This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.
About this conversation
A CIO Talk Network conversation with Kevin Burns (City of Miami), Don Phillips (City of Cleveland), hosted by Sanjog Aul.
What the conversation established
The conversation established that focus is a leadership responsibility rather than something left to each worker. Don Phillips said a city’s mission, delivering services to citizens, is the measuring stick for every project, and that his project management office approves work only when its expected value and outcome are known, so productivity is built in before anyone starts. Kevin Burns said about 5 percent of his projects are true IT projects and 95 percent are business projects with an IT component, so effectiveness matters more than sheer output, and no leader can hold 52 number one priorities. Both argued for matching assignments to a person’s strengths, or DNA, to keep people engaged, and Phillips said he puts IT staff into the field, including riding a garbage truck, to learn the work; he added that about 25 percent of his projects are not technology at all. Both called themselves digital apprentices who test smart city vendor promises against whether they serve citizens.
Host Sanjog Aul talks with Kevin Burns, Chief Information Officer, City of Miami, and Don Phillips, CIO, City of Cleveland, about how city technology leaders keep people and organizations focused when opportunities and projects arrive faster than they can absorb them. Burns and Phillips describe measuring every project against the city’s mission to serve citizens, favoring effectiveness over raw productivity, and tying each employee’s goals and objectives to the city’s strategic plan. They discuss matching assignments to a person’s strengths, pushing IT staff into the field to understand the work, and growing middle managers into digital leaders. Both describe themselves as digital apprentices who judge smart city vendor pitches by whether they actually serve citizens.
Contributors
- Kevin Burns, Chief Information Officer, City of Miami
- Don Phillips, CIO, City of Cleveland
Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network
On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript
Key takeaways
- Kevin Burns, CIO of the City of Miami, said no leader can hold 52 number one priorities at once and must prioritize projects against the city’s strategic goals. He described a flood of ideas as a distraction in the short run that becomes useful in the long run only when a game plan turns it into focus.
- Don Phillips, CIO of the City of Cleveland, said every project should be measured against the city’s core mission of delivering services to citizens. He said his project management office approves a project only when its expected value and outcome are known, so he never has to ask afterward whether the work was productive.
- Kevin Burns, CIO of the City of Miami, said effectiveness matters more than productivity because about 95 percent of his projects are business projects with an IT component and only 5 percent are true IT projects. He said the CIO role now demands business and people skills, not just technology skills.
- Don Phillips, CIO of the City of Cleveland, said leaders should match assignments to a person’s strengths and give people room to take on unfamiliar work with a mentor. He said he sends IT staff into the field, including riding a garbage truck, so they understand the work before designing a process for it.
- Don Phillips, CIO of the City of Cleveland, said he hires managers for passion over skills because skills can be trained and passion cannot, and that his job is to set the vision and then get out of the way. He cited George Patton’s idea of telling people what you want rather than how to do it.
- Kevin Burns, CIO of the City of Miami, said he and his peers are digital apprentices rather than fully formed digital leaders because they did not grow up with the technology. He said his ideal is a fully bimodal organization with a standing innovation team that every employee can rotate through.
Chapters
- 0:00 Introduction: dismissing distractions to deliver value in city government
- 3:14 Measuring every project against the city mission
- 6:17 Why you cannot have 52 number one priorities
- 16:57 Choosing effectiveness over productivity
- 22:36 Matching people to their strengths
- 30:57 Turning middle managers into digital leaders
- 35:38 Hire for passion and get out of the way
- 38:01 Leading as digital apprentices
- 42:21 Testing vendor promises for smart cities
- 48:04 The holy grail of a bimodal city team
Explore more
- Conversations that deliver results
- Creating Value at Scale
- Supporting Value Innovation
- Extracting Strategic Value from GenAI
- The State of Value-Based Care
- Understanding and meeting the value of eDiscovery
Transcript
Introduction: dismissing distractions to deliver value in city government 0:00
Sanjog Aul [00:00:22]:
So our topic for today is, Dismiss Distractions To Deliver Value. And our guests for today’s show are Kevin Burns, who is the Chief Information Officer, City of Miami. Hi, Kevin. How are you?
Sanjog Aul [00:00:52]:
And we have Don Phillips, who’s the CIO with City of Cleveland. Hi, Don. How’s life?
Sanjog Aul [00:01:02]:
So the reason we invited the two smart gentlemen here is because we feel that, as cities, you are doing a whole lot going on that, joining the bandwagon of becoming smarter or a smart city. But besides that, you have to serve the citizens. And all of that, at least in today’s day and age, looks like we are looking up to the digital or digitalization to help out, and it offers options and it has opportunities. We’ve got a number of projects that are unprecedented. But then guess what? We could be going 20 different directions, and it could cause issues with our productivity or value creation if we don’t focus properly. So we are here today to talk about distractions. How do you recognize the distractions? And how do you get hold of your focus at individual and organizational level? So Kevin, let me start with you. When we live in our world growing up, we were told that, okay, you got to charge ahead. You want to do more. You wanna become more, all of that. So the more is the mantra. Do you think with opportunities and projects and initiatives come to us and we are drinking from a fire hose, is that really helping us?
Kevin Burns [00:02:24]:
In the long run, probably it is helping us. In the short run, I think it provides a lot of those distractions; it gives us so many things to think about that you can’t concentrate enough on one particular item at a time.
Sanjog Aul [00:02:46]:
So if you are saying that in the long run now let me turn it around and ask Don. So when we are looking at anything and we’ve got as an organization, you’re trying to become a smart city or at least working towards it, and, of course, the citizens are demanding something more, you can always be looking at the resources and say, where would I put them? Where would my focus be better utilized? How do you determine even that?
Measuring every project against the city mission 3:14
Don Phillips [00:03:14]:
Well, I think you’re correct. Obviously, resources are always limited between time, money, and the actual resources to get it done. So, I think the key is, though, we have to always go back to our mission. And for city and for city services, our mission is to deliver services to our citizens. So, I think the key is to always go back and measure those projects and measure those initiatives against our core value and our core mission. And so at that point, if the business, which happens to be the city, itself is going in a direction, we have to be there with them.
Sanjog Aul [00:03:46]:
So, Kevin, when you look at your charter for the year, that you would put together, how do you look at it in terms of the focus? Because you would have quite a variety of initiatives. And we were always taught that a leader not only delivers results as a way they’re gonna rally the troops and get the projects done, but they also make sure the right type of growth and learning happens for its people. And if you are trying to get them to do way too much or maybe enough, but not with the right focus, which is aligned to their strengths, then as a result, yes, you might get to that end goal partially, but you may cause more damage because the people may not have delivered to their fullest potential and as a result, they have not grown as much. What do you have to say to that?
Kevin Burns [00:04:38]:
And I agree with what Don was saying. We always have to look at what our strategic initiatives and goals are, when we’re trying to prioritize and align projects for the current year, let’s say. So we need to take a look at those and it’s like eating an elephant. You have to take one bite at a time, before you can get to the end. So you have to look at those projects. You have to prioritize them towards the strategic goals and objectives of the city and the citizens, what they tell us to do. And then we have to kind of concentrate on those and assign the resources that are necessary to complete those projects and do it to the best of our capabilities and abilities that we have in order to be successful for each of those projects. And some of them we may have to stall a little bit or start at a little bit later date in order to provide enough resources or the proper resources to be successful.
Sanjog Aul [00:05:44]:
And would you say, Kevin, based on what you just said, is this going to the strategic when you use the word strategic, our strategic priority? That’s also determined by humans. And what comes to us, what we say yes and no to is also being determined by humans. Do you think there is a risk of us saying yes, that may be strategic, but they may also be looked at holistically as a distraction versus a focused effort.
Why you cannot have 52 number one priorities 6:17
Kevin Burns [00:06:17]:
For certain. And again, going back to your example of the fire hose, because we have multiple bosses that we are trying to please and to make sure that we’re fulfilling their objectives and their strategic needs, the city commission, the city administration, and ultimately, the constituents or the citizens and business people of the city. So certainly there is a multitude of ideas and initiatives to enhance and make us more efficient. And all of those can be a distractor, even though, like I said earlier, that’s why I think in the long run those distractors are good because we need to ultimately find that end game. But we have to put a game plan in place in order to successfully achieve all of those because you can’t have 52 number one priorities.
Sanjog Aul [00:07:22]:
So, Don, coming to you, we know that as part of us being a great organization or at least as part of becoming a great organization, we should be inclusive in our nature, which means we are not just picking and rationalizing and prioritizing things in the ivory tower, but the top leaders only, we should also include the very people who are in the trenches. Now it has a bright side to it because you are involving them so they own it and thus the execution will be better and adoption will be better. But then it also has an element of potential risk of getting distracted because once you include them and they may have great ideas. But then there will be way too many great ideas. And if you say no, that also would create disappointment in some people. It’s a regular human nature. So how do you eat the cake and have it too?
Don Phillips [00:08:17]:
So, sometimes you’re right. The priorities of the person with the boots on the ground, as you’re kind of saying there, those people who are closest to the work, may be a little different than the strategic goals of those that may be a little bit higher up. And so, you’re right. I think that’s a very good thing that you have to balance between somebody who just wants to get their job done more effectively and efficiently and is coming to you again, they’re on the ground close to the work versus upper management who has a different vision. So I think it’s critical to mesh those two together. And again, we have to always go back to that central point is, Okay, we all should be looking to make our jobs more efficient and more effective. And when the input comes from the people that are close to the work, how is this going to deliver that service better? How is that going to make the citizen engagement better? How is a citizen going to benefit from this interaction and not just a personal I like to do my job better? So, if we can look at that and somebody comes with a question and says, look, I think here’s a very good opportunity to not only make my job better but to affect the city as well, then we have to take that up to the chain. And we do have some things in place, from a governance standpoint to get that input from those people that are closest to the work and actually put it up the chain of command so that people can see, hey, there’s some great ideas down here. But there is a balance there because sometimes that strategic direction is not necessarily the same as the kind of the people that are actually doing the work.
Sanjog Aul [00:09:38]:
Coming to, the overall performance or the outcome, that when is measured for, an industrial worker is very easily measured when you count the number of widgets. But in an information age or a digital age, a person sitting in front of a computer may not be exactly as measured as well. So Kevin coming to you, if I am going to motivate or incent a person to do the best job they can and also move them into a focused approach or focusing on what they do best or what they can deliver, what all we need to do so that it happens with that person? Because we cannot push something down their throat because it was a strategic priority even when it was inclusive, but there could be a defined line beyond which it will start becoming way too many things. A person is distracted. The energy is dissipated. How do you measure that? Because the person will not be able to tell you because they’re not building widgets.
Kevin Burns [00:10:42]:
And I agree with you. I think that’s one of the big challenges that a CIO has and it’s also kind of the morphing of the CIO role and how we have to start embracing some more of those soft skills that now we’re not just a technology person, now we have to be a business person and we have to be a technology person and we have to be able to equally spread that across the spectrum and talk with our business partners and our business allies within the city. And it’s our job as the CIO to kind of keep that distraction or try to minimize the distractions for those people that are in our workforce that are concentrating on specific projects or specific functions that they’re doing. And yes, sometimes it’s difficult to do that, but it’s a constant communication and a two-way communication that we have to keep open to our whole workforce to try to minimize those distractions the best we can.
Don Phillips [00:11:58]:
I can jump in on here and piggyback with what Kevin is saying is that the role has definitely shifted. We are no longer technologists. It sounds like City of Miami is probably the same way. We have commissioners who run the technology. I have commissioners that work for me who actually manage the technology. A lot of my job now is managing the business processes and making sure that we deliver the value to the business. So in a lot of projects nowadays may not even be technology. I would bet that maybe 25% of my projects currently are not directly technology processes. They’re how do I fix my business process and, oh yeah, by the way, we might be able to use technology to fix that. Because at the end of the day, the CIOs and the project managers are really good at fixing things. So, I think that’s to go back to your question is, we have to look at no longer let’s just get 10 things done and we’re successful, but let’s look at the actual results and say, okay, where are we trying to go? What was our goal? And did we meet our goal? And that goal could be in an efficiency, that goal can be in a satisfaction to a citizen, that goal can be different than just we produced X, Y and Z.
Sanjog Aul [00:13:01]:
Now both of you, when you say that you had everything, what you define here is coming from top down. And if the alignment to what an individual wants to achieve, because we are looking at individual’s effectiveness and productivity. If you look outside in to a person, then they look like a resource. Right? Even sometimes we call people as resources, which means we want to get the most out of them and how we can look at a resource. But if you want to really have a person maximize their productivity, their effectiveness, the sum total could be much higher. When we look at this whole distraction and number of things we are trying to get them to do, how can we convert that into an inside out approach or process so that as individuals, they are most focused, most effective, most productive, and as a result, the organization benefits.
Sanjog Aul [00:15:03]:
So, Don, we are looking at the whole equation from outside in, and we have looked at it outside in. There’s nothing wrong with it. But then there’s also a component where a person who comes who may be a worker in your technology department or even other business user within the city government is coming in to pay their bills, work hard and become something. Are we looking inside out at all in terms of the focus, the effectiveness and the productivity factors for that individual worker?
Don Phillips [00:15:36]:
Definitely. And I think you have to. Again, I very much believe in the people who are closest to the work know what really needs to happen. So, while leadership is charged with setting the vision. So, I get the vision from the mayor and once he sets his vision, we can kind of set up our strategy to achieve that vision. But at the end of the day, it’s the individual worker who’s going to actually implement whatever change we want to do. And they know what the work is. So, it is critical, like I do here with the governance structure to have them involved in those questions. Here’s the vision. Help me figure out how to get there because at the end of the day, whether it be plowing a street for snow or doing recreation centers, they know the work the best. So we have to keep them involved.
Sanjog Aul [00:16:21]:
And, Kevin, when we look at the overall picture at an individual worker level, would it be better off focusing on effectiveness or productivity?
Kevin Burns [00:16:37]:
Better on one than the other.
Sanjog Aul [00:16:39]:
The reason I say that is because if you do less, but you do the best versus how much did I get done. I know at the top, they will say do more with less or more with nothing, but that cannot percolate down to the individual worker because we are trying to develop focus.
Choosing effectiveness over productivity 16:57
Kevin Burns [00:16:57]:
I think that we need to be effective. Going back to what Don was saying earlier, 5% of our projects are true IT projects, 95% of them are business projects that have an IT flare to them or an IT perspective that help that business unit achieve their goal, which is to serve the customers and serve the community. So we have to be effective and we have to provide the best solution possible. So effectiveness or being more effective than productive is much better, I think.
Don Phillips [00:17:40]:
And I’d have to agree. At the end of the day, we have limited resources, so we have to make the most of those resources. And again, I always have this analogy even with my people that’s, I don’t necessarily need you to dig the hole here. I need it over here. So while that’s a great hole you’re digging, can you do it over here for me where I need it, where it’s effective. So, just doing work doesn’t help us. We have to be extremely focused and make sure that we’re measuring the outcome and measuring what we expected to get out of it. And did we actually get that out of it? And how did that help us achieve our ultimate goals?
Sanjog Aul [00:18:14]:
So this is what you want from them, but suppose you were doing someone’s performance appraisal. Would you look at the number of projects did they deliver or they effectively contributed in fewer projects, which is measurable and which moved the organization forward whatever amount it did, but it also helped develop that person. Because if you are looking at the latter approach, that directly has a bearing on how confident, how happy, how motivated that person will remain all the time. But then you have a productivity goal too on the other end. So you cannot tell that person, you cannot focus on productivity at that individual level, but you have to show productivity of the organization. So how do you kind of match the two?
Don Phillips [00:18:58]:
I think the productivity is the effectiveness. So one, they should not be doing projects that have not been preapproved and have shown to have value and add value to the organization. So that’s a lot of my role. That’s a lot of my commissioner role. If I have my PMO office, my project management office, their role is to make sure these projects actually have value. So, that if I put you on a project, I already know what the expected value is, what the expected outcome is. So, if you deliver this project successfully, we don’t have to actually ask the question, was it productive? We know it was productive because we shouldn’t allow you to begin that project. We shouldn’t put resources to that project unless we know or expect a certain outcome and a certain return on that value. So I think that’s a leadership issue to make sure that our projects are effective when they start out. So by doing those projects I think it has a built in kind of productivity and effectiveness.
Kevin Burns [00:19:50]:
And I would say that, what we do in the city is I make all of my managers provide goals and objectives for every employee in our department. So they know what their goals and objectives are for the year and it’s a negotiable tool. They review them on a quarterly basis because of all of the change that we can or do have throughout the course of a year. And what that does, I think you asked the question, how do we motivate the individual workers, the resource, and how do they self motivate? So by having that input into their goals and objectives, which ultimately is going to be their annual performance evaluation, they get to tell how productive or how effective they’re going to be as well. And that ultimately, strategically, how does that align with the strategic goals and objectives of the Department, which aligns to the City’s strategic goals, objectives and vision?
Sanjog Aul [00:21:02]:
Now one is the assignment. Right? Not how much was it assigned, how well did they do, and hindsight is 20/20. And you kind of understand that, okay, what was the productivity level and how effective they were. But at the same time, if you were to look at that individual’s DNA at the time of assignment itself and say, should I put this person on this particular job versus another one or less of this particular project, another one on that one? That has a direct bearing on how well a person is gonna deliver, how much and what a person is gonna deliver qualitatively, and also their motivation throughout. Because at the end of it, that project is not the last project they will do. But if they are tired because it was not aligned to their DNA, you may have done your allocation, but that person may have it, first of all, not as engaged, which will reduce their effectiveness and productivity. Secondly, a person is not a happy camper. So what are you doing as a CIO or as a leader? I would not say you in particular, but as an organization to make sure that we are working towards building that focus, which is not coming just because you said so. It comes based on many of those other factors that I just mentioned. So, Don, if I were to come and challenge you to say, okay. Before you got these 20 projects and you got six resources, what would be your math and science or an art form, if you will, to make sure at the assignment level itself, you’re making sure that DNA matches what has been assigned to a worker?
Matching people to their strengths 22:36
Don Phillips [00:22:36]:
And I think that’s important. I think it’s important both from the organization so that we get the most out of the person. Some people are subject matter experts in certain areas. And so that’s an easy one, right? I know you’re my SME in a particular area of the city or a particular area of technology. So, it’s easy for me to assign that particular role. And that’s something we have to cultivate constantly. Again, part of our job is cultivating people and making sure that we’re aligning people with the right skills with the right projects. And that’s kind of what your question says. So, I think that’s a constant thing we have to look at to make sure we’re doing that. Again, from here perspective, specifically at City of Cleveland, I look at my staff, we’re constantly having meetings and we’re asking those questions. Sometimes it’s as simple as let’s put some projects on the board and ask who’d like to take this? Who’s excited about this project? And somebody puts their hand up and says I’m excited, and hopefully they have the skill set that matches that and we’ll send them on their way. If we have to also give them support, we’ll give them support. I think it’s also very important to give people chances to do things that might be outside their normal comfort range. So some people might step and say, hey, I’ve never done that project before, but it’s outside my comfort zone. However, I want to try something new. And you have to give people the ability, like you said, or they’ll get burned out or they’ll get bored to do something new within constraints. And we’ll give them a mentor. Again, we have a project management office which is nice so that they know exactly what’s expected of them. They don’t get too far out before they, if they need some assistance to come back. So I think that’s very important, especially with IT type projects, which can be relatively repetitive over time, same kind of projects, but it’s critical. We put our IT people out in the business, so they see things they’ve never seen before. It’s not just technology. They have to go out there and they might ride on a garbage truck to see how it actually works. So if they’re going to do a new process or a new program, they understand how the worker is doing. That’s a whole different thing. A lot of them never get out of the office so we put them out there, so they can get that real world experience and hopefully, again, motivate them a little more.
Sanjog Aul [00:24:37]:
Kevin, as a parent, I have children. I’m sure many of our listeners would have and there would be some children who would always want to sit in the front seat of the car. They would say yes to everything. Others may sit quietly and will be more complacent. But it’s our job to recognize the people who are sitting in front that they are not always taking away the thunder and or they are doing the things which are best for them and at the same time, the ones who don’t talk as much. So let’s bring that parallel to your organization. Suppose Don said that we will ask who would wanna take it. And, yes, there will be people who would wanna take it, but there are many others who would be effective or would be more effective. So we have to have some sort of a diagnosis. Which is a parent’s eye to be able to recognize versus the squeaky wheel gets the most attention.
Kevin Burns [00:25:28]:
Exactly. And that’s always like the 10% that are the most outgoing and are willing to jump on everything and anything no matter what it happens to be. And then you’ve got a larger portion that may kind of want to sit back a little bit and be a little more introverted. But I think as Don was saying, communication and having that open line of communication is extremely important. And one of the things that I do every morning or almost every morning is I walk my whole floor and say good morning to everybody. So they know me, hopefully they should know me, and I know them and I get to know their personalities and I get to know their skill sets. I’m not that far removed from them that I don’t know that kind of thing. So when we’re discussing new projects or the possibility of projects coming up, I have a very good working relationship and open communication with their managers as well. So we start talking about projects that are coming down the pipe and we start early in engaging all of our employees, either by assignment because we know that they have the correct skill set, or by asking. But we also like to engage the employee to show them what value this project has, not just for our team as in pride and what we’ve delivered to the business unit, but how it’s going to improve the business unit and ultimately improve that citizen or customer service experience on the outside, so that they feel that pride all the way from the initialization of the project through the delivery of the project and then the support of the project moving forward when they can fix problems if they do arise, but more so, are able to give customers, and especially government customers, a better experience. I think we have a bad rap for having bad customer service and everything takes forever and then there’s a long line for this, but when we can improve that experience for the customer and now we’re pushing a lot of our customer connectivity to the edge, we’re minimizing the fact that they have to come to a city administration building to perform their work. They can actually do a lot more of it online, which makes them more productive as a citizen and it allows them to engage in their own personal business, whatever that happens to be, and less time wasted at city building. So when we can start showing how we’re making the city a better place to live and work in, then it gives them that sense of pride and I think that also improves and makes them want to do more work and makes them feel better about what they are doing.
Sanjog Aul [00:28:36]:
Kevin, as you mentioned, you go and say hello and good morning to everyone in the team and that way they know you and then you are able to tell them about how the initiative’s gonna help the city and the citizens. Now coming to, the town halls, if you will, where you’re giving this message may not happen every day. And then the people who actually stay focused or stay productive or effective, they do it because of their immediate managers. Unless, otherwise, it’s a super flat organizations. The middle managers have to be cloning what the top leader like you is thinking and the way they are behaving because one of the things is they have never lived digital. Right? Middle managers today have not lived their digital. It’s also coming to them new, and they have to figure out how to deal with it. It’s way too much coming down. And then they have to be able to lead their teams or manage their teams in such a way. I would rather not use the word manage. Lead their teams in such a way so that we are not stifling creativity, but at the same time, not encouraging distraction. So how do we do this balancing act where they are not the leader that you are, Kevin or Don? And how do we make sure such an organization exists and such middle managers exist and do the job properly?
Turning middle managers into digital leaders 30:57
Sanjog Aul [00:30:57]:
So, Kevin, we know that most people at the operational level, whether in IT or in business, truly stay in the company and stay motivated and deliver because of their managers even though they may love or not love their leader. So your ability to communicate to them over a town hall would be periodic. Your ability to go and say hello, of course, is gonna be very motivating, but then rest of the day, they have to deal with the middle managers. And those people, like I’m sure you as well and all of us, have not seen as much digital. So this is totally new. They do not have the experience to see how much they should allow people to delve into digital and use their creativity versus getting measured by being productive or making their staff productive. So they have a conflicting directive, if you will, in some cases. So how do you handle this middle management not undermining what you’re trying to do?
Kevin Burns [00:32:06]:
Well, that is like the million dollar question, right? So we have to constantly communicate with them. I think that’s why it’s very important to get to know them, not just as a subordinate, but also as a person. What motivates them? What is their family like? What are their outside activities, what do they like to do. So I think it’s good to take them out, go have a coffee with them and talk about things other than business to get to know them, because then when you start to know them as a person and you start to know what motivates them, then you can start molding your conversations, the business conversations, and start molding how you want to assist them to become more digital and how to become more effective in their management style and motivating their subordinates.
Sanjog Aul [00:33:16]:
Now, Don, while what Kevin mentioned would be the first chapter in that playbook to turn your middle managers into digital leaders if I had to write one, what would the subsequent chapters look like? How would you groom them with you yourself are relatively new? I’m assuming all of us are as leaders. How do you get the middle management to walk that path towards becoming a digital leader in that journey? They become the best possible mentors and or managers for the people who are doing the job. So they become more focused and more effective.
Don Phillips [00:33:53]:
Let me just say we have some great managers here. My commissioners and my line managers are some great people. Some of them I brought on board over time and some of them were already here. But I think part of it is what Kevin was saying is they have to believe in you. And so at some point, they have to be able to say, look, I trust your vision and I’m going to follow you. Same way I trust the Mayor’s vision and I follow him. So I have to sell the Mayor’s vision to my team. And part of that is, again, having some of those personal conversations. Where do we want to go? How do we want to get there, what do we want to look like when we grow up as an organization. So those conversations and selecting those key managers is very critical to the success of our business. There’s just no way around it. So again, we have some great managers and great commissioners here and we’re really all on board from a vision perspective. My biggest thing I tell them is let me get out of your way, right? So, that’s the biggest thing. I hired you to be an expert and I want you to be the expert. If you’re not going to be the expert, I don’t need you. So, my job, I’ve always said, is to set that vision, give those people feedback if they’re not on course, provide all the resources I can, and then most importantly, get out of their way and let them do their job, and remove any obstacles that come aboard. So I think people respect that when they’re considered the expert and their job is to get it done.
Sanjog Aul [00:35:17]:
So what you mentioned was definitely going to ace the people side of it, but what about the digital literacy and digital leadership which they’re supposed to exude in order for them to command respect and be able to lead the troops? When you say get out of the way, so you got out of their way, but we need to make sure that they are leading the troops in the right direction.
Hire for passion and get out of the way 35:38
Don Phillips [00:35:38]:
I’m hoping that they replicate that model, that they empower their people and we truly try to do that again, going down to the individual worker. Again, you’re an expert. You’re just not a resource. You’re not a set of hands that I need. You’re an expert all the way down to the work level and empowering people to do the job. We are counting on you. And that’s very critical. Again, Kevin, you’ll appreciate that. I rely a lot on George Patton and some of his quotes. He kind of says that. He says, don’t tell people what to do, tell them what you want and then they’ll surprise you with their results, right? So, that’s what I tried to do. From a digital literacy perspective, I think people get in this business because they do have that. When I hire managers, I’m looking for that passion. Sometimes I trade off skills for passion because you can’t buy passion, right? I can buy skills. I can send you the training. I can do those type of things, but I can’t buy the passion for wanting to learn, for wanting to deliver. And so that’s critical. So when I’m hiring a new manager, that’s more important to me and we can build up that digital skill set. But again, you can’t buy passion.
Sanjog Aul [00:36:46]:
So let me put this example out there. If I am very passionate about golf, but I’m playing the wrong game of golf. I’m gonna practice like there is no tomorrow, but you may not be effective, and we are talking about focus and effectiveness. So, it’s one philosophy that people don’t do what you expect, but what you inspect. And that’s not that there is lack of trust, but in order for you to kinda shape them and nudge them into a direction which will actually help them learn the right game of golf is the intent. How do you make that happen?
Don Phillips [00:37:21]:
I think having that honest part of my role is to provide that feedback. And I think having a definite plan that says, here’s where I want you to be and if they get off course to provide that feedback, you’re right. They may go out there and practice the wrong thing forever and it doesn’t get them the results they want. So we need to make sure that we’re doing those things. We’re building up those skills. We’re hiring the people that are going to ultimately give us the results that we want. And quickly, if we’re not getting there, we get back on path.
Sanjog Aul [00:37:50]:
Now that said, Kevin, I’d like to come to you. Do you think we are a digital apprentice leader or we are fully cooked leader when it comes to digital as CIOs?
Leading as digital apprentices 38:01
Kevin Burns [00:38:01]:
I would say Digital Apprentice right now because I think for all of us, we’re not the Millennials. We didn’t grow up with a cell phone or a tablet in our hand. Some of us got them much later in life. And so we’re in the apprentice stage as well and we are trying to craft our vision based on all of the things that we can get our hands on reading, whether it’s online or books or attending seminars or self training or whatever we’re doing. But we have to be like a sponge right now and try to absorb as many things in the digital era as we possibly can and then try to spit that back out, at least the things that we think are most relevant or pertinent to our organization or to our city, in our cases, at this point in time, and also ultimately to our workforce. We can’t obviously pull everybody along, but we can certainly nudge them along and we can kind of give the broad vision of we need to really start moving in this direction. I’d like your help. I’d like to encourage you to start looking at this, whatever that direction happens to be. A lot of it right now is the Smart Cities initiatives, obviously. There’s the old saying, you can lead the horse to water, but you can never make them drink. But certainly I think our job is to try to lead them in the direction that ultimately we want to move in, and hopefully that’s going to help us get there.
Sanjog Aul [00:39:57]:
The way, Kevin, you mentioned that we are apprentice leader, and that’s actually an accurate assessment for all of us here. So an apprentice cannot train or build another apprentice leader. Right? That’s a reality if you were to look at it holistically. So what resources, what avenues do we explore? Do we take them along and say, okay. We will both make mistakes together and somehow figure it out as a family. Is that the right approach? Or we say, okay. Let’s go and get some outside help who may always not have the right interest in mind because they could be a vendor because they want to exploit this opportunity. So we are in an interesting, foreign country, if you will, as a family who neither of us know exactly how to go about it, but we still have to survive. How would we make that happen, Don?
Sanjog Aul [00:41:47]:
So, Don, when we are looking at, us being a family, I’m just gonna consider this as an example or analogy of a family going to a totally new country. We are going to learn together but still that family dynamic has to stay the same. That means if we are all new to this digital realm, how do we go about learning together and still be able to maintain the focus, the productivity and effectiveness and not come across as an apprentice teaching another apprentice
Testing vendor promises for smart cities 42:21
Don Phillips [00:42:21]:
No, I agree. There are some things we don’t know yet. We can’t know it all. And we do rely on internal staff and external vendors. And as you mentioned before the break, some of our external vendors may have a stake in the game. So, we have to sometimes take their suggestions with a grain of salt. But this whole Smart Cities initiatives is a perfect example. We don’t necessarily know the entire space there. But again, we have kind of a model that we’re looking at. I know what I want. I know what my vision is. And so, I can work with my vendors or I can work internally to decide, are they telling me something that makes sense? Am I ultimately going to still get to my vision and get to my goal? So, as long as I can still measure that and we have, again, a very mature model for measuring, are we getting the value that we really want out of it? Because, again, I get calls all the time. I’m sure Kevin gets calls all the time about I have this great tool, I have this great technology, I have this great system that will help you. Well, sometimes there’s not a problem to help. But if there is a problem, I have to have that defined and say, okay, how is this going to help me and have some really key success factors to say, yeah, that’s really what worked. So, again, this smart initiative, smart cities initiatives, at the end of the day, any promises that are made to me by vendors for smart cities has to engage citizens. It has to provide services for citizens. So, I have a measurement. I have a measuring stick to say, Yeah, I hear what you’re telling me. It’s not just a salesman telling me something. I see how this is going to directly meet my goal of engaging citizens and making their interaction with the city easier and more effective. So it’s definitely a balancing act with that.
Sanjog Aul [00:43:59]:
Now, Kevin, if you’re looking at the same analogy of people going in there, how would you approach the overall learning? So you would just go and read here and there, or is there a way you are even formalizing your internal leadership development and or digital literacy, if you will, for your organization? How are you even approaching this?
Kevin Burns [00:44:24]:
Yes, we are trying to standardize some of it by looking to outside agencies for assistance. We use a couple of the larger think tanks, if you will, that we have memberships with that we use to ask them about what their research is showing and what their research reveals to help us to formalize our process of moving more digital. And then, obviously what research everybody is doing on their own and we kind of get together and have brainstorming sessions in regards to it as well.
Sanjog Aul [00:45:15]:
So, Kevin, your approach is about creative destruction, which means let go of the old for it to make place for the new, or is it an incremental shift to the digital thinking because many times when you do the incremental thinking, then you are undermining what digital could otherwise do if you were willing and open to allow the creative destruction.
Kevin Burns [00:45:47]:
We try to allow for the creative destruction, as best we can, but I think we have to kind of have a little bit of control on it as well because, while we want that creative thinking and those creative ideas to bubble to the top and hopefully we can implement many of them, we also still have to think about the big picture and what the end game is and obviously that’s that customer experience and that citizen engagement in what we deliver to them. So while we would like to always use that kind of methodology, it’s not always practical or possible because we still have constraints that are provided to us through city commission or through the city administration. So we still have to deliver and we can’t just flail around always kind of thinking about or never coming to an end game.
Sanjog Aul [00:46:57]:
So, Don, when you talk to your people and go through this whole process of rethinking, how your organization works, etcetera, what challenges are your people telling you that they are facing? Which are challenges which I would not call them chronic, but they are tough to crack?
Don Phillips [00:47:16]:
I think not so much challenges or even distractions, as just opportunities. There’s just so many things to get done and there’s so many good things that we can do and it’s just filtering them all out. So, again, we have excited people here who work for me. They want to get it all done and it’s just trying to balance all those things, and make sure they can get them done. So, again, not necessarily distractions, but lots of opportunities in the technical arena right now. And so we’re trying to measure those and make sure that we do the ones that give us the most bang for our buck. We’re excited here about the things that are going on.
Sanjog Aul [00:47:52]:
And if there was to be defined as a holy grail, Kevin, of what your organization would look like, how would you paint a picture for a city like yours?
The holy grail of a bimodal city team 48:04
Kevin Burns [00:48:04]:
The holy grail. In the digital world? I think having the true capability of being fully bimodal would certainly be helpful. And I would always want to have one of those teams that’s always, whatever you want to call it, a research and development team, a smart cities team, an innovation team, you can name it whatever you’d like, but a team that’s always out there looking at the edge and bringing that innovation back into the department, but also allowing everybody within the department to fulfill a role on that team at some point in their career, because that gives them an opportunity to be out on the edge for some period of time and be that digital thinker and really bring back a lot of ideas and hopefully things that we can use to provide a better service to our customers.


