Change Management • Culture • Leadership

Embracing Ignorant Leadership

Embracing Ignorant Leadership

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Steven Burrell (Northern Arizona University), Bill Davidson (Breakthrough: How Great Companies Set Outrageous Objectives – and Achieve Them), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that leading in unfamiliar territory starts with admitting what you do not know and shifting from giving answers to forming good questions. Steven Burrell of Northern Arizona University said a CIO cannot possess all the knowledge or answers, so he filters out the static, keeps student success as his true north, sets aside 20 minutes each morning to test new ideas against his core values, and shadows students, staff, and faculty to see through their lens. He added that CIOs are hired for strategy and fired for operations, so leaders must keep the trains running on time before experimenting through isolated pilots, where about 80 percent of the time nothing results. Bill Davidson said major organizations deliberately rotate leaders into roles with no domain expertise to build listening and learning, that a fixed and even outrageous target focuses learning, and that a deep personal network substitutes for experience when the problem is genuinely new.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Steven Burrell, Vice President and Chief Information Officer at Northern Arizona University, and Bill Davidson, author of Breakthrough: How Great Companies Set Outrageous Objectives – and Achieve Them, about how leaders function when their hard-won expertise no longer fits a new and uncertain situation. Burrell describes filtering out the static, keeping student success as a true north, walking campus to see through students’ eyes, and treating good questions as the most powerful tool a CIO has. Davidson explains how large corporations rotate rising leaders into roles where they have no domain expertise to build listening and learning, and argues that most problems already have reference points to borrow while only true frontier problems need a breakthrough mindset. Both make the case for strong teams, outside help, a fixed target, and shedding old habits.

Contributors

  • Steven Burrell, Vice President and Chief Information Officer, Northern Arizona University
  • Bill Davidson, Author, Breakthrough: How Great Companies Set Outrageous Objectives – and Achieve Them

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Steven Burrell, Chief Information Officer at Northern Arizona University, says a CIO in this day and age cannot possess all the knowledge or all the answers, so forming the right questions matters more than giving answers. He deliberately filters out the static and keeps student success as the true north that guides what his IT organization takes on.
  • Bill Davidson, author of Breakthrough, explains that large corporations place rising leaders in two to three year assignments where they have no domain expertise, specifically to build listening and learning early. He cautions that this rotation model fits general management better than IT leaders, who are usually hired as domain experts.
  • Steven Burrell, Chief Information Officer at Northern Arizona University, argues that CIOs are hired for strategy and fired for operations, so leaders must keep the trains running on time before reaching into unknown areas. He keeps experiments isolated as pilots or a skunkworks and accepts that about 80 percent of the time nothing comes of them.
  • Bill Davidson, author of Breakthrough, says most frontier problems already have reference points that can be benchmarked and adapted, and only genuine de novo problems call for a breakthrough mindset. He warns that most large, established organizations are not suited to a game where the success rate is 50/50 at best.
  • Bill Davidson, author of Breakthrough, argues that a fixed and even outrageous target focuses a leader’s learning in fluid conditions, making it easy to judge whether any new input helps. He favors a three year vision with one year cycles, and Steven Burrell confirms Northern Arizona University works to a 36 month plan with no more than five to seven key result areas.
  • Steven Burrell, Chief Information Officer at Northern Arizona University, says a leader who gets blindsided should own it and state what they intend to do next, treating vulnerability as a way to build trust rather than a weakness. He sets aside 20 minutes each morning to weigh new ideas against his core values and shadows students, staff, and faculty to see through their lens.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: embracing ignorant leadership
  • 2:28 filtering static and keeping a true north
  • 5:02 rotating leaders into unfamiliar roles
  • 7:58 questions as a leader’s best tool
  • 11:04 strong teams and enterprise context
  • 18:57 reference points versus true frontier problems
  • 21:25 balancing wisdom with bold bets
  • 29:19 keeping operations solid while experimenting
  • 33:27 fixed targets focus learning
  • 41:23 owning surprises and building trust
  • 45:04 shedding old habits for a portfolio of models
  • 51:51 the mindset for uncertain times

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: embracing ignorant leadership 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:23]:
The topic for today is Embracing Ignorant Leadership, and our guest is Steven Burrell, who’s the vice president and chief information officer with Northern Arizona University. Hi, Steve. How are you?

Steven Burrell [00:00:40]:
I’m well. Thank you, and good morning.

Sanjog Aul [00:00:42]:
Good morning to you, and we also have Bill Davidson, who’s the author of Breakthrough: How Great Companies Set Outrageous Objectives and Achieve Them. Hi, Bill. How’s life?

Bill Davidson [00:00:52]:
Good morning, and it’s great here in Southern California.

Sanjog Aul [00:00:56]:
Beautiful. So I have a lovely esteemed guests here, and the topic is rather interesting and someone might think, okay, what am I talking about here? So ignorant leadership, what does that mean? And we are saying leaders today come with a lot of experience that they have earned over the years, and that’s what perhaps earned their stripes, but then we are in totally new environment, new fundamentals that are driving it, new customer expectations, new business environment variables that are governing what we are dealing with every day. With all of that said and it keeps coming in different shapes, sizes, and flavors, it can be unnerving for any human being and leaders are still human. So that said, what do they do where in order for them to move forward how do they switch to the new way of thinking or resetting their thinking? Do they just keep going back and looking at what they learned or they fundamentally do a reset and for that can they fund they can just ignore what’s going on and not think that that is gonna be unnerving and that’s how they build it. So it’s gonna be an interesting discussion And the first question I have, and I’ll start with you, Steve, is what we are seeing is a lot of uncertainty in the marketplace, and the disruption doesn’t simply stop. What do you think from your vantage point, suppose you were not playing the leadership role and just observing this, what would you have suggested they should do to think new more or different and to steer their ship?

filtering static and keeping a true north 2:28

Steven Burrell [00:02:28]:
Thank you Sanjog. I think this topic of ignorant leadership fits well with my past experiences. As I’ve gone through life, I realize that the more I learn the less I know, and so I think one of the things about steering the ship and what Peter Vaill called back in the 1980s in his book, Permanent Whitewater, is really about keeping your focus and truly deciding what’s really important. There’s so much static as you’ve alluded to out there. So many things that we can embrace. So many red herrings to chase and new ideas. I think the key thing for a CIO in this day and age is almost to filter out the static, and to take a very positive approach to latch on to those things that seem truly important. Keeping what Stephen Covey described as that true north in front of us. What’s your vision? What are your values? What’s your purpose? And defining that value proposition, and for us at Northern Arizona University, it’s all about student success. So as we steer the ship, as we try to ascertain how to lead in this environment, we put those core values back in front of us, and they become those true north that we move to. A ton of static. I purposely disconnect. The other thing that I do pragmatically to kind of keep things heading in the right direction, I get out. I walk around campus. I talk to students. At first they’re a little uneasy, the guy in a suit, the creepy old guy that’s been following me around the building, but once we get past the introductions and some conversation, it’s really good to get into their mindset and see things through their lens, and so I think these are some of the key things about this ignorant leadership thing: just embracing your ignorance and getting that perspective while sharing your vision.

Sanjog Aul [00:04:45]:
So Bill, based on what Steve just said, we say we will ignore or we will learn, but at the same time we’ll unlearn a whole lot. Do you think we have reached that level of evolution as humans that we can really do that on a regular basis while living our daily life and still pay our bills?

rotating leaders into unfamiliar roles 5:02

Bill Davidson [00:05:02]:
Well, thanks. Appreciate it, and, Steve, great comments. First of all, I want to say, Steve, I’m jealous of your ability to go walk around like that and clear the brain. I, by the way, take a week each year and go hiking in your part of the world. It’s my favorite part of the globe, frankly, Northern Arizona. I’m very jealous of your location and maybe even know my good friend, the outfitter, Pat Connolly there in Flagstaff. The wonderful way to clear the brain to go hiking out through a plateau. I love it. My former partner, by the way, Ron Hubert, is there at Northern Arizona University in the environmental studies area, but I want to come back to the key theme. My experience I have a ton of experience in the IT world, but my experience is more with general management, middle leadership development. In this point of learning, in major corporations that we work with, the pattern of leadership development today is one where the chosen few are given relatively brief assignments of 2, maybe 3 years in areas specifically where they have no domain expertise or knowledge. So they’re put into environments purposefully where they do not have any expertise. The point of that exercise is to ensure that they develop a listening and learning capability early in their leadership development cycle. So that pattern of learning and adapting to the immediate context that they’re in is ingrained, is developed at the earliest stages of their career. Therefore, learning and listening are the central themes in leadership development in major organizations. Now I’m gonna stop there because there are 10 other things I’d like to say, but I want to maybe put that point on the table and specifically mention that, perhaps, unfortunately, that model may not work as well for the IT world because IT leaders are domain experts generally. They are people who have deep knowledge in the areas in which they’re leading. So it may be that this model that’s being used for general management leadership is not as appropriate for IT leaders.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:23]:
So Steve and Bill, great point here, but Steve, what I have heard is as part of you resetting your thinking, you could extract yourself from your day to day operations and go out and draw on a white sheet of paper. Or you fundamentally switch your role to become a business leader, take a sabbatical from IT, and come back. So those are I would still call them tactics, but that doesn’t take away a person’s ability to deal with the next new thing which is gonna come after you’ve taken your sabbatical and your back. It’s not like a one-time reset.

questions as a leader’s best tool 7:58

Steven Burrell [00:07:58]:
Well, I think, to Bill’s point, the question’s probably the most powerful technology of all. Our ability to go out there as leaders and be able to form up the right questions is certainly more valuable to us than providing the answers, at least in my experience, and it’s pretty easy to do in a higher education environment. Questions and questioning is really the basis of the whole premise of higher education, and so I think we can use those kinds of fundamental lessons to get out there particularly when we’re addressing that new and good thing. CIOs have to realize that there is no way in this day and age that we can possess all of the knowledge and all of the answers. So it’s about the questions. It’s about surrounding ourselves with people who also know how to ask good questions. It’s about developing the people skills, the soft skills in people. We’ve done some specific things to do that here because it’s a balance between having that deep technical knowledge and the ability to engage people in a meaningful conversation, that really cuts through some of the issues when it comes to is this really important to us? Is this the most important thing for us to be working on here and now? And that conversation happens at the executive level, and it happens at a very fundamental front line level as well.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:44]:
So even though we are calling this as okay we are CIO Talk Network, so we talk about technology leaders, and Bill, to your point at what you worked on in general leadership and management, and let’s keep the discussion to that because at the end of the day, leadership, whether you come from IT or any other domain, it’s about influence, and it’s about being able to ask the right questions to your point, Steve, and be able to know where you’re going or at least that’s the perception the rest of them get. I’m not telling you, you’re gonna trick the rest other people, but at least you know how to tackle something, but when you are short of ideas on what’s coming next or how you’re gonna deal with what’s coming next, you are essentially not being seen as a leader and rightfully so, but you have to get back to that level by doing something. The goal here is to find what’s that something someone will do who is gonna be temporarily demoted because of something totally new, which the person has never encountered, is encountered by this individual, and this person is gonna react in a certain way or rather respond in a certain way. So, Bill, if I were to ask you, if someone like a very, very competent, very experienced technology or even otherwise business leader has this situation, how is this person supposed to respond to that?

strong teams and enterprise context 11:04

Bill Davidson [00:11:04]:
Wonderful. This is a very, very good point. It’s the heart of really the work that we do with a lot of organizations, and I think it’s a bit situational, of course. So my first reaction would be, how strong is your team in this situation that you described? This uncertain kind of environment, new different environment that the leader is dealing with. How strong is your team? That’s a key question, and let me make it difficult. Let’s say that you do not really have the expertise on your team to deal with the situation that you’re describing. Our immediate reaction to that, I remember tending to work with large, frankly global 100 organizations. So the next step in that process for leadership is to identify the best resources available within the extended organization, and to Steve’s comment, we actively support asking for help from the best resources that we can identify initially within the organization, and, of course, that then extends beyond. So we’re gonna rely on our team to the extent that’s possible, bring them along, of course, and develop them in the process, but if we don’t have the resources and the expertise immediately at hand, then we gotta go to the extended organization and beyond that to external resources. That’s the role of the leader in that situation with one other key component I might add. That is the leader has to bring what Steve referenced, has to bring what we call the enterprise context to this situation, which is an understanding indeed of the organization’s broader, long term strategy, vision, the current initiatives that are underway, the desired future state of that organization. All of those things have to be brought to the table as you’re considering actions and steps to be taken in the situation you’re in. If the leader does not have that enterprise context, we have a very serious problem. So that’s the piece that has to come to the table with that leader. The rest of it can be learned.

Steven Burrell [00:13:23]:
So, Bill, I couldn’t agree more. I really think that’s very insightful. I think it’s why the CIO has to fight for the opportunity to sit at the strategic table, at least in higher education or institutions, and I’m sure increasingly in enterprise businesses. So I think that’s an important aspect and it can be articulated, but in that context, one of leadership’s key responsibilities is to connect frontline work in these teams that Bill talked about with their purpose and connecting their day to day activities with these greater strategies and mission and vision and outcomes and creating at the same time a culture of accountability and innovation and teamwork towards that. So that’s really highly important, and I think to his point as well, in higher education, we have great opportunities. We may be competitors on the football and basketball court, football field, soccer field, etcetera, but many of us are highly collaborative in exchange, but yet our cultures, over the years, have been one of this is my domain, this is my area of expertise, I’ll figure it out, I’ll read the manual, and my sense of value to the institution is in my technical wisdom and technical depth. What I’ve found is we have to turn that around. We have to embrace those individuals and say reach out for help. You’ve got colleagues that are solving these same kinds of problems, peers at these other institutions solving the same kinds of problems. There’s no value in you reading the book. The value is an outcome towards the mission, and higher education is ripe for that, but culturally, many of us are still ingrained to that in our teams.

Sanjog Aul [00:15:23]:
Let’s talk about this subject a little more, and I wanted to throw in a variable which perhaps is the core of what we’re talking today: it’s not the same old same old. You don’t have the capabilities existing in the company. The teams are strong, but they may have other attributes, but they don’t have the wherewithal to deal with what’s coming ahead. So leader and the team and the management and the foresight and the strategy, everything is hazy or weak given what the unknown or uncharted territories we are entering and the variables which are thrown at us. So your responses when we come back from the break would be great if we incorporate that uncertainty, that lack of ability versus what we have been dealing with so far.

Sanjog Aul [00:18:12]:
So, Bill, of course, your response was spot on in terms of what a company would do when they had some clarity or some capability, which is very well defined that you need for a company, but when you’re in a state of flux, when the business models are changing, the customer expectations are changing, the capability requirements are changing, the compliance regulation mandates are changing, privacy and security related issues are changing or expectations are changing. Then at that time, we really cannot benchmark a team, a leader, a partner based on anything that we did in the past. With that haziness, how does one move forward, and how do you prevent a leader from losing their nerve and having a nervous breakdown for that matter?

reference points versus true frontier problems 18:57

Bill Davidson [00:18:57]:
I want to start actually halfway to that because, in experience, I want to say that, in fact, I believe that in most cases, the models, the processes that we are searching for do exist out there. They do already exist and can be benchmarked and can be replicated, and I would argue that applies to the vast majority of the frontier situations that companies are facing. So that’s a position we can debate and discuss, but I believe they’re out there, and frankly, if you find the guys who are doing the state of the art work, I’ll share it, but I think these things have largely been addressed. Most of these challenges have been addressed elsewhere. Now having said that, if you’re in that state, then your job indeed is to find those reference points and embrace them, learn from them, and translate them into your environment. No small feat, frankly. I think that covers most of the situations that we’re going to be dealing with as leaders. Now, if you do find yourself in the situation that true frontier environment that you just described, where the solutions do not exist, where you are really out there, that’s breakthrough territory. That requires a certain caliber of leadership that is in fact, as you indicate, really going to take extensive courage to address and resources and institutional support, etcetera. That’s a very challenging situation that you just described. Requires a very special breed of leadership.

Sanjog Aul [00:20:35]:
And it’s not about just nature issue. We are talking about someone would not suddenly come out as a special breed of very courageous leader. That courage or that approach to be able to keep yourself sane while dealing with those situations could be a function of nurture or the mindset or whatever training and experience or what the organization does to them. So that said, Steve, if I were to come back and talk about this ignorant leadership, so if you have everything which is so much in flux that you don’t know what the heck do I do, is the first thing to just drop all of that and say, I’m not gonna care about what’s the uncertainty and what cannot be done and that’s where I embrace ignorance as bliss and just be foolish, be stupid as Steve Jobs said, and go for the kill. Is that what’s gonna apply?

balancing wisdom with bold bets 21:25

Steven Burrell [00:21:25]:
Well, I think there’s a balance there. There is a certain amount of wisdom, I think. I played football in college and so I quote Vince Lombardi and others too much because there’s a lot of stuff I learned outside the classroom on that field. He said that success doesn’t always go to the bigger, faster, stronger man, but ultimately to the individual or the player who believed that he could. So I think there’s this sense of positivism and preparation and that allows us to prepare our teams to embrace some of these new and exciting things. In many ways, we’re trying to reinvent higher education right now. We’re looking at all sorts of models and technologies and processes and business processes to help students succeed and to turn out students from our institutions who are job ready. One of the things that holds us back that I think you have to get to right away, and Peter Drucker said it, culture eats strategy for breakfast. So I don’t think you can ignore these things. I think there are specific things that you have to go for that do not have solutions in the marketplace having looked and studied and asked the questions of people, gotten through the market conversations about what’s real and not real, to identify specific opportunities, and then to embrace your teams as Bill said, it’s all about the strength of that team and are they prepared to do this. It’s not cheap. It’s an expensive venture. It takes time to innovate. It takes time to do these things and experiment even in agile like environments, and pivoting people off of things like the old waterfall methodologies that we’re so comfortable with. Changing people’s minds at the programming levels. The programmers have to become integrators now, and we’ve got to move system administrators into systems analyst jobs who can go out and use their soft skills to actually engage people to learn what’s needed. This is heavy lifting, but in niche areas specifically, I think it’s absolutely necessary, and realizing that you may not be successful in the long run. So these are the risks I think you take, but we just can’t ignore the opportunities in front of us or say there’s no solution out there when there’s a bigger better problem to solve here for a greater purpose.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:08]:
So being a leader cannot keep playing the leader role or just fake being a leader if they wanted to learn. They have to actually become students to get to know what the new is and what they will have to do to earn their stripes back again for being a leader, but then at the same time, they’re supposed to take care of things that are going on. Do you think organizations have created a way by which they allow that bubble where the leader becomes a student again and repurposes themselves for the newer age ahead and allow them to make mistakes, etcetera.

Bill Davidson [00:24:47]:
Well, I really think the situational learning is ongoing all the time. That’s part of the model of the leadership journey that most organizations are putting together. So your situational learning is a full time job. I think what you’re describing really relates more to a strategic context. Are we fundamentally innovating our business model, business processes, position in the marketplace, our customer value proposition, etcetera, and that’s where more of this kind of broader external learning you’re talking about comes in. That is a challenge. You have got to get outside your organization, frankly, I believe to go through that kind of learning process. So I think that’s where we may have some gaps for leaders, some need. How do you get exposed to these kinds of inputs? I think one of the areas that can be particularly fruitful for that is the peer advisory group structures that are out there, and there are quite a number for leaders. Being part of a group of progressive peers who may not be from your industry, if they’ll be from other businesses, guys who are experiencing these same kind of challenges, we use that model quite heavily for this kind of external learning.

Sanjog Aul [00:26:27]:
So I can give you an example of me moderating quite a few discussions around the globe and talking about this uncertainty and this digital world that we are living in and everything is in flux. There are some areas that I poll the audience on and literally not even a single person in the room raises a hand that they have a handle on it. So God bless us. How are we create any advisory group where everybody is scratching their head.

Bill Davidson [00:26:56]:
I like it, but think about that situation you just described though. Isn’t it helpful when you’re wrestling with something and you’re really lost at sea perhaps on that topic to talk to some people who are also wrestling with it? Won’t those conversations be fruitful? We’re thinking about this. We’re trying that. What about that? I think that can still be extremely helpful. To talk with peers. Now the other piece of this is go find the domain experts inside or outside. The guys who are the best in this particular area that you’re working in. If it does not exist, if this is really a de novo area, you’re in breakthrough space. You need a breakthrough mindset. You’re going to shape this thing. You’re going to define it. You’re going to create the solutions. Certain people are up for that game. Others are not. Many organizations are not up for that game because it’s such a high risk environment. That’s a venture capital kind of environment that we’re in. There is going to be a lot of failure, and frankly, no matter what we say, most large established organizations are not up for that game. They’re not up for a game where your success rate is 50/50 at best.

Sanjog Aul [00:28:14]:
So, Steve, if I were to ask you, given the unique environments that I’m referring to, I’m sure that you’ve got quite a bit of your portfolio which could be based on what you’ve learned over the years and which is still more predictable, but there are new areas that are getting introduced in almost every domain today, every industry vertical today, which are unnerving and where you don’t have a precedence, which you can go for. There is no subject matter expertise which you can bank on. So if you were to approach that, are you going to be the lone warrior who’s gonna take your own sandbox and experiment till you turn blue to find out whatever you find out and then implement? Is that how you’re gonna approach it? Because you still have to play the leader in your company and this position. If you’ll be in that position where things are not the regular ones, these are brand new areas and there is no support available from outside, what are you expected? What’s your expectation from you from the rest of the world out there? How would you react to it? How would you demonstrate your leadership?

keeping operations solid while experimenting 29:19

Steven Burrell [00:29:19]:
Well, I think, first of all, I’m going to take half a step back and then I’m going to get to that. CIOs are hired for strategy and fired for operations. So before you step out into that unknown area, you have to make sure that your operations are solid. The trains have to be running on time, because at the end of the day, those become huge distractions to anything else that the CIO is going on. So you’ve got to put good people in place, get good processes there, and make sure that your day to day ops are solid. That done, I think you become an outward facing CIO. There’s a couple of areas you can go with. There’s somebody out there who’s also thinking like you are. Troll Twitter feeds, peers, other organizations, get outside the United States, for example. There’s some tremendous things going on outside of here and some real innovative thinking that just doesn’t make it into our mainstream media space or dialogue. So leverage the internet, make some friends. Then surround yourself and create a group within your organization of people who are inquisitive, experimental; carve out time in the operations for people to free themselves from the drudgery of day to day and embrace some of these ideas. I’m fond of calling things pilots and really working in what we refer to as a skunk works in some of our military type things. There’s an opportunity for that. I tend to keep it a little isolated. We experiment and share with others who are interested in this. Blockchain is probably a really good example out there today. Keep leadership informed of what you’re doing, but keeping those trains running on time is going to keep them off of your back. Experimentation is at the core of what we should be doing, frankly. Knowing that technology is a fundamentally human thing, that it exists for the sole purposes of enhancing humanity, leverage your human resources to embrace these problems. We also often go out there experimentally and ask our customers, ask our students to participate in these activities. We’re pretty clear about setting expectations there, but they bring marvelous new ideas to play in a sandbox that’s relatively safe. Then we prove some things out. 80% of the time, there’s nothing to show for it and we move on. So that idea of failing fast, failing quickly, certainly comes into play. Keep the trains running on time. Set aside some time to integrate and interface with people out there. There’s a ton of ideas that we can execute on. Find those things that are most purposeful to your mission, vision, and purpose.

Sanjog Aul [00:32:42]:
So, Bill, when we look at any leader who is successful, one of the things that they do well is they pick up the battles which they can win. It’s not that they only want to win, but they will not unnecessarily go about solving world’s hunger problem or things which they cannot really have full control over, but then when we are talking about the newer environment that we are, the percentage of the challenges that they are dealing with today. The more of the challenges seem like the ones which are the impossible types. What should the leaders do then? Should they just use their traditional wisdom approach of only picking up the battles, or they just jump in remaining ignorant?

fixed targets focus learning 33:27

Bill Davidson [00:33:27]:
Well, one of the things that comes to mind is that somewhat of a related point, but I think in my view, it comes back to the subtitle of the book Breakthrough, like the outrageous objectives point. It is really important as you’re in these fluid spaces to have a target. The targets are essential; they focus everyone forward. You may not have the solution, the program, the operational capability to get to that target yet, but you have a very specific target and that should remain fixed. Once you have the target, then it focuses your learning efforts. When somebody brings something to you, you immediately can determine whether it’s going to be helpful or not. It makes decision making much simpler as opposed to, well, let’s try this or let’s try that. So the leader can help here again by developing the target and perhaps even a broader preferred future state vision that we want to get to. At that point, we’re going to be able to take in contributions from various parties much more efficiently. We’re going to be able to dedicate resources to specific projects that support the creation of that future state. I think all of this then becomes a much more fruitful exercise as opposed to simply a learning exercise. It’s applied learning for a specific target that the leader is going to put in place. So I think that’s a big part of the exercise here to make this fluid, uncertain world purposeful.

Sanjog Aul [00:35:07]:
So when you mention future state, that is again taking an assumption that people have clarity on this is how the customers are going to be and that the ecosystem is going to be. People are not even thinking beyond 18 months now. So would you still define that as a future state or is that around the corner state?

Bill Davidson [00:35:28]:
Yeah. That’s interesting. We tend to think in terms of you don’t want to be too far out with your long-term vision. So we tend to think about 3 years, but with 1 year cycles in it. So you’re looking out because the kinds of things we’re talking about in many of these cases, you can’t do in a year even if everything’s perfect. So you’re going to have intermediate stops on the way, but don’t go so far out with your vision that it becomes intangible. Here’s where we want to get to in a 3 year time frame. Here’s where we want to be in 1 year. Here’s where we want to be in 2 years. After 1 year, of course, you’ll be making some adjustments because of what you’ve learned and what you’ve seen so far, and you’re iterating as you go, but hopefully your target isn’t changing at the end of the cycle.

Steven Burrell [00:36:18]:
Yeah. Bill, I think you’ve hit spot on with what we’re thinking here and what I’ve seen as being successful. We’ve pulled back from those long term to us is 36 months now from a strategic planning standpoint. Annually within that strategic plan, we identify key result areas, not more than 5, 6, or 7. One of those key result areas is something on the innovative cutting edge. We tend to focus people around that particular key result area because it’s tied to outcomes of the university or bigger strategies. Then we riff on that every year and that allows us to ride the flow, ride the white water in a way that allows us to be highly nimble, but at the same time attend to the business at hand.

Bill Davidson [00:37:22]:
I was just going to say that’s really a great short summary of how you go about it. Outstanding, and I think I would just reinforce the 5 to 6 result areas; that’s probably the maximum you should be thinking about as well.

Bill Davidson [00:37:40]:
If I could add one more thing, I’d add that 5 to 6. I would say, yes indeed, at least one should be major innovation. At least one, hopefully more, should be immediate customer impact. Another one should be an efficiency impact. So think about the mix of the targets that you’re putting on the table. Well said.

Sanjog Aul [00:38:03]:
Let’s bring focus back on the very leader, the human that we are talking about, and with them dealing with quite a few challenges, the confidence, the empathy, the creativity, whatever are the core attributes you expect out of a leader, they start taking a hit, and when that happens, the leadership influence and the potential and the perception all starts dwindling. How should that leader in that situation deal with it? And Steve, you live it. I’m sure many other leaders that you deal with, Bill, would love to get a feedback on how people are seeing that dip. How are they reporting that dip? And how are they fighting it and coming out successful if they are?

Sanjog Aul [00:40:50]:
So, Steve, I’m sure you would have had situations yourself. At your discretion, please share what have you done when you’ve come across situations which are totally hitting you from the left field, surprise you, don’t have the capability in house or in you. What’s the best way you train yourself or treat yourself in that situation so that you continue to deliver as a leader on the things you’re supposed to, but also be able to effectively deal with this totally new unprecedented incident or situation?

owning surprises and building trust 41:23

Steven Burrell [00:41:23]:
Sure. I think the first thing you have to recognize is that things are going to come out of left field. You’re going to mess it up. You’re going to miss something important. There’s going to be a project that goes sideways. There’s going to be something that hits you on a compliance side that just blindsides you or an audit you had no idea was going to happen. From a leadership position, you have to be truthful about it. You have to be honest. You have to put yourself out there. Interestingly enough, I don’t think being vulnerable in this aspect is really a weakness. I think it’s about building trust. I think it’s about being honest. So when a project goes south here or we’ve been through a security audit and we’ve got this gaping hole that escaped us for whatever reasons, I think you got to own up to it. Say look, this is a surprise to me. I don’t understand it, and then say here’s what I intend to do about it. Some of those intents for me are usually I’m going to talk to peers. I’m going to find out what best practices are. I’m going to rally my troops. Maybe I’m going to invoke our project management office to provide some structure over this, but you’ve got to be able to articulate certain steps, and then finally to say here’s where I want to be 3 months from now, 6 months from now, a year from now to get out there or get ahead of something. Then go back to those teams that have been so important to us and explain the situation. Be honest to them. What is our role here? What are we responding to? What are the expectations of us? And be real clear about that and solicit their input. I could probably go into a lot of examples, but these kinds of things come at us every day, small or big, and I think at the core of it, heroics is not a sustainable model. CIOs can’t be heroes, and here’s the other thing. Mark Twain said you could know more and more about less and less until you knew everything about nothing or less and less about more and more till you know nothing about everything. The CIO’s gotta put yourself in the middle of that somewhere and then surround yourself with peers, mentors, capable people, resources, experts that are going to help you bridge those gaps, and again, it goes back to what I said earlier. Ask the good questions. So it happens to me every day.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:24]:
So Bill, the biggest challenge with any leader will be to shed the belief that what got them here will not get them there, which is actually a book by Marshall Goldsmith, but then the unlearning part of whatever they did, while it may be working partially for what they were doing as part of their portfolio, that’s not going to work for the rest. They cannot have two sets of so called leadership methodologies, two sets of personalities to deal with the old and the new. They have to migrate to the new. So how do leaders, whether they come from IT or from business, shed their old skin to wear the new?

shedding old habits for a portfolio of models 45:04

Bill Davidson [00:45:04]:
That is the central thesis in the work that we do. It is as clear a statement of the reality of the situation for leaders as anything out there. When you look at that process, we tend to go into a full immersion retooling exercise. That is not something you do while you’re on the job. You need to step back. You need to go through a retooling process, and we have formal mechanisms for doing that for leaders as they go about this. In the general management model we’re talking about, remember the leaders are going through 2 or 3 year cycles in new situations. So there is a transition phase between each of those positions. There are formal retooling exercises that we go through before we go into the new situation. How you do this in real time in place, that’s a much more difficult exercise. I would come back and say, however, my world is the global management world, and we teach a multimodal leadership model. The model is when you come into any situation, the first step is to assess, understand the context, assess, adapt, and act. In that model, you might have your old management and leadership model that is relevant in some settings, and you might have a new management and leadership model that you’re using elsewhere. So sooner or later, you’re going to get into a portfolio approach to what you’re doing as a leader. You’re going to need multiple models that you can use with different parts of the portfolio and different people in your team, extended team and in your extended organization. Those are skills we need to develop as leaders, and we need to be able to dial in the appropriate mode that we’re using to be most effective in a variety of different situations. If I could just take one more point, back to the two most challenging environments, the first reaction to that point would be to simply ask how big a part of your portfolio is that extremely challenging situation? If it is your entire portfolio, if you are dedicated to one particular endeavor and you are in that extremely challenging environment, you better go find some help because that is going to be hugely challenging and difficult. If it’s a smaller piece over here, you may come back and say I’m going to write this one off. Then you have to go through the leadership role that’s appropriate for terminating something, disbanding a team, repurposing a team, etcetera. So I think all those points are correct. The sooner you get to a portfolio mindset on this, the better off you’ll be as a leader.

Sanjog Aul [00:48:13]:
So when you’re using the word leadership here, one thing I wanted to clarify, what you said, Bill, is more of a management versus leadership because here you’re talking portfolio rationalization. I’m taking it to a level above, which is leadership, which is a mindset, which is an approach to how you handle anything. That could not have a portfolio approach, and I want to come to you, Steve, on this: would you at all ever take an approach of how you think depending on what you’re dealing with, with your principles, your values, your core attributes that you bank upon to do anything as a leader? You would not shift those based on what you’re dealing with. It has to be the same set of values, and that’s what we are trying to rewire a leader for the time ahead.

Steven Burrell [00:49:01]:
I think the full immersion model that Bill described is a great approach and ultimately a great way to do it, but most of us don’t have the luxury of doing it. It’s difficult. Holding that mirror up, knowing yourself, doing that self examination, knowing what those core principles are. The analogy of the snake shedding its skin is very good because in order to grow, we have to shed that skin, and we have to do it on a regular basis. The faster we grow, the faster we’re shedding. How do we do that around these principles when most of us don’t have this full immersion capability? A couple of ideas. One, I set aside time every morning, 20 minutes. Let what’s new out there? How does this relate to me? How does it relate to my core values? Am I thinking about this right? Maybe I write a colleague I haven’t talked to in a long time say, hey, I was just reading about blockchain and I was thinking this, what’s your point of view? Asking that question. The other one that’s really good is recognizing that in the end we’re ignorant about something in our leadership capacity. Shadow a colleague, shadow a staff member, shadow a student, shadow a faculty member. Find a relationship there and just say look I want to see things from your point of view and your lens for today. It’s an amazing way to get outside of your own skin, to walk in somebody else’s moccasins for a day or two to see the world from their point of view. Do that with the discipline to do that on a somewhat regular basis. I think you’ll find yourself changing, and you’ll find yourself adapting your leadership style and your capabilities, your technology choices, your processes, in a much better way.

Sanjog Aul [00:51:15]:
Now, Bill, when we come back to the different ways or different environments that we’re going to deal with, if you were to look across the portfolio clients that you may work with or the deep thinking you would have done as part of writing your book, what is the mental state that this new leader (I’m not saying the leader is new, but the environment that they have is new) so the new leadership approach which will work well for the times ahead, what would the mental state be? How would we define a mental state that somebody should embrace for them to be relevant for the times ahead?

the mindset for uncertain times 51:51

Bill Davidson [00:51:51]:
Wonderful. My world is primarily around a global environment and an emerging technology or an innovation project model. I’m talking about that particular kind of environment, not the operational mode. The qualities we’re going to need: first that comes to mind is mental agility, the ability to shift from A to B to C. I think that’s going to be important. I think you come back to having a depth of experience and as a substitute for a depth of experience, a very deep broad network that has been developed, cultivated, and is maintained and is accessible as needed. That quality is underrated. That’s not genetic; that’s something you build. Your personal network is critical here. So I think those two pieces are the first things I would reference. Think about what’s going to take to be successful in the kind of environment that we’re in. I would also say frankly so much of this is about uncertainty and secondarily about risk. There are people who are simply not well suited for highly uncertain or risky environments. So this is some self knowledge that Steve referenced: you better be knowledgeable about your own ability to handle uncertainty and risk. If you’re not comfortable in that setting and you’re not able to get comfortable in that setting, it’s not for you. So we better be looking at people who are able to handle diverse, fluid, dynamic environments that are fundamentally uncertain and risky. Better love it; better have a natural love and passion for dynamic and highly uncertain environments and a love of learning about what’s going to happen in these places.

Sanjog Aul [00:54:12]:
One final question I have for you, Steve, and I have only 30 seconds. If you could give me the one word that comes to mind which will symbolize the personality of the new age leader or the mindset they should wear, what would that one word be?

Steven Burrell [00:54:32]:
I think you have to be an entrepreneur. I think you have to think about the agility that Bill spoke to and the willingness to fail, to be honest with yourself, to celebrate and build upon what has been successful in the past. That’s the one word that comes to mind from a new leadership paradigm.

Contributors

Steven Burrell

Steven Burrell, Vice President and Chief Information officer, Northern Arizona University

Dr. Steven Burrell’s has more than 35 years of higher education technology leadership experience holding positions at Colorado State University, Hutchinson Community College (Kansas), Plymouth State University (New Hampshire), Saint Leo U... More   View all posts
Bill Davidson

Bill Davidson, Author, Breakthrough: How Great Companies set Outrageous Objectives – and Achieve Them

Bill Davidson started his career as an academic. Before his extra-curricular activities prevailed, he served as a tenured Professor at USC from 1985 to 1996. An active researcher and writer, he was acknowledged as the most widely cited aca... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

TECHM - CSRM - MPU01 - 300x250
Steven Burrell