Culture • Leadership

Creating an Authentic Organization

Creating an Authentic Organization

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Sue B. Workman (Case Western Reserve University), Stephen Elkins (City of Austin, Texas), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that an authentic organization is one where the values and purpose of its people line up with the organization’s mission, and that this is a tall order. Sue B. Workman of Case Western Reserve University argued that a value-driven organization survives longer than a results-only one, because IT people have too many job choices to stay where their ideals are ignored, and she said leaders should hold coaching sessions at regular intervals, set stretch goals, and even encourage strong people to leave for a better opportunity while keeping the door open. Stephen Elkins of the City of Austin, Texas said his department rewrote its mission from an IT shop to a customer service shop about a year earlier, built its goals inclusively around pillars of customer experience, employee experience, flexible sourcing, and One City IT, and aligned them with the city’s mission. Both concluded that leaders must be honest about what they can deliver, telling the business you do less with less, not more with less.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Sue B. Workman, Chief Information Officer at Case Western Reserve University, and Stephen Elkins, Chief Information Officer at the City of Austin, Texas, about how to build an authentic organization where people’s values and purpose line up with the organization’s mission. Workman argues that a value-driven organization retains talent longer than one focused only on results, and that knowledge workers want to be coached, set stretch goals, and understand how their contribution ties to the mission. Elkins describes changing his department’s mission from an IT shop to a customer service shop, developing goals throughout the organization rather than pushing them down from the top, and aligning the department’s mission and vision with the city’s. Both compare coaching employees to raising children, favor developing strengths over fixing weaknesses, and argue for replacing help-desk metrics like ticket counts with measures of customer and employee experience.

Contributors

  • Sue B. Workman, Chief Information Officer, Case Western Reserve University
  • Stephen Elkins, Chief Information Officer, City of Austin, Texas

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Sue B. Workman, Chief Information Officer at Case Western Reserve University, says an authentic organization is one where the values and purpose of its people align with the organization’s mission. She calls it a tall order because leaders have to get the right people into the right spots so that both the people and the organization move forward.
  • Stephen Elkins, Chief Information Officer at the City of Austin, Texas, says the goals of an organization cannot be developed at the top and pushed down but must be built throughout the organization. About a year earlier his department rewrote its mission from an IT shop to a customer service shop, with pillars of customer experience, employee experience, flexible sourcing, and One City IT.
  • Sue B. Workman of Case Western Reserve University says a value-driven organization outlasts a results-only one because IT people have too many job choices to stay somewhere that ignores their ideals. She tells her staff she wants them to be ultra successful and hopes people giving 8 to 10 hours a day actually enjoy the work.
  • Stephen Elkins of the City of Austin, Texas says leaders must be honest with the business about what current tools allow, telling his city management he could give best effort but not best managed. He summed it up by saying you do less with less, not more with less.
  • Sue B. Workman of Case Western Reserve University says traditional measures should give way to coaching sessions at regular intervals such as 3, 6, or 12 months and to metrics on whether customers got a solution and were treated with courtesy and respect. She even encourages strong performers to leave for a better opportunity while keeping the door open, and reviews exit interviews to learn why people go.
  • Stephen Elkins, Chief Information Officer at the City of Austin, Texas, says the softer leadership and customer service skills are where IT training falls short, not the technical training. His department runs Crucial Conversations sessions open to all levels, assigns mentors from the leadership team, and buys books for the executive team to read and discuss.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: creating an authentic organization
  • 1:42 Why an authentic workplace is a tall order
  • 5:13 Authenticity in a government IT organization
  • 7:43 Building goals throughout the organization
  • 10:30 The leader’s role in authenticity
  • 16:26 Coaching people like a parent
  • 22:36 Aligning mission and vision
  • 31:22 Value-driven versus result-driven
  • 41:16 Metrics beyond help-desk tickets
  • 46:41 Training the softer skills
  • 54:18 Three words for fellow leaders

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: creating an authentic organization 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:22]:
The topic for today is creating an Authentic Organization, and our guests for today’s show are Sue B. Workman, who’s the Chief Information Officer with Case Western Reserve University.

Sanjog Aul [00:00:52]:
We also have Stephen Elkins, who’s the CIO with City of Austin, Texas. So Steve must be joining us shortly, but we will get started here. So, Sue, when we are looking at this topic and, actually, as part of developing this topic, we looked up the definition of what authenticity is. It is basically when we are being ourselves, true to ourselves and to others, not only in feelings, but also in actions, in the way we express, in the way we even process ideas. So it’s authenticity all over, being true to self and others all over. That said, we say we want to build an authentic organization, which in this case is a workplace. Is this a tall order?

Why an authentic workplace is a tall order 1:42

Sue B. Workman [00:01:42]:
Yes. It is a tall order. I think today I really think of authentic organizations as where the values align with the values and purpose align with both the organization’s mission and the purpose of the people and the people that are in that organization. In today’s world, that’s a hard thing to do, just in getting the right people and figuring out how to get them in the right spots in order to really move the organization along as well as them.

Sanjog Aul [00:02:17]:
And so when you say that it is, of course, it is tough. We understand that. Now if we don’t do it, it is grossly going to undermine what an organization can deliver to its customers and to the people who work for that organization. So the stakes are high too. So what do you think, we have reached a point where what we are trying to deliver is making us, basically motivating us to ignore what other challenges we may have and charge ahead and actually convert any organization into an authentic organization.

Sue B. Workman [00:02:51]:
Well, I think it is tough. I think just the challenges that we have daily in organizations now to be able to stay afloat and make sure that we are, if you’re in a company making a profit or if you’re in an organization like I’m in, in higher education, that we’re able to deliver the services at a price that students are willing to pay. Then I think it’s really a tall order now, but I think it’s really required in order to really move the country and the world along. I think we’ve got to have organizations that can function at a very high level and have people in it that are quite motivated and excited about the work that they do and understand really where they fit in that organization and how they relate to the mission of that organization.

Sanjog Aul [00:03:51]:
When we look at commercial organizations who are there, of course, to make profit, there would be some people, if they were to listen to a topic like this, they will pooh-pooh it because they’ll say, okay, if we were to get real, that’s quote unquote real, then authenticity cannot survive. What do you have to say to that?

Sue B. Workman [00:04:10]:
Well, I think that’s just not right anymore. I think the workforce that we have, and the one that’s just entering the workforce now, these people want to be real. They want to contribute. They want to have a sense of purpose and mission, and so I think in order to really attract the right people into your organization, you really have to think about, it’s more than just days of old where people would come into a factory and work 8 hours and leave. Now you need the knowledge workers that really want to be there and can contribute above and beyond what’s maybe even expected.

Sanjog Aul [00:04:53]:
So we have Steve Elkins, Chief Information Officer, City of Austin, Texas, has joined us.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:01]:
Now you just may have heard Sue’s comments about authenticity, and you work for the government. Now let’s talk authenticity with you. How’s that going?

Authenticity in a government IT organization 5:13

Stephen Elkins [00:05:13]:
So it’s interesting. As I looked at what the topic was, I wasn’t actually familiar with the term, and as I started researching, I realized that the process has been in place for a long time. It’s just the terminology is new. So I would say that this is something we’re striving to do, is to become an authentic organization. We’re focused on the customer service side of things, the customer experience, the employee experience. These are things that are very important to the city’s organization.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:50]:
Now what does an authentic organization look like, Sue, compared to an inauthentic? What are some of the things, not essentially that somebody’s cheating or lying, but what do you see as a difference in the characteristics of some organization which is authentic versus the one which is not?

Sue B. Workman [00:06:09]:
Well, I think that an authentic organization really knows what it’s striving for, and it has a sense of purpose. I think you said the definition was really to be yourself, and so I think the organization has to be able to know what it is and then align the people, the jobs, and the processes and every part of it with all the stakeholders, basically, in order to really maintain that sense of purpose. So I think people that work in a real authentic organization align with it, and I think that can change from time to time, but there are people that understand that they make a contribution every day and what their contribution is, versus inauthentic, where maybe they just go in to do their job and leave.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:09]:
So, Steve, one is to think about authenticity as a tool or a carrot, if you will, to attract the right talent. Now that’s great. You are bringing people in and the right talent, which is going to serve you well. However, when they do come in, the DNA of the organization could transform them for the better or for the worse. How do you maintain authenticity within the organization that these people are actually improving on what they brought and eventually, the cumulative effect of everyone working in an authentic manner leads the right results?

Building goals throughout the organization 7:43

Stephen Elkins [00:07:43]:
Good question. So I think, just to build on what Sue was talking about, it’s important that you’re inclusive with the goals of the organization. You cannot have the goals of the organization developed at the top and then try to push those down. So what you have to do is develop the goals of the organization throughout the organization. We actually went through this process about 1 year ago, and we changed our mission statement. We no longer say that we’re an IT shop. We say we’re a customer service shop, and we’ve actually come up with some, what we call pillars, which are our focus areas, which is customer experience, the employee experience, and we look at flexible sourcing. What is the right mix of people we need in our organization? And then the other one is One City IT, that we’re all marching in the same direction to achieve a common goal. By developing that and the goals, we were really inclusive in developing those so that there’s buy-in throughout the organization on what it is we’re trying to do. I tell folks that we’re not in the fixing PC business, we’re in the customer service business. If folks feel included in the culture as we bring in new talent, then hopefully that culture resonates throughout, and the individuals that we bring in are free to say, hey, I got an idea. How about we do this? Or here’s a way we can improve the customer experience, or here’s a way we can improve the employee experience. We allow the ownership to not sit with just the leadership, but the ownership can sit within the whole organization. So I think that’s what you have to do. You have to have the right culture, and the new folks coming in have to buy into the idea that the organization is walking the talk and not just talking it.

Sanjog Aul [00:09:43]:
So we could have a great vision. You could have a leader who is really a charmer, and then you could have a very compelling value proposition of why you should do what you should do, but then the devil is in the very execution: how individuals come together, how they interact, how do they truly put the agendas on the table, and get the grievances addressed, and interact with each other. All of those things that happen within an organization and the sum total of that is what we deliver is where authenticity can be compromised or enhanced. How do you keep a check on all of that?

The leader’s role in authenticity 10:30

Sue B. Workman [00:10:30]:
Well, I can start off with that. I think it’s really up to the leader to make sure that those things are happening. You can do that by building your teamwork, making sure that communication is happening between them, training them, giving them leadership training. Especially in the IT organization, we often say, oh, you’re a really great technologist. How about you become a manager? And we don’t really train people what it takes to be a manager or even beyond that to be a leader and a strategic leader. So I think we really have to have some professional development, and we have to tell them what’s expected and measure upon that. So if we expect that they will act like an authentic organization, first of all, the leader needs to act that way and make sure that they are very trustworthy and give people the environment that they need in order to thrive and then hold people accountable, and then coach them. Everybody needs coaching along the way to say, let’s get you back on track here. Let’s figure out how to make this work. So I really think much of the actions of the employee are actually requirements of the leader.

Sanjog Aul [00:12:07]:
So, Steve, if you were to look at any organization where people are working, whatever they are doing, they are coming from different backgrounds. So you may have people who are long timers, who may have things happening in their personal lives and their social life, etcetera, which may, or there may be influences where people may tell them to do this or that and which may not be true reflection of how they think, and you on the other hand are working hard to try to build that authentic culture. So you’ve got competing forces here. How do you beat those forces? Well, these are tough questions. Right, Steve?

Stephen Elkins [00:12:44]:
So I would just say this has to be a journey in trying to get to the destination, but you have to go through the journey. You have to realize that you’re not going to be able to have 100% compliance. I think what you want to do is focus your efforts on the folks who are interested in being part of an authentic organization and hope that some of the naysayers who feel that, oh this is just another program that’ll just last another year or two, and then something else will come up after this, will see the culture shift and want to be part of that culture shift, or maybe determine that the culture shift is too much and they’re not a good fit for the organization anymore. As you do it, it has to be a long-term commitment. You change as outside forces change; you have to change what makes your organization authentic. I don’t think you actually achieve 100% compliance within your organization, but you try to change the culture and hope that the folks who are challenging either get on board or they find out that they’re on the wrong bus.

Sanjog Aul [00:14:19]:
So we’ll take this question after the break, but I wanted to lay it out for you. So how about us thinking as a parent? And when our child may be getting some advice or notions which they will bring from school or some of their friends, which may not be right for them and which may otherwise be rendering them as inauthentic. So it’s our job to somehow tell them or somehow change that, or maybe make them immune to such comments going forward. The same concept applies to a leader who would basically counter whatever the counterproductive inputs that are being given to our employees or people in the organization and which is making them inauthentic. We have to counter it and where the parents had. How would we do that? What will we say or do so that they start listening to you more versus the outsiders and also shed that negative influence and start working with you to build an authentic organization?

Coaching people like a parent 16:26

Sanjog Aul [00:16:26]:
So, Sue, let’s compare ourselves to a parent, and how would you take care of your kids?

Sue B. Workman [00:16:33]:
Well, as a parent and now a grandparent, I would take the grandparents’ approach as the easy way out and say, you need to talk to your parents, but I think the thing is to just sit down and really address it with people. People have emotions. I think we used to ask our workers to check their emotions at the door, and that’s really not a good way to have an authentic organization. We need to, just as we would with our children, sit down and say, let’s talk about it, and help them think through things. Maybe don’t just tell them what you want, but help them by asking questions and getting them to come to that conclusion on their own. That will help them to really make things work better for them. I think you can do the same thing with adults and just help them come to their own conclusion and they’ll buy into it better than if you’re just telling them.

Sanjog Aul [00:17:42]:
So, Steve, your comment for the question that I’d asked previously: you’d suggested that we at least work with the A players, if you will, the ones who voluntarily want to be authentic and want to work with you, and the others, you try, but you do not try to a degree where you take the focus away from the A players. Do you think that’s the strategy that’s going to take the company forward, the organization forward, and make everyone authentic?

Stephen Elkins [00:18:09]:
It’s a strategy. There’s an HR methodology that identifies people’s strengths and their weaknesses, and then you try to develop their weaknesses. Another approach is that you cater to their strengths. Maybe the A players represent the strengths of the organization, and then you focus on those individuals to move the organization forward and not try to expend all your energy trying to turn folks who are not interested in going in the direction that the organization is going, but Sue has some valid points. You allow people to have a voice; maybe they have ideals or a reason why they’re a naysayer or not interested. If you can help them get to the same place, then you’re better off, but if there’s no way of turning those folks, I don’t think you invest a lot of time and take away from the folks who are interested.

Sanjog Aul [00:19:25]:
So the interesting part about authenticity is that sometimes even us as leaders, for example, Sue, I’ll take your example. You may be leading people with the best intent, but sometimes you may get caught in that authentic versus inauthentic dilemma, and you may not know if you have tilted more towards inauthentic. I’m not saying you are doing it, but I’m saying any leader could have that temptation, and if that happens, smaller or bigger decisions are being made every day, and that could lead to, again, a cumulative effect of what’s the level of authenticity an organization achieves. So how do we, as leaders, try to lead by example and be authentic at all times because the whole organization depends on us?

Sue B. Workman [00:20:14]:
Well, I think that is our job as a leader: to be the example, come in every day, and basically have your game plan ready to go. You can be authentic, and there are times when maybe you aren’t on your A game or life is getting in the way for you. I think you do have to sit back and think about that and be very careful. People are usually pretty good about accepting those things and trying to help you. I think you can also say, I need a little help. Let’s think through this. Or I could use a little coaching here. Whether they’re direct reports or whether they’re your teammates.

Sue B. Workman [00:21:21]:
I think it’s okay to show that maybe you aren’t quite sure about where you need to go. I think there’s all this stuff about life balance and career balance and that kind of thing, and I really don’t think that exists. I think it’s more of a harmonic. Today’s workforce and our jobs and our lives are about 24 hours a day. We really have to figure out how this works in a harmonic. Sometimes we have a major chord that’s going just fine, and sometimes we have a minor chord that might not quite be where we want to be. So I think we just have to work together and figure out how to make things the best we can make them.

Sanjog Aul [00:22:13]:
Steve, if this was a result-driven organization, which is going to look at the results versus the process or the capabilities we are developing for our people along the way, then authenticity can be compromised, but at the same time, the top-level people just care about results. How do you battle it?

Aligning mission and vision 22:36

Stephen Elkins [00:22:36]:
Hopefully, you can have your mission and vision, which is driving the authentic organization, aligned to the mission and vision of the overall organization. For me personally, I’ve been fortunate that the City of Austin has really focused on the customer experience. My vision statement for the department says to be the strategic IT business partner of choice. The mission statement says to provide excellent customer experience and deliver innovative business technology solutions. We’ve tried to align our mission and vision with the city’s overall mission and vision so that we’re in alignment. If you’re out of alignment, my recommendation would be that maybe the mission and vision of the department may need some adjusting to align, because you’re going to get better as you try to become authentic if the folks in your organization can see the linkage between what they do, what the mission and vision is, and how that ties to the mission and vision of the overall organization. It’s easier to digest. If you are trying to say something completely different, like the mission and vision is to put out 10 apps a year and it doesn’t tie to anything, then you have a hard time getting folks to follow you in that space. So I think you probably need to review whether you have the right mission and vision to lead that authentic organization effort.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:26]:
So, Steve, your point is well taken that we should have vision and mission which will drive everyone. Now let me take an example. I will not name the company, but I spoke to someone who was this leader in the customer service department, and the CEO came to him and said, I want you to make the absolutely best customer service organization and go do whatever you want to do, but then at the same time, when he started looking at the budgets, the people that are assigned, and the quality of people he’s allowed to get, there has been resistance across the organization. So here from the top he’s getting the pressure that you have to deliver results, but when you are kind of given the responsibility with one hand tied behind your back, what do you do? This person admitted that he had to succumb to that pressure, and he had to keep telling the CEO that we are working hard, and also even when he said he wanted to have more resources, that was not really considered to the degree he would like to. So, of course, the results would suffer, and then he started falling into that spiral of inauthenticity where he was telling, oh, yeah. Everything is going great, but behind the scenes, it was really not because he was tied and his job was at stake. So, Sue, when I bring you this situation, what should have happened from an organizational standpoint? What should the organization do to extend their support? Or how could they have done to change this? And how should this individual as a leader have performed or responded to the situation?

Sue B. Workman [00:26:05]:
I think, first of all, if that’s what the leader really wants, then the person responding, the manager, should be very honest with his response and should not be saying, yeah, everything’s going well if everything’s not. I think you can always say, if this is our goal, this is what I have to have in order to do this. This is what I’ve already reallocated or this is what I’ve already done to address that, but in order to reach the goal that you’ve outlined for me, this is what I’m going to have to do. Is this still the goal, or do we need to do something different? I think you should be able to actually tell the truth and be very factual about how things are presented. I do think in that situation, and I’ve kind of been in that situation in different parts of my life, you do have to also be very innovative and look and see, are there new things that we can do? Are there ways to prevent any kind of occurrence that would require customer interaction with your service desk? Are there ways to set expectations at a lower cost? Sometimes if you can’t hire the level of employees that you want because of, say, a salary or a compensation budget, sometimes it’s better to think about, instead of two entry-level people, maybe you need to hire a more mature, higher-level person to do that job. I think you just have to look at things differently to see what you can do first before complaining or telling people you can’t do it. What is it that you can do first and then figure out what it’s going to take to really make the goal work, but all in all, it doesn’t do you any good to say things are going well if they aren’t.

Stephen Elkins [00:28:39]:
Sanjog, can I also comment on this question? I also had a similar situation. The city manager’s message is always to be the best managed. We want to be the best managed organization in the country. When I was given what we would like to get out of a best-managed IT shop, when I looked at what was being asked and what could actually be delivered, I had to go back and have a conversation with city management and say, I can’t give you best managed, I can only give you best effort based on the tools I have available today. It was a hard conversation, but you have to be in an organization where you’re free to say what you’re asking for doesn’t match the pieces that are in place. Based on what you want me to do, we either have two choices. We change the expectation, which is I give you best effort with the tools I have, or you provide the tools to help us get to a best-managed organization. We met somewhere in the middle, but you have to have that conversation. You cannot say, yes, we can do it, we can achieve it. There’s that phrase they say, do more with less. I always say you do less with less. You don’t do more with less.

Sanjog Aul [00:30:01]:
Let’s compare and contrast a result-driven organization and a value-driven organization. Which one would actually be more conducive to instilling authenticity across the chain of command?

Value-driven versus result-driven 31:22

Sanjog Aul [00:31:22]:
So, Sue, why don’t you take this question about a value-driven organization versus result-driven, because result-driven organizations may not really care as much about the process. Did they trample over people’s heads? Did somebody get fired or someone was demotivated? Somebody lost their authenticity? They just want to see the numbers, and value is when value is created at all levels. Which one is more practical, and which one would lead to a more authentic organization?

Sue B. Workman [00:31:57]:
Well, I would really like to see organizations that have both results and values. I think if you’re only results oriented, your people are not going to stay around long now, especially in IT organizations. There are too many choices. There are a lot of jobs that are available for people that might align better to their ideals. So it’s hard to retain talent in that kind of organization where we’re just looking at the bottom line or really looking at just a goal for the corporation and not including the values of the people of that organization. A value-driven organization will, in fact, survive longer. It will allow people to think about what it is that they’re doing and contributing. I have actually told my own organization here that we need to enjoy this. Yes, we work very hard, and we do deliver results, but I hope that if people are giving 8 to 10 hours a day, maybe even more, to their work, that they are enjoying that. That’s a big part of their life. I really want them to have fun doing it, at least most of the time. I don’t think you can have fun all of the time or they wouldn’t call it work. I do think that I want them to really have an experience where they know how they’re contributing. They know what their individual contributions mean to higher education or to the students, faculty, and staff here at Case Western Reserve. So a value-based organization, I think, will be much more successful in the long run.

Sanjog Aul [00:34:00]:
So, Steve, when you’re looking at this value-driven versus result-driven, are you thinking that with value-driven, we would produce the results anyway, but at the same time, people will be far more relaxed and they would feel more connected to the cause?

Stephen Elkins [00:34:20]:
I do. I really can’t add much more to what Sue said. I think you’re right. You want both. You would hope that the values will lead to results, but your focus cannot be results only because you will not get people to stay. They will not buy into the cause. It would feel like just a factory. By having values in the front of all of that, your organization is going to be a healthier organization, and you’re going to get more out of employees, and hopefully you’ll get less turnover because of that as well.

Sanjog Aul [00:35:09]:
So we’ve heard that when it is a knowledge worker versus someone who is pulling out widgets or creating widgets, as Steve said, in a factory, then their mindset is a little different. Their way they would produce better quality would be a totally different set of incentives, totally different set of environment. So given IT and maybe many of the businesses today have moved to becoming more of the knowledge-worker oriented, if you were to provide the environment that will make this knowledge worker become the best they can be and all along be the most authentic they can be, what would that look like?

Sue B. Workman [00:35:50]:
I think it looks like the leader or the manager of that person needs to sit down with them and establish goals and ask about their own career objectives and give people opportunities, give people stretch goals, and help them to really grow. When those opportunities come about, then you can help them to move into those and coach them and mentor them. In today’s world, knowledge workers really need to be coached. They want to be coached. They want to learn and excel and succeed. So we have to give them all the tools and resources that they need in order to make realization of those goals. It’s not that hard if you think about it. I tell people all the time in my organization I want them to be ultra successful. When I first started saying that, they looked at me like, really? You do? I’m like, yeah. I do. I want you to be ultra successful. I want you to have everything that you need in order to grow and be able to do the current job that you have and be able to move on to the next one. If we take that position and really help all people to be successful, then everything will be a lot better for the entire organization.

Sanjog Aul [00:37:34]:
So, Steve, when you’re looking at the short-term goals versus the long-term goals, this is something where we have eye on the ball, everybody’s working so you can watch it, but then once the project is over and you’re looking across multiple projects, more different people come and go. If you were to have an authenticity meter, which you had to maintain as people are coming and going and especially in today’s day and age, to be very frank, when you have got this Agile project management techniques where things are literally getting done within months, do you think you have the luxury to start assessing the authenticity level and the value driven, etcetera?

Stephen Elkins [00:38:14]:
I do. I think you have to figure out a way to assess it. There would not be a one-size-fits-all type of assessment. I think what you would do is try to come up with some common assessments, but then also try to determine for the Agile space, maybe the assessment is not so much on the process itself, but more so the customer experience. If we assess the customer experience and if that’s our focus, then I think you could assess whether or not we’re an authentic organization based on that. If we’re striving to deliver the best customer service experience and at the same time have an enriching employee experience, I think you could actually figure out metrics around that.

Sanjog Aul [00:39:23]:
So, Sue, if I were to ask you the same question about having an authenticity meter in the fast-paced, warp-speed-based organizational velocity, if you will, that we have today, do you think these things matter? If they do, then how do you change tires of a moving car? A fast-moving car.

Sue B. Workman [00:39:48]:
Yeah. You do it really fast, but I think there are some metrics. I do think that we need to have performance evaluation and coaching sessions for every employee. At some regular interval, maybe 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, whatever really fits that need. We need to have those. We need to have employees set their own goals as well and figure out what they have done in order to meet those goals, just professional development in general. I’ve heard people say I don’t have time to go to this professional development activity. It’s like, oh, yes, you do. We have to make that. We have to have either some time flex or backup so that employees can continue to hone their skills, especially in IT, where very quickly current skills can be quite out of date. I do think there are some metrics. Maybe they’re not the general how many Xs did you do, but more how did you achieve the goals that were set before you?

Metrics beyond help-desk tickets 41:16

Stephen Elkins [00:41:16]:
One thing to add on to that is some of the common goals in our space are how many help-desk tickets did you close, how fast did you close them, what is the uptime of the hardware. Those traditional things do not measure whether or not you’re an authentic organization. So you have to move away from those traditional performance measures and look more at the employee side and have coaching and mentoring. On the customer side, are the customers satisfied with the level of service they’re getting? At one point, when we tried to close tickets as fast as possible, staff was closing tickets without solving the problem. So we had to say, can we close the ticket and not have it reopened? That’s a different metric now. It’s making sure that we fix the problem and we’re not just focused on closing the tickets without addressing the problems.

Sue B. Workman [00:42:16]:
Right. I think there are metrics around all of those. I don’t believe in measuring first-call resolution for its own sake. I don’t care how many calls it takes. I want them to solve the problem as fast as possible and get the customer working productively, but along with that, we do measure, did you get a solution, were you treated with courtesy and respect, so that we do have some feedback on how interactions were done. That doesn’t mean people would necessarily get in trouble, but it may identify a training opportunity that we need to address with our staff. You can look at metrics like exit interviews. Why is this employee leaving? Is there something I can do to retain them? Sometimes it’s best for the person to leave in order to expand. I even encourage that sometimes: kick them out of the nest. You need to grow; you need to be able to fly a little bit on your own. If people are leaving because they’re unhappy or a personal situation, then you need to figure out what you can do to address that. If they’re leaving because somebody’s offering them $50,000 more to go, then you need to be thinking about what you can do to address that problem or just know that you can’t. If somebody is leaving for a great opportunity, then you congratulate them and make sure that you always leave the door open. So I just think that there are different metrics that you can begin to look at that maybe traditionally haven’t really been ones you focus on.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:31]:
I’d like to pose a question to you, Steve: if I have to take my daughter for a swimming class, I want to make sure that the trainer knows how to swim properly and he or she will not cause issue while training this individual to the maximum. My daughter’s life and well-being should not be jeopardized in the process. I wanted to relate this back to the type of training we spoke about, that we have to send people for training. What are we training them for? Especially people at the lowest most level in the organization, mostly skills, but we are talking about authenticity here. Who trains them? How do you get that type of training? And how do you rely on the type of outsourced training, or even your own managers, that they are being trained by the best?

Sanjog Aul [00:46:25]:
So Steve, I asked you this question about a swimming class that my daughter may be sent to, but I’m not sure if I can really rely on the trainer, whether they would really teach her well, but at the same time also be taking care of her well-being.

Training the softer skills 46:41

Stephen Elkins [00:46:41]:
I think that’s a good question. In the IT space we do a good job of sending folks off for technical training. We make sure they understand how to work on the different hardware and the different applications they support, but the area where we may not be as good is on the softer skills, which are leadership skills and customer service skills. How do we get them that training? One, you could have work groups within your own organization. We have a work group where we do Crucial Conversations; it’s open to all levels so individuals are given an opportunity to learn how to engage in conversations that may not be comfortable. We assign individuals mentors on our leadership team so they can have a relationship with somebody in a leadership role and bounce ideas back and forth. As far as outside training, one thing I’ve done is purchase books. I’ll buy a book that I think is good for my executive team and say, here’s a book I’d like all of you to read, and then have a discussion about the key points inside the book.

Sanjog Aul [00:48:41]:
So we know that most organizations are not just 10 people. Sometimes we compare the leader to a coach and you’ve got an NBA team and someone really makes all of them stars, but that doesn’t happen in real life for the larger organizations. So you’ve got to be able to identify either your clone, assuming that you are the person who can make people become most authentic. Otherwise, what’s your plan?

Sue B. Workman [00:49:08]:
Well, that’s a tough one. You’re right, not everybody’s a star. Actually, in athletic teams, not everybody’s a star either. Everyone on an athletic team has a role. My role on my college basketball team was to be a really great practicer. I was there to make everybody else better because I’m not the star. I think you still have to have roles for people, and you have to help them figure those roles out. Not everybody may be the rah-rah cheerleader. You have to have your organization in a good place so that you have the right people leading and able to set the environment well. For people who can’t or don’t want to do those kinds of things, get them in roles where they don’t have to. I’ve had organizations up to over 400 people, and people don’t scale. The more you have, you really have to take care of them. If you have 2 children or 6 children, just because you have more doesn’t mean they scale. They each need care and feeding and attention and emotional support. So with an employment team you have to make sure your team is laid out so that each does get professional development and technical support as well as emotional support and ways to help them grow.

Stephen Elkins [00:51:26]:
I think that goes back to something I said earlier as well: you can either try to find somebody’s weakness and develop that weakness, or you try to take advantage of their strengths. In some situations, you identify what a person’s strength is and that’s the role they play in your organization, which may not be a superstar role, but a valued role. They need to understand what their role is and how that contributes to the overall goals of the organization. Again, it’s not putting them in a position where you’re giving them development opportunities that are an uncomfortable space for them and where they’re not going to thrive. You may have set somebody up for failure. There are other folks in the organization who, as soon as you push them out of the nest, will thrive, but there are others who will not. So you allow them to operate in the area where they’re best suited.

Sue B. Workman [00:52:35]:
And let them know it’s okay.

Sue B. Workman [00:52:39]:
Steve referred to strengths. There is a good book by Marcus Buckingham: First, Break All the Rules and Now, Discover Your Strengths. It really talks about how you want to increase your strengths and not just always increase your weaknesses because that may not be where you will thrive, but thriving on your strengths.

Sanjog Aul [00:53:22]:
And one last question for both of you, 30 seconds each. If you had to give three words each to the fellow leaders who may be improving the way they are going to work towards building authentic organizations, what would those be? So starting with you, Sue, and Steve, you cannot repeat what Sue shares.

Sue B. Workman [00:53:44]:
Well, I think first is examine your own values, and I guess that’s 4 words there, but I would concentrate on values, make sure that you have people in the right seats in your organization, and I guess also professional development: concentrate on your own professional development, be it leadership or technology, and your staff.

Three words for fellow leaders 54:18

Stephen Elkins [00:54:18]:
So my three words are lead by example. When I first joined the IT organization at City as the CIO, one of the things I was working on putting in place was a governance process. Prior to that, the CIO had pretty much all the authority on technology decisions. By putting a governance process in place, I allowed the businesses to be part of the process and help determine the direction we should go from a technology standpoint, not so much on the solution side, but on the business solutions that needed to be implemented. Leading by example showed my team that this overall was good for the organization. In turn, we have better relationships with the customers we support because now they’re part of the decision process. They understand the transparency behind the decisions. Lead by example has been helpful for me.

Contributors

Stephen Elkins

Stephen Elkins, Chief Information Officer, City of Austin, Texas

Stephen Elkins Chief Information Officer, City of Austin, Texas Stephen Elkins is the Chief Information Officer for the City of Austin, Texas. The Columbus, Ohio, native came to the city of Austin as head of the Small & Minority B... More   View all posts
Sue B. Workman

Sue B. Workman, Chief Information Officer, Case Western Reserve University

Sue B. Workman, Vice President for Information Technology Services and Chief Information Officer of Case Western Reserve University, has had more than three decades of experience in a broad range of functions within the field of Information... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

E-Con Systems MPU 300X250
Stephen Elkins