Governance • Innovation • Mobile • Sustainability

Could Global Connectivity Transform the World’s Economy?

Could Global Connectivity Transform the World’s Economy?

Over five billion people, nearly two thirds of the world’s population, are without Internet access. Attempts to bridge the gap of this Digital Divide have struggled due to poor infrastructure and an inability to generate greater commerce or quality of life. But new innovations with mobility have made it such that people can receive 3G connectivity in places without electricity. So can global Internet connectivity have the necessary gradual impact on a region’s economy and living conditions in order to see a significant change? How are governments, the commercial sector and non-profits joining hands to contribute to this cause, and how can working on this help solve the impoverished world’s other priorities?
Contributors

    • Dr. Jon Gant, Director of the Center for Digital Inclusion, Professor, Graduate School of Library and Information Science at the University of Illinois
    • John Windhausen Jr., Executive Director, Health & Libraries Broadband Coalition

Transcript

Sanjog Aul
Hello and welcome to CIO Talk Radio. To learn more about the show, please visit www.ciotalkradio.com and as always, we invite you to join the discussion on Twitter #Ctrlive. And look for this show as #Digital Divide. Today’s topic is Could Global Connectivity Transform The World’s Economy? And our guests for Today’s show are Dr. Jon Gant, who’s the Director of the Center for Digital Inclusion and a Professor at the Graduate School of Library and Information Sciences at the University of Illinois. Morning, Jon. How are you?

Jon Gant
Hi, how are you? Thank you, I’m good.

Sanjog Aul
Yeah, thank you. So life is good there?

Jon Gant
Sure. Yep. I’m in Los Angeles today, but yeah, life is very good.

Sanjog Aul
Great. And we have William Brindley, who’s recently retired CEO and Executive Director of NetHope and a Special Advisor to several firms in the social sector. Morning, Will. How are you doing?

William Brindley
Good morning. Doing well.

Sanjog Aul
All right, great and finally, we have John Winhausen Jr. who’s the Executive Director of the School’s Health and Library Broadb Coalition, which is also acronym is SHLB. Good morning, John. How are you?

John Windhausen
Good morning, Sanjog. It’s a pleasure to be with you.

Sanjog Aul
Thank you. Welcome all of you and so this is an Internet based radio show, as we know, and many of us now take for granted that we have Internet access in order to listen to something like this but guess what? Nearly two thirds of the world’s population does not have connectivity. So some coalitions have proposed the idea to spread Internet connectivity globally and we wanted to see and explore how that works, could help the greater good and stimulate a region’s infrastructure as well as the economy. Dr. Jon Gant, a question, the first question I have for you that why should anyone be thinking about global connectivity as a priority when we talk about other agenda which is put out as part of political parties or governments to essentially work on poverty or employment or other things which are more a direct impact versus thinking about whether I have Internet access or not.

Jon Gant
Great question and I actually think that both topics go hand in hand. I think building out the world’s global infrastructure for sharing information goes hand in hand also with addressing those issues of poverty, economic disparity, hunger, health issues and things like that. One way that you can, it’s often framed just as you said, a trade off between investments to try and improve, building more broadband networks and more connectivity versus programs to help alleviate hunger and poverty and things like that but I actually look at it as both pieces need to fit together very well. Way I look at it is that simply if when you do have those parts of our world where there is a lot of poverty and a lot of hunger and things like that, there’s actually a very high information need as well. There’s a great information need of trying to figure out where can I go to get help, where can I get go to get help services or where can I go to get food or relief for my crops and things like that. So I think that becomes very expensive to get that information when you’re not well connected

Jon Gant
there’s so many different examples. My research team has been in different parts of Africa where we hear stories of people having to walk miles just to get information about a government program or to get to go see a doctor or to go to school and things like that and that’s pretty expensive in terms of a person’s time, if most of the time is spent actually trying to get to that information. One thing about connectivity, improving connections with computers and through the Internet and so forth, is that you can really help to reduce the time it takes to search for the information that you may need and it also provides an infrastructure that may make it easier to provide some of these services as well. We’ve seen emerging examples in Telehealth, for example, where there are so many areas of and even in the United States where it’s hard to have a doctor who’s available that’s nearby. But by being connected through the Internet, the doctor can see more patients instead of spending the time on the road trying to go from one clinic in one part of a state to another rural part of the state and so forth

Jon Gant
and so those are just a couple examples. So I see this issue as actually going hand in hand and I think it’s actually an imperative that we do try and find ways to improve our connectivity to address these very critical human development problems that we have around the world.

Sanjog Aul
Bill, question for you and this is basically based on our piggybacking on Dr. Jon’s response. We say, yes, we need it, and we did not have this particular connectivity as a major agenda. Why now?

William Brindley
Well, I wanted to give an example

William Brindley
to piggyback on what Jon said and

William Brindley
then come back to your question. Maybe go from the specific example to the general answer sheet but take for example the world’s largest refugee camp, which is in Dadaab, Kenya. We have, we see one of the largest areas of concentration of people that are fleeing drought and persecution in the world. It is the largest, and it’s a great example of what he was talking about because the various, the UN and CARE and Save the Children, various relief organizations wanted to provide health, education and so forth for the refugees but before they could do that, we had to build out the broadband access in order to enable that for the relief workers in the first instance, and then to put an umbrella up over the entire camp in order for the refugees to be able to get direct access, begin to reconnect with persons with their family members, get help from various other sources, transfer payments and so forth

William Brindley
and it became an ecosystem of partners, the government, the various international organizations, commercial corporate organizations, safaricom and others, as well as others on the ground, local NGOs working together. So there’s an example where the access buildout led to the applications, if you will, of that were needed for education and health and we go into that in more detail. So that’s a specific kind of microcosm.

William Brindley
It’s a huge one, but it’s a

William Brindley
microcosm of what we’re talking about. I think we can extrapolate from that and see it all around the world in terms of the various countries of the world, mainly the lesser country, lesser developed countries that need Internet penetration. When they do, they see enormous gains in economic and social benefit.

Sanjog Aul
So this question is for Dr. John Winhausen, your coalition, which is talking about schools, health and libraries and I’m assuming that there is some connection with what you do in the United States, which is a developed nation, and also what other organizations could be doing in connection with you in underdeveloped nations. What’s that connection and coming back to the same question, you could have broadband and have people get smart boards and many other forms of interactivity, which is more incremental enhancement to what we have already been doing but do you think that can fundamentally bootstrap an underdeveloped nation?

John Windhausen
Well, I do, Sanjog, and thank you. So our coalition specializes in highlighting the importance of providing broadband for anchor institutions. So the school’s health and libraries, but also community centers, medical clinics, public media. The idea behind our coalition and the philosophy that we have is that if you can build out broadband first to these anchor institutions, they provide a really solid foundation for extending broadband throughout the rest of the community later on. So in other words, the anchor institutions for the community can also be like an anchor tenant on a the build out of a broadband network. They’re secure, they pay their bills, they’re institutions that have a lot of respect in the community and if you can build out to these institutions that are also using broadband to provide essential services to the residents of the community, then you can extend that broadband further out to serve the residential and business consumers. So in other words, this is the opposite of a build it and they will come philosophy.

John Windhausen
We advocate a success based build approach where you build out to those anchor institutions that are more likely to be good tenants and help the sustainability of that broadband network but if I could just also comment on the applicability of broadband to lesser developed nations. We’ve also found that mobile broadband connectivity, wireless broadband connectivity is increasingly important for agriculture. John Deere, the tractor manufacturer, now has some really interesting things going on where the tractors themselves are equipped with devices that can monitor the soil conditions, the weather conditions, provide instantaneous feedback to farmers about how they should work the land and improve food productivity. So this has enormously valuable implications for lesser developed countries that broadband can benefit them. In fact, the fellow from John Deere likes to say that if you work the land, you need broadband.

Sanjog Aul
Coming Back to Jon, Dr. John Gantt. Now, based on all the different responses, one approach is to say that we will create this and there will be an automatic adoption as John Windhausen said, that normally doesn’t happen. So is there an outcry from the lesser developed nation that give us connectivity and that would become the platform or the plumbing through which information will flow and that’s what’s going to become the backbone of our development?

Jon Gant
Well, that’s a really good question. It’s often mentioned earlier that once John Windhausen said a strategy that does not work well is to build it and assume they will come. Adopting broadband is a challenge everywhere around the world, and particularly in lesser developed countries. It, there’s one, of course, the whole issue of building out the infrastructure itself but the second issue is around the adoption of the devices to access the Internet and using those devices effectively. I’ve done a significant amount of work looking at these issues around the adoption and it’s not just oftentimes we hear it’s a matter of cost. If we can drive down the cost of these devices, that’ll work

Jon Gant
but there’s an important digital literacy component that’s relevant here and it’s a very complex issue when we look at this digital or computer literacy that really focuses on trying to understand how to make people feel comfortable using the computer or these smartphones and tablets or other devices and so that’s one level of literacy. Just how do you work your way around the computer with a keyboard and the mouse and or around a smartphone with apps and things like that but that’s the only the starting point. The other thing is how do you feel comfortable using it for things that you’re really trying to do? It’s not only that device, but it’s also the service that you’re trying to access. This example of John Deere or looking at agricultural or crop development or post harvest loss and things like that. I’ve had a couple of my students doing work in Sub Saharan Africa looking at the adoption of these technologies for agricultural uses and they overwhelming find that it’s not only the digital literacy but it’s about how do I understand the content that I’m looking at. How do I understand the data that’s being provided here about different approaches for planting my seed or taking care of my crops or harvesting or protecting the crops so that I minimize loss and things like that.

Jon Gant
How do I understand this really complex information when my own literacy level may be relatively low? It’s hard for me to understand the, the context as well. So that adds to the complexity of doing this.

Sanjog Aul
Let’s take a quick break. Let’s just be right back. And Bill, when we come back I’d like to pose this question where we spoke about John Deere putting some cool technology to look at soil but if an organization or a community can afford a John Deere tractor, I’m sure there would be other things that they can put on but here we are talking about people who do not know where the next meal is going to come from and so if you have to look at that type of, that strata of people, what is the technology and or other processes and other social fabric which will have to be created in order for them to be able to leverage the connectivity that we are offering here. Please stay tuned listeners. We’ll be right back.

Sanjog Aul
Welcome back Bill. As I mentioned that if you have already invested in a larger equipment and you’re able to put some more mobility in or other devices, then that’s great for an organization or a business but then when we’re talking about hungry and poor people who do not know where the next meal is going to come from, what is the type of fabric or foundation that needs to be created and so to that what do you have to say?

William Brindley
Well, first of all, let’s bear in mind that this is the fastest access, is the FA broadband, the fastest growing technology in human history. So this is spreading like wildfire. Even though now we know that more than 90% of the people in the 49 least developed countries are without broadband access. It’s growing fast and we see it all over Africa, the global south, so to speak. So that said, to your specific question, what we’re finding is in the frugal innovation, if you will, the creative approaches that people in need use to gain access so they will share SIM cards. If one has a phone but doesn’t have, but can be shared with others, they can get the SIM cards to swap out and put in and several people can use the same phone. The kiosk idea of years ago has been reinvented in a number of places. I mentioned the refugee camp in Dadaab,

William Brindley
there are a number of places now that are doing micro outsourcing where they’re doing various type of testing and review in the refugee camp because they now have access, giving economic opportunity, particularly the young women and girls who normally don’t get access because they can get access through these forms of new forms of kiosk or centers that are being set up by the various NGOs and the international groups such as the UN. So we’re seeing a lot of innovation, if you will, at the grassroots. I call it trickle up innovation or someone else does, I borrowed the term where you see the necessity is the mother of invention and a lot of these creative ways of getting access, people want access, are being developed.

Sanjog Aul
So Dr. John Windhausen, your particular environment where you are talking about schools and health and libraries and they are connected through broadband. Do you think those underdevelopment nations have those schools and healthcare organizations and or places where people can go to get healthcare and as well as libraries for them to piggyback on a wireless or a wired broadband connection to finally get the value?

John Windhausen
Well, our view is that you need a complement of both fiber optic cables to distribute a wired signal to the anchor institutions and then wireless from then out to the community is often going to be the best economic strategy because the schools and libraries generate an enormous amount of bandwidth or Internet traffic, so they need very high capacity, large bandwidth solutions and fiber optic cable is really the best transmission medium to carry that kind of traffic but then from there a mobile wireless solution really makes a lot of sense to extend the reach of that signal in a lower cost way to individual consumers but I think the, the key point is that just following on what Bill discussed, broadband is increasingly not just growing, but it’s seen as the foundation for economic growth. There’s a lot of evidence in the United States that once you deploy a broadband network to the anchor institutions in the community, that businesses have a much greater incentive to locate there and it creates jobs not just from new employment, but also the people in that community are more economically productive and I think that in developing countries that argument is even stronger. I like to say that broadband is really a meta infrastructure. It’s not just on a par with energy and transportation.

John Windhausen
It really enables smarter highways, enables smarter utility use of energy. It increases the overall economic productivity of that community and frankly, communities and countries are competing with each other now about who’s going to be able to deploy this technology best, because that’s going to be the way to attract more businesses and economic growth which will eventually lead to addressing the food and health problems of that community and bring them better resources.

Sanjog Aul
Dr. Jon Gant, question for you. This is not a new idea and we might have been thinking about it and perhaps you might have been involved or your group might have been involved in doing research on it five years ago as well. How has the evolution taken place, do you think? Now we suddenly feel that we have capability to create a wider impact just because the broadband is going to be more affordable or more accessible everywhere or what are the newer challenges that you’re finding, which you did not think earlier when you had that grand idea, or us as all of us had a grand idea, that if you put connectivity out there, the life is going to become beautiful for all people concerned.

Jon Gant
Yeah, I appreciate Bill’s point earlier, talking about how rapidly broadband is being adopted around the world, how aggressively countries are trying to expand their network and how focused they are on trying to get the network connectivity really improved to, as John Windhausen is talking about, to community anchor institutions, schools, libraries, health organizations at a community or a neighborhood level but it’s taken us some time to get where we are this morning. When I woke up, I just, I was thinking about it a little bit more but it’s been this long lasting, perfect convergence of what we’ve seen happening because the Internet itself is pushing 40 years old. Then we have the, the telephone in the US we’ve got the telephone service and then cable on top of it. As we’ve seen computers improve in terms of the processing speed, we’ve seen more and more people become comfortable having a digital life. We’re at a point now where we see this really intense convergence of the network and also devices and our processing capabilities like we’ve never ever seen before. It’s pretty remarkable to think that you can have a smartphone and be connected and be able to actually do something meaningful.

Jon Gant
It’s not the perfect platform, it should not be your exclusive platform for doing it but when I have a friend who’s from Ghana who was there over the Christmas or over the holiday break, Christmas time, and he was talking about how they’re kind of leapfrogging ahead to really trying to deploy more wireless and that everybody in his family, extended family there, is using a smartphone and really seeing that being used as a way of being connected. Phone calls, but doing all kinds of other things as well, like they’ve never been connected before. So I see that we’re moving very, the evolution is very quickly. But then there’s all kinds of hidden things that we don’t think about. We’ve got the privacy issues, we’ve got security issues to think about as well. We’ve got reliability issues as well too. We’re coming more and more comfortable using these, the phones and the Internet and we’re depending on it more.

Jon Gant
So reliability becomes a big issue and that means then we’re looking at issues, how do we improve our electric supply so that we can do this. We’ve seen innovative things happen. I’ve seen in Kenya, for example, people setting up these battery stations out just in rural areas so people can charge up their mobile devices so they can remain connected and turn that into a small business and that type of thing. So that’s something that’s coming out more that we don’t, we didn’t really think about and then the whole regulation of the use of the, of the network as well too is, is becoming important local policy problem around the world as well too. Who has access, who owns the network, what rights they have, how much do they charge, how do we regulate use and things like that

Jon Gant
and there’s a lot of effort to try and figure out how do we break down some of these regulatory barriers that we’re now really starting to understand its impact on how it can limit in some countries the spread and use of the network as well too. So there’s some hidden things that are starting to come up that we didn’t really think about early on.

Sanjog Aul
So Bill, when you look at all three of your respective organizations that you represented or are representing, they had an agenda to do a come create some common good for all people concerned. But then you are also partnering with for profit organizations who want to of course, bring a healthy profit and yes, they have a community give back program. How much of your assumption that they will give you their services at a subsidized price or give you the same level of service that you could otherwise demand if you were a commercial enterprise so that you can carry out your agenda with respect to creating this broadband connectivity across the underdeveloped nation where they don’t seem to have a direct opportunity in many cases to make a lot of money.

William Brindley
There are kind of two ways to look at that. One is during emergencies there’s often free broadband, if you will, repositioning of satellite, various ISPs and other providers. So that’s kind of one model and that’s understandable during a crisis that often will be afforded to organizations that are responding to the disaster. To your specific question on an ongoing basis, you have different depending on the locale one of the johns alluded to the environmental regulatory environment. Different environments afford different opportunities for the commercial providers because the governments restrict different things in different locales. So for example, in Ethiopia, VoIP is technically, I believe, still illegal so you can’t get VoIP access in

William Brindley
certain places as a result.

William Brindley
So you have to be creative and innovative in those contexts and environment but generally speaking, if you can come with enough scale, they’re very receptive. Let me take a guess but to be example, to speak to both of these after the disaster, sadly, in Haiti in 2010, a group of companies, NGOs and others responded by sending CISCO, Microsoft, NetHope and a number of the NGOs sending engineers to build out WI Fi and VSAT satellite connections over Port au Print. They did that within 2448 hours. They’re on planes going in, equipment was shipped. They built out the network because much of the network was down. As you may recall, the cable was cut and they weren’t able to get access.

William Brindley
In fact, Secretary Clinton said until we get access, we can’t deliver the goods that need to be delivered. Certainly not in an affected and a coordinated way. So we went in with others, an ecosystem of partners and built out that network.

William
Great.

William Brindley
We brought back up the NGOs you had, the hospitals and others started to get access to that, the relief workers. Over the next nine months and this is where the story kind of gets to phase two. We built a value added network through this sort of capex, if you will, that was provided by groups like CISCO and Microsoft and others that, if you will, invested during the emergency by supplying, we created a value added service that nine months later, because Net Hope and other organizations didn’t weren’t in the business

William Brindley
of being a vendor, they turned that

William Brindley
service over to indigenous Haitians who run as a value added network now on top of the now recovering city, but became a sort of two step thing where if you will, the CAPEX came in through the emergency and the OPEX came, the operating expenses were provided, you know, through the run rates of the group and they improved service at a lower cost and the ISPs and others as they came back were pleased to have this additional value added service. In fact, many of the organizations and NGO’s that we know well, we’d never had such good service and that of course has the economic and social panel benefit. So I hope that’s a good illustration of what we’re talking about.

Sanjog Aul
Great response, Bill. Thank you so much and listeners, please stay tuned. We’ll be right back and when we come back, John Windhausen question for you is if you were given a card branch and to do things the right way or the way you feel best, what could you do, leveraging your organization or what would you envision can be done with respect to schools, health, libraries and also other areas in which an impact can be created. If connectivity was put in a proper way and if at all it is not happening today, what is preventing those things from happening, the ideal state. Please stay tuned listeners. We’ll be right back.

Sanjog Aul
Welcome back, John Windhausen. The question here is that if you were given the carte blanche and you were given all the resources, what do you think is possible and what’s truly holding it back?

John Windhausen
First, I’d say there needs to be a well thought out plan for broadband deployment. It can’t just be that you deploy the fiber cables or you deploy an infrastructure alone. It needs to be a comprehensive strategy because what we found is that it’s really, it requires an environment of not just the broadband transmission facilities, but also the computer equipment, the applications running over those broadband networks and then training for people to be able to understand how they use this technology and all four of these components need to be addressed in a more comprehensive way for it to be successful. There have been some economic studies that show if you just deploy broadband alone without the rest of the ingredients, it really falls flat it doesn’t generate the kind of economic growth and productivity that you’re looking for so that’s one point. The other point is that I think we’ve seen from some experiments about trying to over invest all the way to the home can sometimes be economically not the best way to go from the get go

John Windhausen
and I guess I’m thinking right now of Australia that five or six years ago announced this very ambitious plan to get fiber to all of the homes or 95% of the homes or so in that country and now they’ve had to pull back on that strategy a bit because it seems as they’re not sure that they can make that economically viable. I think the New Zealand strategy might actually be a better long term approach in that they focused on getting fiber into each community first and then allowing some competitive market forces to incite greater competition for use of those facilities and lease of those facilities and take advantage of some of those innovative incentives to develop a more robust suite of services riding over that dark fiber facilities that the government is invested in. So even though it sounded as initially as a more cautious way to go in New Zealand than Australia, that may be a better long term approach for developing countries as well and again suggesting that investing out to the schools and libraries and other anchor institutions is a really smart way to go because they provide such important services for their communities. So if you can’t get broadband all the way to the individual consumer, at least give them a place in their community where they can go to ao go to the library and then you can get Internet access there. You can use their computers,

John Windhausen
you can get trained by the people, employees at the library, who can bring you up to speed and show you how to use the technology, you can go to the health institutions and get remote diagnostics of your health conditions relayed back to the urban hospitals and of course, the schools are really important as well, because so much of the future jobs are going to be in technology rich industries. And this is true in the United States, but it’s true across the world that the future employment is really going to depend upon your ability to use Internet technologies, computer technologies, online applications and that’s why a lot of these high tech companies are beginning to invest in the school in order to help train students so they have more well trained potential employees that they can hire afterwards and that’s a big step towards solving some of these unemployment problems that plaguing the whole world right now, because students don’t have the technology skills to really be productive workers in the workforce. So it’s really a comprehensive strategy set of solutions that need to be pursued simultaneously.

Jon Gant
Add onto that a little bit and John lays out this comprehensive strategy which is absolutely the right and smart way to move forward but there’s a second part of the story that needs to be included maybe in the second part of the comprehensive strategy is within those different sectors to look more deeply of how do we make sure that the libraries, the schools, the health care organizations have the right resources and capability to do this. So one reason why I’m out here in California is I’m actually looking at the other end of the spectrum, the next generation of the Internet and how do we get more libraries and schools connected to that whole next generation ecosystem that’s out there. But, and so as I’ve been going to small and large libraries around the country and schools and so forth, a common story that I hear is saying we’re connected, but we’ve got to make some changes inside of our library so we can accommodate the larger numbers of people who are coming here to use our services and so they’re looking at how do we change the work structure, how do we retrain librarians to be on the front lines to provide that digital literacy training and support, how do we even do some things with changing our hours or making sure we have enough computers for people to get things done. Acommon problem that I hear that’s very disheartening.

Jon Gant
I’ve been in some very poor areas around the world and people make it to that library to go, let’s say, fill out and like in rural parts of the United States, fill out a job application but yet they only get a half hour on the computer and how many people can do a job application in a half hour? Not many and that type of thing. So what I’m seeing is these calls from library leaders or school leaders saying help us develop strategies so that our organizations can do a better job of providing information access to the Internet and so forth as well, because that wasn’t really their first line of training and so now they’re saying how can we be smarter and be more effective at helping to provide access now that we are showing up on the front lines providing the support to our community?

William Brindley
Can I piggyback on that too?

Sanjog Aul
Yes, Bill, please go ahead.

William Brindley
Great. In terms of the comprehensive and I agree with everything, that’s the multifaceted, multi pronged approach. I mean, we have to. I’m sure we all know I’m calling the listeners know that a mobile device is the Internet in most of the developing world, obviously the developed world in the first instance, but now increasingly in the developing world, 95% of Kenyans have access, for example, according to the Communication Commission of Kenya, to a mobile device. You see this increasingly. I was just not long ago in Rwanda, we came out of Kigali, we were driving in the darkest, all the way up through Lungari, way out on here, and it was dark. You didn’t see any light

William Brindley
we would go through a town and the headlights of the Land Rover that we were in, we hit it looked ahead of us and we saw people clustered in the middle of the road and they parted as we came through. Our light shown, you didn’t see light from the village, but as they parted as we came through, almost all of them were on cell phones or had cell phones, mobile phone. It was a real eye opener to me because then I knew this and I’ve seen it elsewhere but it was like even then and even in that kind of circumstance, their increasing active to mobile devices, that is the Internet. So I think we have to kind of remember that as we that this year the leapfrog opportunity in the developing world is riding on the wave of mobile access. Now you have access in the phone, but then the data part, internet subscribers, of course, is where the expense is. For example, In Kenya, while 90 some percent have access mobile phone active, only 25% currently have Internet on their phones

William Brindley
so that’s going to be the growth area and then of course there’s enormous business opportunity there as well.

Jon Gant
Can I just add on to that too? And so it goes back to John’s original point too about building out the fiber. More mobile means that increases the demand for more fiber because all those mobile phones have to get out, get back from the towers and into the Internet itself. And so having that fiber infrastructure, really making sure we’ve got a good, strong, reliable fiber infrastructure within countries around the world is imperative.

William Brindley
To that point, I mean we may recall not just five years ago the cable, the submarine cable came down from Djibouti, East Africa which enabled East Africa and what I just described start to happen you very point. The cable came in to, to the country and then into the east eastern part of the East Africa and started to then go across land and across the airwaves and access became increasingly available at a more and more affordable price.

Jon Gant
And then the second part of that too is the reliability. We’re seeing single strands of chunks of fiber entering into countries but if we can, this connectivity also depends on those networks being connected to each other. Not only to provide for the key reason of providing diverse paths of this traffic to get back to the main major trunks so that if there’s a cut anywhere, the traffic can be rerouted a different lane so there’s no interruption in service. So here’s where you need that inter country collaboration and agreement so that we can have not only chunks of fiber go through but also establish redundant paths so that we can make sure that there is a reliable path to go through regardless of what’s going on. If there’s some kind of crisis, man made or natural cuts and lines and things like that, that traffic can be rerouted and then of course then it opens up all these other kinds of questions of intercountry agreements for doing that type of thing and so forth

Jon Gant
but that I think that’s also an important.

William Brindley
And the other thing is you have to look at the economic incentives back to a little while ago. In a disaster you get the sort of philanthropic or charitable, however you want to describe it in hope and that’s wonderful, that’s great that you see the better angels, if you will, of human nature and of corporations and others but really let’s face it, for something to be sustained there has to be a series of economic incentives all along the way and that’s what opportunities for economic growth in the countries and for corporations and that’s what will drive this and is driving it and it’s inexorable. I mean, it’s spreading like wildfire in terms of the mobile growth across the developing world.

Sanjog Aul
Let’s take a quick break, listeners. We’ll be right back and John Windhausen, and I’ll ask you a question. You did mention about Australia and New Zealand and it seems both of them are not truly underdeveloped or lesser developed nations. They were trying to bring it for incremental benefit. So what if we actually go beyond thinking that we have to have this landline infrastructure? Yes, fiber has to be brought in to provide mobile Internet access but if you do that, then instead of trying to create the aggregation point for schools, health and libraries, instead have that be available on mobile devices to those individuals and then start working in terms of how they can get better jobs or how they can get better care and even the commerce flourishes. What’s your take? If that was to be taken as the route, is there a problem with it or if not, then what is preventing us from going that route? Please stay tuned, listeners.

Sanjog Aul
We’ll be right back.

Sanjog Aul
Welcome back. John Windhausen. The question here is that if you were to bypass the desktop access age and which already to some extent has bypassed and now we are in a mobile age, then many of the perceived issues that we were trying to struggle may no longer be relevant. Why not concentrate our energies to say I have infrastructure, I have mobile Internet access and what do I do with it now?

John Windhausen
Well, I mean, there’s no question that providing mobile access at the start is probably the cheapest and easiest way to get the technology into people’s hands most quickly. I think the question I would ask in the countries, developing countries need to ask themselves is how is this going to lead to economic productivity in a way that’s going to generate more investment and more jobs in the country going forward. So there’s a certain level of basic connectivity that you can get through mobile access. I’m not sure that going to provide the technology skills for the future and as Bill mentioned, how so many mobile phones are not connected to the Internet today, even when they are connected to the Internet oftentimes the speeds of transmission over a mobile device are not really the kinds of bandwidth that you need for innovation for using higher quality applications. So for instance, it’s very difficult to do a lot of e commerce over a mobile phone and increasingly that a huge source of additional business and revenue is using the Internet for commercial transactions and so that’s why I’m still going to advocate for some deployment of wired infrastructure.

John Windhausen
Fiber optic infrastructure would be the best, although there are, there are other wires as well. But at least with fiber, once you deploy a fiber optic cable, that cable may last you for decades. It can be upgraded just by changing the electronics on either end of that fiber so the big challenge I think for developing countries is how can they integrate a fiber optic solution that does give you the foundation for innovation and has almost unlimited amounts of bandwidth that you could use for decades into the future and really be a foundation for economic activity, for educational activity, for health activity. You really are. It is an investment, it’s an upfront cost and I know that’s easier said than done but the payback for having a widespread fiber infrastructure that’s compatible with the mobile infrastructure that builds off of it is really the best long term strategy that that a country can pursue.

Sanjog Aul
So people are hungry now, they need the next meal in few hours and yes, I totally agree with what John Windhausen says that they have to do it but Bill, I come back to you, what do you do with this catch 22? I want to feed those people and yes, I want to give that long term strategy too.

William Brindley
I think it’s short, medium and long. There’s immediate need to your very point and they’re very resourceful people providing that and people are using SMS and various lower level technologies. We found in one of our studies that we conducted that radio is one

William Brindley
of the key ways that you get.

William Brindley
Information out very low back. People are creative and they’re finding ways. So there’s short terms, there’s no proverbially no silver bullet for that kind of thing, but for doing that if I strive with the, DAAB refugee camp and with Haiti, there’s medium term where you’re starting to see 30% growth a year in access to mobile devices in the developing world. It’s spreading like wildfire increasingly and you’re seeing creative uses with low bandwidth Facebook&Facebook 0 and other games bringing young people onto the Internet. So you’re starting to see gamification, other things on mobile devices and to the point that was just made, commercial uses on mobile devices increasing that median and then long term, absolutely, creating the regulatory and infrastructure environment and the infrastructure increased broadband as was described as critical.

William Brindley
That does take a lot of capital, a lot of time, but clearly there’s amazing salutary benefit.

Sanjog Aul
Jon, if you were to look at everything that was said and we are closing out in a few minutes, what is it that are the top three things that you would like to appeal to the government, to the not for profits and also to the commercial sector for them to create whatever is necessary. So we are not going and playing the scatch 22 game and instead start feeding some mouths?

Jon Gant
First of all, it’s a complex problem. It’s not a problem that can be solved exclusively by any one of those sectors. It’s a problem that has to be solved with those sectors working together and collaboratively to do that. That’s the first thing I would say that the priority would be to continue to build out, develop these long term strategies for building out the infrastructures that are necessary and then also a second priority is improve the capacity within various organizations to actually utilize these technologies. If the whole point is to try and drive down the cost it takes for using this information and to make, and to actually use it in a productive way for making better decisions and things like that and thirdly, we can’t ignore that these short term needs are here, they’re here now.

Jon Gant
We’ve got to address these now when somebody’s hungry, they’re they, they need food today, they need a job today and they need healthcare today. So we’ve gotta address those problems as best we can right now. But those organizations coming in want to solve them effectively and they need lots of information to be able to do that, to enhance accountability, to enhance transparency. Now also I’d say another priority is to make sure that we are doing things in a way that really protects the privacy of the people that are being served. That is often overlooked. We have digital bits of our lives all over this Internet and so forth and when we get down to local problems and issues, there’s a lot of information that can be aggregated to really reveal private things about people and so we’ve got to make sure that no matter where we are in the world and we’re trying to bring technology in to help address these issues, that we’re really doing a good job being good stewards of the privacy of the information, keeping it secure

Jon Gant
and then the third piece, the assurance piece, that anything that comes in is good, anything that comes out of the computer is good and accurate and so forth. And these are some of the things that make people resistant to want to use the technology. I worry that if I go to the doctor, my information is going to be somewhere, somebody’s going to know that I’ve got a particular disease or something like that and that that’s a terrible example, especially if that information is revealed and that makes people apprehensive about using the computer at all because I don’t know who’s looking at my information or what they’re going to do with it, or how long they’ll keep it, or will they use it some way to come back and get me for something if there’s some kind of political change within the country and things like that. I mean, these have been long standing problems with the use of computer technology in not only developed countries, but developing countries as well. We’ve really got to think about those particular issues to help people to feel comfortable, as well as the digital literacy and training which is imperative.

Sanjog Aul
On behalf of the show and our listeners, I’d really like to thank you, Dr. Jon Gant, William Brinley and John Windhausen Jr. for sharing your thoughts on how the global connectivity can have an impact on the world’s economy. Thank you so much.

Download Podcast
Apple Podcast, Google Podcast, Spotify, Pandora, iHeartRadio, SoundCloud, TuneIn, and Stitcher. Find other syndication channels here or search CIO Talk Network podcast on any other app.
Explore More

Contributors

Dr. Jon Gant

Dr. Jon Gant, Director of the Center for Digital Inclusion, Professor, Graduate School of Library and Information Science at the University of Illinois

Jon Gant is a professor at the Graduate School of Library and Information Science at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign where he serves as the Director of the Center for Digital Inclusion (CDI). Gant is a national leader in the ... More   View all posts
John Windhausen Jr.

John Windhausen Jr., Executive Director, Health & Libraries Broadband Coalition

John Windhausen, Jr. is the Executive Director of the Schools, Health & Libraries Broadband (SHLB) Coalition, a diverse coalition of community anchor institutions, broadband companies, foundations (such as the Gates Foundation) and publ... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

Persistent - HiTech- MPU - 300x250
Dr. Jon Gant