This is an audio conversation from the CIO Talk Network podcast. The timestamps in the chapters and transcript below refer to the audio recording.
About this conversation
A CIO Talk Network conversation with Bob Kantor, hosted by Sanjog Aul.
What the conversation established
The conversation established that authentic leadership is a skill anyone can build, not a fixed trait, and that it is hardest to hold onto under stress. Bob Kantor argued that the potential to lead belongs to everyone, from an individual contributor to a 14-year-old at home. He used a hand-clasping exercise to show that even a trivial change feels uncomfortable for about 85 percent of people, and said larger behavior changes carry more discomfort that leaders must work through. Kantor described leading an IT team through a looming downsizing by being honest about what he could not disclose, and recounted a manager he called Fred, who lost credibility by saying only thank you when his team deserved the credit. To stay honest, Kantor recommended a mini 360: asking six colleagues what to keep doing, what to stop doing, and what to start doing. He added that leaders owe people clear, specific feedback rather than sugarcoated messages, because respect is earned by being straight.
Host Sanjog Aul talks with Bob Kantor, a leadership mentor and CIO coach, about authentic leadership. They discuss why authenticity slips under pressure, a mini 360 feedback method, leading through downsizing, and balancing likability with respect.
Contributors
- Bob Kantor, Leadership Mentor and CIO Coach
Host: Sanjog Aul, Founder and Host, CIO Talk Network
On this page: Key takeaways · Chapters · Explore more · Transcript
Key takeaways
- Leadership mentor and CIO coach Bob Kantor says authentic leadership is something people build over time, not a trait reserved for those with titles. He argues that anyone, from an individual contributor to a 14-year-old in a family, has the potential to lead and to learn from what is working and what is not.
- Bob Kantor says authenticity is easiest when things go well and hardest under stress. He describes moments of disappointment, fatigue, and impatience as the times leaders are most likely to forget to be authentic rather than choose to be inauthentic.
- Bob Kantor uses a hand-clasping exercise to show that change is uncomfortable, with about 85 percent of people feeling discomfort from even a trivial switch. He says bigger behavior changes carry more discomfort, and leaders have to work through it for their skills to grow.
- Bob Kantor recommends a mini 360 in place of the once-a-year anonymous review, asking six colleagues three short questions. The questions are what to keep doing, what to stop doing, and what to start doing, repeated every six months with different people.
- Bob Kantor says a leader can stay authentic under pressure by naming shared values, showing how a request conflicts with them, and offering alternatives. He points to an IT deadline that cannot meet time, function, and quality at once as a choice about priorities rather than a flat refusal.
- Bob Kantor says earning respect matters more than being liked, and that sugarcoating tough messages serves no one. He cites First, Break All the Rules on people leaving managers rather than companies, and his own book Shatter Your Leadership Limits on a six-step leadership life cycle.
Chapters
- 0:00 Introduction: are you an authentic leader
- 1:35 Everyone has the potential to lead
- 4:57 Responding to a team member’s idea
- 10:13 Discomfort with behavior change
- 12:24 Leading honestly through a downsizing
- 19:20 A mini 360 for honest feedback
- 25:46 Keeping your job versus your values
- 33:41 When urgency overrides consensus
- 37:50 Helping a quiet leader play to strengths
- 47:31 Balancing likability and respect
- 51:29 Does serving others make you likable
- 53:03 Not enough to be right, also helpful
Explore more
- The Leader Is In
- Are you a Daring Leader?
- Learning as a Leader
- The Leader Essentials
- How to Win as a Leader
- Life of a Leader
Transcript
Introduction: are you an authentic leader 0:00
Sanjog Aul [00:00:27]:
Today’s topic is, are you an authentic leader? And our guest for today’s show is Bob Kantor, who’s a leadership mentor and a CIO coach. Welcome to the show, Bob.
Sanjog Aul [00:01:14]:
Now, when you talk about the very authentic leadership and you talk about leadership in general, so to start out and confine the scope to authenticity. How much of that is just an attribute versus something which drives what is going to be the fate of a leader?
Everyone has the potential to lead 1:35
Bob Kantor [00:01:35]:
Okay. I think you’ve got a lot of interesting points in that question. Talking about the fate of a leader, I think first, what it might be useful or interesting to talk about is leaders and leadership in terms of when we look at authenticity, it’s not just people in the positions of leadership or with titles of leaders, but it’s anyone and everyone in an organization or a group that has the potential to lead. So that whether I’m an individual contributor on a project team, whether I’m a member of a community organization, or even a 14-year-old kid in a family organization, I have the potential to lead. And I think you used the word destiny or fate as a leader. Day in day out, I have the opportunity to learn from what’s working and not working and to change what I’m doing. So we were chatting a little bit before we went live on air, and I mentioned that as I coach executives, especially information technology executives, not only am I coaching them and helping them see life and leadership from different perspectives, I’m also coaching myself and allowing myself more and different opportunities to see things differently and change what I’m doing.
Sanjog Aul [00:03:01]:
Now when you look at different folks who say that they are leaders and from the outside in, it looks like there is still work in progress. What’s the delta?
Bob Kantor [00:03:13]:
Well, I think we all owe it to ourselves to acknowledge that we’re doing the best that we can in the moment. And particularly when we have positions of leadership, we certainly are leading. We’re impacting what others are doing. We are coordinating activities to deliver results to our organization, to our marketplace. And just because we’re not doing everything that we can do doesn’t mean that we’re not leaders. So coming back to the authentic leadership question, the gap that I most often see with clients is that many of us can be authentic when things are going well. And it’s in the tougher times when something happens that causes us to feel disappointed, or maybe overwhelmed, or we’re tired because we’re not feeling well, or we’re irritated because things are not working outside, or we get impatient in the moment. That’s where maybe the challenge for maintaining our authenticity becomes larger. And sometimes we meet the challenge, and sometimes we don’t.
Sanjog Aul [00:04:25]:
So if you think that the people who are trying to do it, everybody comes and says, I want to be a great leader and the intention is there. And sometimes the capability and or, they are not able to see in which direction are they going. Do you need an outside-in input all the time? Is that what leadership requires? Or you could have some sort of a reflection that you can do on an ongoing basis to see if you’re running at 100 miles an hour, or at least you’re going in the right direction?
Responding to a team member’s idea 4:57
Bob Kantor [00:04:57]:
I think that’s a great question. And the answer would be, you said either or. I would say both are most helpful. Authenticity requires discipline, and discipline takes practice. And it also requires awareness, and awareness takes practice. So sometimes when we screw up in the moment because somebody says something and we react from a feeling of frustration, we may or may not catch that we weren’t authentic. And if we catch it, then the opportunities exist for us in that moment to exercise the intention, as you called it, to be more authentic. And I’ve had people where I’ve coached where they’ve had a problem with reacting too quickly when, say, a junior member of their team puts forth an idea and they’ll criticize the idea. And I remember one conversation where one gentleman said to me, But if we’re in a group meeting and one of my team members or group members says something and it’s really a stupid idea, how can I not criticize it? And I asked the person, Well, how do you know that it’s a stupid idea? And he said, Well, it just doesn’t make any sense. I said, Who does it not make any sense to? He says, Well, it doesn’t make any sense to me in that moment. I said, Okay. So from an authentic perspective, one authentic response is for you to shoot from the hip, so to speak, and call it as you see it and say, hey, that just doesn’t make any sense. Another possibility is for you to maybe reach for more authenticity and say to yourself, well, it doesn’t make any sense to me at this moment, so maybe I don’t fully understand it. And can you then go beyond the initial response of, wow, that’s stupid, to, I don’t think I fully understand your idea. Can you tell us a little bit more about it? Or can you answer a couple of questions for us about it? And in so doing, you are being much more engaging and really much more authentic with who you can be as a leader in terms of connecting with people and encouraging people.
Sanjog Aul [00:07:18]:
If you were to go out and try to poll and or do any kind of research, I’m sure you may have spoken to quite a few aspiring and current leaders. Do you see the success rate is because they were just born with that DNA or there were some grooming that was done and that was done in a planned fashion and which resulted in this fully cooked leader?
Bob Kantor [00:07:42]:
Well, I don’t know any leader who’s fully cooked. I know some are much better cooked than others. I’m a strong believer, Sanjog Aul, in leadership is something that we build and develop over time. Some of us are fortunate enough to be born with a personality or a disposition that makes it easier to be authentic. But I think it’s something that anyone can learn, anyone can practice. There are thousands of books on leadership out there. Many of them have great ideas. And I think it’s less about which ideas that we apply, and more about I’m gonna go back to words you used before intention. If we have a strong intention to continually grow, develop, and evolve, and if we are open to learning from every experience in every interaction, then I think we can all grow more as leaders. Can we do an interactive exercise, even though this is a radio show?
Sanjog Aul [00:08:54]:
Oh, definitely. I’d love that.
Bob Kantor [00:08:56]:
Okay. One of the challenges that we all have, including authentic leaders, is the discomfort that trying to do new things or things differently creates for us. So what I’d like to do is just illustrate that. If you and everyone else listening to this would just put your two hands out in front of you with your palms facing, and hold your hands about 12 inches apart.
Sanjog Aul [00:09:24]:
Sure, did it.
Bob Kantor [00:09:25]:
Okay. Now clasp your hands by interlocking all of your fingers.
Sanjog Aul [00:09:29]:
Alright.
Bob Kantor [00:09:30]:
And one of your thumbs should be on top, either the left thumb or the right thumb.
Sanjog Aul [00:09:34]:
Sure.
Bob Kantor [00:09:35]:
Which one is it?
Sanjog Aul [00:09:36]:
It is the right thumb.
Bob Kantor [00:09:38]:
Okay. Now, unclasp your hands, hold them out in front, reclasp, but this time put your other thumb on top.
Sanjog Aul [00:09:46]:
Did it.
Bob Kantor [00:09:47]:
How does that feel?
Sanjog Aul [00:09:49]:
A little different.
Bob Kantor [00:09:50]:
Okay. So it’s a little different. Is it a little uncomfortable?
Sanjog Aul [00:09:55]:
Yeah. The natural instinct is to have the right thumb up because I’m a right-hand person. And if you put the left thumb up, and especially when it was an instruction given, that’s why it looks that I’m not going with my natural instinct or DNA, and I’m doing it because somebody told me to do so.
Discomfort with behavior change 10:13
Bob Kantor [00:10:13]:
Okay. So, I’ve done this exercise with thousands of people in coaching sessions, in training classes, in presentations. And I’d say about 85% of the people feel a moderate to small level of discomfort with the switch. And then the other 15% either feel no difference or they feel major discomfort. And the point I make after the exercise is what we’ve just done is a trivial behavior change. And 85% of the people making this trivial behavior change experience a small degree of discomfort. Now, as we talk about larger behavior changes, such as how we respond when somebody says something in a meeting that doesn’t make sense to us, or how we respond when a member of our team addresses us in a particular way in a meeting, or when our boss says something to us. Those behavior changes are not so minor and those typically have a much higher level of discomfort associated with them. And unless we are prepared to accept a certain level of discomfort and work through that discomfort until it’s no longer uncomfortable for us, then we’re going to have difficulty making the changes and enhancing our skills as a leader. So I thought of that in terms of your question about nature versus nurture or DNA versus skills, because we can all learn to be more effective and we can all learn at any point in our lives, provided that we can accept that the learning is not always going to be comfortable. And if our intention is strong enough to really evolve and change, we need to work through that discomfort.
Sanjog Aul [00:12:08]:
That’s a great way to put across what you just mentioned. Now coming back to the word authenticity, does anyone ever want to voluntarily be inauthentic? And what would make them do so?
Leading honestly through a downsizing 12:24
Bob Kantor [00:12:24]:
I think that when all of us have moments or periods of, I don’t know if it’s a word, unauthenticity, it’s less because we planned or chose to be inauthentic and more because we forgot to be authentic or lost the awareness of authenticity. And when I observe this in people with whom I work and in fact, when I’ve seen it myself, more often than not, it happens when we are feeling significant stress. So one example that I can think of is, I’ve worked with people who have had to lead organizations through radical downsizing. And frequently when that happens in an organization, people get wind of it and they know it’s coming and they begin to ask questions that the leader realistically can’t answer. And I remember myself being in a situation like that and having one of the project managers in the IT organization come to me and say, Bob, is this really going to happen next month? And I looked at her and I said, Steph, it’s really not appropriate for me to discuss that. And what I wanted to do in that moment was just shut down. And this little voice in the back of my head said, how do you relate to this person who very obviously is uncomfortable, frightened, scared, and is asking you reasonable questions that you know you can’t answer? And she was sitting there, and I looked at her and I said, Look, I can’t discuss what may or may not happen. I can’t even tell you that it is or it isn’t. We know that these things periodically happen in companies. Obviously, you’re getting a sense of something, otherwise you wouldn’t have asked me the question. The best that I can do is talk to you about how to maybe deal with what may or may not be happening, and do the best that you can over the coming months in case something does happen. And I invited her into a conversation about when these things happen, some people have a strong negative impact, and the bulk of the people are not impacted. Very often, the people who are impacted go through a difficult transition period, and it doesn’t last as long as they expected it would. And they very, very often come out of the other side in a much better position and feeling great about the situation. And at the end of the day, the only thing that any of us can do to control and influence these things is to continue to do what we’ve been doing, which is the best possible job that we can do each and every day, and to really focus on continuing to contribute value and not get distracted by what may or may not be happening. And so at the end of the conversation, she looked at me and she said, well, that’s not what I wanted to hear. But it was really, really helpful. And I appreciate the fact that you didn’t just tell me you couldn’t discuss it. That’s helpful. And thank you very much for going the extra mile.
Sanjog Aul [00:15:48]:
Let’s explore that. Let’s look at the signs that a person in a position of power shows signs of not being authentic. And how does that person himself or herself recognize it before other people do? Because if other people do before that individual does, then it would cause far more damage to the very trust, the leadership potential, and what the outcome can be as this person is trying to lead the troops for the desired outcome. So how does this whole diagnosis happen? And based on what your experience is, Bob, what is it that we have found in real life? Are people finding out before other folks find out, or is it happening that they are usually told, and by the time they’re told, the damage is already done? And perhaps some people may lose their jobs.
Sanjog Aul [00:18:42]:
So Bob has the question: where are the signs that you could see from a leader not being authentic? And typically, you can expect either the person to recognize themselves as they’re doing it. Of course, if they’ve been doing it on a regular basis, they will know it. But if, suppose it’s more of an incident versus a norm, then how do we make sure that before anybody else comes to know, this person gets to change their behavior? Because people from outside, if they’re going to be noticing it, it’s going to cause much more damage. And perhaps we can even quantify the amount of damage it can cause.
A mini 360 for honest feedback 19:20
Bob Kantor [00:19:20]:
So let’s talk about the damage first. I think we’ve all had the experience of it takes a very long time to build trust and to earn people’s respect, and it’s a lot easier to lose it and a lot quicker to lose it than it is to build it. And I remember a case of one of my clients having really put together a wonderful team and over the course of a very challenging project, done a wonderful job of building up the team and promoting the team. And he was in a management team meeting where they were getting recognized for having done the work and succeeded with the project. And the CEO of the company turned to him. And I’m gonna change names here to protect the innocent. And he turned to him and he said, Fred, you did a fantastic job with this. You deserve a tremendous amount of credit. And in the moment, Fred looked at him and said, Thank you very much. Period. End of conversation. What Fred didn’t say was, Thank you very much, and I really need to recognize that this was a team effort, and everyone on the team deserves the recognition and your appreciation for what it is that we delivered. Very small difference. And even though the team wasn’t in that meeting, somehow the word got around that Fred took credit for what the team had done. Now Fred didn’t really take the credit. He simply said, Thank you. But because he didn’t go that extra step, it allowed people to make some assumptions or presumptions around what was going through his head. And he lost a lot of credibility. And as we examined it and discussed it, I advised him to actually go back to the team and to reconnect with his authentic self and to call it what it was, a mistake. And so he did. He sat down with his team and he said, Look, I think some of you have heard about this conversation that happened in the management team meeting. This is what happened. He said, You know, in the moment, I thought that saying thank you was appropriate and enough, but in hindsight, I realized that I stopped well short of what I should have done. And what I should have done was yada yada. And I made a mistake, and I’m sorry. And I realized that I’ve damaged some of the trust that you had in me. And I realized that it’s gonna take some time to rebuild that trust. And I just want you to know that I’m totally committed to doing that. And I hope you’ll give me the opportunity to do so. So I think that that comes back to your question about measurement as well. It’s all well and good for us to know when we’re being authentic and building trust or when we’re not and losing trust. And there’s no reason for those of us who are living authentically to make getting feedback from other people an essential and integral part of the process. So one technique that I advise most of my clients to use is what I call a mini 360 feedback. And many companies do these large anonymous 360-degree feedback exercises for their executives, and they typically do them once a year where anywhere from 6 to a dozen or so colleagues are asked to fill out an online form, and then you get the anonymous results of what you’re doing well, what you’re not doing well. What I advise clients to do is to actually have conversations with people. And I suggest that they identify 6 individuals with whom they have interactions: 2 people who work for them, 2 of their peers, and 2 people who are at higher levels of management in their organization, and that they ask each of those people to answer 3 questions for them. The first question is, what am I doing that I should keep doing? The second question is, what am I doing that I should stop doing? And the third question is, what am I not doing that I should start doing? And the way that I advise them to go about doing this is to send the questions and a request for a conversation to their 6 individuals as an email. And to also mention in the email, please do not respond via email. I’d really like to sit with you for 5 or 10 minutes and talk with you about this. And second, please keep your answers very, very brief because I truly want to respect your time and only want to take a few minutes from you. And then what they do is they schedule a meeting and they get the feedback. And if they need some more clarity, they can ask some questions. And the reason that those 3 questions are sequenced that way is that when we ask, what am I doing that I should keep doing? We put the focus on something that is successful. And that sets a positive tone for the conversation. When we say, what am I doing that I should stop doing? We identify something that either isn’t effective for us or maybe we should be delegating or allocating to somebody else. And if we were to stop doing that, it might free up our time and energy for the third question, which is what am I not doing that I should start doing? And I advise people to do this maybe every 6 months with different individuals as a way to request and obtain regular feedback on their effectiveness in the way that they engage with people around the organization.
Sanjog Aul [00:25:22]:
Now when you talk about the demands the world places on us, do you think we are coming to a point where even though we have all the intentions and the capability to remain authentic and do the job, the external factors could almost have a predicament posed in front of us that either you keep your job or remain authentic?
Keeping your job versus your values 25:46
Bob Kantor [00:25:46]:
Oh, there’s no question that the work environment is becoming more and more challenging for us. I’ve been at this long enough to remember when time management was really a question of answering the phone or attending meetings. And then the technology came along and we went from any place and any time to all the places and all the time; we were on 24/7. I believe that authenticity is not an either-or approach. Even when we are under tremendous pressure, we can choose how we want to respond. We talked earlier about shooting from the hip, versus having a more thoughtful response. I’ve had clients who have been asked to do things that they felt were truly unreasonable. And in the process, they’ve had to make a decision as to whether they were going to be true to their values or not. And there are times when you do choose to compromise a value in the moment, and then you live with that decision. And based upon how you responded to that situation in terms of how you felt it went, how you felt days or weeks later, you learn from it and then you learn how to balance those challenges. So let’s take a very concrete example that most of us in IT are familiar with. You’re asked to deliver a new product or a new application or a major upgrade in a very challenging amount of time. And your immediate internal response is, There’s no way I can deliver that in the time frame that’s being requested. So one thought would be, an authentic response would be to say, That’s not reasonable. I can’t do that. Another approach, and this is, I think, the way to think about your question about when do you have to give up being authentic, I could say, Well, okay, we’ll do it. Knowing or believing that it’s not going to happen, that wouldn’t be authentic. I could say, We’ll do our best and maybe we can, maybe we can’t. That would be more authentic, but it’s still not totally authentic if you believe that it’s not going to happen. And then there’s maybe a third approach that says, look, based upon everything that I understand about your request, based upon all of my knowledge about the underlying system, based upon the importance of delivering only the top-quality applications and services to our clients and community, there’s too much here for us to hit the deadline, hit all of the functionality, and hit the quality level that we all believe and are committed to delivering. So let’s take a look at whether the time frame is the most critical component, whether the function set is the most critical component, and whether there might be a way to look at addressing the quality level so that we can have a much higher probability of meeting everyone’s expectations.
Sanjog Aul [00:31:45]:
Actually, in fact, you brought it to a logical point, and I had a question I wanted to ask you, which is about immunity. Do you think today organizations have offered an immune culture, or for that matter immunity to a leader who, when posed with this predicament, chooses the right path of being authentic?
Bob Kantor [00:32:05]:
Wow. That’s a really, really hard question for me. I think some organizations are a lot better at that than others. I work with all sorts of Fortune 500 companies as well as middle-market and even small companies. And generally, it varies from company to company and even sections within a company. So if you’ve got, say, a business unit head who is very, very authentic in terms of holding herself accountable and not looking to pass blame and being open to feedback about what’s working and not working, I think that you’re going to see much more of that immunity that you referred to, Sanjog Aul. Whereas if you’ve got someone who views himself more like a master of the universe and always expects everyone else to be perfect and someone takes a risk and the results aren’t as expected, in a case like that, there probably won’t be immunity. So I think it varies.
Sanjog Aul [00:33:13]:
Where is the fault, Bob? If there is a problem with giving an immune culture and at the same time you want results because real leadership and real results actually come with everyone working authentically versus just looking for a short-term gain. So do you think these people are blindsided or looking for instant gratification by just solving this problem now by doing whatever they have to do versus being a marathon runner?
When urgency overrides consensus 33:41
Bob Kantor [00:33:41]:
Well, I think you’ve hit a lot of important keys right there and results and short term versus long term. There are always going to be situations where something is so urgent that what might be a more collaborative or quote unquote authentic approach may not be viable. I can think of situations where I remember several years ago myself working in an organization where there was a tremendous amount of cyberattack activity going on and our security infrastructure, our firewalls just weren’t doing the trick. And while we had a process in place and a cross-organizational team in place to be able to problem solve and take the best possible action, things were happening so fast and furious that we were falling behind the curve. And so finally, I got everyone together and I said, look, we’re going to have to take more drastic action. We’re going to have to take what looks like a higher risk action. We can’t use all of those policies and procedures. They’re not working for us. And so I looked at everyone. I said, look, normally, I would ask all of you to come up with a consensus and we’d follow the group consensus on this. But right now, since that’s not working, I’m going to have to take a little more control and I’m going to ask some of you to just do things and see how they work out. Now, a couple of thoughts on that. Number one, I didn’t say, This isn’t working. You’re screwing up. Just do this. I set a context for letting go of that more authentic response. And in the process, I maintained authenticity.
Sanjog Aul [00:35:25]:
With this striving to remain authentic, do you think when you talk to a number of people, have they come back? The leaders or the wannabe leaders or people who are not there yet and maybe don’t have that immunity available in the culture, what is it that they are struggling with, and what has worked for them in order for them to still rise and shine? Because we cannot basically blame the external environment all the time for our shortcomings or the fact that we are not able to remain true to our character and integrity is maintained and authenticity is maintained. So what is it that they say they have done to overcome those hurdles?
Bob Kantor [00:36:07]:
Well, I think that the key there, Sanjog Aul, is that we can’t blame others or the environment. So everyone that I coach has a situation that they feel isn’t optimum, isn’t going right, and so on. And the question I always ask is, Okay, given that you don’t have any control over what somebody else is doing, what are the various options that you have to respond differently to the situation? Because the reality is, even though we can’t change anyone else, either who they’re being or what they’re doing, we always have the option of choosing how we’re going to respond to it and changing our response. And in the process of changing how we respond, we almost always change the nature of that relationship. Now, we may not get from the current situation to the final outcome that we want in one conversation or one move, it may take several interactions or even the course of a couple of years. However, if every time we find ourselves in that difficult and uncomfortable situation, we check our reaction and take an extra moment to reflect and think about what would be the best possible response that I can offer in this situation so that I can maintain my own integrity while at the same time being realistic, I think that’s the opportunity that those of us who are most successful take and those of us who become the most effective leaders find ourselves following. Can I give you an example?
Sanjog Aul [00:37:49]:
Yes, please.
Helping a quiet leader play to strengths 37:50
Bob Kantor [00:37:50]:
Okay. I started coaching a woman and she walked into our first session and she sat down and she said very quietly, I need you to help me figure out how to be rough and tough. And I looked at her and she was very quiet, very laid back. And I said, Well, why do you need to be rough and tough? She said, I’m a member of a management team, a bunch of guys, and they are loud, they are boisterous. And at all of the management team meetings, there’s a lot of testosterone flowing. And I looked at her, I said, well, are you by nature a rough and tough individual? And she giggled a little bit. And she said, Well, no, that’s not me at all. And then I asked, Well, so why do you think that you can be successful pretending to be rough and tough with guys who are really rough and tough? And she said, They’d see right through it, wouldn’t they? And I said, I think so. So then I looked at her and I said, Why don’t we focus on what strengths you bring to this team and what contributions you can make that they wouldn’t have without your participation, and see if we can find more effective ways for you to make those contributions and leverage those strengths. And so we did, and we had several of our coaching sessions over the next couple of months on that. And what emerged for her was that her ability to sit quietly and listen intently and then reflect back what she was hearing and at the same time be able to analyze and present a balanced perspective was really her strength. And so she started to try to do that in meetings. And the first couple of times that she tried to do it, she got steamrolled over and no one paid attention to her. But about the third or fourth time that she made an attempt, one of the members of the team said, Wait a minute. Alice here has, in the last couple of meetings, tried to make a statement, and we really haven’t listened to her. I’d like to hear what she’s trying to say. And she did make her contribution. And everyone looked at it and said, wow, never thought of it that way. And then over the next several meetings over the course of months, people began to create more and more of an opening for her to help them out. They began to become more aware of when they were getting stuck and beginning to butt heads and not making progress and beginning to invite her more and more to offer her perspective and to share what she was seeing and hearing. And I guess four or five months later, she had emerged as a much stronger leader in that management team by leveraging who she was, which I think we would both agree, Sanjog Aul, was one of the measures of authenticity, and not by trying to be somebody who she wasn’t.
Sanjog Aul [00:40:46]:
So what you are sending as a message is people have to be who they are, work with those strengths and weaknesses, and then be tenacious in sticking to their guns and see if, basically, always work towards creating value, and eventually somebody will notice. Very well taken points. Now how about the patience of the people around them? Because folks in management say if this person cannot deliver within a given number of meetings or number of months and this person has to lead the troops, this person is perhaps weak. And they may lose the opportunity to make a difference because they held their patience thinking just by being themselves, somebody eventually will wake up. So in your example, somebody did wake up and basically take notice. How about they don’t? And what is the norm here, or what is it that’s seen usually: do people start taking notice relatively quickly, or do some people just go unnoticed and eventually get fired before they make a difference?
Bob Kantor [00:41:55]:
Well, unfortunately, both happen. Some people don’t make a difference. And I wouldn’t say that people who don’t make a difference in leadership roles fail because they were trying to be authentic and that was too slow of a process. At the end of the day, we are accountable for delivering results. And in today’s world, we’re accountable for delivering big results in very short time frames. And one of the results that we’re expected to deliver is not only bottom-line and top-line numbers improvements, but also building the capacity of our organizations to continually improve and deliver better results. And I guess going back to the example I used a few minutes ago about these cyberattacks, there are times when taking it slower gives you the result that you want, and there are times when you have to be much more aggressive. So in the example I gave with this woman, Alice, if she were under the gun to demonstrate that she were really an equal partner here, she might have taken one of the members of the team aside before one of the meetings and said, Look, I think this is a contribution I can be making. I think that all of you guys are wasting a lot of time and missing opportunities, and here are a couple of examples. I’d like your support in inviting me into the conversation to help with perspective.
Sanjog Aul [00:43:17]:
Isn’t that begging though if she goes?
Bob Kantor [00:43:19]:
I don’t think so. I don’t think so. It depends, again, on how you approach it. Is it weak to ask someone for support? Is it weak to ask someone for feedback and input? Is it weak to ask someone a question and to include and engage them in a conversation?
Sanjog Aul [00:43:42]:
It is perhaps not if other people think that it is. So maybe fundamentally let me ask you this question. Should people who want to remain authentic and actually be successful by becoming authentic seek external validation of whether what they are doing is working or not?
Bob Kantor [00:44:00]:
I think we all need external validation. That was that mini 360 we talked about a little while ago. And there are other metrics and measures of success that we need to constantly be tracking as well. In the case of results, I think even when we have very, very tight and tough results, there are ways that we can authentically approach putting pressure on ourselves and our team to step up to those big challenges.
Sanjog Aul [00:44:33]:
And let’s look at how do you balance between remaining authentic and also being likable. Because they also say that leaders should be likable for people to follow them. And they are able to connect better when people like them. And if you are authentic and if you’re going to speak your mind, if you’re going to do the things that are best, you may not always have that 100% likability poll like a president gets. And that could also have a detrimental effect on what you can actually get to deliver. So what is that balance where you focus on likability or authenticity or both? Where do you strike that balance or is there a balance required?
Sanjog Aul [00:47:21]:
So million-dollar question. What’s the balance between authenticity and likability we need to strike in order to be successful as a leader?
Balancing likability and respect 47:31
Bob Kantor [00:47:31]:
Okay. About ten or twelve years ago, there was a book published called First, Break All the Rules, and the subtitle was What the World’s Greatest Managers Do Differently. And one of the findings, maybe the key finding from that book, was that people who leave their jobs typically leave their managers rather than leave their companies. And people who are really, really satisfied with their jobs like working or are comfortable working with their managers. And I think that one of the challenges we have is to distinguish like from respect. I do a lot of coaching around managers who are dealing with performance management challenges from one or more members of their staff. And they are always concerned about pushing too hard, being seen as too tough, being seen as unreasonable. And one of the questions I always ask is, what is in the best service of the individual whose performance is inadequate? Is the best service to soften the message and allow them to continue to underperform? Or is it really in better service to be very, very clear and straight with them and to give them some very aggressive challenges with reasonable support to meet those challenges so that they can in fact address the problems that they’re currently not addressing. Because at the end of the day, we do no one any favor by allowing them to underperform. And whether that’s not delivering enough or on time, whether that is through the quality of their interactions you’ve heard about people very, very brilliant programmer, but you can’t have him in meetings because he doesn’t know how to talk to people or wonderful person to work with always says yes, always does their best, but is always late with their project. Or always hits the project on time but the quality isn’t there. There are always problems that somebody else has to clean up. It doesn’t do anyone any good to sugarcoat tough messages and to not hold people accountable to a high level of standard of performance. And I gave you the example earlier of my having a conversation with someone who was scared and afraid about a downsizing that they were anticipating. I told it like I could, without saying those things that I couldn’t. And in performance management or even creating conditions of accountability, I invite people to be as specific as possible. If you have a tough deadline, acknowledge you’ve got a tough deadline and sit down and talk about, we have to meet this deadline. We have to deliver something that is going to be a reasonable semblance of the level of function required and reasonable quality. Are you confident that you can do that? If you’re not confident that you can do that, what do we need to do to ensure that we are still successful here? And it’s only by giving people grounded feedback based upon, I’m gonna call it empirical evidence or the facts, that we, in fact, can continue to command or earn their respect. And while some people will say, I don’t like the message, but I appreciate the fact that you’re being honest with me, that is where we build the respect and earn the respect that we need to continue to be effective and authentic leaders.
Sanjog Aul [00:51:08]:
Now we also talk about servant leadership, which is you are helping everybody else. And does that come automatically that if you are remaining authentic and you just stand to serve others, you’re automatically going to become likable and that becomes a good overall recipe for success?
Does serving others make you likable 51:29
Bob Kantor [00:51:29]:
Well, I don’t know if serving others always makes us likable because let’s go back to that example. If you’re not doing your job and I believe that my highest and best service to you is to put you on a performance improvement plan because we’ve had several conversations about you’re not cutting it and you haven’t changed your behavior. So now I put you on a performance improvement plan because I really, really want to get your attention. I really, really want you to understand that it’s time to fish or cut bait. And, oh, by the way, you’re a member of a team and everyone else on the team knows that you’re not cutting it. And everyone else on the team is being negatively impacted by the fact that you’re not pulling your weight. And everyone else on the team is looking to me to do the right thing. In that case, I do believe that an authentic leader would be serving the individual that she’s putting on the performance plan. I do believe that she would be serving all the other members of the team even though that individual might not like it, even though they might not like the leader, I still think that it’s the right thing to do and it’s authentic in terms of serving the greater good of the organization and the individuals.
Sanjog Aul [00:52:48]:
Now while I asked you a number of questions, but I’m sure because you’ve written a number of good books here, what is your central message about leadership and what is it that people should do to become an authentic leader? How do you inspire them?
Not enough to be right, also helpful 53:03
Bob Kantor [00:53:03]:
Okay. I guess the most fundamental question that I ask people and that I’ve actually seen used to change cultures in organizations, well, it’s actually a statement. It’s not enough to be right. We also have to be helpful. And so what I invite people to consider is when they are making choices, are they being helpful? And to whom are they being helpful? And in what context? Because you can be right and go down with the ship because you were right. And because no man is an island, if you don’t mind the ship metaphor. Because we make it together and we don’t make it by ourselves, we have to be helpful. When people feel that we are being helpful, they are more likely to be inspired to work with us, collaborate with us, and cooperate with us. When they feel that we are digging in our heels and it’s our way or the highway, they are less likely to be that way with us. So rule number one is not enough to be right, we also have to be helpful. And then number two is you have to be able to say no in a positive fashion. When you have a request that you don’t believe is aligned with the values of the organization, the business unit, and so on, you have to look at how to frame the situation in terms of the values that you do share, frame the request in terms of how it conflicts with those values, and then present alternatives that are more in line with the values. So you’re saying yes to shared values, no to the request, and yes to a positive way forward that is aligned with shared values. If you do those two things, I think that you’re halfway there.
Sanjog Aul [00:54:59]:
Great. Now one final request. Could you actually name the books that you’ve written and the ones which kinda connect the best with the authentic leadership angle that we have spoken about today?
Bob Kantor [00:55:13]:
I’d actually recommend just one, and it’s my most recent one from last summer. It’s called Shatter Your Leadership Limits, and the subtitle is Better Results in Less Time with Less Stress. And I talk about a 6-step leadership life cycle. And the life cycle seems to resonate well with IT professionals because we use life cycles in project management, in applications development, and so on. And by just going through that life cycle, over and over again, it’s a simple framework that keeps us focused because great leadership can be very simple. It doesn’t mean that it’s easy, but as long as we stick with simple approaches and we stay focused on saying what we mean and meaning what we say, a lot of the detail tends to take care of itself.


