Workforce Mobility • Change Management • IT Strategy & Business Alignment • Leadership

Enabling an Effective Virtual Enterprise

Enabling an Effective Virtual Enterprise

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Frank Modruson (Accenture), Scott Blanchett (Vanguard Health Systems), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that an effective virtual enterprise depends far more on strategy, leadership, and trust than on any single tool. Scott Blanchett of Vanguard Health Systems argued that organizations must first decide what they are trying to accomplish and whether a virtual model even fits their culture, since talent acquisition, productivity, and workforce engagement drove a very different design than cost arbitrage would. Frank Modruson of Accenture made the case that video is becoming as ordinary as the telephone, backed by about two times return on early video conferencing and 150,000 to 160,000 meetings a month across a converged IP network that cut cost by more than half while tripling bandwidth. Both agreed that performance should be measured by output rather than visible activity, that managers who blame the virtual model are usually treating a symptom, and that the real leadership task is to set clear expectations and build the trust that lets people do their work from anywhere.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Frank Modruson of Accenture and Scott Blanchett of Vanguard Health Systems about building a virtual enterprise: the strategy, leadership, trust, video technology, network investment, and output-based metrics that make distributed work succeed.

Contributors

  • Frank Modruson, CIO, Accenture
  • Scott Blanchett, Senior Vice President and CIO, Vanguard Health Systems

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Scott Blanchett of Vanguard Health Systems says a virtual enterprise has to start from a clear strategic agenda, not from the technology. He points to talent acquisition in healthcare, where hard-to-reach talent is common, as the primary driver that shaped a program very different from one built around cost arbitrage.
  • Frank Modruson of Accenture reports that early room-based video conferencing returned about two times the investment, mostly through reduced airfare. Accenture tracked meetings that would have been in person but became virtual, confirming significant cost savings from the technology.
  • Frank Modruson of Accenture says desktop video reached 150,000 of the firm’s 250,000 people and drove roughly 150,000 to 160,000 video meetings in the month of June. Usage more than doubled over the prior year, and he now runs more than 100 immersive video rooms after a four-year buildout.
  • Frank Modruson of Accenture argues that remote work should be judged on output, not on whether someone is seen working. He compares it to home repair, where he checks whether the job met spec and finished on time rather than whether the carpenter used a hammer or an air gun.
  • Scott Blanchett of Vanguard Health Systems says expectation setting, performance management, transparency, and a focus on outcomes do not change much between office and virtual work. In his career he has not seen anyone game the system and still deliver the results expected, and he expects the bar for virtual workers to be at least as high.
  • Frank Modruson of Accenture calls the network the one strategic piece of infrastructure and says Accenture cut network cost by more than half while tripling bandwidth. It did so by combining voice, data, and video onto a single IP network, which also made it easy to add room-based video.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: enabling a virtual enterprise
  • 2:25 Getting strategic about objectives
  • 4:00 Focusing on the opportunity
  • 7:49 Talent, productivity, and retention
  • 9:17 Video is the new voice
  • 13:07 Rethinking what the office is for
  • 19:57 Readiness and cultural fit
  • 23:48 Scaling video adoption
  • 26:32 Collaboration beyond video
  • 29:38 Measuring output, not activity
  • 43:33 Developing leaders remotely
  • 51:35 The network as strategic backbone

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: enabling a virtual enterprise 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:26]:
Today’s topic is enabling an effective virtual enterprise, and our guests for today’s show are Frank Modruson, who is the CIO with Accenture. Good morning, Frank. How are you?

Sanjog Aul [00:00:55]:
I’m actually in Dallas right now in a hotel room and enjoying this conversation. We also have Scott Blanchett, Senior Vice President and CIO at Vanguard Health Systems. And how are you, sir?

Sanjog Aul [00:01:23]:
So the topic here is based on the fact that we are living in a new age, with a new workforce, and now technology has helped us get well beyond just working from home or perhaps outsourcing. But at the same time, we recognize that building a virtual workforce, be it to become more agile, productive, or global, takes a lot more than giving an employee a laptop and a smartphone to work from anywhere. So it takes leadership, perhaps new policies, and there have been some debate recently as to the best ways to go about this transition. And we would like to explore that today. With that said, Scott, the first question I’d like to pose is, what do you think would be some of the top challenges that a virtual enterprise may face? Would there be specific ones related to logistics or management, communication, and, of course, leadership challenges, which did not exist or don’t exist in a regular world where people come to office every day?

Getting strategic about objectives 2:25

Scott Blanchett [00:02:25]:
Well, I think all of those are fair challenges and to one extent or another will surface. But I think the first challenge is more of a strategic one and that’s your organization’s ability to try and accomplish well, getting very strategic about what it is that you’re trying to accomplish and designing a program and a solution around those objectives. And just like any initiative, this won’t be the solution to all problems. So I would encourage folks to think about being very clear about the agenda and reminding your colleagues and leadership about the agenda for your virtual enterprise or reframe that as necessary. And one example that comes to mind is a program designed around talent acquisition, which is a significant driver specifically in the healthcare industry. Hard-to-reach talent is commonplace. It’s going to be very different than one built around cost arbitrage, for example. And so once you’ve, I think, gotten a good strategic framework in place and some nice guardrails established, building and maintaining a virtual program becomes much more clear and concise. I wouldn’t say that it becomes easy, but certainly a much more solvable problem.

Sanjog Aul [00:03:44]:
So, Frank, you’ve been at it for a couple of years, I’d assume. How did that journey start, and when you look back, hindsight is 20/20, of course. What kind of challenges did you see going in and what do you see them morphing into now that you’ve been in it for a couple of years?

Focusing on the opportunity 4:00

Frank Modruson [00:04:00]:
Well, we have been at it for a few years. And I guess I would step back and I would take a different tack a little bit. There are always challenges, but why do you put up with the challenges or why do you go after the challenges? I’d rather focus on what are the opportunities and then challenges that could come up with any opportunity, okay, what do you do about that? So to me, with newer technologies, particularly with the advent of video, we can see and interact more creatively online than ever before. What opportunity does that present for us? Well, it presents teams being able to work globally and see each other rather than having to travel there. It also presents people flexibilities in their lives about when they work. Accenture is a global organization, so we have teams operating basically in every time zone around the world. The challenge with that is if you’re on a team that’s in a different time zone, a significantly different time zone than you, you may need to be on a call at an awkward time. It’s a lot nicer to be on that call on video at home at 6:00 in the morning or 9:00 at night rather than needing to be in the office. And the technologies allow us to break down that space continuum. It doesn’t solve the time problem, but it does solve the space continuum. In addition, companies are faced with rising rent costs, space costs. What are the opportunities that that presents itself for people to work virtually to reduce the carbon footprint of people commuting to, in-town locations, for example. These are all opportunities that the technology lets you take on. Now with that, there are always going to be challenges, but I tend to like to focus on what’s the opportunity, the why of doing things.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:51]:
So Frank, what you just said, of course it could be a great PR angle in terms of reducing the carbon footprint, etc. And there’s, of course, cost reduction. Do you think if you were to do a net calculation between what you gain versus what you lose and so far the journey the way you had it, do you think what you are able to get in terms of people working from wherever and you’re able to reduce the logistics issues and hoteling issues for all your workers, has that paid off already or do you think that calculation is still being worked on?

Frank Modruson [00:06:26]:
No, it’s already paid off. We paid a lot of attention. When video conferencing was more expensive a few years ago, we looked at that very aggressively because we said, for this investment what’s our return? And we had a significant return on the investment, about 2x what the investment was, and that was primarily in reduced airfare costs. We could track meetings that would have been in person that became virtual as a result. So we already know we have a pretty significant cost savings by using the technology.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:03]:
So Scott, if you look at the calculations that, of course, in Frank’s case, it was 2x and there are still companies who have not gone full throttle with it because of some issues. Now what could those issues be? Do they not feel the need? Or if they do feel the need, they don’t know how or they’re on the fence?

Scott Blanchett [00:07:23]:
Well, before I answer that question directly, let me speak to an implied assumption here. We didn’t necessarily pursue a virtual enterprise for the purposes of cost savings. We do have the benefit of being a domestic operation and even so inside of that domestic agenda, we have kind of six regional markets. So we’re fairly concentrated in limited geographies.

Talent, productivity, and retention 7:49

Scott Blanchett [00:07:49]:
We looked at this really for three purposes. The first was talent acquisition and I talked a little bit about that challenge in healthcare and I think that more than anything was the primary driver. I think the second was around workforce productivity gains, which are less tangible than strict cost arbitrage ROI type calculations, but still have some economic benefit. And then I think the third was attracting and retaining a new generation of workers and by new I mean those that have been exposed to the virtual enterprise over the last 20 years. I don’t necessarily mean recent college graduates. And so I think very different than the Accenture model, cost management I think was less a concern for us and I think to a lesser extent globalization was less of a business driver, but the issues around talent acquisition, productivity and workforce engagement were really the key drivers for us. And that created a different, I think, a different program design than what you would see at Accenture because again it was aligned around some very clear and in some cases different business objectives.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:04]:
And, Frank, in your case, you’re not the only global organization who have the travel needs, etc., but not everyone went the route that you went.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:15]:
What did you find differently for yourself?

Video is the new voice 9:17

Frank Modruson [00:09:17]:
Well, I guess a couple of things. And first, I would pick up on a comment that Scott made. I think every organization’s drivers are going to be different. Every company, every organization and it’ll vary by industry and culture of the company. So I think what drives you to start is going to be different. The flip side of that and when you introduce it, the flip side of that is I believe video is the new voice. So if you roll back the clock and you go back to the late 1890s and telegraph was the primary means of distance communication and the telephone showed up, I’m pretty sure there were skeptics about how fast that would permeate our culture and now we have more phones on the planet than we have people. Clearly that’s become ubiquitous. I think video is going to go through a similar journey faster, but it will still take many years. The consumption of video has gone up significantly in our organization. If you look at global usage, it’s gone up, but it’s only been over the last 4 or 5 years. As the cost comes down, people become more comfortable with it and use it to solve individual problems like talking to their grandkids, which was one of the major uses of some of the popular, free video on the web. I think you’ll see changes happen. We started early. It doesn’t mean that we’re going to be the only organizations who are doing it. I think it’s going to become ubiquitous as the cost goes down and I think we will see uses we didn’t anticipate. One, give you an example, not necessarily related to online video, but a similar technology. I was having some work done in my house recently and the guys were going to move some stuff around and disconnect some wiring from my stereo and I said, okay, you guys will never be able to figure out how to wire that back up and they said, we don’t have to. Our phones have cameras in them. We’ll just take a picture. It’s not that hard. I was like, wow. There’s a use case that no one ever thought about for a built-in camera in a phone. I think video is going to show up so ubiquitously that we can’t even anticipate all the use cases. We think about the use cases now. You can see a call where someone reacted negatively to a comment that I had made, and I thought it was actually quite positive because I could go back and probe into the issue and the problem at hand. These nuances of video are gonna be very, very important. I think there’s an awful lot of opportunity for us.

Sanjog Aul [00:12:21]:
So, Frank, you did mention video and yes, it is a technology and over a period of time, we’ll see adoption. Do you think this being a common denominator and given video will go where it is, some organizations are successful in making a virtual enterprise reality where you are able to maintain productivity and actually get the things done versus having people go out doing whatever they’re doing. And eventually, there are some examples where people said, we don’t want to do that anymore. Bring them back again. So I’m sure there are certain things. And you being humble, you are attributing that to technology, but if you’ve successfully done it, what are those other things that you had to look at besides introducing video in your mix for you to get the desired results?

Rethinking what the office is for 13:07

Frank Modruson [00:13:07]:
Well, I think one thing that plays in our favor is we have a very technology-astute employee group, so they’re used to and they like to engage and use technology. In addition, they’re a fairly mobile group. They tend to work with our clients at our client locations or at our facilities, but it’s never nine to five this one location, you come in, punch a clock, sit down, work for eight hours, get up and leave. It’s a fairly dynamic set of work and the work is always changing. So I think the idea that how we work and where we work becomes more fluid. We moved to hoteling for office space somewhere in the early 1990s, which is so long ago, it’s such a natural part of our organization. It’s hard for me to remember exactly when, but it was somewhere in the 1991 to 1993 timeframe. And you think about it, that’s a pretty sensical way, particularly if someone is not sitting at the desk every day. That will vary by company and by organization, by industry. But I think you’ll see more of that. You have to also remember particularly the office. The office, I would postulate is a modern invention to get over the challenges of communication that existed 50 or 100 years ago.

Frank Modruson [00:17:12]:
The office is a relatively modern invention, and I believe it was to conquer communication. We were mostly paper-based or we were completely paper-based when the office was invented and we moved things around the office. Now there are good reasons to get people together, but I would postulate before computers and before the telephone, it was largely to push paper around. Now that the paper is largely, if not completely, automated, what is the office for? How should we use it? What does space look like? What’s the best way to make use of it? And how do you use technologies, particularly video and virtual technologies to change the dynamic of how people work to either make it more efficient or more effective or best both?

Sanjog Aul [00:18:00]:
So, Scott, do you think it’s old-fashioned to keep talking about in-person communication always being better than a virtual communication even though you can get that super HD video conferencing in place?

Scott Blanchett [00:18:15]:
Well, I think there’s two scenarios and I think it’s probably important to differentiate that our hospital business, which has hospital aspects, has significant benefits, if not absolutely critical components of in-person interaction that are necessary for us to conduct the business. But that is also being disrupted by the virtual enterprise and I’ll talk about that in a minute. On the administrative side of our business, which is the office space, I think there are some limits to scale and I don’t know that the complete virtualization of the office-based workforce is the end goal nor is it infinitely attainable in terms of scalability, which is why I come back to my original comments around you have to be very strategic about what problems you’re trying to solve and who you’re trying to solve them with. But then I also think be very deliberate in your execution to not allow things like thinking that this is the old way of doing business and the right way of doing business versus the new way and the wrong way. I think you need to get back to the specific problem statements you’re trying to solve and try and align specific strategies and tactics around those.

Sanjog Aul [00:19:28]:
So, Scott, you mentioned being strategic. So if you were to lay out, say, a playbook or steps in a playbook. First is to identify whether your organization is even ready, and there may be some prerequisites that you may want to fulfill and then go ahead with the plan. So would you have some idea or would you like to share in terms of what kind of due diligence could be commonly done in any organization to see if it is prime for going virtual or even ready for going virtual?

Readiness and cultural fit 19:57

Scott Blanchett [00:19:57]:
Yeah. I think you’ve hit on some of the key ones. The first is organizational alignment around what you’re trying to accomplish and is it even culturally feasible and I think you need to be quite honest about that. There are certain corporate cultures where a virtual enterprise is just not going to work and it has nothing to do with organizational competencies, technical competencies, it’s just philosophically, it’s not in the organization’s DNA. I think secondarily, we’ve talked enough about strategy, but you need to be very deliberate about that. And in particular within that strategy determining scope, timeline and setting expectations. I think thirdly, there’s an opportunity for technical readiness and that includes a human technical readiness. I’ve seen programs where 100% of the solutions are deployed and deployed effectively that would make the program successful, but yet their adoption rate may be 10% or 20%. And that comes back to a human capital issue and not a technical issue. So there are clearly some steps strategically, organizationally, philosophically that I think people need to get through before you start getting down into practical things around human performance management, leadership management, technical readiness, etc.

Sanjog Aul [00:21:14]:
Frank, do you think you need to hire all Type As in your company because that will take care of having to manage them or them having to learn anything new because they will be kind of go-getters who will say, okay, bring it on, I’ll deal with it?

Frank Modruson [00:21:28]:
Well, I think you’re going to have a mix in any organization of types of people, and you want diversity. So I think you start there. I think technology will be adopted at different rates by different individuals and by different generations and by different motivations. And you need to kind of crack the code on that, understand it, recognize it and embrace it. Think about this: video on the Internet has exploded. There’s essentially no question about that through some of the popular free programs that are out there. One of the biggest users have been grandparents. Their motivation is to see their grandkids. High motivation, and bingo, it’s become a pretty common thing because they’re very motivated and seemingly comfortable with their grandkids seeing them and vice versa. So there’s a lot of high motivation. In a work setting, some people are very comfortable with video. I see the younger generation not even thinking about it. But you start getting into different generations and the generations kind of say, well, do I really need to be on? I’m not wearing my tie on, I don’t have a jacket on, I don’t know if I’m in the right setting for this meeting. So it does change things a little bit. You have to educate people and understand that the world is different. When people are working more virtually, you’re going to hear the dog barking in the background. You’re going to see a different setting. But you also have to recognize that these people may be working more hours in the day because they’re not commuting. What’s the win-win for the individual and for the organization? So you need to look at it, understand it, and really understand what the technology can do. And I do believe you’re going to have unexpected consequences both positively and negatively.

Sanjog Aul [00:23:27]:
So, Frank, based on your comments about the grandparents trying to talk to their grandkids and there’s a high motivation, now that’s one thing which is voluntary. So, yes, you see quite a few people going in that direction. Now when you talk about a corporate pressure cooker where the adoption needs to be planned and actually ensured for you to show ROI to your boss, how do you do that?

Scaling video adoption 23:48

Frank Modruson [00:23:48]:
Well, there’s a couple of things. For our first foray into video and this was the more expensive room-based systems, we actually made a pretty big incremental investment. We basically bought a dozen rooms, tried it out, measured our effectiveness and what we found over time was that there was some education but people liked the technology, they liked the immersive nature of it, it got used. And we were able to measure cost savings that justified getting more rooms. And we got more rooms and we got more savings, and we got more rooms, we got more savings. If I had known the amount of money we were going to save, we have over 100 immersive video rooms today. If I had known that I would have bought all 100 right at the beginning, because it took us about four years of watching this. So if I were doing it again, I would go more aggressively. As we’ve rolled out desktop video, which is almost free, not free, but quite inexpensive, we’ve extended that to 150,000 people of our 250,000. And because it’s pretty ubiquitous, we’re getting very aggressive use of it beyond what I would have imagined. I don’t worry as much on the ROI on that because the cost is so low, but we’re conducting about 150,000 to 160,000 video meetings a month. That was the month of June, but it’s up substantially from earlier in the year. In the last year, it’s more than doubled. You see that kind of growth. You see that people are adopting this and using it. They’re interacting differently. To me, that’s a positive thing.

Sanjog Aul [00:25:45]:
So one is, Scott, this is for you. So Frank did mention video and that is, of course, one of the ways people see each other and interact with each other. But then there are other forms of collaboration and other forms of discussions that may be happening or may be required so that people are able to do the work collaboratively on, say, a project which is not straightforward dialogue. It requires other type of exchange. So would you say there should be a technology stack which is preconfigured, if you will, which should be brought, and then a set of policies which are preconfigured and connected and then are basically enforced so that people are actually able to adopt it timely and you are able to look like a hero?

Collaboration beyond video 26:32

Scott Blanchett [00:26:32]:
Yeah. I really appreciate Frank’s comments that certainly hindsight is always 20/20. And if we knew today what we knew some number of years ago, we probably would have gone after all sorts of these opportunities much more aggressively. I agree that video has really had a substantial impact on the enterprise. And for no other reason, psychologists or sociologists refer to unspoken conventions of human behavior, which are very difficult to discern on the phone, but much more easily discernible in person and on video. And I think that has really improved the quality of communication, as well as reinforcing trust. That has been a huge game changer. Inside of that package that you’re referring to, chat and the convenience of chat has been huge. And that doesn’t necessarily need to be inside of something native like Microsoft. I think other more global chat and sophisticated platforms like Yammer are particularly attractive. I think compounding the effectiveness of this is some form of formalized information sharing platform and there are all sorts of emerging companies that are trying to create niches here and do them, I think, better than the incumbents in this space. So, if you think of the Dropboxes of the world, or some structured sharing mechanism. And then an area that’s of particular interest to us and I think would be of interest to a number of businesses would be a common set of performance management dashboards that come with this communication suite because I think between old email, video, chat, information sharing mechanisms, and dashboards for performance management, reporting and oversight, that portfolio of capabilities is a pretty tight suite of capabilities and really begs the question about the necessity of getting on a plane, flying someplace, and sitting in a room and effectively doing the exact same thing that those solutions allow you to do. So if you can hone those, refine those, and couple those, I think you’re pretty well down the road.

Sanjog Aul [00:28:57]:
Now, Frank, we would not want to doubt anyone as a worker in a virtual enterprise, but how on earth do you know after you’ve spent so much time and energy in deploying something and you do see meetings happening, how effective are they? And secondly, even when the meetings are not happening, of course, there has to be work done by people when they are by themselves and not talking to someone. That’s also part of the virtual enterprise. So if you are to just count the number of video chats that happen and feel good, yes, we should feel proud about it. But then how do we actually evaluate against the productivity that we should be having at the minimal, if not a gain because people now are given the freedom to work from wherever they are?

Measuring output, not activity 29:38

Frank Modruson [00:29:38]:
Well, that’s a great question. These are tools that enable communication. Scott really gave a number of examples, but if you step back, it’s all about communication. We know communication and collaboration are very important. So the metrics we have are largely around are the tools being used. What you have to look at and this gets much harder because you don’t look at the tools for this, you look at the output. What is the output of teams? What are they getting done? Because I get a lot of questions, people say, well, if somebody’s working virtual, how do you know they’re working? Well, you measure their output. Are they doing their job? If they’re on a team, are they contributing? Is the team being successful? Is the team meeting its goals? That’s really what you need to look at. And I think we sometimes get wrapped up in measuring actually the wrong things. There are process metrics that tell you about is the work going on, but they don’t tell you something about the process itself. The more important metrics in my mind are what people label as output metrics. What is the output? If a team is supposed to build, say, a new system and deliver it on September 1, is it built? Does it work? Is it of the right quality? Was it delivered on time and on budget? To me, those are the metrics we need to look at, when you look at things. I just had some work done on my house. To me, I look at the output of the house. Was it the spec? Was the color right? Was the job finished, etc.? I don’t look at, did the carpenter use a hammer or an air gun? Did it take him two hours to put the studs in or an hour? I don’t really care. As long as it’s done. That’s where we tend to get a little confused when we look at this. So I think you need to look at the output metrics.

Sanjog Aul [00:31:46]:
Scott, now let’s talk about the output metrics and see what do we benchmark it against. So the healthy skeptic could say, oh, well, the project was to be done by October 1 and that was because original date in mind was September 1, but they took a month slack and the rest of the time people were vacationing. That could be a distrusting leader and that would have its own repercussions. But then how do you make sure that whatever you’re measuring against, whether to say that these people will finish it on time versus not, how did you come up with that particular benchmark for you to effectively know that your virtual enterprise is actually producing at the same level as it would have produced if everybody was in the same office?

Sanjog Aul [00:35:01]:
Based on Frank’s remark about being able to measure the outputs, let’s challenge that in a healthy way. How do I know if my benchmarks are accurate and what is it that I should aspire for and compare the outputs against, especially when you moved on to a virtual enterprise already? What’s your formula then?

Scott Blanchett [00:35:23]:
Well, I think Frank hit on the key point, which is there’s a very heavy emphasis on expectation setting, performance management, accountability, and transparency of performance, with the most heavy emphasis on outcomes. And that doesn’t largely differ from how we manage our resources in the office or not in the office. Now there are some unique expectations I think around responsiveness, but again that’s not all too dissimilar from an office environment. But I think there is an implied assumption here around leadership having some capacity to understand how to manage the business of the virtual business and then also an implied assumption around having a high performance team. And if the team isn’t performing then diagnosing that becomes a little more challenging remotely. And I think one of the things we’re going to talk about a little bit later is an organization that went through this performance management exercise with a virtual workforce, and wasn’t successful in diagnosing the root cause and so opted to in-source that group. But I think at the key point, which is, if an individual is able to achieve their results in 10 hours versus 50 or 60, then good on them. And I’d hope they use that efficiency as an opportunity to assume more responsibilities, move on to progressively more significant roles, share that same expertise with the rest of the team and hence raise the entire tide for all the boats in the water. I haven’t seen anybody in my career who’s been successful in gaming the system and still capable of getting the results expected. And I think the expectations virtually are still very high, whether they’re benchmarked against an office environment or other virtual exercises. They might even be higher for that virtual workforce. So I don’t necessarily acknowledge that there’s a huge opportunity here for people to circumvent the system.

Sanjog Aul [00:37:34]:
So, Frank, do you think there is some sort of benchmark that you may have established by now that this is the type of work it is and this is how long it should take? So when somebody gives you an estimate in your chain of command, there’s a way to assess whether it is a realistic one or has a lot of buffer or slack built in. And once expectations are set, then you just measure the output. Is that how it works?

Frank Modruson [00:38:03]:
Well, first, let me start by saying I think Scott hit on and articulated a lot of important points because I think people get distracted by this idea, if I can’t see him working, how do I know he or she is actually working? It’s got to be about are they getting their work done. And I do believe that the people who take the 50-hour task and get it down in 10 hours generally come back and say, yo, what else do you need help with? They don’t say, hey, I’m going to go sit on the beach for the rest of the week. And I think you will also get a sense and we do a lot of this in our organization. At Accenture we have a methodology for doing various types of work that we do. We use our own methodology that has estimating parameters. We run projects using those and then you feed them back and look at the results, look at the variances. So we have pretty good metrics and if I look at our overall IT performance as an example, we are aggressive users of our own collaboration technology. We also benchmark the best in our industry on our IT spend. And I would tell you, I also think it’s very, very good technology. So we must be doing something right, at least at a macro level. But in reality, there is no magic benchmark that if you use video, the project is going to be 10% cheaper, 10% better. There isn’t a particular metric around that, at least none that I’m aware of yet. I think what you need to look at is, is the organization responding and changing? Because one of the key things here too, and I kind of believe this is the case for Scott’s organization, is the real value that people bring to the table is the ability to continue to evolve and change an organization. Because if you’re not getting better, by definition you’re getting worse because somebody around you is getting better. The competitive environment that we have today across industries is pretty high and the world keeps changing. Our real challenge as leaders and our people is to help an organization move into the future and to be better than it was before. Kind of a continuous improvement metaphor. Video just becomes one more arrow in the quiver to help make you more effective. So some of this stuff has to get back to, are we changing fast enough? Are we keeping up? Are we out in front? Because you have to look around and see where you are vis-a-vis your competition.

Sanjog Aul [00:40:42]:
So, Scott, would you think that if somebody’s delivering well, they are really happy? Because the fact that you are looking at them as a worker, but they’re also a human being and your attention, your ability to retain them in this very competitive marketplace would also be a challenge. If you just have that as a measure, I’m saying as long as this person does his job well and asks for two other things, I think he’s happy with what he’s doing. Is that how we assess and move forward?

Scott Blanchett [00:41:08]:
I think that is a good indicator. And one of the things that’s difficult in this model is establishing and reinforcing motivation. That’s always easier to do in person. Anybody who’s been in a sales role or a sales culture understands that sales via phone or via videoconference are just tougher by nature. There’s some lack of interpersonal connectivity there and I think not having the ability to establish and reinforce motivation for certain tasks or missions is harder to do. But I think you can have very clear indicators along the way around not only people’s personal productivity, but their engagement. I’m sure Accenture uses some engagement mechanism as do we. So we have that as a feedback mechanism. I think productivity is another indicator. I think the performance management process, where leaders should, could and should take a genuine interest in helping develop all of their colleagues, if it’s taken with a degree of seriousness, also provides other insights into how people are performing. Are they liking what they’re doing? Are they liking the manner in which they’re doing it? Do they believe in what we’re doing? Do they believe in the team that’s leading them in that direction? There are a lot of indicators along the way. I wouldn’t look to one or two, but there’s a portfolio of data points along the way where we as leaders or managers should very rarely be surprised by feedback that may be counterconventional.

Sanjog Aul [00:42:51]:
So, Frank, I’m sure there are worker bees or people who are at different levels who are supposed to do a project and life is good there. You might remember when you were climbing up the chain of command and you may have had a few other mentors who worked with you side by side. You may have watched them do certain things and you learned. That comes down to leadership development. An organization that wants to go virtual would also have to develop leaders from the same virtual workers. So would you bring them in, or do you think having a chat and a video conference is going to still be able to deliver that result?

Developing leaders remotely 43:33

Frank Modruson [00:43:33]:
I think it’s an and. I don’t think it’s an or. One of the most effective leaders on my team is a gentleman who runs a lot of our data center architecture and network stuff. Guy is fantastic. He’s a great technologist, but the thing that’s actually really special about him is how effective he is at developing his team and how much they just love working for the guy. I was talking to one person recently, who was working for him and was just bubbling over about how great it was to work for him. She had been a good performer, but under him, she became a really fantastic performer. I was asking her, how’s it going working for him and all that? And she’s, oh, it’s great. He gives me so much air cover. I can really get stuff done, etc. And then I talked to him and he goes, yeah, she told me the same thing. I’m not really sure what I’m doing, but she’s doing great. I’m just staying out of her way.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:39]:
So what’s the message we get from this?

Frank Modruson [00:44:41]:
Well, the message was that he connects with her, he listens to her, and he lets her do her job.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:47]:
So physical proximity has got nothing to do with the person’s style and the way they come across wherever they are.

Frank Modruson [00:44:53]:
Interestingly, he is based in a city where we have no one else on his team. No one. He works remote 3 to 4 weeks a month. He comes to our office in Chicago maybe once a month. But when he interacts with people, he demands that it’s over video and he connects very well with his team. He was good in person before we did video. He’s good on video. I think it’s a little less about the technology and a little bit more about the individual. He’s just good at helping develop and get people to perform. The video is just one more way that he gets to interact with people, and maybe he gets to interact with more people because it’s a little bit easier. The physical proximity stuff’s broken down. But ultimately, it’s less about the technology and more about the skills of the individual. I think video has a place. I think in-person has a place. There are certain things you’d like to deliver in person. But I do a lot of face-to-face discussions over video as well. My sense is if you can see people, you get more comfortable having the conversation.

Sanjog Aul [00:46:14]:
Continuing on that leadership, you should be developing leaders and whether you do it over video or in person. But to be able to develop other leaders who are in turn able to get the best output, not just the most, but the best output out of all people who report to them, what is it that you would want to coach them and train them on so that because of this change in the way people are interacting, they are not physically present at the same location? What all would have to change in the way you would like to coach your lieutenant in order for them to be effective in a virtual enterprise?

Sanjog Aul [00:49:18]:
So Scott, what would you do to coach your lieutenant so that they are effective leaders in a virtual enterprise? How would you coach them differently?

Scott Blanchett [00:49:27]:
Well, I think one of the key issues that we haven’t spent a lot of time talking about is the trust relationship that I think is absolutely critical to being an effective leader. We’re very fortunate in being a domestic enterprise that we physically assemble the team once or twice a year to try and build some of those strong interpersonal relationships that help drive that trust. At scale when that’s not practical, we try and push that onus onto the management layer. But I think some of the biggest issues that come once you’ve established that trust foundation are things we’ve talked about: expectation setting, performance management and transparency, and being deliberate in your expectations. I would say one of the other things that’s also an implied leadership obligation here and might be a new twist is that there are going to be those that are more comfortable and those that are less comfortable with this type of delivery model. In fact, you might very well find people that are vehemently opposed to this type of delivery model. Those that are more comfortable with it, whether peers, subordinates, or superiors, have an opportunity to help their colleagues understand how to develop strategy, how to develop an execution plan, help get more comfortable and familiar with the tools and technology when they’re not comfortable or familiar with them, and also do a better job at communicating the performance benefits of the virtual enterprise. A combination of those activities will really lead you to a high performing place.

Sanjog Aul [00:51:10]:
So Frank, you did mention a lot about the video and its effectiveness. Do you think our plumbing, that is our underlying network and infrastructure, is ready for most organizations to take this leap or is an overhaul required? And if it is a very large investment, would that put a damper on this virtual enterprise initiative that some people may want to take on?

The network as strategic backbone 51:35

Frank Modruson [00:51:35]:
Well, I think you bring up a very good point, Sanjog. The network and in fact if I look at infrastructure, in my opinion, the network is really the one strategic component. It’s how you get to the cloud. It’s how you communicate. It’s how you connect with your customers, with your colleagues, etc. It’s what really ties organizations together. Many companies over the years have built layers of technology. They have a voice network, they have a data network, they have a video network. If there’s been acquisition, sometimes they have multiple networks with multiple different providers, technologies all mixed together. I think there is an opportunity, in fact I witnessed it with ourselves and with some of our clients, that if you have a network that you really haven’t stepped back and looked at strategically and said, what’s the future? there is an investment to be made. There is a huge cost savings to be garnered and unlocking dramatic performance increase. For example, over the past 4 or 5 years, we cut the cost of the network by more than half, but also tripled the bandwidth. The way we did that was combining voice, data, video onto one IP network. Money fell out of the bottom, saved a ton of money and more than paid for the investment. But the other thing is it unlocked the ability. It was actually perfect timing around the time that we went to room-based video systems. They were actually easy to add to our network because of the work that we did. It was a bit fortuitous, but video churns a lot of bandwidth. Companies need to be ready for that. And I think there’s a real opportunity not to just slam in a video network, but to step back and say strategically and architecturally, what do we want our network to look like? What kind of traffic and flexibility do we need and where are we going to go with it? So I think there’s a huge opportunity as well as challenge there.

Sanjog Aul [00:53:46]:
All right. Scott, so we’ve heard about this. There was a controversy recently in the news about companies debating eliminating working from home throughout the organization. So they went virtual and they basically brought everyone back. Do you think there was a major disaster or was that a mindset change or management thinking that it is not producing the results? What could have happened because, of course, no one knows why somebody would do that? But if you’ve already seen the value of somebody working virtual and producing good results, why on earth would someone bring it back?

Scott Blanchett [00:54:24]:
Yeah. I think the natural tendency for some managers to go after the virtual workforce as being the root issue is generally going after the symptom and not the cause. That response I think is appropriate if you’re in an environment where you have significant cultural issues, trust issues, transparency issues, performance management issues that are very difficult to diagnose in a virtual environment. And that’s largely not a function of the virtual environment. That’s a function of how that environment tends to get stood up and operated, how the tools and technologies and processes support that, and understanding the strategic objectives of even standing up a virtual environment. Some managers, new managers tend to look at the virtual environment as being the problem. But in many cases, the smart ones will look at that as being a short-term solution to getting at much more fundamental foundational challenges. Once those are fixed, I won’t be surprised to see those types of managers getting back to the virtual enterprise mainly for all the benefits we’ve talked about today.

Sanjog Aul [00:55:46]:
Frank, any advice since you’ve lived this successfully in terms of making an organization virtual? Any three top words that come to mind which leaders should keep in mind and follow those in order to be successful?

Frank Modruson [00:56:02]:
Well, I think the key, as I said at the top of the show, is focus on the opportunity. What’s the opportunity? Where do you want to go? What’s the destination? How do I embrace the opportunity and focus on the opportunities and how you can evolve the organizational culture and then handle the challenges within that.

Contributors

C. Scott Blanchette

C. Scott Blanchette, SVP & Chief Information Officer, Vanguard Health Systems

Scott Blanchette is currently Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer for Vanguard Health Systems (NYSE: VHS), a Fortune-500 company. He is also Founder and President of Hangar9 Solutions, a professional services firm that prov... More   View all posts
Frank Modruson

Frank Modruson, CIO, Accenture

Frank B. Modruson, CIO of Accenture, leads a high-performance global IT organization that directly supports the business goals of a $27.9 billion company. He oversees all business applications and technology infrastructure, enabling more th... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

RCN 1 MPU 300X250
C. Scott Blanchette