Legal & Compliance • Digital Transformation

eDiscovery: Best Practices and Trends

How confident are enterprises about their eDiscovery capabilities? What are the best technology solutions supporting eDiscovery? What best practices should be followed? Among enterprises and law practices, what are the top trends for the handling of technology driven eDiscovery?

Contributor

Download Podcast
Apple Podcast, Google Podcast, Spotify, Pandora, iHeartRadio, SoundCloud, TuneIn, and Stitcher. Find other syndication channels here or search CIO Talk Network podcast on any other app.
Explore More

Transcript

Sanjog Aul:
Welcome listeners. This is Sanjog Aul, your host, and the topic for today’s conversation is eDiscovery best practices and trends, and I have with me Vivian Tero. Vivian is the Program Director for Governance, Risk, and Compliance Infrastructure Service with IDC. Hello, Vivian. Thank you for joining us.

Vivian Tero:
Hi, Sanjog. Thank you for having me and good afternoon to everyone.

Sanjog Aul:
Good afternoon to you. So the life and your work, how is that going?

Vivian Tero:
It’s been going very well. It’s very busy. It’s summertime, so we try to get out as much as we can after work, of course.

Sanjog Aul:
Great, great. So, as the topic that we picked up today, eDiscovery best practices and trends, basically what we are trying to do is to identify what is eDiscovery’s value proposition and what are the organizations doing to make the most use of this phenomena and/or this approach to handling litigations effectively. Now, the first question I’ll have for you here is that what are the most pressing eDiscovery issues for enterprises? Where do you think they struggle the most?

Vivian Tero:
So I guess let me set the context first. Like eDiscovery is a process and it requires, close collaboration between the litigant, and in this case, let’s talk about, corporate litigants, specifically their in-house counsel who take the lead from the side of the corporate litigant, as well as the outside counsel or, their batteries of outside counsels to help them figure out how to best address a litigation event. So when we look at the process of eDiscovery, it’s not necessarily going to be something that’s coming, that’s coming out of the plaintiff’s bar. eDiscovery also takes place when you have a request for information from any regulatory agency. So all these SEC investigations, for example, they are considered litigation events, and in many instances, companies have to put in place a process for eDiscovery. Now, with regards to challenges, The challenges for a lot of companies stems from the fact that if you are a serial litigant, they face a lot of requests for information and complaints from the plaintiff bar over a short period of time.

Vivian Tero:
As for them, it’s managing that process, managing the deluge of data and information, because I’ve heard a lot of lawyers refer to finding the relevant information in eDiscovery as trying to find a needle in a haystack. They’ve got a very specific amount of time wherein they have to respond to the event, but in order to respond properly in order to determine the appropriate legal response to an event, they need to understand what’s going on, but in order to understand what’s going on, they need to find the right individuals and the right information who can point them so that they can properly assess the risk as well as the merits of a specific case.

Sanjog Aul:
So would you say in an enterprise, they are basically banking too much on law firms and/or any outside parties to be able to help with eDiscovery? And are there any specific area they feel that they’re struggling the most?

Vivian Tero:
So, the old model for eDiscovery was having the outside law firms taking the lead in terms of crafting together the strategy, and the strategy not just for eDiscovery, but also with the data management process around it, which is, finding the information, and because that’s where most of their challenges are these days. They get so bogged down in the minutiae about finding the information that in many instances they have no more time to actually understand and assess the information so that they can respond accordingly. That has changed. It’s changed a lot because the 2006 amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure came into place and it clearly defined what is ESI, what is discoverable, what is undiscoverable. It basically sets a lot of the ground rules in terms of how corporations are supposed to litigant corporations are supposed to engage with each other. So, and increasingly because of the traditional model wherein, or wherein where they farmed out everything to an outside law firm or to a third-party service provider was very expensive. The pricing models was all based on per Gigabyte, time and materials. In many instances, when they had to do a discovery, especially if they’re doing serial discovery, they may be looking at the same sort of data or a subset of the sort of data.

Vivian Tero:
So a lot of these corporations started to figure out, you know what? let’s see if there are some efficiencies that we can adopt. So in many instances, they’ve started putting together some processes in place to how to best handle the data management aspect, how to best handle the litigation response, the legal hold activities that they need to do, and in doing that, they’ve started taking control of the eDiscovery process, and so I’m sure you’ve heard about how over the last 3 or 4 years, because the corporate counsel’s office also have limited budgets, and so the pricing models, how they negotiate with their outside law firms and their third-party litigation support service providers, they’ve changed, and so you hear a lot about these alternative pricing or fixed pricing arrangements, and in many instances, if a company really wants to take control of discovery, one of their primary motivations is also to make sure that regardless of where the case is located, they want to have have a sneak they’d have to have some sort of standardized response. So a good example would be, and obviously I can’t mention the names of some of these organizations, let’s say this very this insurance company.

Vivian Tero:
So when I spoke to their corporate counsel’s office, they basically said they’ve put together a process in place for certain types of cases. So if you’re an insurance company, obviously you’ve got different kinds of insurance claims, for example, and different kinds of litigation. So they wanted to be sure that if there’s a specific claim was filed in the Midwest, for example, they had the process that they used to respond to those claims was similar if that case was also filed by a different individual, let’s say in Seattle or in some other part of the country because I guess before they had these standardized processes and protocols in place, there was no consistency in terms of how they would respond to some of these standard claims. So that was one of the things that they wanted. In many cases, there are companies that have very because they’re serial litigants, they have to have they deal with a lot of matters consistently, some very complex matters where they have to work with multiple outside law firms, but at the same time, they have their own internal processes, and so managing multiple outside law firms, managing their own internal activities in place, they wanted again to have some standardized process in place because It’s a coordination effort, and having policies and processes in place allows them to do that.

Vivian Tero:
So what they do is they start working with perhaps 3, 4, or 5 trusted outside counsel and trusted third-party service providers, and they come to some sort of arrangement, and the arrangement really comes to, having these trusted advisors become very familiar with the information infrastructure, for example, of a specific organization, and this is pretty common with a lot of these in the very large, very serial litigants, what they typically do is if they have already identified the top 5 outside law firms and the top 5 service providers that they would work with, there’s usually for the outside lawyers, there’s usually probably 1 or 2 attorneys that are assigned to work very closely with the client to understand the client’s information management infrastructure, their practices, their policies, so whenever there’s a discovery event, they know exactly how to work with a team in terms of crafting together an eDiscovery response, and in terms of crafting those policies and practices, it’s consistent regardless of which law firm they would use.

Sanjog Aul:
All right, so now what are the top eDiscovery technology trends that you find?

Vivian Tero:
In terms of the technology trends, I think the hot topic right now is what is known as computer assisted technology review, which is very actually large scale review, or in some cases they call it predictive coding, and there are many approaches to it, but without getting too technical about it, what they’re really trying to do is they’re trying because as I mentioned before, let me set the context for this. In the past, it was pretty common for organizations to have average collections per matter of maybe 100-200 Gigabyte. Over the last 2 or 3 years, I’ve seen a huge jump in the number of corporations who say that their average collection of raw data matter was more than 2.5 Terabytes. So from 100 to 150 to 2.5 Terabytes, that’s a pretty big jump, and so it becomes economically unsustainable to have a large battery of reviewers go through that data, especially at a very short amount of time, and so there are these technologies in place that enable these organizations to do the analysis, do the data mining, understand relationships, and do so consistently and defensively, and so, this is the intent of, what they call this predictive coding technology.

Vivian Tero:
So, at the end of the day, what this coding technology tries to do is it uses machine learning, it uses clustering so that once they have built out or understood how, I would say, a subject matter expert would review a particular matter, the machine learns from that so that going forward, once they’ve taken out and built out the model using the sample set from the documents, and they’ve developed enough confidence in the algorithms and in the predictive code, to apply that to the entire corpus, that’s when the machine comes in. So basically they’re saying that instead of having 100 lawyers review 2.5 Terabytes of data, what they would do is perhaps get a subset, maybe 1%, 2%, 5% of the sample from that 2.5 Terabytes of data, have the right experts review and code it and see if and then program use the predictive coding technologies to model the decisions, the subject matter experts, the human reviewers, and in doing so, and then tweak it because it’s, it’s machine learning. So it becomes more intelligent as the samples become more sophisticated.

Sanjog Aul:
Let’s take a quick break. We’ll be right back.

Vivian Tero:
All right.

Speaker C:
Take control of eDiscovery with flexible integrated solutions designed for early data assessment processing, document review, and litigation presentation. LexisNexis offers comprehensive solutions that work together as well as with other industry-leading tools to help you maintain a seamless chain of custody throughout discovery. Most of these solutions can be offered in a hosted environment with access to fully customizable support resources dedicated to your success. You are listening to CIO Talk Radio Viewpoint.

Sanjog Aul:
Welcome back, Vivian. So what are the standard best practices that are established for eDiscovery and that enterprises can adopt today?

Vivian Tero:
So there’s 3 things that basically a serial litigant should have in place. First of all, they should have an information governance program in place where the governance really covers all types of ESI, and not just ESI, but also physical based information as well. So your paper based information, because in many instances, we find that companies do not have consistent information management practices between the physical as well as the digital version of the data, and when that happens, they could potentially get dinged on that when they’re negotiating with the opposing party. The second thing that they need to have is they have to have a legal hold practice in place, and when it says legal hold, they shouldn’t just keep everything forever. They should have a practice in place that they also have a protocol to dispose of the data when it’s no longer important because, the matter has closed

Vivian Tero:
and in many instances, we find companies who are overpreserving, but they don’t really know how much they’re overpreserving because they haven’t inventoried it. Or in many instances, there was no protocol in place on how to do preservation. It wasn’t properly documented, and it becomes it can it’s a potentially risky strategy for them because if they keep everything forever without having a proper disposition protocol once the matter is closed, it opens up another it could potentially open up another can of worms. The third thing is having they need to have a legal hold response, an eDiscovery response team in place as well. So a lot of these standards and protocols are really just some sort of protection for the companies so that when they go and negotiate with the opposing party, they’ve got their ducks in a row, they know what issues they have, and it becomes easier for them, or at least they’re in a better negotiating position when they start figuring out what is a discovery scope, what is a discovery strategy, because it can get potentially expensive. To the extent that they know as much as they can about where the data is, what the data is, whether it’s relevant to the matter or not, they’re in a much better position to negotiate the scope of discovery because in terms of the gotchas, in many instances, companies, they track the cost of discovery from collection to review and analysis, but they don’t really know how much it costs them to do the preservation.

Vivian Tero:
In many instances, if they keep preserving a lot of data, their review costs are going to go up in addition to their preservation costs.

Sanjog Aul:
Now, how well do you think solution providers, councils, and corporations are truly working together to address eDiscovery effectively?

Vivian Tero:
So it’s an evolving issue, in many instances, for a lot of the serial litigants, they’ve started to develop these trusted advisor relationships with their key outside counsel and their service providers, and so for the most mature organizations, in many instances, the third-party service provider really, who are, and the outside counsel really helps working with them in planning out the standard, the best practice, in many instances, helping them figure out what’s the appropriate architecture, what are the staffing levels required, those sort of things. It really varies for every organization because there’s some organizations, they’re very sophisticated, they’ve got a lot of in-house expertise, whereas there are some organizations that they don’t really want to make that investment because they feel that based on their needs, maybe they just need to work very closely with another, with their outside counsel and with their trusted litigation support houses. So it really varies, but at the end of the day, they’re working closely. It’s just, it’s in a state of flux. If you notice, there’s a lot of the definition of managed service for eDiscovery has evolved to support different kinds of models.

Sanjog Aul:
Finally, one last question. How do you see eDiscovery challenges and solutions evolving over the next few years?

Vivian Tero:
So there will always be technology will continue to evolve. There’s new applications that are going to be deployed in the organization. There’s going to be new architecture models, and obviously, this impacts how data is managed, how data is going to be searched, going to be analyzed, and so, in the near term, and I’m talking, within the next 12 to maybe 24 months, if you look at what’s going on in the technology environment, all these trends around bring your own device, mobility, cloud computing, big data, the developments around this will pose some discovery challenges for a lot of organizations, and the other thing I forgot to mention is the use of social platforms. So these new technologies present unique data management challenges, and so for a lot of organizations, they have to figure out, first of all, what’s our information governance protocol so that we know what’s the acceptable use for our employees and, for our business partners

Vivian Tero:
and then secondly, if they have to do discovery in these types of environments, in these types of applications, they have to figure out how do we address chain of custody? How do we address what’s the right scope? And these sort of things. How do we address secure information sharing? So a lot of these emerging technologies, it presents opportunities for companies to improve their competitiveness, to have multiple touchpoints with their customers, but from a discovery standpoint, it also presents data management challenges for the organization, and they need to plan for that. So for like nowadays, we found in our latest survey that only 33% of companies actually have policies and programs in place to manage social platforms like Facebook, LinkedIn, those sorts of applications, as well as corporate logs. So going forward, as they expand their commercial presence in these types of environments, they have to have a program in place to address how do you do search, how do you collect collection, how do you do analysis in these types of environments?

Sanjog Aul:
Thank you so much, Vivian, for sharing your thoughts and insights about eDiscovery best practices and trends.

Vivian Tero:
It was a pleasure.

Sanjog Aul:
And listeners, I invite you to find more conversations about eDiscovery on our website at www.ciotalkradio.com/eDiscovery.

Contributors

Vivian Tero

Vivian Tero, Program Director, IDC

Vivian Tero is the Program Director for IDC's Governance, Risk & Compliance (GRC) Infrastructure service. Ms. Tero’s primary focus is research, analysis, and strategic advisory on information and system infrastructure technologies tha... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

Cigniti-Kobiton-Webinar-364776190-mobile-centric3-MPU
CIO Talk Network