Leadership

Can a CIO Lead from the Middle?

Can a CIO Lead from the Middle?

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Neil Jarvis (AAA NCNU), Damon Anderson (State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that a CIO can lead from the middle but should not let it become permanent. Neil Jarvis of AAA NCNU said the CIO must decide when to work the frontline and when to return to strategy, build service organizations whose leaders speak in business terms, and invest in coaching, citing eight direct reports and coaches for himself and each leader as essential rather than expensive for a multibillion dollar business. He described a previous employer where a CIO pushed down a level gave up and staff left, and the organization recovered within twelve months only after the CIO was replaced. Damon Anderson of State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources said leaders get stuck through thin staffing and micromanaging, and that management by walking around, 360 evaluations, trust, and getting out of the way keep him on the horizon. Both concluded that delivering business value, which Anderson calls WIIFM, what’s in it for me, is how a CIO climbs back out of the middle.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Neil Jarvis, Vice President and CIO at AAA NCNU, and Damon Anderson, CIO at State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources, about whether a CIO can lead from the middle rather than get stuck there. Jarvis says the CIO should choose when to move between frontline work and strategy and should never feel forced down a level, pointing to a previous employer where a CIO who was pushed down a rung gave up and the organization recovered only after the CIO was replaced. Anderson compares the role to a ship’s captain who belongs on the helm watching the horizon rather than in the engine room, and ties time stuck in the middle to thin staffing, micromanaging, and weak mentoring. Both describe how coaching, trust, delegation, and clear business value pull a CIO back out of middle management.

Contributors

  • Neil Jarvis, Vice President and CIO, AAA NCNU
  • Damon Anderson, CIO, State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Neil Jarvis, Vice President and CIO at AAA NCNU, says a CIO should never feel forced into the middle and should decide when to move between frontline work and strategy. He warns that a CIO who stays down just working on projects devalues themselves, and that the choice of when to work the coalface and when to return to strategy should be the CIO’s own, to keep the respect of both teams and customers.
  • Damon Anderson, CIO at State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources, compares the CIO to a ship’s captain who belongs on the helm watching the horizon, not down in the engine room where nobody is steering. He traces being stuck in the middle to thin staffing, micromanaging, or not using staff to their fullest, and says the work is to break that paradigm and get back to the front of the ship.
  • Neil Jarvis of AAA NCNU argues that leadership happens at any level, so the term middle management is overused. He expects his infrastructure services lead, even while handling the silver boxes, flashing lights, disaster recovery and security, to speak in business terms and drive change across the business rather than only talk about availability and network traffic.
  • Damon Anderson of State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources credits his first 360 evaluation with changing how he leads. He was hit hardest on his peers because he was not spending enough time with the business leads, and since then he has made keeping staff and business partners in the loop, managing up and down, a fixed part of his process.
  • Neil Jarvis of AAA NCNU keeps himself out of the weeds by investing in coaching, with eight direct reports, a team coach, and an individual coach for every leader. He calls it essential rather than expensive for a multibillion dollar business, because a safe environment to try things and make controlled mistakes stops leaders from always reaching back to the CIO.
  • Damon Anderson of State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources says a CIO climbs out of the middle by finding the business value for the customer, which he sums up as WIIFM, what’s in it for me. He cautions that negativity spreads through the IT organization, while delivering value gets the CIO consulted and brought in first instead of left in the middle.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: can a CIO lead from the middle
  • 4:53 Why CIOs feel stuck in the middle
  • 7:13 CIO role versus middle management
  • 10:45 What an effective CIO day looks like
  • 16:36 Mentoring the next level of leaders
  • 19:14 Investing in coaching and a safe environment
  • 24:28 Stepping in without taking over
  • 32:36 The CIO as a culture change agent
  • 38:56 Earning a seat by partnering with the business
  • 42:57 Keeping teams focused under cost pressure
  • 48:31 Attitude and climbing back from the middle
  • 52:42 Not letting the middle become a pattern

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: can a CIO lead from the middle 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:00:47]:
Today’s topic is Can a CIO Lead from the Middle? Our guests for today’s show are Neil Jarvis, who is the Vice President and CIO with AAA NCNU, which is AAA in Northern California, Nevada and Utah. Good morning, Neil. How are you doing?

Sanjog Aul [00:01:15]:
We have Damon Anderson as well, who is the CIO with State of Pennsylvania Conservation and Natural Resources. Good morning, Damon.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:27]:
So how are your respective lives going? Is it summer, enjoying games, the golf game or shopping? What’s going on?

Neil Jarvis [00:01:42]:
Yes, I’m enjoying golf at the moment when I get a chance, Sanjog Aul. But I’m calling in from San Francisco where our headquarters are, but I most of my IT organization is in Glendale, Arizona. So I get the best of both worlds.

Sanjog Aul [00:02:04]:
So this topic, this is kind of an interesting area where we all may have faced in some point in our career, that even when we are IT leaders and we are pulled into those so called managerial or tactical roles and we have to roll up our sleeves. 1 definition of leadership says that if you cannot roll up your sleeves then people will not respect you. But if you start rolling up your sleeves way too often then you are not leading, you end up managing. So when we are stuck in such situations, do we go ahead and blame the environment around us? Or is it something which you would say is a self inflicted pain? Neil?

Neil Jarvis [00:02:54]:
I don’t think we should have a blend in the environment. I think there’s always an opportunity for a CIO to be able to move seamlessly between the different opportunities. At times we need to be able to lead the coal face as it were, and others we have to then quickly be able to move back to the strategy level. I think always making sure that strategy and customer advocacy are at the forefront of our mind. I think it’s essential. A CIO that stays down in the train, she’s just working purely on projects. I think devalues themselves a little bit. I think the major opportunity for all CIOs is to lead their team and the business customers of the value chain. So it’s important to be able to move between. Over times I think it’s a CIO has to balance when do I have to do that, and it probably depends on the customer situation, the economic climate and everything else as to when you have to step between the two. But I don’t think we should ever, CIO should ever feel that this is I’m being forced into that. We should be the ones making the decisions and driving that move between the two to gain respect both from our teams and from the customer at the same time.

Sanjog Aul [00:04:43]:
So Damon, in your view, why would somebody say that I’m stuck in the middle?

Why CIOs feel stuck in the middle 4:53

Damon Anderson [00:04:53]:
Why would someone say they were stuck in the middle? Maybe it’s an opportunity, I don’t know, I look at those things as opportunities. Maybe it’s an opportunity for somebody who feels that they’re stuck in the middle. You have to be a visionary to take a look at the big picture. Every organization has the big picture that they’re trying to get accomplished. Sometimes, if you look at the captain of the ship, he’s on the helm watching the horizon. If the captain is down in the engine room, nobody is driving the ship. It may be a situation where there’s a lack of staffing, it could be a situation where sometimes we can be a little micromanaging. It could be a thing where we’re not using the staff that we’ve been given to their fullest. Those are the kinds of things that I guess would consider us being stuck in the middle. Breaking those paradigms and getting back to the bow, or getting back to the front of the ship to steer the ship, is where a CIO really needs to be, breaking that paradigm.

Sanjog Aul [00:05:49]:
So in your view, when you gave a few instances, a few examples, a few environmental parameters, like let’s suppose we are not given enough resources, that’s why we were stuck in the middle, or if we are true micromanaging. Now if you were to take the case where the resources are not made available, again it boils down to how do you sell to the people up there in the executive management area that guys, if you don’t give me the required resources then I will be a highly paid manager for you. But do you think is that a logic that people buy there? Or there’s a better way to phrase something like that so that it is so compelling that they don’t find the most expensive guy in the IT team doing some management and tactical tasks?

Neil Jarvis [00:06:40]:
Well, I think if you’re focusing on the key business drivers and the key business opportunities and those things start to slide, or as they start to slip, they’ll be able to see, based on what you were just mentioning, that if I don’t have these resources, then we’re not going to be able to get these projects done. We’re not going to be able to move the business forward. So I’m hoping that they would understand that this is the direction that you have to move into. I’ve got to get out of the end room. I’ve got to get back in the front. I’ve got to get the resources that are necessary in order to move this thing forward. So

Sanjog Aul [00:06:41]:
For some, I think the interpretation of what is the middle is also, for some it’s a relative thought. So if you were to inventory, what we would call as the middle level or middle management task, what would be some of those, and how do you differentiate from a CIO sitting at the top and on a revolving chair or just giving orders? What how are we differentiating what is a CIO’s role versus what is a middle management role? Neil?

CIO role versus middle management 7:13

Neil Jarvis [00:07:13]:
I think the CIO’s role is to create that organizational structure that the business can understand, where there’s true services. So when you talk about the middle management, I never quite understand what middle management or middle leadership really means, because at whatever level you sit in an organization, you have the opportunity to lead. So I would say, if I was to take a stab at what would the next level leadership to a CIO look like, and can you call that middle management is debatable, but let me try that. I would say that creating service organizations, because that’s what a CIO really is doing in my mind, is driving services on behalf of the corporation to the business and to the end customer. So I would build the analogy that the structure would look like the traditional architecture services, application services, infrastructure services, and then the project management services alongside that, then with your probably leveraged themes of finance and HR. Now, can you actually say that those levels are middle management? I think it’s an overused term, because you should be able to influence from wherever you are. So I expect my infrastructure services lead, although they may be dealing with the pure silver boxes, flashing lights, disaster recovery, security, that type of work, I expect them to be able to talk in business terminology at all levels and be able to influence and drive change across the business. I’m not just expecting them to be able to talk to availability and network traffic and things of that nature. I’m truly looking to them to be able to talk to the meaning of availability. What’s the impact to the business? How does that actually show itself in the business terminology? And I think, to the last point Damon was making, that if you can do that, then there’s a natural influencing role that allows the CIO to certainly concentrate more on strategy, just certainly sit in the executive table and help to drive the business direction, the business strategy, and what’s going to differentiate that company cooperation in the marketplace.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:43]:
So in your view, Damon, what would be a typical effective CIOs day be including in terms of what the calendar should look like?

What an effective CIO day looks like 10:45

Damon Anderson [00:10:45]:
We’ll always have time for planning. 1 of the things that I like to do when I first get in, I do something called, you probably heard the concept of, a way I’m walking around management. Normally, I try to go through the area, check on all my lieutenants or my chiefs to see if there are any issues maybe impacting some of our business, some of those kinds of drivers, taking a look at what kinds of things would be on the mind of my management, ensuring that there are no issues. And then once those things are done, I try then to refocus, looking at all the work that we’re currently working on, ensuring that everything is aligned with where the business should be heading. Within the Commonwealth, we have a keystone plan. We have some other priorities we’re working on each agency.

Damon Anderson [00:11:40]:
We have an action plan. We have a, in the Commonwealth, they have a strategic direction that we’re doing. And so one of the things that I always try to do is make sure that the work that we’re doing is aligned. So kind of going over that in the morning, looking at, okay, what are we going to accomplish today? What are the hot buttons? What kinds of things happened maybe the night before? What kinds of things are on the radar? When are these projects due to be delivered? As I mentioned, just checking in with your chief, your staff, your lieutenants, making sure that everything is going well. And then one of the other things that I do is I also spend time with some of my key stakeholders. I’ll maybe walk down into one of the areas and just kind of stop in, just a casual conversation just to see how things are going, just to get an idea of how our services are being provided, how they’re feeling they’re being treated by my IT organization, because of course we can’t make it without our customers. That’s really why we exist, to serve them as they serve the greater purpose for the business of the organization.

Damon Anderson [00:12:41]:
That’s kind of a typical day. There’s some other things that are thrown in, but one, making sure I touch base with my customer, making sure that I definitely touch base with my lieutenants, looking at what things are on the horizon, looking at what key projects are moving forward, those kinds of things. There’s other little bag of things we do, but we won’t get into that.

Sanjog Aul [00:12:42]:
Based on what Damon said is a supposed to do, can only happen when they are not bothered with the tactical level of middle management things. And then if we have to have these people not bother us, not in true sense bother, but we not be pulling us down to the this middle management level that could also be the root cause of that, if we really do a root cause analysis, that could be because of the fact that we did not prepare them enough to see the big picture and be able to deal with the people around them. And that’s why maybe they’re calling us to step down and help them out. So again, since this is our crew and we are responsible for them, so what could be happening because of the fact, what kind of lack of mentoring that exists there? Or maybe there is an inability of these lieutenants because of which they are basically not prepared or not ready for this role, and that’s why we are constantly being pulled down. Let’s discuss and explore this a little bit more.

Mentoring the next level of leaders 16:36

Sanjog Aul [00:16:36]:
Let’s go to the basics here. If we do have these lieutenants that we are hiring, are we mentoring them right? Are we showing them the big picture and changes in the big picture that continually happen? Are they able to relate well to the top down directives? And if we were to look even further, have we hired the right people, or maybe there is a reason why they’re not able to do their job properly, is because they’re not maybe ready for the second in command. So what exactly could be some of the things that may be happening here? Damon, what do you think?

Damon Anderson [00:16:58]:
As you mentioned, I think mentoring is vital with your staff. Sometimes we have to come out from behind the desk, as I mentioned how I do in my day, just to spend some time with them, ensuring that they’re understanding the big picture, that they’re also focused on the big things of the business, leading by example, spending time with them with the projects, helping them to make sure that basically helping them understand their decision process as they’re moving these things forward. Sometimes it’s kind of different with a civil service system, that sometimes you don’t have to go by folks that are on the list, but picking the right staff is vital to having a successful organization. Every staff member brings a different thing to the puzzle or brings a different thing to the data and ensuring that if, for example, we do with an organization, we sometimes do Myers Briggs, color coding, or a 360 evaluation. That way, you help the staff member to understand what tools they’re bringing to the table. Just simple communication, understanding that, for example, Sam might be a type A personality. You might be dealing with somebody else who’s visionary. If those 2 people are trying to sit down and resolve an issue, they’re looking at that issue from 2 completely different points of view, and they may actually be saying the same thing. So ensuring that your lieutenants have an understanding of who they are, have an understanding of how they need to communicate with the other team members, even when they’re communicating with our customers, are things that are vital. Because if those things are in place, then you begin to find your involvement as CIO being less and less, then you can focus on the big picture, then you can focus on the vision.

Sanjog Aul [00:17:38]:
So Neil, while we could be very proud of those good hires, how do we handle this 500 miles an hour type of business change and IT change that is happening? And how do we keep our lieutenants up to speed on these changes in the big picture while we have to do our job, so that we don’t have to roll up our sleeves and do what they do, or they’re supposed to?

Investing in coaching and a safe environment 19:14

Neil Jarvis [00:19:14]:
Yes. I think the important thing is to really build in that time and energy into people development. A CIO, in my mind, greatest job in the world, get to deal with change of technology, the business and people all at the same time. So I think making sure that we’ve actually built that time for our leaders and created a safe environment where coaching and mistakes are okay. It’s nobody sets off for work in the morning and says I’m going to make a mistake today. That’s just not how we’re wired. So I think the important thing is for our leaders to know that they can actually expand their boundaries and try new things, as long as it’s done in a controlled fashion. And I don’t mean this is your tight swim lane. I think it’s important that we allow our leaders to be able to move over those swim lanes at Simon and watch those environments and watch those opportunities, and then give instant feedback that is open and honest. I have 8 direct reports and we work with an external company who are our executive coach as a team. So I have an executive coach from that company from that I work with. Then we have the coach that works with my leaders as a team, and then each of my leaders also has a coach. And some people would say, well, wow, that’s expensive, but in the big scheme of things, multibillion dollar businesses, it’s not an expensive investment. It’s actually, to me, absolutely essential to invest in those individuals. And it’s amazing the environment that you create when you sit down and you go through that, there are no hidden agendas, there are no left conversations, there are no background conversations going on in people’s minds, that the team becomes open, because I always believe it’s a team effort and never an individual effort. If any one of my leaders is struggling and feels the only person they can reach out to is a CIO, then you’re going to get sucked back down into each area. And no matter how clever we CIOs think we are, we’re not ever going to know everything, and we’re going to need that team to really gel and feel that we’re all on the field together, playing in the right game. But at times we can allow the CIO to step off the field and play coach and let the individuals in the team play quarterback at different times. I think really building in that time, really investing in whether that’s external coaches, whether that’s internal coaches, and then creating a safe environment where individuals can try new things in a controlled environment, is a great way forward.

Sanjog Aul [00:19:35]:
So Damon, how would you instill a sense of responsibility, that instead of me pulling CIO down to my level, let me support him so that he can stay at that level? How do you instill that passion and or thought or a support type of mentality in your crew?

Damon Anderson [00:22:53]:
As mentioned earlier, having a key understanding of why we’re here and our role in support of the business is vital, because if they can lock into that, then they feel empowered, that the suggestions that they come up with, the ideas that they come up with. They might say, hey, I have an idea. We’ll run with it. Do you want to know it? No, I trust you to be able to make those kind of decisions. You wouldn’t be in the position you’re in if I didn’t trust you. So having trust in them and then just allowing them to do things, allowing them to move forward with their ideas, with their vision, with those kinds of things, that also builds confidence. And as Neil mentioned, sometimes you let them go forward, they may make a mistake. Like I said, nobody comes to work planning to make a mistake, but you’re there in support of what they’re doing. You’re there in support of them moving the mission forward. And as long as they’re making a mistake working and focused on the business, I think that’s a good mistake to make. But I believe that with them being focused on moving things forward, I just get out of the way, just get out of the way and let them do what they need to do. That builds trust, it builds confidence, then you find yourself less and less being pulled to the table, that you can focus, as I mentioned earlier, on the horizon.

Sanjog Aul [00:23:11]:
So while, Damon, you mentioned the things that you do to help them come up to that speed, but then if you were to demonstrate that you know it all, don’t you have to ever roll up your sleeves to actually go down and do it? And that’s basically, again, you’ve chosen to go down to that level and do it, at least temporarily?

Stepping in without taking over 24:28

Damon Anderson [00:24:28]:
I guess the first thing, I’ve never tried to act like I know it all, we would be in trouble if I did try to do that. But there are times that we’ve had to step into to do some things, but those then become learning experience. Those then become, as we mentioned earlier, those then become mentoring experiences. We do lessons learned. Once you finish a project, or if a work effort didn’t go as planned, you sit down with staff and you debrief and you try to determine, okay, how could this have went better? How could this process have gone off without a hitch? What changes could be made? Who could we have brought in? What things could we have done to make this process go smoother? And then once that’s done, that’s documented, that’s stored, and then in the event that a situation like that were to arise, then the first thing the manager or the lieutenant would do is, hey, I remember we had this situation before. How did we solve this? And then they’d be able to go then back to documentation, run through some things in their mind and move forward. Ultimately, as CIO, we’re responsible for all things that come out of our organization, but we still want to be able to empower our staff to move forward.

Sanjog Aul [00:24:51]:
So Neil, question. Damon just mentioned that if CIO was to know it all then we’ll be all in trouble, and rightfully so. But then the expectation is that he’s supposed to know it all.

Neil Jarvis [00:26:04]:
I think that the important thing for the CIO is to always stay abreast of where we’re going, and the team. I think it’s a great point, and Damon made some great points, that our teams are going to look to the CIO and the business is going to look to the CIO to bring that expertise, to bring that knowledge, to bring that guidance and leadership between technology and the business. But I think an important part is for this is where the building of the confidence of the team is essential, that bringing the team in at the right time and the right situation with the right help to actually present to the business or talk to the customer, talk to the executives or the Board of Directors is a key part of the CIOs job. When do I bring my Chief Architect into the picture? When do I allow my Chief Architect to lead from the front? That to me gives a level of confidence in my for my Chief Architect to know, okay, my CIO trust me, the business trust me, I actually get to come forward and talk about this. It gives the business, I believe, the confidence that it’s not just a dictatorship that the CIO is running, because the only person I ever see is a CIO. So I think there’s that great balance of bringing in the team at different times for different situations and allowing them to the team members to truly show their knowledge and highlight that. We’ve all probably worked with those leaders who like to be the only person in front and claim all the ideas as theirs. I think it’s much more powerful for a CIO or a leader to actually show that they’re prepared to bring in the right people at the right time and on the right subjects. But I think that’s the key for the CIO, is to know who and when and on what subject they need to bring in their teams and support them. And I think that in itself shows all of the different communities that we deal with that our knowledge is at the right level, the right level of technology, the right level of business, and then the aptitude to know when we need to bring in the appropriate people to add weight and validity to the story that perhaps we’re trying to sell although the business is asking us to bring back to them.

Damon Anderson [00:26:15]:
And Neil, I would also add to that, that also has a ripple effect then in the organization, because the areas that they’re responsible, then their staff begins to step up and do the same type of thing.

Sanjog Aul [00:29:08]:
There must have been times when you don’t feel in control and you are almost being forced to go down to that middle management level. Would you say the culture of an organization is something that could have done to you? Or should we again say, no, it cannot be culture, I’m the CIO, I should be a change agent, I will transform the culture before it will force me to go down that path. Is that expecting too much of an from an IT leader?

The CIO as a culture change agent 32:36

Sanjog Aul [00:32:36]:
So we were talking about the culture of an organization, which could be forcing an IT leader into becoming a middle manager, or that could be a perception, or that could be a scapegoat. But if indeed the change agent, which is the CIO in this case, is already there, then might as well change the culture before it will suck you in into becoming a middle manager. Is it easier said than done, or is this expecting too much of an IT leader or a CIO? Neil, what do you think?

Neil Jarvis [00:32:57]:
I don’t know whether it’s expecting too much of an IT leader. In fact, I don’t think it is. I think the IT leader, the CIO’s job is to change all aspects. At a previous company that I was with, we had an incredible, incredible CIO from a technology perspective, business perspective, brought into the company, and the individual was ultimately pushed off the executive team. A new CEO came in, changed the way they wanted to do business, and the CIO was moved down in the to the next level down. Still same responsibility, still the same title and everything else, but couldn’t manage to influence from that next level down, and literally gave up the impact of giving up by the CIO because the whatever analogy you want to use, the shadow that the CIO casts, or the net that we cover and what have you is immense, that when the CIO gives up in that situation and just becomes a middle line leader, it affects everybody in the corporation. The CIO’s leadership team, the CIO’s full team, became very disheartened, very disgruntled, started to leave. Some just sat back and decided, okay, this is just a job and not a passion anymore. And then ultimately the customers then saw that the IT organization was no longer an influencer and no longer a leader and driver. So consequently any failed scenario suddenly became IT’s fault. I don’t know how many times as technologists we always hear that failed delivery or failed scenarios are always technology, rather than, was it the business requirements that were there, was it that we didn’t put the right person with the right opportunities, did we allow individuals to become cowboys in their own environments. And then it’s easy to point the finger if the CIO and the IT department isn’t sat at the table helping to drive influence and strategy, and isn’t there truly as the change agent and pushing to be up that business value chain. So I’ve actually seen it. The way that ultimately that was resolved was the CIO has changed. And it’s interesting when the CIO has changed with the same leaders under that new CIO, that organization turned it around very quickly, not within 2 years, but within 12 months, to the point that they were back influencing, and that CIO was still sat at the same level in the organization. So it really is the CIO’s responsibility not to fall victim, but to really say, I own this, this is mine to do, this is the culture I need to drive and change. So I don’t believe it’s too much or too big for any CIO.

Sanjog Aul [00:33:30]:
Damon, what do you think? What could be happening, and why, if suppose a CIO is saying that he’s stuck with that particular culture, why could he or she not change it in the first place?

Damon Anderson [00:36:55]:
I agree with what Neil just said. One of the things, that as a CIO, and also, I guess more importantly, as a leader, you have to be able to lead from wherever you’re at within the organization. Different organizations have different cultures. And sometimes, CIO has to earn his spot at the table. A lot of times where sometimes IT might be seen as, I don’t know, maybe I’ll call it an afterthought. A lot of times in our business processes, organizations might say, well, we need this, we need this, we need this. Oh, yes, there’s an IT part too. And of course that’s not the optimal way for things to get accomplished. But as you start to develop value, as you start to add value to your customer, this also helps to bring your whole organization out of the middle. Quitting definitely is not an option. I’m sure there’s some situations that maybe some CIOs that have been in that have been kind of unbearable. But I always like challenges. I like to be placed in a challenging situation. And there’s always a solution, depending on yourself, how hard you want to work to find a solution. I go back to it, as I mentioned earlier, if you can find a way to provide business value as a CIO, if you can help your staff and your organization see if there’s business value in what you’re bringing to the table, I believe that those are the kind of things that cause things to change and things to begin to move forward. And you find yourself not in the middle, you begin to find yourself being consulted, being asked by leadership, being brought in first on things, until eventually that other CIO you were just mentioning finds his way back at the table and able to make decisions.

Earning a seat by partnering with the business 38:56

Neil Jarvis [00:38:56]:
Damon raises a great point there about the partnership between the business and IT, that as a CIO, our role is really to create that partnership where the business automatically sees IT as that true business partner, and we’re at the table together. So there isn’t that scenario, as Damon said, where the business goes right at the end of whatever it is they’re discussing, oh, there’s an IT part that I need to go and look for, that technology piece right at the end. So I think the way a CIO can influence that is to truly understand the business. So when I came to AAA, one of the first things I did was to go out, not on my own, but with my whole leadership team, to visit the AAA field frontline team. AAA is built on caring for our members, and the people that actually have to do that every day are not the IT people in the background delivering the right solutions. But our job was to go out and meet with those frontline troops and sit with them and see what they have to do every day, and how what we deliver impacts that, and then listen to them. And sometimes that’s just a cathartic opportunity for the frontline leaders and employees to tell us that our IT systems are subpar, they don’t work for them. And we have to listen to that, and perception is reality when you do that, and that really then helps us to earn their respect, as long as we listen and we go back and change things. It also helps the IT leaders in the IT organization want to be able to talk in their language, but two, to understand at times the pain that we by accident may inflict on them when they’re trying to do their job.

Sanjog Aul [00:38:59]:
Now, when we want to have all this accomplished, where we have trust, we have got relationships, and that’s how IT leaders are able to maybe build a culture and or create a good set of lieutenants who would do their job, so that he or she can do his own, her own. Very, very fast paced, very high turnover environments, lot of pressure on IT to keep the costs down and keep the lights on. Do you think we can really have an IT leader lead with such things happening, where if you don’t have relationships then one of the key pieces of building that team or that trust is missing? So Damon, how would you handle a situation as we have today, and this is a reality today?

Damon Anderson [00:41:02]:
I can remember, they were just mentioning the key dealing with our customers. I can remember when I had my first 360 evaluation, and I thought I was doing a pretty great job. You’re spending time with your staff, building your IT organization. And when I read my evaluation, I got hit the hardest on my peers, because I wasn’t spending the necessary time with the people in the organization, with the business leads in the organization, to ensure that we were truly focused on the things that they really needed to have accomplished. Needless to say, that was an eye opener. Since that time I’ve been driven to ensure that that’s a part of my process, ensuring that I’m keeping those folks in the loop, ensuring that I’m keeping my staff in the loop, ensuring that, up and down, whether I’m managing up or whether I’m managing down, or however, even outside of our organization to our customers, that the customer’s focus is first and foremost, the business focus is first and foremost.

Sanjog Aul [00:41:50]:
So Neil, in your view, what should an organization do when they have the mandate of keeping the lights on and they’re firing people, or basically reduction in force is happening, and then there are other reasons why there is an attrition? So all the effort that was put in upfront to build those relationships, which in turn would foster trust, all those basic key ingredients are gone. So then of course the CIO will have to roll up the sleeves and get down to the middle management level?

Neil Jarvis [00:41:57]:
Yes. I think it’s as you say it’s something that we all face today. For me, as with all companies, part of my job is to make sure that our expense base, our blended rates, our percent of expense to revenue are all at industry standards. And at times, the hardest part there is not, they’re not with the customer, but more with the IT team, when you really have to dig in and help your organization understand why you’re doing that, why you have to do that, what the decisions really make. So one of the ways that we looked at it here with my organization, and I’ve talked to my team about, is that for every expense dollar that we achieve absolutely impacts the company’s performance. So, again, not falling victim and having to step back in, so let me go down and help just drive a project. I think, again, the important thing is to actually be able to explain the strategy and what that means. So when you’re actually looking at expense management, that actually means that if I take out a dollar of expense, that may allow a drop in revenue not to be as impactful for the whole corporation, and still be able to move forward. So I think being able to balance, with your CIO organization and with the business, that we are doing the right things, and the ultimate goal is for the corporation, not just for my little organization. I’m going to make sure I protect that. I think that’s a very powerful message for the company and for all.

Sanjog Aul [00:41:59]:
This is a question that has been asked, that how do each of you keep your direct reports focused on the key deliverables for the year and prevent them from getting sidetracked on all the nice to have, which basically erodes focus?

Keeping teams focused under cost pressure 42:57

Neil Jarvis [00:42:57]:
I think that’s the essential part of our job, is to make sure we know what are the strategic goals. So, at our company we have a very simple corporate goal, then we have 6 strategic initiatives, and then we have our individual organizational objectives, and then the people objectives. And being able to tie them all together is absolutely essential. So the developer who sat at their desk, even if they’re not a permanent staff member, but maybe they’re from a partner company that’s working with you, everybody should understand how their work, their deliverables fit together and really drive the ultimate corporate goal and strategy. And I think that’s where the teams stay engaged and everybody can get excited around what it is, what they’re trying to do, and not try and do too much. When I arrived here, we were trying to carry out hundreds of projects all at the same time. And for the team, on both sides of business and IT, that becomes very confusing, because it just becomes too much. Our new strategy in the company is, we’re laser focused on our strategy, the 6 key initiatives and then the objectives beneath that. And I think that empowers people, that excites people. I know what it means to me, I know how we succeed as a company, and I can relate what I do at my desk to that end goal. And to constantly celebrate success along the way, because this isn’t we start in January and finish in December activity. There’s major goals along the way, and celebrating them successes and making sure you have those regular town halls and brown bag lunches and is absolutely essential, and always talking about the objectives, the 6 strategies, the corporate goal, is very empowering for people.

Damon Anderson [00:48:28]:
I was going to say, Neil, I couldn’t agree with you more. In our organization we do a similar thing. We have our key action items, and we have also some key strategic projects that we have to get completed. Staff reports back weekly on the status of those things. We report back on our priority projects. We also, of course, employ your project management techniques. But then again, we also sit down from time to time, not just with the chiefs, but with the entire organization. We actually have that planned for this afternoon. We sit down in the room and we just kind of air out, just kind of making sure that everyone is focused on what the key business drivers are, what the key focus areas are. And then also, from time to time, we take some time out to party, just to kind of celebrate. And it doesn’t really have to be like a huge thing, but just those little things, they help to build camaraderie among your team and kind of help them see that, hey, I’m not just somebody here banging keys, but I’m actually a part of this organization, and the work that I do brings about change, especially with the work that we do, since we’re involved heavily with the environment. The work they do, they understand how it impacts, and they can kind of latch a hold to that mission.

Sanjog Aul [00:48:30]:
Question is, if an IT leader who actually feels helpless and feels actually stuck, and instead of being able to lead from the middle feels that he’s stuck in the middle, how does one get out of it? Is there a set of things that they could do? Would you say, now they’re stuck, there’s no point in us fighting upwards, and just quit? Or do you just kind of lobby support from anyone? What other ideas would you have for someone who is feeling like that at this time?

Attitude and climbing back from the middle 48:31

Neil Jarvis [00:48:31]:
I think that’s a great question. And I actually have a firm believing, and we use it as a mantra, and I see it here, that our attitude will determine the altitude that we can achieve. And I think, once the CIO, once the IT leader has lost that positive attitude, then the altitude starts to shrink, it comes down and down. So I think one thing is that the CIO always has to maintain that positive attitude. And that doesn’t mean walking around smiling and being the cheerleader all the time, but certainly always making sure that we’re understanding the business, we’re talking to the executives, we’re talking to the end customers, and we’re constantly seeking new ideas. Part of my job is to bring innovation, not just in technology, but in the business world itself. One of the things that we’re doing right now is that my IT organization has an innovation program that we’ve kicked off, and it’s not about, hey, let’s use the newest technology, let’s use this new widget or gadget, it’s more about what’s the innovation I can actually bring from a business perspective and talk about in business terms. And I think then the IT organization, the CIO, starts to move up that value chain. There’s a natural progression. If the business and the executives see you wallowing in despair and negativity down in the ranks, then guess what, that’s where you’re going to stay, you’re not going to climb out of that hole. If you actually turn that attitude and say, okay, I can actually still influence from wherever I am, because I’m looking at the business impacts and I’m bringing forward business change through technology, because our job is to enable. I think Damon said earlier it is to serve. I actually believe our job is to enable. And once you get that mindset, and you work hard on that as an organization, I attest that you will move up that value chain very quickly.

Damon Anderson [00:48:33]:
Neil, I agree with you as well. Also, too, once that negativity starts, it also spreads throughout your IT organization. That’s a hard thing to pull yourself back from. One of the things that we always try to do is focus on, when we look at our customers, or when we look at those who kind of have our destiny in their hands, I always say it’s their favorite radio station, WIIFM, what’s in it for me. That’s the focus that they’re looking at us as IT folks, they’re looking at what are you going to provide for me as an IT organization. What can you do for me? What is it that you can bring to the table that’s going to make my life easier, better, that’s going to help serve my customers, that’s going to help move my organization forward. And I believe the successful CIO is really good at finding out that what’s in it for their customer, and then gets busy at trying to provide that. Just like you said, that will also bring about the change in the organization, and they’ll start to see themselves elevated or lifted up to the organization.

Sanjog Aul [00:49:44]:
On behalf of the show and our listeners, I would really like to thank you, Neil and Damon. It was great, your thoughts about how a CIO can truly lead from the middle, or in fact should they, even if they are stuck in the middle, or they feel they have to basically bounce back and reclaim their role of being an IT leader, and empower the middle management so that they can do their own job, and then of course the CIO is left to do their own. So it was a great discussion.

Not letting the middle become a pattern 52:42

Sanjog Aul [00:52:42]:
So it is not uncommon for us to get pulled into trenches, preventing us from leading. There are times when it may be a necessity. However, this should not become a pattern. So if you have assumed the role of a desktop IT leader, eventually the responsibility will lie with you to find your way back to the top, if you indeed get pulled down to becoming a manager, as we just discussed. So set the right expectation with the middle management that you’re available for guidance, and if required would roll up your sleeves a few times. However, let’s not make it a habit. And while you are in the middle, you can actually show the managers how to become a person who can manage relationships and influences within the organization. And while you can be in the middle and get the required support and following, which itself would be a great real time training for your middle managers who want to be future IT leaders. And of course, they will respect you more, and you can then go back and do your job.

Contributors

Neil Jarvis

Neil Jarvis, Vice President and Chief Information Officer, AAA NCNU

Mr. Neil Jarvis is responsible for AAA Northern California, Nevada & Utah’s (AAA NCNU) technology strategy, management and delivery including applications, infrastructure intellectual property, data protection, information security, a... More   View all posts
Damon Anderson

Damon Anderson, Chief Information Officer, State of Pennsylvania - Conservation and Natural Resources (PA-DCNR)

Damon began serving the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania in June of 1992 and is currently serving the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources as Chief Information Officer and is credited with the creation of DCNR’s Bureau of Informat... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

TECHM - DNA - MPU01 - 300x250
Neil Jarvis