Governance • IT Strategy & Business Alignment • Leadership • Sustainability

Cutting IT Costs vs. Increasing Organizational Risk

Cutting IT Costs vs. Increasing Organizational Risk

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Robin Arendt (Zurich North American Commercial), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that cutting IT costs and protecting the organization are not opposites when the work is done deliberately. Robin Arendt of Zurich North American Commercial argued that random across the board cuts of 10 to 20% are short sighted and create risk, and that the better path is a cross functional effort that looks at process, people, and technology together. She described using Lean Six Sigma to redesign broker support at Zurich, removing non value added handoffs, moving administrative work off underwriters into a central group, and collapsing five front end policy writing systems into one, which cut processing time 40% to 50%. She tied this to a three year blueprint to decommission $100,000,000 of redundant legacy systems, and said she drove $45,000,000 and $18,000,000 of non people related savings in two years without waiting for finance to mandate it. She said risk is managed by talking to the people doing the work, not just managers, and by using data and internal benchmarks rather than emotion.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Robin Arendt, CIO for Zurich North American Commercial, about cutting IT costs without increasing organizational risk. Arendt describes shifting spend from running existing systems to strategic investments, and a three year blueprint that targets $100,000,000 in redundant legacy systems. She contrasts random cuts of 10 to 20% across the board, which she says create risk, with a thoughtful approach that engages the business and the people doing the work. She also covers a Lean Six Sigma redesign of broker support that cut processing time 40% to 50%, risk governance at Zurich, and who owns the risk when a cut goes wrong.

Contributors

  • Robin Arendt, CIO, Zurich North American Commercial

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Robin Arendt, CIO for Zurich North American Commercial, says cutting IT costs does not have to raise organizational risk when the cuts are made deliberately rather than at random. She says random reductions of 10 to 20% across the board are short sighted and create risk, and she has always pushed back on that approach.
  • Robin Arendt of Zurich North American Commercial says the aim of running IT like a business is to move spending away from running existing systems and toward strategic investments. She says 70% of her budget was going to legacy systems when she arrived, so she set out to decommission them and integrate into Zurich’s global environment.
  • Robin Arendt of Zurich North American Commercial says a thoughtful cost cutting effort has to engage the business and the people doing the work, not just managers in a room. She used Lean Six Sigma to redesign broker support, removed non value added handoffs, and moved administrative tasks off underwriters into a central group, which cut processing time 40% to 50%.
  • Robin Arendt, CIO for Zurich North American Commercial, says consolidating redundant systems cuts cost and lowers the risk of a complicated legacy environment. She pointed to a three year blueprint to take $100,000,000 of redundant legacy systems out of the environment and to collapsing five front end policy writing systems into one.
  • Robin Arendt of Zurich North American Commercial says leaders should find savings on their own instead of waiting for finance to order an across the board cut. She says she started with non people related low hanging fruit and drove $45,000,000 in savings in her first year and $18,000,000 the next.
  • Robin Arendt, CIO for Zurich North American Commercial, says risk is managed by understanding the work before changing it and by using data instead of emotion. She says she talks to the people doing the job, treats Gartner and internal benchmarks as directional data points, and models the best practices she finds inside the company.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: cutting IT costs versus organizational risk
  • 2:58 Shifting IT dollars to strategic investments
  • 3:57 Integrating acquired systems to reduce cost and risk
  • 5:57 A roadmap for decommissioning legacy systems
  • 7:15 Thoughtful cost cutting with the business
  • 13:17 Earning respect for IT instead of firing first
  • 17:00 Changing the conversation with business partners
  • 22:53 Managing risk by engaging the workforce
  • 33:35 Where IT should be visible or invisible
  • 38:30 Security risk and the three way dialogue
  • 40:56 Insourcing versus using consultants
  • 52:41 Advice on avoiding across the board cuts

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: cutting IT costs versus organizational risk 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:47]:
Today’s topic is cutting IT costs versus increasing organizational risk. Our guest for today’s show is Robin Arendt, and she’s the CIO for Zurich North American Commercial. Good morning, Robin.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:09]:
So how’s your business treating you?

Robin Arendt [00:01:12]:
It’s been a rough year, relative to the marketplace, but, we’re going to end up finishing up the year quite well with record profits. So that feels good.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:24]:
So all along this year when we call it rough is because of course the business has some turbulent times, it kind of percolates down to IT as well. Would you say? Is that the case typically?

Robin Arendt [00:01:35]:
It is. And not just trickles down to IT, I’d say it’s trickled down across the organization, across all functions. So I’d actually say it’s been the last 2 years. The market condition started early last year, so we’ve been in that mode for some time.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:53]:
Now with respect to doing more with less, this is a very, I would say in some cases, cliched, in many cases for IT, but then lately what we have been hearing people say is that we have been asked to do more with literally nothing. Now, that could be a figure of speech, but then in some cases they say our budgets have been cut to the bones. Is that something by design or is that something they ask for?

Robin Arendt [00:02:18]:
Yeah. I think the doing more for less cliche holds true for not just IT but other parts of the organization. You’ve got to look for ways of driving a culture of efficiency and constantly looking at where can I implement process improvements, where can I look at efficiencies, redundancies? That’s our job as leaders of the company.

Sanjog Aul [00:02:43]:
So would you say that some people who asked for it did not have enough business case for them to keep getting the dollars that they want to be able to keep the lights on from the IT standpoint, at least the light bright enough?

Shifting IT dollars to strategic investments 2:58

Robin Arendt [00:02:58]:
Yes. That’s one of the key measures we look at is how much of our IT dollars are going to strategic investments and building new capabilities versus keeping the lights on. And really the goal is to try and move as much as you can from keeping the lights on and running the business to strategic investments. That’s really, I think, running IT like a business. You’ve got to challenge the thinking around that and try to re-shift the dollars to invest in business capabilities.

Sanjog Aul [00:03:31]:
In any business, if you notice that there are definitely some areas where the senior management always says, you know what, let’s invest in this, maybe acquire a company or if I have the capability which I feel could really take us to the next level of progress and success, let’s invest in it. What would it take for IT to ever rise and shine and become one of the members of that particular group, which is in fact a type of attention?

Integrating acquired systems to reduce cost and risk 3:57

Robin Arendt [00:03:57]:
Yes. So let’s take the acquisition example because I think that’s real and it was part of the work that we did, from a Farmers perspective, which is part of the Zurich family as we took on the 21st century. And really, IT did have a major seat at the table and in the way that we approached that is, like many companies that acquire, there’s a decision to be made. Do we integrate the systems of the newly acquired company into our existing or do we keep it as separate silos? And it was very much the opinion here is, let’s integrate. And over time that, I believe that it’s the right decision to make because you end up if you don’t, you end up with costs that can continue to go up over time and then you’ve got a legacy environment that’s complicated and that drives risks in and of itself. Now, I think we made the right decision this year with that, but I think historically, we have taken on a number of acquisitions in the past over the last 10 to 20 years where we didn’t do that integration. And when I came in here 2 years ago, it was an opportunity that presented itself was the ability to really look at the fact that we were spending 70% of my budget on running those legacy systems, and I had the opportunity to look at things differently and say, you guys, we need to uncomplicate things and we need to start decommissioning these legacy systems and integrate into the Zurich, global landscape. And that’s really the journey we’ve been on over the last 2 years.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:39]:
Would you say that if there was not such a disruptive event as an acquisition available as much or as frequently to companies and when business is going on as usual, how do you create an excuse to be able to take a second look at those legacy and see how you can clean up the shop a little bit?

A roadmap for decommissioning legacy systems 5:57

Robin Arendt [00:05:57]:
Yes. No, that’s a good question. And last year, we started by laying out what is our 3 year IT technology blueprint? What is our strategy based on the business changes, the business model, where we’re heading? And it was an effort that we did across all business units, and we landed on that. And then from that, we laid out what’s our road map for decommissioning? What are we gonna look like 3 years from now, 4 years now, 5 years from now? And we’ve started that journey, and we’ve got a plan that’s gonna drive $100,000,000 in cutting redundant legacy systems out of the environment. And it’s not just a cost cutting. The benefit you get is speed to market. The fact that I’ve got 5 different front end policy writing systems and I really only need one, I can shut down 4 and that saves a significant amount of money and helps us deliver projects a lot quicker.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:00]:
Now this actually looks very good on a blueprint or a roadmap to cut legacy, but sometimes when it comes to execution people do too much too quick slashing and that could backfire because there’s something to be said about continuity.

Thoughtful cost cutting with the business 7:15

Robin Arendt [00:07:15]:
Yeah. And I think that’s a very good point. There’s two approaches you can take in cutting costs and one which I highly don’t recommend and I’ve never done personally is randomly just cutting 10 to 20% across the board without much thought. I think it’s short sighted and it’ll create issues and risk in the end. But I do believe the right approach is a thoughtful approach and it’s not IT doing it alone. It’s engaging the businesses and looking at the business process from an end to end perspective. And it takes a little more time, which, sometimes time is not always on your side, but you really gotta put together that cross functional team and look at what efficiencies do we have, for instance, from a process perspective. And we did that here. We started this last year. We used Lean Six Sigma. We worked with our business and we looked at how can we better service our broker partners. It was taking us weeks to turn around a request for them. And so we not only looked at the technology, we looked at processes between offices, we looked at the people, what roles they were performing, and we really took a three pronged approach. And I can walk through this as an example. The first was we eliminated unnecessary handoffs. We took out non-value added business steps that were taking way too long for us to be responsive and we had quality issues. And really where we came to is a one consistent streamlined process across the company to support our brokers versus the 10 different ways we were doing it before because each business unit wanted to do it a different way. And that was the first step. That’s the process piece. And then the people piece was we looked at the work that was being done. So we looked at redistributing the common more administration functions. Instead of letting the underwriter do that, we really put it into a central processing group and we let the underwriters underwrite, which is why they came to work for Zurich. And that was the people part and then it came to be the technology and what we were able to do since I now had the common process and we had a centralized group, I was able then, tying back to the decommissioning, to get to one system. I no longer needed 5 different systems to do it anymore, and that really operationalized this road map that I was speaking about and helped us to take the action that we needed to take. But it wasn’t done in isolation where IT just shut things off. It was really done in a thoughtful manner of engaging the business and looking at it holistically. And not only did we reduce processing time by 40% to 50%, which is a really good thing for our brokers, it helped us to save costs significantly through the process, through the people, the process and the technology changes we made.

Sanjog Aul [00:10:19]:
Who triggers such an effort? Who drives it? And who should be accountable?

Robin Arendt [00:10:24]:
Yeah. So I worked hand in hand with our COO and it was an engagement of the business unit COOs in the process. So we’ve got an enterprise COO and then each BU business unit has their own COO and that was the team. And we knew what we had to go after. We knew what the objectives were on improving our service levels for our brokers and improving quality and cutting costs where we could in a thoughtful way. And it really became our a joint team effort to go after it together. And I think that’s the thoughtful approach you wanna take and you can get competitive advantage if you do it the right way, which some people don’t really see how cost cutting can get you competitive advantage, but it can if you do it the right way.

Sanjog Aul [00:11:16]:
Now while we see that, when it comes down to cost cutting, we look at the portfolio where you can suppose CFO has something spread out in front of his on his table or her table, they would say, okay, I’ve got to cut here, cut here and then say, let’s look at this with the respective business unit later. And then you invite IT to say, okay, you cut costs. I don’t understand where you’re going to cut costs, but you got to cut costs. Is that what happens? Because what we’ve seen and at least what people tell is that when it comes to business unit related cutting costs and if there’s IT component involved, of course, IT is invited to help with it. But then when it is a problem with IT where we have to cut costs and what would make sense, business is not invited or told to get involved because that’s the only way you could justify what should be preserved versus what should be cut.

Robin Arendt [00:12:05]:
Yeah. It gets back to the approach that I mentioned before, which I don’t advocate to be the right approach, which is the random you get the CFO and the finance team sitting at a table and telling everyone you need to cut 10 to 20%. And I’ve seen a lot of companies do it, and then they feel the pain. And I have never been in the situation where someone said, Robin, you just need to drop 10 to 20% of your staff, and you’ve got, 6 months to do it. I would push back. Our job as leaders is to not wait for that conversation. And I’ve never had the conversation because 3 months on the job when I came here, I looked for the opportunities. I didn’t wait for someone in finance to sit me down around a conference table and tell me that I needed to drop 10 to 20%. And so I came in here and I looked at I started with the non-people-related low hanging fruit, and it exists. I drove $45,000,000 last year and $18,000,000 this year in non-people-related, low hanging fruit that we have. You’ve got to look for those opportunities as part of the culture of driving efficiencies.

Earning respect for IT instead of firing first 13:17

Sanjog Aul [00:13:17]:
And the fact is, Robin, you’re lucky that, I would say your organization is lucky to have someone like you who can look at it this way and you’re able to push back. At the same time, what would it take for us to develop the required respect for IT? Because that is actually almost the only tool left for organizations to create a competitive advantage? And how come we can proactively create a culture or a mindset so that IT is not just told to cut and we are not firing and then aiming?

Sanjog Aul [00:16:24]:
So we are always looking at these issues in many companies where the painful exercise still is repeated year after year. When we have business coming to slash cost, we go ahead and execute it. It goes beyond what it’s supposed to be, then the pain is there across the board. And what is creating this firing first and aiming second? Why is this a chronic issue still in many companies? And Robin, you may have been able to successfully dodge this or prevent this altogether, but why is the rest of the world suffering still?

Changing the conversation with business partners 17:00

Robin Arendt [00:17:00]:
Yeah, the fire and aim concept, I do believe it’s really taking a leadership role in running IT like a business and really getting not only you as the CIOs, but also your team underneath you changing their mindset that they’re owners of this company and to engage with their business partners in a problem solving, strategic, innovative thinking so that it’s not about managing MIPS anymore. It’s about having the right conversation on how we together, IT as an enabler, can help you get to the next level, get that next piece of business, improve the quality, improve the service turnaround time. It’s changing the conversation to that instead of managing every dollar. You really gotta change the conversation, but you’ve gotta earn the right to sit for that seat at the table. And that right comes with the business acumen. It comes with challenging maybe how they’re doing things and putting the right people with them to figure out what should be the right path forward. It’s having that right conversation and it’s changing the conversation that they’ve always had with IT in the past.

Sanjog Aul [00:18:33]:
Now there’s an old saying that nobody likes to be sold but they love to buy, right? So why is there distortion in the approach that an IT leader might take in terms of making a case because they would look like more they are selling versus making a business case which is then automatically embraced by the business leadership and they get the blessing?

Robin Arendt [00:18:57]:
Yeah. So it’s really the way that I’ve changed that conversation related to that is when we put forth a business idea, we end up laying out the business case that is very much of this is what we can change for the business. I’m gonna need some investment in order to, for instance, decommission some of the systems to simplify it. Give me a little money now, and this is what I’m gonna return to you in the future. And that needs to be compelling. And you’ve gotta build the confidence in the business leaders to know that I’m just not putting something on paper. I’m actually gonna deliver it for you. And you’ve gotta follow through on those actions. Otherwise, the next time you come in sales mode as you call it, you’re not gonna get the respect. If you don’t execute on your commitments, you’re gonna end up not having a seat at that table.

Sanjog Aul [00:20:05]:
Now some people may look at IT as a cost, but then it’s also to be looked at as a necessary cost to doing business. So if that’s, very small shift, could possibly get us greater, you can say investments that you could request and you will be approved for and so that you can go about doing the job that you want. Because it is just that borderline case where just below that you will start seeing law of diminishing returns even from the cost cutting.

Robin Arendt [00:20:34]:
Yes, I agree with that. And with the cost cutting, you need to be able to articulate what that’s going to mean to them, right? So from a service level, you’ve gotta turn it away from the numbers and make it a conversation that helps them understand what that’s gonna mean to them. If you really wanna cut deeper, that means that you gotta go back to the service level. Today, we can turn around giving them a new BlackBerry device, for instance, within 24 hours. And if they wanna reduce the cost around telecom, I can make that 3 days and they’re not going to like that. That’s just a very, simple example. But you take that in a broader scale, if they’re not going to make investments in the strategic capabilities, then we’re not going to get ahead in the market. It’s going to take us 9 months to introduce a new product instead of making the investment and we can get products out in 3 months. You just really need to turn the conversation into what that technology is an enabler to the business.

Sanjog Aul [00:21:49]:
Now would you think it would be creative to ask for a barter that okay I’ll save you a buck on the support costs but you give me R&D dollars or try to do something new out of the same money. I’m not going to give that back to you in your balance sheet, but I’d create that some more value, some more top line growth opportunities using the same money, which I showed you that I saved from cutting the operational costs.

Robin Arendt [00:22:11]:
Oh, absolutely. And that gets into the key measure around changing the mix. So being able to free up the dollars from running IT from an operations perspective and be able to infuse and self fund the strategic capabilities by taking the right action. And that’s critical and you need to be able to show how you’re turning that dial and that you have an action plan in place that’s going to get you there.

Sanjog Aul [00:22:42]:
Now how much of risk planning do you think there actually is, the level of due diligence that we put and the level of risk planning we do before we actually start cutting costs, truly in the world out there?

Managing risk by engaging the workforce 22:53

Robin Arendt [00:22:53]:
Yeah. So from a risk planning rate, again it gets back to the thoughtful approach. You can’t get a bunch of managers in a room and figure out how we’re gonna cut costs. You can’t do that. It’s not gonna give you the right answer. What you need to do is you need to engage the workforce in the process. So the example I gave you before where we looked at the processes being done in support of our brokers, we had to go talk to the people that were doing the job today and understand their day in the life of someone that supports our brokers and understand step by step what it takes for that process to be successful. And what do they need? What tools do they need for them to do their job? But I think a big thing is getting rid of the non-value steps that just weren’t adding value. It was just more red tape and processes and handoffs that were not necessary. And it’s really about the streamlining of those processes. And so how do we manage the risk? I think you manage the risk by understanding what the implications are that you’re gonna do and you’ve got to take the time to do that right. And that means talking to the people that are doing the work, not just engaging the managers.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:16]:
Now would you say that if you bring back a poll from a bunch of people from the shop floor to mid management all the way to senior leadership and this gives you certain areas where the risk could get introduced if you were to cut costs beyond a certain point, and while it’s qualitative measurement and there is no number that would support it, would that be sold or would that be bought?

Robin Arendt [00:24:40]:
You’ve got to have the data. You can’t make an emotional decision. You’ve got to have the facts. You’ve got to have the data that support the evidence that this may be the wrong direction to take. And that evidence and that data in my mind, you can take benchmarks and that’s one data point that you can introduce that maybe might put you down the right path, whether it’s Gartner or CIO Council that kind of gives you an idea of what others are doing. But quite honestly, it’s looking at the best practices within your organization in my mind that give you the confidence that you’re going to make the right decision. So just to give you an example, I’ve looked at spans of control. In an IT organization, what is the right span of control for the work that we do? And Gartner will say 10+ people. I looked internally and I had one management group that was high performing and they could manage 12 people with the outsource model we have. And that really became my benchmark. How can Jenny do it and do it successfully and this is the processes she has in place and her management style? How can I duplicate that across the organization so I can ensure that we’re gonna get the right answer? And so I think it’s looking at the data, looking at the facts externally and the benchmarks just directionally, but then it’s finding the best practices internally and then modeling those best practices across the board so it really becomes more of a sustainable approach.

Sanjog Aul [00:26:30]:
No, we always have this mantra of cutting costs wherever we can to make our company more bottom line savvy. The approaches or the mindset that changes drastically from the time when the times are good versus when we have to keep the lights on. But then can we afford to change the approach?

Robin Arendt [00:26:50]:
Yeah. No. I’m a huge believer in really getting to the heart of the culture and in creating a culture where process improvements and inefficiencies are rewarded and are given the right incentive because we should always be looking for that. Not so much to reduce the bottom line from an annual budget, but more to be able to, again, shift those dollars from running IT and the operations back to the strategic capabilities. Everyone wants to work on the new technology. And if I give my team the incentive, hey, guys, if we can make this happen, we can decommission these systems. We’re gonna have, X millions to turn around and bring in new technology to support our business. My team gets excited about that and the business gets excited about it. And that’s really the environment you want to create, whether times are rough like they have been over the past 2 years or times are good. It’s really what we need to do as leaders.

Sanjog Aul [00:27:49]:
No. What people look at as status quo is at least preserving what they have so far in the turbulent times. But then truly, a company can any company for that matter in such a demanding business environment afford to be in status quo even though that market may not be the greatest?

Robin Arendt [00:28:08]:
You can’t. You can’t stay status quo. That’s one thing. Change is constant. And so you need to have that culture and you need to have an adaptable team and environment that allows you to change along the way. So status quo is not acceptable anymore. You won’t last long as a leader if you do.

Sanjog Aul [00:28:32]:
Now when you mentioned you would not last long as a leader, but then this mindset could again be prevalent across many of the board members and our senior executive folks and then you cannot be a Hercules as an IT leader to go and try changing that mindset. And it is sometimes I’m not sure if in how many cases is an IT leader given or you can say they can take that, opportunity to really try to change the people at the top. And if they can, what’s that secret sauce? Because everybody would love to know that.

Robin Arendt [00:29:06]:
So I, as leaders, we’ve got to add our value. That’s something we have to do every day we come, whether the value is driven from cost cutting, which is the topic here, or the value is driven from developing your people or improving project execution turnaround time. There’s always value that you can drive across multiple dimensions, and that’s our job. And to be able to articulate it, sell it, and communicate what’s working, what’s not, and this is the success you’ve had, and then rally your team around that scorecard and what the goals are and the objectives and together we’re gonna do this and then remembering to celebrate when you do. I feel like that’s what we need to do as leaders and we need to add the value every day.

Sanjog Aul [00:30:12]:
See if there’s a way organizations can take an inventory on the typical critical roles that IT plays and or could play in the strategic and or operational aspects. And then if you are able to get that information, then you can build upon it. But if you don’t know, then that could possibly hurt you. So how do you go about doing it?

Where IT should be visible or invisible 33:35

Sanjog Aul [00:33:35]:
The question that we wanted to pose out there is that what are the different critical roles that IT plays in the strategic and operational aspects of running the organization? Now if you don’t know what it does, then when it comes time to really say, okay, where could IT may or may not play that critical role, then you can wipe it out or do things which may not be the right things to do. Because there may be some thumbs up and thumbs down when it comes to pulling the business users. And secondly, while we want to look at it, there is also another approach that some people say with respect to IT, that IT should remain invisible because the only time it should come up is when there’s a problem. So Robin, what are your thoughts?

Robin Arendt [00:34:21]:
Yeah. So one, I disagree that IT should be invisible, but let’s start with your first question here around it’s really the education of the business of understanding IT. And they’re not gonna wanna engage in a five hour dialogue to explain it. But I really put I would classify it in two different pieces. One, which is more of the run, the operations, they don’t need to know the details of that. And I do agree that you want that to be seamless to them that when they get in in the morning, their computer’s working, their phones are working, and you want that to be transparent and invisible. But really where I see the value and I think where this conversation is going and what I believe in with running IT like a business is you have this influencer role. It’s not the operator role as I described before but the influencer role. And this is really the role of not being invisible but being visible, having a seat at the table, helping to take that strategy and turning it into how IT can enable that beyond what the business could think of through automation. And that needs to be a very visible role. And you’ve got to earn, you’ve to have the right people within your organization that can challenge the business back, that has the business acumen and can really play that influencer role. And if you don’t have those people, I agree, you’re gonna end up becoming invisible. So it is about having the right people engaged, but then it’s having that dialogue with the business and changing the conversation. It’s not talking to them for five hours about how your operations group is managing the laptops and the systems. It’s not about that. It’s about how can you give them the next technology that will give them the business capability that will be differentiating in the marketplace. That’s the conversation you want to have and that’s what you want to be visible.

Sanjog Aul [00:36:28]:
So it’s great that we could be visible at the top and you can identify the opportunities that might exist for the top line growth and bottom line savings. At the same time, there’s something to be said about adoption being done bottom up, anything that you bring on board. And then anytime when you want these people to adopt or embrace any new changes that you are saying that IT is gonna help trigger and drive, then these business unit folks should also be having the respect that, hey, IT was there to help all along. And frankly, I didn’t have a problem. I could go about doing my job the whole day, and I didn’t have to call an IT guy for support. So this is like a two pronged. So you’ll be very visible at the top, and you’ll be invisible in the middle and the lower layer so that when it comes to getting the adoption done, you are not fighting the same people who are supposed to give you a thumbs up on any new technology because frankly you can bring the best system. But that might be given a thumbs down when they say IT just keeps throwing things at us.

Robin Arendt [00:37:25]:
Yeah, no, I agree with that. And that’s why you’ve got to have throughout all layers of the organization those relationships. And so I’ll just use an example of my project managers. Right? They’re the ones that are driving this new technology day to day, working with our business customers. And I needed to look at my project managers. I needed to look at, do I have the right skills of the people with the right business acumen? It’s not just following a work plan. It’s about really understanding the business at that level and ensuring that they can have those challenging dialogues with the business day in and day out. And so I don’t agree that it’s just at the top. You do have to infuse it in your organization and the key roles, and I’ll just call them business facing roles. But you gotta ensure you got the right people to do it with the right skills. And then you gotta give them the incentive and the goals and hold them accountable.

Security risk and the three way dialogue 38:30

Sanjog Aul [00:38:30]:
Now when we go about talking about risk and, of course, one of the biggest areas is security. Because when you try to say, you know what, if I’m gonna cut too much cost and there are so many other vulnerabilities that might become exposed to. And if IT leadership takes on that hat of wearing and telling that, hey, you know what, I’m going to be telling you how much risk can get introduced, it could potentially be seen as someone trying to sell us security, which is like selling insurance. And no pun intended, you being an insurance company. So what do you do here? Who comes and tells about the vulnerabilities? You want an external party to come and champion that for you?

Robin Arendt [00:39:08]:
Yeah. So we’ve got an internal audit group that we work very closely with and we’ve got a governance process around risk. And I think the combination of the IT folks with the audit individuals and then this risk governance group, it’s really a three way dialogue and together we have a process that together we identify what are the key business risks that we have now and that we believe based on the emerging trends we’re going to have in the future. And that really becomes a disciplined process here at Zurich on determining how we’re gonna invest in the coming year. And I think it’s a very mature process. Probably the best I’ve seen, having been in the industry here for 23 years, is really that risk is a big part of us determining managing those risks is in determining our investment strategy. And that feels good for me. So it’s usually not about me coming to the table with this is the risk I think we have to go after in selling it. It’s the three way dialogue that we have.

Sanjog Aul [00:40:18]:
Do you think there’s a common definition of organizational risk that actually exists and people buy into before you would start kind of course further slicing and dicing that?

Robin Arendt [00:40:29]:
I think it probably varies from company to company, but I do believe based on the frameworks we have here and the people that get engaged, we do have a common understanding and a threshold and the right people at the table to understand what are the right risks for us to focus on. But I think risk tolerance varies from company to company. But it’s an important part of how we work today within Zurich.

Insourcing versus using consultants 40:56

Sanjog Aul [00:40:56]:
Now when it comes to cutting costs again and not introducing risk at the same time, one of the mindset people have is like, let’s do it ourselves. And that is almost a small business mentality in some cases that if I have to save a buck, let me do it myself so that I don’t have to pay anybody outside. But even though you might end up spending more time and that could mean a lot more money, but then most large companies also end up insourcing many of the things, which they otherwise would have given out to a consultant or say, you know what, we’ll use our internal resource to do it who may not be capable without recognizing the capability. So why is this small business natural constraints of resources and accordingly the mentality creeps in into even the most like most large organizations sometimes?

Robin Arendt [00:41:42]:
Yes. You always have to have a balance I believe of putting a team together that is comprised of people internally that understand the business and a small, light group of consultants that have seen other industries and taken best practices from those industries and other insurance companies in really putting a team together of both. I think that’s the only way you’re gonna get the right actions to go after. I think if you bring in a 100% team of consultants, you’re gonna end up with nothing but a bunch of facts and numbers that you may not get the right answer. And it goes back to my belief of engaging the workforce in the process. And if you do that and you listen to them, they’re going to give you a lot of really good insight and a lot of really good opportunities by talking to them and taking the time that you wouldn’t have if you brought in a bunch of consultants sitting in a conference room within the executive towers. It’s just not the right way to go about it.

Sanjog Aul [00:42:53]:
No, it’s not uncommon to see a situation where while it is turbulent times, but then you also see a strategic project which needs to be executed and you do recognize that you don’t have the in house capability. What’s more risky? Whether to go ahead and outsource to an unknown set of people? Of course, you may know them from some relationships, but you don’t know how they’re going to play out in terms of helping you build that capability or build an inside group or somehow try to get it done using your workforce who may not be capable and that could jeopardize the whole initiative.

Robin Arendt [00:43:25]:
Yeah. So I’m a little bit, having been a consultant for 13 years before going into industry with an insurance here, I may have a different view than others. But I do believe it’s not an either or. I think it’s a combination of leveraging the consultants in the right work and ensuring that you’re taking your best talent to figure out a strategic project internally because that’s the only way it’s gonna be sustainable is because at the end of the day, they have to own it and they’re the ones that understand the day to day and you’re gonna come up with a better answer if you combine the two. But we do a lot of outsourcing here. Within the IT organization 5 years ago, a lot of our application maintenance went to an offshore provider. And that’s the reality of the businesses today. But we gave them the right work, the non strategic work for us, and they can do it at a more effective, more efficient price and we’re getting the lift for it. So you just again, you have to take a thoughtful approach.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:41]:
Now do you think that could actually work out well? Of course, the whole idea was that or the question was that if you are just at that time, the moment is such that when it’s turbulent time and you want to get a capability created, that’s the time when you’re embarking upon this journey versus an existing one where you’re just giving them more work. That’s where it could become a predicament for most organizations. So what would you suggest a company might do to evaluate the risk because it’s both like you’re stuck between a rock and a hard place?

Robin Arendt [00:45:11]:
So why wouldn’t you engage some consultants to give a point of view, but why wouldn’t you engage a high performing team within your organization augmented with that group?

Sanjog Aul [00:45:22]:
So you’re saying take a hybrid approach?

Robin Arendt [00:45:24]:
Yes, absolutely. That’s in my mind that’s the only way to do it.

Sanjog Aul [00:45:29]:
And if we are looking at collaboration when this whole cost cutting initiative is to be done and of course Robin mentioned about as you have to sit down with the folks today, what is the end result attributed to or who takes the credit and or the penalty for something’s not going right when you did go about creating some cost cutting going through some cost cutting measures and there were some risks which got introduced which you may not have planned for, who happens to take the ownership of that.

Sanjog Aul [00:48:56]:
So we’re talking collaboration, and we have spoken about it, during the show earlier when, we have to really work very closely with the business. Now you could collaborate at the time of planning, you could collaborate at the time of execution. How much of attribute, who attributes the risk or who takes ownership of the risk in terms of in the IT we have cutting costs and going on in IT and then there is some problems that surface?

Robin Arendt [00:49:27]:
Yes. So I think there’s been a common theme through the conversation that I’ve brought to the table around collaboration is key. And, to me, it’s I really don’t think about who in the end is gonna take credit or get the penalty if something goes wrong. That’s just not how I think. But what I do like to do is upfront, you really need to look at the end result. You need to define what success looks like, and you need to define what success looks like for all the parties around the table. And if that gets measured, and I’m a huge believer in measuring kind of the before and after because then that really defines what success looks like. And then working towards that, and if something goes wrong, you gotta quickly reassess and change course and get it back on track and not waste the time finger pointing. The way I look at things is it’s an all hands on deck approach when issues come up, regardless if it’s a business issue, an IT issue and having the right people at the table solving the problem regardless of your role is really the culture and my expectations that I set within the IT organization here.

Sanjog Aul [00:50:47]:
No, we always try to strive for bringing some structure to the kiosk in almost every area of management. So this could be one of them. Do you think there are standards, best practices or something that some people can look up and say, hey, this is tried and tested? At least this is a good starting point and maybe this could become a guideline that we could embrace and work with.

Robin Arendt [00:51:07]:
Yes. So again, it goes back to look for the best practices within the organization and then use that as models and propagate. A lot of the times people will go outside for thinking that they’re gonna get a better answer or a better framework or a better process or a better technology because they’re paying a lot of money by going outside. And I just think some people just don’t take the time to ask the people within their four walls and look for the best practice within that organization. And a lot of times, that’s the answer for you because it exists. There’s high performers in this organization and they’re doing really good things. And it’s a matter of you getting out of your office and going to talk to people and finding out where they exist. And then that people get excited about that because, they see that their coworker is getting recognized. And then they’ll try and do something different and change and improve. And it helps create the right culture you want versus any problem you have bringing in external to help you.

Sanjog Aul [00:52:18]:
When you look at the world around you and of course coming out of the Zurich side of things, you see many of those folks and having their horror stories and the painful journey that they’re going through. Are there some very obvious pitfalls or shortcomings that you see they could overcome and then they would not have such a painful journey?

Advice on avoiding across the board cuts 52:41

Robin Arendt [00:52:41]:
Related to the cost cutting is my advice is don’t ever go in and do a random 10% to 20% across the board. That just is not gonna it’s very shortsighted. So I think that is the first piece of advice. The other piece is really be a role model for others. So taking that owner’s mindset that you have a piece of the share in this company and if you were an owner of the business, what action would you take? What would you do different if you owned this business? I’ve asked people that question and they give me a different answer when I ask them that question versus them just following a process because a policy exists on a piece of paper. So it’s another piece of advice. And then I’d say the third piece of advice is to look internally at the best practices versus always looking to get the expertise from the outside because you’ve got the best practices and the thought leaders a lot of times within your own organization. You’ve got the quality people. And if you tap that knowledge and you give the recognition, it’s gonna really help lift the organization and provide the right culture you want.

Sanjog Aul [00:54:06]:
Now since this is part science and part art, would you say there’s any part of the art that has not been mastered or that you would love to get better hands on?

Robin Arendt [00:54:20]:
I do think it’s the balance. But I would love to have, if I was the CEO here, I would love to be able to rotate people between the IT organization into the business and vice versa. I would love to do a lot more rotation because I think if you walk in the shoes of someone else and you understand the job that they have to do day in and day out, you’re gonna create an environment of a lot more collaboration and a lot more joint problem solving and I wish that we could do more of that.

Sanjog Aul [00:54:59]:
Now if you were to look at the current situation where we are neither in total dire straits in terms of economy nor are we totally in the heyday. So in this transition period, would you change your strategy a little bit on the cost cutting?

Robin Arendt [00:55:16]:
Well, we’ve done our homework, I should say. The due diligence has been done. And so in my mind, now is the time to ensure that you’re focusing and you’re investing in the strategic capabilities that when we see the market turnaround you’re in a position to take advantage of those market opportunities. And so, I wouldn’t change the strategy because we’ve been on this journey for the last 2 years in anticipation of this and we made the tough decisions, but now we’ve refocused and we are going to be in a position with some new technology to be able to take advantage of the market turn. And that’s important. You sometimes just got to stick to the strategy.

Contributors

Robin Arendt

Robin Arendt, Chief Information Officer , Zurich North America Commercial

Robin Arendt is chief information officer for Zurich North America Commercial and is responsible for end-to-end delivery of IT Services in North America. She also develops and maintains strong relationship with the Executive team, Global IT... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

FPT Webinar DigitalPractical MPU 300X250
Robin Arendt