the demand for IT talent has been out there for a while, it’s going to continue to grow. Look at the role that IT played in productivity improvement in the last decade or two. Look at the role that IT is playing in terms of new products and services that are rolled out. The Web 2.0 obviously has a heavy technology component to it around individual collaboration and team collaboration. So my sense is that the need for IT talent is not going to go away. So if you’re an experienced IT leader or professional or specialist, now is not the time to think about switching careers. Now is the time maybe to upskill a little bit and learn some new skills, but I wouldn’t change careers. I think you’re gonna be in a catbird seat very quickly if you’re not already and so I wouldn’t switch.

Sanjog Aul [00:37:41]:
Now talking about this career development, this is I think a responsibility that the employers have and also the academia to help groom these people who are maybe at the mid management or about to become a mid manager or they are fresh graduates or they are about to become a fresh graduate. So what are we doing? And in fact, during one of the breaks, Diane used the term digital native, these newcomers who are supposed to be very technology savvy, how are we further leveraging or piggybacking on the already know-how of the technology to make them better IT professionals?

Diane Morello [00:38:38]:
If I were just to launch off on some of the issues around the digital natives, just as to clarify this, this is a phrase that Mark Prensky developed a number of years ago to really start to capture the younger people who are I guess maybe at their oldest right now are 22 and they come into the workplace with a much more, they’ve grown up with digital technology. So they’re not like many of us still translating a lot of things between what we did manually and what we do now with technology. Now you asked me how people are using these guys to really kind of maybe fit them into the IT profession. Those really truly personal technology. And they’re not all necessarily technically savvy. They are good with technology. They don’t get intimidated by it and that enables them to use things in a different way and to participate and contribute to things in a different way that most companies are very loathe to understand. Many of the companies that I’ve spoken to continue to try to figure out how they can thwart the introduction or the entry of personal IT into their business environment. When if you start to look at digital natives and the how they communicate and how they share information and where they’re getting their feedback and things, those are the trends and the patterns to watch because they are at the real cusp of innovation for the next 5 to 10 years, not necessarily the individuals themselves, but how they’re using technology. Smart companies will start using those people as ways to start shaping the patterns and the services and the next consumers of nearly everything that everybody is talking about. So it’s really important to pay attention to them and look at what the opportunity is that they represent rather than to try to force fit them into older molds maybe.

Consumers versus creators of technology 40:48

Rick Davidson [00:40:48]:
I heard somebody say the other day, technology is the stuff that we didn’t grow up with. In other words, today we wouldn’t think a CD player in a car is technology, but 20 years ago you would say, well that’s technology. We wouldn’t think today that an iPod is technology whereas 20 years ago to be able to carry around 40 GB or 80 GB of music would be something that would be even unheard of or unthought of. So technology is the stuff that you grow that’s new to you, that you haven’t thought about. So the technology that you’ve talked about a little bit Diane, that this young generation, the net generation or meat generation whatever you want to call it, they’ve grown up around this and it defines kind of who they are. And in some cases it might even be a fashion statement. As I was telling a group the other day, I’m of that generation that’s a little older where I still haven’t figured how to download ringtones to my phone. I’m happy if I can just turn the volume up so I can hear it. And so we need to be careful how we look at the technology here. There are those that consume it and I think this younger generation certainly are consumers of technology. I’m not sure that all of them are interested in becoming the creators of new technology and the developers of new technology. And without that kind of focus and getting these young people involved in developing the next generation of technology, we may see a loss of leadership in terms of America’s positioning around the world. So we’ve got to get these people excited about creating the next thing, the next iPod or what have you. And that’s where our challenge is going to be.

Sanjog Aul [00:42:24]:
Now talking about the fact that grooming from one level to another, that itself is a challenge and especially it will become more challenging when you want a fresh graduate to become a mid manager in a short span and similarly mid management to become a senior IT leader who’s going to retire, the baby boomer issue that we just spoke. What is the plan around it? What are we doing? We heard about some tag team approach that you got to mentor protege kind of relationships or the arrangements being made. How successful are those and where are we getting with it? Because the clock is ticking basically.

Sanjog Aul [00:45:27]:
Before the break, just about to answer that, but we stopped and then we’re going to go again, grooming how easy it is, what are we doing about it? We have tried to use the mentor protege approach and other approaches to make sure that the business knowledge is retained. The know how and the experience is somehow dumped into a person who is at a lower experience level. How realistic is that and how much success have we achieved in this?

Rick Davidson [00:46:19]:
Sanjog Aul, this is a real issue and I think you’re on top of a major problem that we face and I’m not sure we have a solution, a good solution quite yet. As you know the more seasoned IT professionals when they leave a company take a lot of business knowledge with them. These are the people that quite often wrote applications that support the business processes and they really understand those business processes. And so perhaps this idea of mentoring, mentoring protege is a good way to do that. But we’ve got to figure this out. As I talk to my peers, just even other Midwestern corporations, those companies are really, really struggling with us, particularly in the financial services area where they see a lot of retirements taking place in the next 4 or 5 years. So we’ve got to find a way. I don’t have the answer, maybe Diane has the answer.

Retirement and knowledge transfer 47:10

Diane Morello [00:47:10]:
It’s miracle work. Actually what I’ve been seeing I’ve been talking to a number of companies about this idea of the retirement and how do you move through. Most of the issues that I encounter are around what does the knowledge exchange look like. And I think that this isn’t, the retirement is just one of several things that introduces significant workforce disruption and change that points to whether or not a company is smart in how it’s managing its information, its knowledge and its history of some of the things that it’s done. So if I look at retirement as one catalyst, so is merger, so is outsourcing, so are consolidations, any number of things that would basically disrupt the workforce. Now the retirement is kind of interesting because unlike many of the other things that we just talked about, retirement has actually been something that people could anticipate for years. So it’s always a surprise to me with the level of surprise that we hear. Oh, my goodness, the people are going to be retiring at a heavy base. Now just to give you a sense, I went out and I was talking to a group, there were probably about 250 people in the audience and I usually take these rough polls and ask people to raise their hand. I said, how many of you are expecting to retire fully from work when you reach the end of this job? And one person in the entire room actually raised a hand, another 249 expected to move to different types of careers. Rick’s comments and one of yours earlier, Sanjog Aul. The idea is how do you create this kind of rotating mechanism in there, but also go back to the companies themselves and say, what have you done to actually analyze are your people going to stay for 5 years? Are they going to stay for 10 years? I mean, you might see in a couple of years, for example that people don’t really want to retire or they can’t afford to retire and they don’t leave their company. So then you have all these new employees who might be getting IT degrees maybe not, but they won’t have any place to come into except for maybe external services providers. So it’s a very a little bit more complicated I think and the retirement is an issue, but it’s not one that has been of any surprise to anybody. So it’s a bit surprising to me it’s taken only until now where people are actually starting to do something about it.

Rick Davidson [00:49:47]:
Now that Diane has given me a chance to think about the question, and she’s jogged a couple of thoughts. There is the science of IT and there is the art of IT. And I think from the science side of it, we’re going to need to make sure that we’re developing talent organically. The technologists as Sanjog Aul said taking the programmer and developing their management skills and then maybe moving them into senior leadership position eventually. But some of the best IT leaders I’ve seen have been those that have come out of a liberal arts background because they’re better at managing the art of technology. And that’s why I think you might see many more IT leaders sourced from a business who may not have the technical breadth, but understand how to apply technology and certainly have an understanding of the business processes and then can go to third parties whether they’re onshore or offshore to actually deliver the technical part of the solution. So that might be an option as well.

Diane Morello [00:50:46]:
I think that’s a really great point because it starts to really look at the notion that many of the people who could participate in the world of IT will come from areas outside the world of technology or technical skill sets. Some of our surveys have already revealed that about 30% of the people who CIOs expect to bring into their organization will come from people who have business experience or are coming out of the new recruit world. But there’s a substantial percentage and we expect it to be growing. Some of the ideas that we’ve seen have been captured in this notion that Gartner has talked about called the Versatilist, where you’re really looking at people who have a greater degree of versatility. And for many CIOs and IT leaders out there, those Versatilists are people who can actually move and range around a little bit more effectively than people who are deeply specialized. And if you’re in a changing and highly dynamic organization with lots of teams and lots of assignments and especially with lots of new investment going in, then the likelihood is that you want to have people who have maybe some expertise in some area, but they’re enriching that expertise with new assignments, new relationships, familiarity with multiple disciplines, multiple functional perspectives and all sorts of things, they become much more versatile and most likely more valuable to their company. That I think is something that tends to come from people outside the domain of the technical skills and the technology infrastructure and services area.

Sanjog Aul [00:52:24]:
On behalf of the show and our listeners, I’d really like to thank you, Rick and Diane, for sharing your thoughts and insights about how we can actually work towards developing and sustaining quality IT talent pool for our needs within the United States, Europe and of course, all of our global needs.

Sanjog Aul [00:52:44]:
Now Global IT Talent Crunch, as we already saw, is no doubt a very serious problem that we are currently grappling with and it could become even more serious in coming years. We all know that successful talent management is actually a key to high performance and we have to treasure what we have and make sure that retention is given a top priority, because talent retention is far less expensive than talent acquisition. While there is an inevitable exodus, which is imminent of these baby boomers, but there may also be an opportunity that we could look at where we could infuse some fresh talent with some new ideas and groom them, which you cannot do with the folks who had some fixated ideas because of their experience and other things. Knowledge transfer also needs to be carried out with careful planning and impeccable execution. We are striving to do that. We’re not there yet, but hopefully we’ll get there. Meanwhile, leveraging outsourcing and shared services approach may also allow us to run our IT staff you can say our IT department lean and not having that much dependence on the IT staff altogether.

Contributors

Rick Davidson

Rick Davidson, CIO, Manpower

Rick Davidson is the Senior Vice President and Global Chief Information Officer and has overall responsibility for leading global IT functions across Manpower's operations in 73 countries. Previously, he served as Senior Vice President and ... More   View all posts
Diane Morello

Diane Morello, Research VP, Gartner Fellow

Diane Morello is a vice president and research director in Gartner Research. She covers numerous areas, including workforce strategies, people-oriented resource management, the impact of outsourcing on people and organizational change manag... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

E-Con Systems MPU 300X250
CIO Talk Network