Data Analytics • Innovation • Leadership

Balancing Crystal Ball and Capabilities

Balancing Crystal Ball and Capabilities

This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.

About this conversation

A CIO Talk Network conversation with Pamela Arora (Children’s Health), hosted by Sanjog Aul.

What the conversation established

The conversation established that analytics only creates winners when it is tied to the organization’s mission and disciplined by data integrity, which Arora called the foundation that keeps people debating insights rather than the data itself. She said Children’s Health, now 104 years old, built an enterprise electronic medical record in 2007 over three years and a data warehouse on top of it, then used that foundation to move care out into the community where children live, learn, and play. Arora argued that former investments are not wasted even when they are sunset, because each one informed later decisions, and that the real constraint is not IT but the end users and leaders who must consume the data and change how they work. She stressed tracking key performance indicators as a tripwire, reviewing dashboards with the CEO’s leadership team and a clinically integrated network, and partnering outside the organization, as with Parkland Health’s Pieces solution, to move faster.

Host Sanjog Aul talks with Pamela Arora, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer at Children’s Health, about how to balance the pace of analytics with the capability to act on it. Arora explains why data integrity and a single source of truth come first, how Children’s Health moved from treating patients inside its walls to preventive population health, and when to keep investing in a tool versus sunset it. She points to concrete programs: telemedicine into about 99 schools, the Proteus medication chip for transplant patients, the Andrews Institute placed where the data pointed, and Family Health On Call house calls.

Contributors

  • Pamela Arora, Senior Vice President and Chief Information Officer, Children’s Health

Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network

On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript

Key takeaways

  • Pamela Arora, CIO of Children’s Health, argues that analytics only produces winners when it supports the organization’s mission and strategy. She frames the patients as the winners, because accurate data lets Children’s Health deliver informed care and run proactive wellness programs instead of waiting for patients to enter its walls.
  • Pamela Arora of Children’s Health says data integrity is the discipline that makes analytics work, not the number of tools an organization buys. She compares buying analytics tools to buying exercise tapes you never use, and warns that without agreed data definitions people end up debating the data rather than the insights.
  • Pamela Arora of Children’s Health describes letting analytics and strategy drive each other rather than choosing one. She points to telemedicine delivered into about 99 schools, where data first identified where to target and then showed how to refine the programs for children needing a second clinician opinion.
  • Pamela Arora of Children’s Health says earlier analytics investments are not wasted even when they are retired. She notes Children’s spent six years investing in population health tools, sunset some along the way, and warns that any IT system is the gift that keeps on taking through maintenance and upgrades.
  • Pamela Arora of Children’s Health uses data as a check on leaders’ blind spots by reviewing dashboards with the CEO’s leadership team and a clinically integrated network. She cites using shared quality data to reduce asthma severity in the Dallas Fort Worth area and placing the Andrews Institute for orthopedics where the data pointed.
  • Pamela Arora, CIO of Children’s Health, says the heavy lifting in analytics is not IT but the end users and leaders who must act on the information. She urges organizations to look beyond their own capabilities and partner outside, as Children’s did with Parkland Health’s Pieces solution for quality care delivery.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Introduction: balancing analytics and the capability to act
  • 2:48 Winners and losers tied to the mission
  • 5:07 Data integrity as the discipline
  • 10:21 Contradictory insights from 2010 to 2017
  • 18:32 Course corrections and transplant care
  • 23:46 Population health investments and sunsetting tools
  • 33:18 A single source of truth and KPIs
  • 39:04 Reviewing data with the leadership team
  • 41:52 Placing the Andrews Institute by the data
  • 48:50 Creative destruction and Family Health On Call
  • 53:58 Partnering beyond your own capabilities

Explore more

Transcript

Introduction: balancing analytics and the capability to act 0:00

Sanjog Aul [00:01:01]:
Our topic for today is balancing crystal ball and capabilities, and we have Pamela Arora, who’s the Senior Vice President and CIO with Children’s Health.

Sanjog Aul [00:01:21]:
So we wanted to talk about something which is very current, and people are hot about analytics. Everything in the business world is being looked at from the lens of analytics to see if we can figure out what’s happening today as well as what’s gonna happen tomorrow and almost like have a crystal ball. All that being said, the challenges which have been expressed by many leaders is, it’s good that we can see in the future what’s gonna happen or we can plan, but we are trying to go at way too fast a pace in terms of figuring out what’s gonna happen in future, what we need to do, and on the ground, the capability development takes time. So if we get overanxious with building capability, we might undermine the outcome. So what is that balancing act that we should have, or a balance that we should strike so that we are not going overboard with analytics. At the same time, the capabilities should not be suffering. So that said, first question is, the data analytics is predicted to define between what we call the losers and winners. That’s how at least the rest of the world is saying, but then if someone were to map out a journey from insights to outcome, what would that look like?

Winners and losers tied to the mission 2:48

Pamela Arora [00:02:48]:
When we talk about winners and losers, people tend to think about the longevity of an organization and its ability to adapt and survive. I’d offer Children’s Health has entered into its second century of service to the community. We’re 104 years old this year, and we are committed to longevity. What we’re really talking about though when you look at Children’s mission, when we say winners, is the patients, and if we do analytics well, the patients are the winners. Because we can have an accurate picture of the data and be able to have very informed care and be in a position to proactively work wellness programs versus waiting till they enter the walls of our organization. So as far as the winners and losers, I think regardless of what you are doing with your analytics strategy, you need to make sure it’s in support of your mission and your organization strategy, and it’ll keep you focused where you need to be.

Sanjog Aul [00:03:50]:
And frankly, there is no doubt as you very rightly said that analytics cannot be done just because you feel like doing it. It has to be connected to an organizational strategy and the mission as in this case in Children’s Health. Children’s Health perspective, that’s what you are doing. Totally understand it, but then we can go overzealous to say, okay. Let us find out the next level of insight or dig deeper into the analytics. That’s great that you were charging ahead with the mission, but then you got way too many things you find out and then you want to act to make a change in your organization to really get the value out of it, but you need capability development, which doesn’t mean you just have to put another piece of software. There could be changes in processes. There could be people. There could be other cultural change that you would need to fundamentally rethink. So that doesn’t happen overnight the way you could do something, like, say, put analytics in a cloud and get a result tomorrow. So that’s what people struggle with. How do you kind of handle that particular approach? And if you were to lay out a road map to say, okay. I’m gonna get these analytics, and then I’m going to work towards these outcomes. I’m sure there has to be a science to this and a method to this madness.

Data integrity as the discipline 5:07

Pamela Arora [00:05:07]:
Well, from a method standpoint, I would agree with your comments that there are plenty of tools in the marketplace for analytics, and many of those tools you can invest in all of them and still not achieve your goal. It does not address data integrity if you just take a random approach around your analytics. From the standpoint of organizations, many organizations realize that data integrity is the mining of the goal. When it comes to analytics, it’s an organizational discipline. I can buy all the exercise tapes in the world, but it doesn’t mean I’m necessarily doing them and getting healthy. In our case, that data integrity piece, that discipline around that is so critical. What that requires is understanding your data definitions, leveraging that information. The way to look at it is if people are questioning the data because they don’t have that level set around the definitions, you end up debating the data rather than the insights they’re provided to you. So that system level view, that discipline that you need, it helps you gain a more accurate picture and you’ll be able to have insightful stories that you can build from there. I’ll give a specific example with Children. Again we’ve been around for 104 years, and the community knows to come to us when they’re not well. We’re an acute care facility. We have a partnership with UT Southwestern as an academic medical center, and we’re good at delivering care to the acute patient, but what we really need to do is take the aggregated information across the entire community and reach out to the community for wellness programs, and that requires a very disciplined approach around data analytics, but first and foremost, you need to know that your definitions are aligned and how you’re using the information is in a uniform way.

Sanjog Aul [00:07:17]:
So I totally see if you were to look within analytics how to make analytics itself as a function more effective, and you rightly said about the data integrity and even the data quality, which will go into it. Totally understand. Now imagine analytics is a black box, and you’ve got that down to a science. You are able to get the right insights, but then in order to convert those insights into actions, from actions into outcome, something has to happen outside of IT or with IT and maybe in some places on the business side for it to be converted into an outcome. That cannot happen overnight. You can keep churning out analytics at the speed you want, but then the world cannot follow at the same speed. So you want to, and then also if you create too many insights and say, oh my god, we can do this, that, and the other, then it creates anxiety because as if we are losing the race. So shouldn’t we feed it only as much as we can chew when it comes to doing just enough analytics which we can actually put in action?

Pamela Arora [00:08:24]:
What I would offer is that sometimes you’re going to have analytics drive your strategy the way you’re describing it, and sometimes you go after analytics because you have a certain strategy, and when you’re trying to determine how much you bite off, I think the key is that once you have that foundation and alignment around data integrity, and the organization has a governance to make sure that any kind of investments are being made in a prioritized way, then you’re getting into the very culture of how the organization consumes the information. Many of our data analytic programs have helped spawn different initiatives. So for example, we have telemedicine that goes into the schools. We have about 99 different schools that we telemedicine into with the school nurses and children if they have a need for that second clinician opinion with the school nurse are able to get that. Well as far as those approaches that we’ve taken, the information goes both ways. First we use the analytics to determine where we wanted to target, and then secondly, we’re looking at the analytics to see how we can best refine the programs so that we can help those children in that example in the school setting. You wonder which came first, the chicken or the egg? In the case of analytics, sometimes it comes first and it drives it. So you get an insight and it drives your strategy, and in other instances you have a situation where you have a strategy, so you look at analytics to make sure that you’re targeting that strategy well.

Contradictory insights from 2010 to 2017 10:21

Sanjog Aul [00:10:21]:
So let’s take an example of say circa 2010, right, you may be collecting a certain type of data because you felt that data if collected and analyzed could give you a certain insight which you can put in action and get some value for the business. Come 2017, maybe the way the data was collected, maybe the source, the very form, the volume, and the velocity at which the data is coming, you find that, okay. Maybe I can do something else with this new form of data that I found, and the insights that you get might contradict or might force you or prompt you to go in a different direction than what you thought you’d go in in 2010, and in both cases, you had performed analytics. What then? So do you allow that creative contradiction, if you will, in your organization? That’s good if you’re just playing with numbers, but when you’re trying to have the organization move in a certain direction, could you just have your organization move on a dime today in one direction and tomorrow in another?

Pamela Arora [00:11:29]:
It’s a very good question, and to your point, I’d also say that analytics is not happening in a vacuum, especially in healthcare when you look at the models around clinical care delivery. They are evolving tremendously if you look back at 2010 to now, there are a lot of changes in the environment. So certainly the analytics would reflect that, but to the comment that you’re making, when you take a look at Children, our model has been in the past about children coming to us. They knew when the patient families knew when the child needed help and they would come to us, and that would be an older model. Relative to where Children’s strategy is, we want to go to where children live, learn and play. So that’s outside of our walls and very preventive. So to the very point that you’re making, historically we’ve been extremely good at gathering data within the walls of our organization. We’re digital, we have an electronic medical record. I joined Children’s over 10 years ago. When I first joined, our emergency room was on paper, and many of our clinics were on paper, and we have that all in our electronic medical record. On top of that, we even host community physicians on our electronic medical record that are not part of Children’s that are privately owned. If community physicians are interested in doing that, we provide that as well, and it all intermingles that data so that you get a very comprehensive view of that patient, but to your very point, in 2010, we have a good picture of what is in our walls. In 2017, we’re getting a better picture of what’s outside of our walls. So that we’re reaching out with health information exchange, we have new partnerships in the community, we want to connect to other sources that can help those patient families like food banks, the YMCA, etc. So the data gathering that takes place in 2017 and beyond looks very different than the data gathering in 2010, and you are so correct in that that additional information informs our wellness programs and it’s an imperative that we expand what that data set is so that we can do a better job with our strategy of meeting patients where they live, learn, and play, which is very different than waiting until they come into your walls. We want to go out into the community and prevent them, if at all possible, from even having it enter our walls at all. We want to have that preventive wellness program. So your point’s well taken, and in those instances you leverage the datasets that you have available to you, but you also have some theories on where you think we can get some improvements and many times you start gathering data and expanding your data set to help with those types of strategies. Does that make sense?

Sanjog Aul [00:14:56]:
No. It does. I’d like to further expand on this point where what you did from an inside development and perhaps sharing it with the leadership, and they made a few decisions in 2010, just for example, and now you’ve not exactly broken the walls, but you’re looking inside and outside the walls, and even those initial decisions could be questioned or challenged because now you have a new insight. Maybe the customer demands are changing. So did we jump the gun? Or are we continually jumping the gun by doing what is just today versus thinking tomorrow? And if you’re thinking tomorrow, will that tomorrow stay the same? What you thought of 2017 compared to 2010 is no longer the same. So how far do you go with the crystal ball? And if you do go, do you really go all out with it or just always tread cautiously?

Sanjog Aul [00:18:03]:
So 2010, you found some insights, some actions were taken, some decisions were made. 2017, the world looks different. It just did not expand the horizon, but it could be fundamentally different in some cases. So should we have gone gung ho with what we found at that time and then go all the way in terms of implementing only to make it a throwaway work? How do we balance it is what we’re trying to do here?

Course corrections and transplant care 18:32

Pamela Arora [00:18:32]:
Very good question. There’s the overused comment or statement where people say it’s about the journey, it’s not the destination. I think what’s key when you take a look at 2010 versus 2017 for Children, is that we have new information along the way, and the business leaders take that information and they do some course corrections based on that. So for example, we have many primary care offices across our community here in Dallas Fort Worth, and we did that because we were trying to get closer to the community and make sure that children had a medical home in their neighborhood there, and when you take a look at 2017, that strategy helped us because in some cases, children would go into our emergency room, and we had analytics that showed that our emergency room was overflowing and that if we were able to help the children in the community that we would not have an ER that wasn’t able to handle the capacity of the demand in the community. So we built all these primary care offices out in the community, and based on the data, based on seeing how it operationalized, seeing the community patterns, which you can have a theory, but you have to see how it plays out based on patient families because they’re the ones that are making choices on where they’re getting their care. Well, in 2017, we looked over that and in some cases we consolidated some of our offices and we put offices in other locations. Was it that we had poor data in 2010? No. It was based on the data that we had, we made informed decisions, but in 2017, if you’re taking a look at how things progress in the community, we have to adapt, and I think that that’s one of the key winning statements to any analytic strategy is using the data to help adapt your organization so that you can do a better job serving your mission. So I’ll give you a kind of an unusual example. When you think of transplant patients, they are very high complexity, and when you take a look at the analytics around what it takes to keep those children well, it’s quite fascinating because what’s inside our walls here at Children’s when they’re in our hospital system, we can have a very clear picture of the child’s condition and also the factors that affect that child’s condition. Well when they go home and start to get into their new normal, usually when the children are young, the patient families are very good at managing the medications and they take things according to plan. It starts to get challenged when a child is in high school. So now you have a teenager, they’re kind of administering their own medications, and you get into some difficulty there. Well, through our analytics and through our experience with working with these children, we knew that that was a problem. So we worked with Proteus, and they actually have a chip that they have on medication pills, so that when a child is taking their pill, we know, we have that information, we have it analytically, and we can determine whether that child is likely to get off course. So when you take a look at environment, there’s the massive where do you put a primary care office, and then there’s also the individual where it’s are they adhering to the discipline of what it’s going to take for them to stay well, because many of these transplant patients, it’s an imperative that they stay on their medication regimes or they can get quite sick. I’ll pause there, but it gives you an idea of where you kind of do broader strategy work and investment, but also we get into specifics on patients as well as how we manage overall populations as well. So for example, those transplant patients.

Sanjog Aul [00:22:59]:
So what you just mentioned is a fascinating point challenge and analytics driving a point solution. Now you mentioned earlier in that response that when you have some data in 2010, you opened a few offices, and then you invested in certain type of capabilities in house to be able to treat patients of a certain type in a certain region. All that could be fundamentally changing based on what you find out now. So while the word adapting is cool and people like that idea that you’re a nimble organization and agile organization, but there was some sunk cost of you investing in infrastructure and people and capabilities. So do we write it off?

Population health investments and sunsetting tools 23:46

Pamela Arora [00:23:46]:
It’s a good question. I will offer that there’s population health initiatives that many regions and health systems are adopting right now, and honestly Children’s has invested extensively in various analytic solutions to help with those population health strategies. So in brief, when we’re talking population health, again it gets into Children’s Health going out to the patient families and helping them with wellness programs versus waiting until they come into our institution, into our hospitals to treat something when it’s gotten very severe. So population health, for the last 6 years, Children’s has been investing in various analytic tools, different community outreach, to try to effect change with patients, and one could argue that some of those analytic tools we switched out, took different approaches, and I guess it begs the question whether the investments were for naught. I would argue that again back to it’s a journey, we needed to make those investments and there was much that was learned with each one of those investments. Some of the analytics work that we’re doing, we’re doing it in partnership with other institutions like Parkland Hospital System has an analytics solution called Pieces, and we actually use that for quality care delivery, but I guess the key point to your question is, were the investments poorly made? I would say no. Absolutely not. I think the key is to get started, be disciplined around data integrity, be disciplined around focusing any new investments to where the organization’s strategy is going, and relative to former investments, while they’re continuing to give you value, continue to use them, but if they’re not, this is really key. You need to sunset them. I joke at my organization here that once you put in IT, any IT solution, it’s the gift that keeps on taking. Meaning you have to pay for maintenance, you have to pay to upgrade it. There’s just a lot of care and feeding to any system that you have out there, and to the degree that a tool is no longer serving you, you really want to sunset them so that your organization isn’t having a drain of resource where there isn’t high impact, but I would argue that all of our former investments, even those that we sunset, were very important to us learning and being able to make informed decisions at that point in time.

Sanjog Aul [00:26:52]:
And would you recommend that we do fewer investments at any given time versus going all the way because of the fact that everything is morphing?

Pamela Arora [00:27:02]:
I think it depends on where the organization is. I’ll give the example of in 2007, Children’s had decided that we were going to have an enterprise electronic medical record that would hit all of our forms of care delivery, and we deployed that in a matter of 3 years. That was a very sizable investment, and there was a data warehouse that was on top of that that has been incredibly important to us. Much of the work that we’re doing in the community today, connecting across our community, we would not be able to do that as effectively and as informed if we had not made that sizable investment. So, from the standpoint of whether you do a modest and incremental or you do kind of a broader enterprise investment, it depends on where an organization is. I would offer that around the population health areas that I was talking about a moment ago, that in some cases the market wasn’t providing a good comprehensive solution. If they had, we would have invested in it in that time, but we ended up piecing components together around our core electronic medical record, and I am seeing the market start to mature around population health as these models are becoming more widely adopted, and you really have to do small incremental until the market provides that type of solution or you decide to build it yourself, but if you’re in the business and your core business is making life better for children, we prefer to let IT businesses bring those solutions to us, but there have been a handful of instances where we’ve done custom builds just because the programs weren’t available out in the marketplace. So either or, it has a lot to do with what the market provides and also what your organization has as a foundational level.

Sanjog Aul [00:29:13]:
Let’s talk about the interpretation of analytics towards building a roadmap. The reason I bring this up is because, of course, you came up with some analytics, and in some cases, the very outcomes that you say could happen or the actions that we should take for us to maximize use of that analytics could be subjective, could be almost people dependent, almost having a bunch of data scientists who look at that and say, okay. This is what you can do or the people who are developing the strategy, they say, I would want to go here. Do you think there is a risk of veracity, means the reliability of what that analytics is, number one, and second, is there a risk of us misinterpreting the outcome and in that case go towards the wrong course or maybe weigh too much or too little?

Sanjog Aul [00:32:17]:
So we have a good strategy or maybe rather we have, say, analytics. Now the way you define a strategy and even subsequently roadmap is subject to interpretation of the insights that were presented. Suppose you take that insight to a business leader. Number one, can they rely on the output that you provided them as or rather an input that you’re providing them? And then secondly, can we rely on that leader to properly interpret and make decisions which will make or break an organization? And does it not become subjective? How do you make sure that, of course, while you’re at it, you do the most objective analysis of something like that versus someone’s whims and fancies or some trends that we get all enamored with and see everything with a colored lens?

A single source of truth and KPIs 33:18

Pamela Arora [00:33:18]:
Very good question, and I would offer that Children’s has had its own struggles in this realm as well. Relative to analytics, what we were finding is we want to get the data in the hands of the people that are making decisions, so there’s at the leadership level, but also at the front line level of people who are hands on with patient care delivery. What we ended up finding though over the years was that in some cases people picked the analytics that supported what they were trying to promote, and in some cases this is where we’ve had to work hard around the data integrity piece, because we wanted to make sure that there was a consistent source of truth or a consistent version of truth. So for example, just a basic example, there are patient visits, and then there are visits where we might drop a bill. Those don’t necessarily match, because in some cases we deliver free care in the community. Making sure that it’s the right context for the right example is very important as far as making sure that when people are promoting a particular approach, it’s backed by a source of truth, a definition that actually is the right context for that information. So it’s a simple example, but it gives you an idea of if you don’t have good data integrity, it gets back to that earlier point that I was making. The other part of it though is as you’re going through, and you place certain bets because you’re saying the data is telling you that you should go in a particular direction, you need the key performance indicators to track, to gather to make sure you have the data for it and you track it to make sure that you’re on the right direction, and if you’re not, you have to look at that in a factual based way and figure out whether a course correction is needed. So that’s kind of the basics around the data piece of it, but when you’re talking about roadmap and the investments around people, process, and tools and technology as some of the tools, infrastructure like a building could be some of the investments that would be made. Many times there’s sizable investments that are made based on certain strategies, and I think there’s a couple, it just seems like mom and apple pie, but having good project management is incredibly important, especially if that enterprise program management office can be like your air traffic control and tell you whether you’re on track with the various investments that you’re making, and the other part that sometimes people lose sight of, especially when you’re working in the IT realm, is it’s not about getting things in on time at budget or below, from the stamp to scope. It’s also whether the organization realizes the key performance improvements that they were planning on. So analytics is a big component of that, and many times analytics are being gathered to define KPIs or to be your measurement around key performance indicators. I would say that if people do not have that kind of tripwire of determining whether they’re on track to their strategies, no data is going to help you and tell you to be able to, oh, you got to go back and look at the data. You need to have the disciplines kind of in place and these kind of structures, which are quite known in the industry, sometimes get overlooked for some jazzy new tool. It really gets into doing the basics well and having those disciplines in place.

Sanjog Aul [00:37:28]:
So based on when you build a roadmap, are you not taking a snapshot versus watching it every day? Because if you try watching every day, you’ll never be able to develop one roadmap. So if you take a snapshot, is it not almost a function of when you did it is what’s gonna define whether the roadmap that you develop and the type of investments you make would turn out to be any good.

Pamela Arora [00:37:51]:
I think that snapshot is where you’re defining your strategy, but relative to that dashboard and it evolving, I think that ongoing reporting, that ongoing monitoring, which gets back into what are the performance indicators, what are the needles that we’re trying to move, that is an imperative to the success of any approach, and being open minded enough to say if the data isn’t telling you what you were expecting, what do we need to do differently to adapt to be able to realize what our objectives were?

Sanjog Aul [00:38:32]:
Would you say if someone as a business leader makes a decision based on even a snapshot or whatever they use as a resource, and then comes something different, which the same analytics is offering, would a human’s ego kick in, and they’ll say, you know what? Yeah. Whatever it’s showing, but that’s just a hiccup or something which we really don’t need to heed because we made a decision. How do you kind of tackle that?

Reviewing data with the leadership team 39:04

Pamela Arora [00:39:04]:
It’s a good question, and I do know here at Children’s, we have a leadership team that takes a look at the dashboards, the analytics for each of the disciplines that we have across the hospital system, and in addition, if you take a look at our clinically integrated network, which is basically the network of clinicians out in the community, private clinicians that have patients that we share with our hospital system. So for example, my daughter might go to a private physician in the community, and that private physician can be part of our clinically integrated network, and the data can be mingled with Children’s data, Children’s Health, and we can get a holistic picture of that patient. So to your point on dashboards, is it just a snapshot? The point I’m going to make is that we review the data with multi disciplines at the highest levels of our organization with our CEO’s leadership team, so that if someone has a blind spot based on a predisposition around a strategy, they’re going to have other leaders that are going to discuss that with them to say, hey, is that really a good spot for that primary care office based on the way we’re looking at the data? So that healthy debate really I think helps people keep an open mind, but when you think of the power of having a similar type of forum with our clinically integrated network with these community physicians, we use quality data with that clinically integrated network, which we call a CIN, and collectively the group says how might we decrease the cases of asthma, or the severity of the cases of asthma in the Dallas Fort Worth area, and when you get that collective multidisciplinary group looking at the same data, seeing how they benchmark against other institutions, we have benchmarked data around different quality metrics that we can even compare against national databases, and then you start to get into a very powerful look that basically gives you fact based data and in getting a collective wisdom, you end up having different insights. Does that make sense?

Sanjog Aul [00:41:36]:
No. It does. It does, and you know what? That’s where we are trying to figure out what that organizational structure should be, and when you mentioned your leadership group, which looks at it, so it always has to be a committed decision. Is that what you’re saying?

Placing the Andrews Institute by the data 41:52

Pamela Arora [00:41:52]:
It does. We have the strategies that we’re delivering on, and then we’re looking at the day to day operational dashboards that tell us if we’re moving in the right direction. Sometimes you’re doing a broader cast of the net and looking at broader market data and comparing it to what you’re seeing in your particular hospital system, for example, but I’ll give you a specific example. We have in our Northern suburbs here, it’s a very athletic region, and Children’s was basically figuring out where we wanted to help those patients with wellness programs, and naturally when you have very active children and they’re getting involved in sports, they’re more apt to have injuries around orthopedic nature, that sort of thing. Well, we have an Andrews Institute, and that Andrews Institute basically focuses on orthopedic needs, and we looked at data to determine where that was best served, and it was our Northern Dallas suburbs area for patients, a lot of team sports. We did a great deal of research to determine our strategy on this effort. We wanted to meet, again, the patients where they live, learn, and play, and we place Andrews Institute there, and we also have programs on where those clinicians work with the coaches in the region. Now that’s an important strategy for us, but it’s something that we’re constantly monitoring because we want to make sure that that is the best place for that location as well as we’re reaching the community as we should, and some of that’s informed by knowing what that market looks like as far as the number of children that are in that area. We have so much growth in Dallas Fort Worth relative to pediatrics. Some regions, it’s negative growth of 2%. In the Dallas Fort Worth area, we have about 10%+ growth, and it has continued year on year. So when you take a look at even something as simple as where do you place this orthopedic clinic and this ability to do orthopedic surgery, that was an important way of informing that and making sure that we were meeting the children where we want to, which is where they live, learn, and play, and it requires that we be there, but that is all informed by analytics, and it’s constantly reviewed on whether we’re getting the volumes that we would expect as well as meeting the children’s needs based on what we’re seeing on the field because some of our clinicians actually go to some of these sporting events to see.

Sanjog Aul [00:44:49]:
Let’s talk about the creative destruction process that an organization needs to go through in some cases for them to effectively transform. What I mean by that, Pamela, here is that you might have to really let go of what you have and is working in some times to embrace what’s possible because you want to position for the future. How do we do something like that in a setting like yours? And even in other industries, there should be some pushback but then your analytics says if you continue to do what you’re doing today, you may not stay relevant. How do we go about this whole process of shifting people’s mindsets, getting people to really embrace the change that you’re talking and fundamentally transform. We’re using that analytics as the source which tells us to do so. Even if they do so, that’s the capability development part we’re talking. How difficult is it and how do you go about it?

Sanjog Aul [00:48:02]:
So we are talking about reinventing the processes, and that could sometimes mean letting go of what’s truly working and replace it or at least start suggesting or starting the process of replacing it with something which will position you to be relevant. Now this, while on paper, looks very, very good, and that’s something we should do, but when you hit the ground, talk to the business people who are ready to talk to the people who have worked for ages doing a certain thing, and you say we will not do it this way or we will not do this at all. What do you see we can do as technology leaders or work with business leaders to make that change happen? Because otherwise your analytics would be useless.

Creative destruction and Family Health On Call 48:50

Pamela Arora [00:48:50]:
I would offer, when we’re talking creative destruction, many times, we’re looking at what your business has been known for and its core, and you’re very good at it, and having to morph it in a dramatic way, and helping to inform that based on the analytic information that you have. So when you think of Children’s Health, again we’ve been around for 104 years, and children have come to us. They’ve come to us in our hospitals. They’ve come to us in our emergency room. They’ve come to us in our primary care offices, and our telemedicine into schools and various community hospitals. When we take a look at the data that’s being gathered, as I mentioned earlier, we’ve been gathering all this information in our electronic medical record, and that greatly informs where the children live, learn, and play, and some of them have not entered our walls recently. So our definition of what it means to make life better for children, that’s our mission, has to do with preventive wellness programs that will allow children to have less acute conditions. So in doing that, the analytics, first and foremost you have to gather different analytics. You have to have a wider net because you need to look at patients that aren’t in your walls, and that’s where you’re best at gathering your data. So as far as working through this, this is one instance where our strategy was driving the analytics information that we’re gathering. Then with that, it required a whole slew of other tools that were needed, but that balancing act, that’s a prime example of if you’re just doing what you’ve been good at for the last 104 years, we wouldn’t even be getting visibility to all the areas where we can help children with wellness programs. So our strategy says basically do a great job when they enter your walls, but we’re going to have different programs that reach out into the community, and we’re going to have to do that not just with people who are employees or academic medical partners, we’re going to need to work with private physicians, be able to measure the quality, be able to have goals collectively, to be able to drive this broader strategy, which is basically not they will come to us, it’s we will come to them, and out of this has been really quite exciting because we’ve even come up with programs that are like the Uber of medicine delivery. If you think of the old Doctor Welby model where someone would go to the home, we have solution sets that we call Family Health On Call where, based on what we can see as a need in the community, doctors will give house calls, clinicians will give house calls, and now you’re getting into a very consumer centric model, but if we just stuck with the old ways and didn’t really balance where we needed to go in the future and measure that, we would just be stuck with some of our older methods and frankly, become irrelevant over time.

Sanjog Aul [00:52:44]:
If you look at all the different things that we have spoken about, and we know that analytics also has a cost starting from data collection to churning it to coming up with interpretation and presenting and then, of course, use. So on one hand, you have a cost of analytics. On the other hand, you have a cost of building capabilities, which could be dependent on what you say you’re going to build and how you interpret. The best possible balance would be where you just create analytics for what you really feel you need, and then the business just about invests only in the areas where it sees that there is most value, and both in some way as we had been talking about this common thread all along the show, is that they both have to be calibrated at both ends so that you are not having unnecessary leakage or you’re not creating throwaway capabilities. If you were to give a suggestion to the listeners, the leaders who may be CIOs in health care or other industries, what would be your suggestion on how to approach creating this balance?

Partnering beyond your own capabilities 53:58

Pamela Arora [00:53:58]:
You need to look beyond your own organization’s capabilities, and I do think it takes a competent organization to recognize that many times the best way to accelerate their objectives is to work with other parties outside of their organization. I’ll give the example with Parkland Health. They developed a solution called Pieces that helps with quality metrics within the care setting. It leverages the same electronic medical records that we’re using here at Children’s, and in partnership with Parkland, we’re able to leverage that solution towards higher quality care delivery within Children’s walls. So that’s a small example, but there’s just so many different areas that if you look outside of your walls and you build those partnerships, sometimes it’s a vendor partnership. Frankly, many of these vendors are wanting to get into this space and they don’t have the data. Really, the hospital systems have that data. If it looks like it’s outside of the realm of what you have in the way of in house skills, certainly as you’re researching the marketplace you’ll find different vendor partners that can help you. So I think that key balancing act of what does it cost you as well as what is your speed to getting it in place, this comment around analytics, it makes it sound very much like it’s the IT heavy lifting. The truth is the heavy lifting is in the end users and the leaders of an organization consuming that information and having it drive decisions. So, in that instance, figure out a need for speed and ways to partner if it isn’t obvious on how you’re going to solve it internally.

Sanjog Aul [00:55:57]:
On behalf of the show and our listeners, thanks so much Pamela for sharing your insights on how Children’s Health has been able to create a balance between analytics and the capabilities it has developed and reap the benefits and also how organizations can start calibrating both sides which is creation of analytics and the capabilities in such a way so that the overall outcome is in the best interest of the customer and also doesn’t break the bank.

Contributors

Pamela Arora

Pamela Arora, SVP and CIO, Children’s Health

Pamela Arora, SVP and CIO at Children’s Health in Dallas, directs all efforts of the organization’s Information Services groups, including systems and technology, Health Information Management, and BioMedical technology and support. Ms.... More   View all posts
Add Comment
Click here to post a comment

Advertisement

MTECH - MSUMMARY - MPU - 02 -300x250
Pamela Arora